Ian McShane: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

From Deadwood to the dead wood of the Hercules actor's career.

This weekend sees the release of Hercules, the latest Hollywood attempt to cash in on the popularity of the Greek Myths in the absence of another Percy Jackson film. Picking up after his legendary twelve labours have been completed, the film sees Hercules (Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson) as a sword-for-hire to the King of Thrace (John Hurt). Directed by Brett Ratner of X-Men 3 notoriety, Hollywood executives will be hoping it fares a lot better (commercially at least) than The Legend of Hercules, which bombed back in January. While other writers on WhatCulture! have already written the film off, there is one grain of hope for film fans: a supporting performance by the eminently watchable Ian McShane. The graduate of British TV may not have reached the stratospheric heights of Hollywood in the way that his early career may have suggested, but even in his seventies he is still capable of turning in eye-catching, gleeful performances that can lift the cast around him. Certainly there's a lot more to him than chewing the scenery as Blackbeard in Pirates of the Caribbean (more on that later). But of course, like all the actors we've covered in these segments, McShane's career is far from a perfect one. For all the enthusiasm that he usually brings to a role, there are times when he's been coasting or just found wanting in an obvious way. Today we're looking back over his career, highlighting five performances which prove his acting chops and five which left us running for cover. We'll start at the top end of the scale with one of his rare forays into period drama...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Benjamin Disraeli - Disraeli (TV, 1978)

McShane isn't an actor you would naturally associate with a Tory Prime Minister. With his boyish good looks, roguish streak and knack for playing aggressive characters, you wouldn't expect him to flourish in a role rooted in the British establishment of the 19th century, but that's exactly what happened when he took on the role of two-time Conservative statesman Benjamin Disraeli in this highly-acclaimed four-part miniseries. Disraeli follows the eponymous politician over five decades of his life and career. Beginning with his early life and numerous political failings, it chronicles his fortunes under the Earl of Derby, his two terms as Prime Minister, and his famous feud with Liberal Party leader and fellow PM William Ewart Gladstone (John Carlisle), Through his actions, audiences gain an insight into the formation of the modern Conservative Party and the development of 'One-Nation' Conservatism. While its production values are nothing to write home about, Disraeli is a surprisingly detailed miniseries which brings a nuanced perspective to the intricate politics of Victorian England. McShane brings a certain amount of swashbuckling glamour to the part - looking at the above still, you might swear it was Mark Strong in Stardust. But he's far from a lightweight, carrying off the key debate scenes with elegance and bringing out the personal frustrations of Britain's only Jewish premier.

4. Lovejoy - Lovejoy (TV, 1986-94)

When most people hear the word 'antiques', they probably think of one of two things: either a bunch of middle-aged people standing around old objects telling dull stories, or the surviving cast of Last of the Summer Wine. But back in the 1980s and 1990s, as the Antiques Roadshow was finding its feet, there was a more exciting series which made antiques suddenly cool. That series was Lovejoy, and it made McShane a household name in the UK. Lovejoy is based on the series of picaresque novels by John Grant, and was co-written for the screen by Ian La Frenais, one half of the team behind Porridge and Flushed Away. Its lead character (McShane) is an unorthodox but lovable antique dealer, whose skill for spotting fakes or forgeries is second-to-none. Over six series and numerous specials, Lovejoy and his dim-witted assistant Eric Catchpole (Chris Jury) pull off numerous successful deals across East Anglia, exposing copious con artists along the way. Lovejoy is very much a product of its time, but it has aged pretty well compared to other comedy dramas from that period. Despite professing no love of antiques himself, McShane is clearly at ease in the part, cultivating great chemistry within the central cast and making much of the jargon accessible to a modern audience. While purists of the novels may complain about how much was toned down, there can be no denying McShane's charisma. He owns the screen for every second he's on it, effortlessly shifting from passionate anger to a winning smile.

3. Judas Iscariot - Jesus of Nazareth (TV, 1977)

In my article on Willem Dafoe last month, I spoke about the challenges of playing Jesus Christ. The fact is, however, that playing any of the characters in the Gospels can be a tall order: there's not always a wealth of material to work from, and it's easy to make a given part dull by over-egging the religious significance of his or her actions. If, as Sherlock says, "every fairy tale needs a good old-fashioned villain", so a compelling Jesus must have a convincing Judas - and with McShane in Jesus of Nazareth, we have one of the best. Directed by the great Italian auteur Franco Zefferelli, Jesus of Nazareth explores the life of Jesus (Robert Powell) in enormous detail, working from the four gospels as well as extra-Biblical sources. Co-written by Anthony Burgess (author of A Clockwork Orange), it depicts many of Jesus' most famous miracles as well as the calling of the individual disciples and of course the Crucifixion. The series features an all-star cast, including Anne Bancroft as Mary Magdelene, Laurence Olivier as Nicodemus and Christopher Plummer as Herod. Just as The Last Temptation of Christ focussed on a different aspect of Jesus' character, so Jesus of Nazareth makes an interesting departure in the depiction of Judas. Rather than portray him as a money-obsessed coward or disillusioned follower, he begins as a well-meaning man of good intentions who is ultimately duped into his betrayal by a non-Biblical character, Zerah (Ian Holm). McShane rises to the challenge in his second Jewish portrayal on this list, emphasising Judas' desire to do good for his people and his conflicted feelings towards Jesus as Holy Week unfolds. Clocking in at just over 6 hours, this miniseries is not for the faint-hearted, but if nothing else it's worth seeing for McShane and Powell going toe-to-toe in their scenes together.

2. Teddy Bass - Sexy Beast (2000)

Peter O'Toole once said that "great parts make great actors". No matter how highly skilled the performer is or how inventive the direction may be, if the character they present isn't well-written then the audience won't fully suspend their disbelief. McShane has had his fair share of duff roles over the years - we'll come onto those in a minute - but in 2000 he was handed a terrific script with an equally fine character marked out for him. That script became Sexy Beast, and that character was Teddy Bass. Directed by Jonathan Glazer (who later made Under The Skin), Sexy Beast is a crime drama from the team behind Gangster No. 1 and 44 Inch Chest (which also featured McShane). It stars Ray Winstone as Gary 'Gal' Dove, a former safe-cracker who is enjoying his retirement in Spain with his ex-porn star wife DeeDee (Amanda Redman). But his paradise is disrupted by the arrival of Don Logan (a career-best Ben Kingsley), a sociopathic former associate who has been sent from London to recruit Gal for a bank heist. Though a barrage of swear words, violence and other intimidation, Don eventually persuades Gal to take the job. Sexy Beast is a great British crime film, combining wonderfully surreal sequences with some of the most visceral and hysterical language you'll ever come across on screen. While Kingsley rightfully got the lion's share of the plaudits for his performance, McShane is more than capable of filling the void once Don completes his task. Teddy Bass is a meticulous, elegant yet violent man, who is deeply intimidating but so enigmatic that you find yourself wanting to spend more time with him. In any case, anyone who can hold their own against Ray Winstone has really done their homework.

1. Al Swearengen - Deadwood (TV, 2004-06)

While much of his best work has been in supporting roles, McShane should never be written off as nothing more than a very good second banana. On the rare occasions when he's had the limelight almost to himself, he has frequently delivered powerhouse performances which play on his unique delivery and domineering masculinity. But for all the good films he's been a part of, there is no better example than his role in Deadwood, for which he won a Golden Globe back in 2005. Created by David Milch of NYPD Blue fame, Deadwood is the story of the eponymous community in South Dakota. Set in the 1870s, when the future states of North and South Dakota were one territory, the series charts the rise of the community from its beginnings as a gold-mining camp to becoming a fully-fledged capitalist town. The show interweaves fiction and reality, with Milch drawing on historical diaries of Deadwood's residents to bring many of its most famous residents to life. McShane plays Al Swearengen, a ruthless and brutal man who runs the Gem Saloon and forms a series of murky political alliances over the show's three-year run. It would be easy for him to be played as a pantomime bad guy, but McShane find the humanity in him and in doing so makes him all the more monstrous and intimidating. As much as we disapprove of his abusive and murderous tendencies, we understand his motivations and his desire to bring Deadwood into the fold of the Dakota Territory. He creates a multi-layered, uniquely formed antagonist, and it remains his finest work to date. Having seen McShane's brilliance in Deadwood, now let's turn to the times when he was genuinely wooden...

... And 5 That Sucked

5. Ragnar Sturlusson - The Golden Compass (2007)

In 2002 New Line Cinema were looking for a new fantasy franchise, hoping to replicate the enormous acclaim and public enthusiasm for the first Lord of the Rings film. Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy certainly ticked a lot of boxes, being a highly popular series of novels set in multiple fantasy worlds full of strange creatures, creepy authorities and humanity dabbling with powers beyond its reckoning. But while Peter Jackson's trilogy flourished, The Golden Compass killed the franchise at instalment one, and McShane was not absolved from blame on that front. Based on the trilogy's first book Northern Lights, The Golden Compass follows Lyra Belacqua (Dakota Blue Richards), an orphaned girl living in a parallel universe similar to ours. In this world every human being has a daemon, an animal being which contains their soul. Orphan children are disappearing all over the world, and Lyra must travel north to avert the plans of her uncle Lord Asriel (Daniel Craig) and evade the clutches of Mrs. Coulter (Nicole Kidman). The film was directed by Chris Weitz, who went on to helm the second Twilight film. The Golden Compass was subject to huge production problems, during which time its pro-secular subject matter was severely watered down. All of that compromise is evident on screen, particularly in the rendering of the CG characters and their vocal performances. If McShane's performance in Coraline (which just missed out on this list) was the epitome of showmanship and confidence, this is altogether more confused. Even if we mitigate the dodgy CGI, he doesn't succeed in making Ragnar a threatening character, coming across as more grumpy than anything else.

4. Paul Griffen - We Are Marshall (2007)

It's hard to fathom the decision-making in Hollywood sometimes. Just as someone out there figured that it would be a good idea for Michael Bay to make a film about World War II, so someone thought that the director of the utterly empty-headed Charlie's Angels movies would be the right man to helm a tender sports drama. That man being McG, the result was a disaster, giving us McShane's next shameful performance. We Are Marshall is about the aftermath of the 1970 plane crash which claimed the lives of the entire Marshall University Thundering Herd American football team. Having considered shutting down the football programme entirely, University President Donald Dedmon (David Strathairn) is persuaded to hire a new coach in the shape of Jack Lengyel (Matthew McConnaughey). He sets about rebuilding the team in the face of much opposition, culminating in a much-anticipated game against the Morehead State Eagles. We Are Marshall is a classic example of 'right story, wrong director'; McG is at home in the kinetic sporting shots but he doesn't give space for the drama in-between to become genuine. If you want to see how to do this story properly, go and watch the TV movie United, which covers the Munich air disaster of 1958 which decimated Manchester United. McShane doesn't get much to do in the film, but he makes the very least of his part, failing to form a believable bond with McConnaughey and looking like he doesn't want to be there - like many of the actors in McG's films.

3. Blackbeard - Pirates Of The Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011)

When Gore Verbinski signed on to direct the first Pirates of the Caribbean, he could never have imagined that his bloated yet entertaining romp would re-invigorate a genre that had been sent to a watery grave with Cutthroat Island. Two terrible sequels later (both of which I covered here), Verbinski made for Rob Marshall, the man behind Chicago and Nine. Despite his best efforts, the result was depressingly awful, and McShane didn't exactly help matters. Nominally inspired on the novel On Stranger Tides by Tim Powers, On Stranger Tides sees Captain Jack Sparrow (Johnny Depp - duh) being sent on a quest by King George II (Richard Griffiths) to find the Fountain of Youth before the Spanish do. Teaming up with his old nemesis Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush), Sparrow sets sail and soon runs foul of an impersonator, Angelica (Penelope Cruz). Angelica is the daughter of the legendary Blackbeard, who practices voodoo magic - and the whole plot slowly un-spools from there. It's pretty much accepted that, along with Rush, McShane is one of the best things about On Stranger Tides. But that doesn't make it good by any means, with much of his screen time being taken up by a hamming-up contest between him and Depp. Despite the impressive wigs and make-up, his Blackbeard is far too pantomime to be remotely threatening, with the dialogue is far too ripe and silly to take him seriously. It's not McShane's worst performance, but it is one of his most disappointing given how good his villains have been in the past.

2. Frank Powell - Hot Rod (2007)

I consider myself a fan of cult cinema. I recognise the appeal of films which break a lot of the accepted rules of cinematic storytelling, and I've hosted radio programmes which have celebrated their unique appeal. But for all the time I've spent persuading audiences to see the likes of Logan's Run, Flash Gordon and The Magic Christian, there are some cult classics that I genuinely don't get. Hot Rod is one of those films, and it's also the place where we find one of McShane's laziest performances. Hot Rod is the first and so far only feature film from Akiva Schaffer, best known for his work on Saturday Night Live and for the comedy video 'Jizz In My Pants'. It follows Rod Kimble (Andy Samberg), whose late father supposedly worked with legendary daredevil Evel Knievel. Desperate to follow in his father's footsteps, Rod is hamstrung by a lack of talent and his stepfather Frank (McShane) who humilitiates him in their sparring matches. After Frank becomes ill and in need of a heart transplant, Rod resolves to jump the length of fifteen school buses and donate the proceeds towards the surgery. Hot Rod isn't a bad film so much as a misguided one. It can't decide whether it wants to be a throwback to 1980s comedies with adolescent jokes or a moving drama about family values. Much of the problem lies in McShane's performance, which falls down when presented with either of these options. His comic moments are too aggressive and mean to gel with the lighter, dorkier comedy between Rod and his friends, and when he tries to be dramatic he comes across as forced and mawkish. It's a thoroughly unconvincing performance - but not quite the worst of his career...

1. Joe Strombol - Scoop (2006)

In 2006 three films were released whose stories all revolved in some way around magic or illusions. There was The Prestige, Christopher Nolan's brilliant period drama about warring 19th-century magicians, featuring a brilliant supporting role for David Bowie as Nikola Tesla. There was The Illusionist, a capable story from Divergent director Neil Burger about a magician who uses his abilities to woo a woman in 19th-century Vienna. And then there was Scoop, one of Woody Allen's weakest films which gave us the low point of McShane's career. Scoop is a romantic comedy/ murder mystery which reunites Allen with his Match Point collaborator Scarlett Johansson. She plays Sondra Pransky, a beautiful but socially awkward American journalism student who is spending her holiday in London. One night she attends a magic show hosted by Sid Waterman (Allen), who calls her up from the audience to participate in a trick called 'The Dematerializer'. Once inside the box, she is visited by the ghost of reporter Joe Strombol, who tells her to hunt down Peter Lyman (Hugh Jackman), believed to be the legendary Tarot Card Killer who murdered numerous prostitutes. Scoop never received a UK theatrical release, and it isn't hard to see why. Like most of Allen's London-based work, it's shambolically assembled, generally unfunny, horribly forced and has all the suspense and dramatic intrigue of a sub-par Nancy Drew mystery. But while Johannson and Jackman both struggle to make their characters compelling, McShane is the worst offender among the cast, turning what could be an entertaining Basil Exposition-style role into a total drudge. He seems embarrassed to be there and delivers his lines without an ounce of commitment or charisma, resulting in the worst performance of his career. Disagree with my choices? Drop me a comment or visit Mumby at the Movies for more reviews.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance copywriter, film buff, community radio presenter. Former host of The Movie Hour podcast (http://www.lionheartradio.com/ and click 'Interviews'), currently presenting on Phonic FM in Exeter (http://www.phonic.fm/). Other loves include theatre, music and test cricket.