Hunter Killer Review: 3 Ups & 5 Downs
So bad it's good, or just plain bad?

Though awards season is very much in full swing, that doesn't mean audiences are left totally deprived of more "escapist" tentpole entertainment this time of year.
As such, Gerard Butler's new submarine thriller Hunter Killer hit UK cinemas this past week and releases in the US this week, and it's...pretty much exactly what you think it is.
Scarcely screened in advance for critics, the throwback blockbuster has scored mostly scathing notices from the press, mostly living down to everything the trailer suggested it would be.
If you're after an occasionally so-bad-it's-good action thriller, though, there are some giggles to be had, even if you might be left wishing the movie leaned into its silliness a little more eagerly throughout.
Nobody would blame you for missing it at the cinema, especially during this busy period of the movie calendar, but if you're stuck looking for something to watch on Netflix in six months' time, it might make for acceptable background noise. A back-handed compliment? You bet...
Downs...
5. Gary Oldman Is Completely Wasted

Recent Oscar-winner Gary Oldman appears in the film as Admiral Charles Donnegan, a trigger happy American military man who frequently proposes a rather hung-go approach to dealing with the delicate submarine stand-off against the Russians.
Sadly Oldman doesn't appear in the movie for more than about 10 minutes, and it's apparent for every second of those 10 minutes that he mailed his performance in from several continents away.
Oldman's never been one to turn down an easy paycheck, but this is an especially low-effort performance from the acting legend. He gets a few amusingly shouty moments, but for the most part he's given little interesting to do and is thoroughly squandered as a result.
4. The Wildly Inconsistent Production Values

The budget for Hunter Killer hasn't been formally disclosed, but it's clear from the film's first few minutes alone that the movie wasn't made on the cheap.
With its stacked cast, abundance of elaborate, sweeping crane shots and occasional practical use of actual submersible vehicles, this thing evidently had a decent amount of cash poured into it.
Sadly the visual effects are the one giveaway that corners had to be cut in order to keep the budget down, because as sharp as the movie often looks, the CGI frequently feels like it belongs in the cut-scene of a PS3 game.
From hilariously awful green screen shots - where Gerard Butler has an ugly, blurry hue around his body - to embarrassingly low-rent digital explosions and the rather murky nature of the submarine action itself, the VFX are mostly a mess.
There are certainly moments where the CGI looks surprisingly solid, but these are outweighed heavily by those effects sequences that evoke a distinct straight-to-video vibe.
3. The Plot Is Bloated & Unfocused

This movie is 121 minutes long and it really makes you feel that run-time by the end of it.
The most glaring issue is that the screenplay forces two separate scenarios upon the viewer: the submarine survival plot and an above-the-ground mission to retrieve the Russian President from a rogue Russian fortress.
It would've been far more interesting for the movie to focus on the claustrophobic tension of the submarine story rather than randomly cut in cheesy, Call of Duty-esque men-on-a-mission action sequences.
The result is a schizophrenic and bloated movie that doesn't appear to have much confidence in either of its competing plots, and just hopes for the best by nonchalantly switching between them.
2. It Takes Itself Way Too Seriously

A movie this fundamentally daft really needs to embrace its thorough silliness and just have some fun with it, but sadly Hunter Killer is a mostly self-serious, po-faced film without the necessary self-awareness to succeed.
The absurd dialogue and ridiculous political machinations are fired through with a total somber sincerity, which in turn proves unintentionally amusing.
It is effectively a cornball Hollywood action flick that doesn't want to admit it's such, and instead attempts to present itself as a legitimately plausible and stately film.
The problem clearly rests mostly with the humourless script and the cast's fairly on-the-level treatment of it, but one suspects with a more experienced director than no-namer Donovan Marsh, it could've turned out a little more fun and free-wheeling.
1. It's Insanely Generic

Hunter Killer is exactly the sort of film you'd expect to be created by a Hollywood computer algorithm if you asked it to magic a blockbuster up out of thin air.
It's got a solid cast, a decently timely premise and a stonking budget, and yet, the end result feels so utterly familiar and workmanlike.
There's zero inspiration to the way the movie is put together, feeling more like a film assembled by a team of studio executives than a filmmaker with their own singular vision.
From the cliched character development to the rote dialogue and mediocre action, it's all very much "been there, done that", to the extent that it could very nearly pass muster as a parody of these kinds of movies.
So, Hunter Killer is not a good film, then. But it isn't totally worthless, it has to be said, and if you go in with a knowing mindset, there are some sure chuckles to be had...
Ups...
3. The Solid Central Performances

Though the cast aren't exactly given killer material to work with here, they deserve a measure of credit for at least lending it an acceptable amount of gravitas.
Gerard Butler leads the pack as sub Commander Joe Glass, and while it's a bit of a shame he decides to rein in his usual hammy excesses, he ultimately manages to achieve an impressively subdued and, yes, commanding lead performance.
Toby Stevens is also perfectly cast as the gruff, wise-cracking Navy SEAL Lieutenant Bill Beaman, and seems to be one of the few actors truly in touch with the kind of movie he's starring in.
Linda Cardellini meanwhile does solid - if thankless - work as NSA analyst Jayne Norquist, and of course, we can't forget the late Michael Nyqvist, who gives a compelling turn as Russian sub Commander Captain Sergei Andropov in one of his final performances.
Again, the material sure ain't Oscar worthy, but the performances certainly rise above the low standard you're most likely expecting.
2. Its Amusing Political Message

It's something of a happy accident that Hunter Killer's fictional politics ended up intersecting with real-world politics.
After all, the movie was shot over two years ago, before Donald Trump had become President and various related Russian scandals had come to light, and yet by happenstance, the film has an oddly topical air to it regardless.
Its ultimate message, that we're all human beings and we need to co-operate in order to weed out bad actors in our midst, might be corny and ridiculously earnest, but in our current era of geopolitical uncertainty, it honestly feels a bit refreshing.
In a time where the U.S. President is promoting tribal nationalism more than ever, for a major Hollywood movie to embrace a "'we're all citizens of the world" mindset feels mildly rebellious. That it does this without waving American flags in the audience's sight-line the entire time makes it all the more audacious.
Few will praise the movie for having a nuanced understanding of international relations, but as a fever dream of global co-operation, it's something absurd to aspire to for sure.
1. The Entertainingly Silly Third Act

Though the vast majority of the movie is overly stern and serious, its barmy third act does at least deliver some of the heightened insanity you were probably hoping for.
From absurd, video game-esque shootouts to ridiculous CGI submarine manoeuvers and an hilarious final showdown, only in that final half-hour does the movie finally accept its wanton trashiness.
While it's a tough sell asking audiences to sit through an hour-plus of mediocrity to get to the fun stuff, at least the climax does deliver a literal boatload of silliness sure to leave you smiling on your way out of the cinema.
What did you think of Hunter Killer? Shout it out in the comments!