James Gandolfini: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

The Drop brings the curtain down on a screen great.

James Gandoflini The Drop Last year saw the tragic loss of one of the greatest, most versatile and humanistic performers working in Hollywood. James Gandolfini often played thuggish, violent characters, owing to his New Jersey heritage and large stature: in reality, the actor was an avowed pacifist who had reservations about the malicious conduct of his best-known character Tony Soprano, and produced two documentaries about post-traumatic stress and life-changing injuries suffered by war veterans. Gandolfini was an interesting guy. Refusing to be typecast despite being known to most audiences as a remorseless - if complicated - mobster, he managed to get through a great deal of diverse and interesting roles before suddenly dying of a heart attack, aged 51, during a vacation in Rome. He made his on-screen debut relatively late and all, with an uncredited part in 1991's The Last Boy Scout, before breaking through on The Sopranos some eight years later. An interesting guy and, in the few short decades he was working, one of the most interesting actors we had. Still, even a rose isn't without its thorns, and with the release of crime drama The Drop this weekend - almost certainly the last time he'll appear on screen - it's about time to look at five of James Gandolfini's best performances...and five that sucked.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Virgil - True Romance (1993)

There were a few small roles in films before this - The Last Boy Scout cameo, bit parts in forgotten flicks like A Stranger Among Us and Money For Nothing - but it was with his performance as henchman Virgil in True Romance that James Gandolfini finally stuck out for audiences. Tony Scott's adaptation of Quentin Tarantino's original script is a sort of darkly comic crime thriller, with Christian Bale's deranged comic shop employee heading on a killing spree across the states with former sex worker girlfriend Alabama. Along the way they come a cropper of Alabama's former pimp Drexl (Gary Oldman with dreadlocks), whose murder is assumed to be drugs-related and puts the entire criminal world of California on their tail. Which includes Christopher Walken as Don Vincenzo Coccotti, Brad Pitt as hopeless stoner Floyd, with Val Kilmer playing Bale's hallucinations of Elvis. Gandolifini manages to stand out in this insane ensemble with just one intense scene, where he interrogates Alabama in a hotel room on behalf of the mob. Frightening stuff.

4. Lt. Gen. George Miller - In The Loop (2009)

Gandolfini was best known for his dramatic works, but he was one of the few "proper" actors who managed to parlay his talents into comedic parts as well. Most notably with his turn in In The Loop, the big screen adaptation of Armando Iannucci's singularly sharp political satire The Thick Of It, with current Doctor Who star Peter Capaldi leading the pack as foul-mouthed adviser Malcolm Tucker. The film expanded the purview of the show across the Atlantic, which is where Gandolfini's pacifistic Lieutenant General Miller comes in. A loose commentary on the the Invasion of Iraq, Miller comes in as a military adviser who's against intervention in the Middle East. Some of the American cast struggles to match up to the towering talents from Britain, but Gandolfini acquits himself rather well: for the majority of the running time he's a gentle giant, but at the film's high point he manages to stand up to the formidable Tucker in a spectacularly violent and scatological tirade that needs to be seen to be believed.

3. CIA Director - Zero Dark Thirty (2012)

A very different view on the same conflict came in the form of Kathryn Bigelow's controversial depiction of the killing of Osama Bin Laden - a surprisingly divisive film for an actor so politically switched on (and so clearly left-leaning). Zero Dark Thirty wasn't anywhere near as jingoistic as some critics took it, however, with the depiction of the CIA operation that resulted in the death of their public enemy number one being neither glowing nor condemning. It merely attempted to create the most realistic adaptation of true events, something which actually landed the filmmakers in hot water with security services for a time. James Gandolfini again appears as part of an impressive ensemble that includes Jessica Chastain, Mark Strong and, erm, John Barrowman, and once again manages to tower against even that incredible set of acting talents. And again, it's only in a relatively small role that he manages to do that, as high-ranking government official €œJeremy€ (supposedly modelled on the former director of the CIA, Leon Panetta). It's a different kind of intensity he brought to the explosive Lieutenant Miller €“ let alone Tony Soprano €“ but a magnetic one nonetheless.

2. Carol - Where The Wild Things Are (2009)

Seriously, why do people not talk about this film more? Spike Jonze's adaptation of Maurice Sendak's classic children's book was non-traditional, to be sure, but it's probably also one of the most realistic and powerful depictions of childhood and imagination that's ever been committed to celluloid. Taking the book as a starting point, Where The Wild Things Are sees the young, angry Max leaving his suburban home - complete with single mother and annoying older sister - to a fantasy world of his own creation. Whilst there he meets the titular wild things - huge, furry monsters created using a mix of CGI and practical effects - which appear to represent different aspects of his own personality, which Max struggles to reconcile. Each wild thing has a pretty great actor behind their voice, but Gandolfini stands out as Carol, the "leader" of the monsters before Max shows up. Tears shed during Max's departure from the island and abandonment of the monsters is as much down to Gandolfini's vocal performance as the pained look on Carol's face.

1. Tony Soprano - The Sopranos (1999)

This probably didn't come as a surprise to anybody. Nor should it: whilst it probably didn't help a whole lot with the typecasting problem, Tony Soprano was definitely the role of James Gandolfini's career. David Chase's Mafia drama was ground breaking in terms of television dramas, paving the way for the likes of Mad Men and Breaking Bad - but also for its lead character, who was infinitely more complex and interesting than basically any TV protagonist that came before him. Well, sort of protagonist. The morals of Tony Soprano were a little skew-whiff throughout the show, something which made for both interesting plot developments and gave the character something to tell his therapist. Mobster characters - especially of the Italian-American variety - have existed in caricature for so long, Gandolfini demands praise for creating one that was so three dimensional as to be real. Horribly, terrifyingly convincing. If only the same could be said for every part in his filmography...

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Mayor Of New York - The Taking Of Pelham 123 (2009)

James Gandolfini finally reconvened with director Tony Scott several years after True Romance €“ and really, they needn't have bothered. The Taking Of Pelham 123 was a great, taut little seventies thriller, based on the novel by Morton Freedgood and starring the likes of Walter Matthau and Robert Shaw. The 2009 remake, meanwhile, stars Denzel Washington on one of his off days (which tended to align with the times he worked with the inconsistent Scott), and John Travolta with a funny haircut. It wasn't a very good remake, nor a particularly good film. The Mayor Of New York was originated by Lee Wallace in the original film, with Gandolfini taking up the mantle for the remake. It's an interesting character, one who's balancing being pragmatic with the hostage situation aboard the New York subway train Travolta has held up and trying to make sure he looks good to the public. A lot of pressure in that job, y'know. Unfortunately the hackneyed script and pedestrian direction don't give him much to work with, leading to an incredibly ordinary performance.

4. Ben Pinkwater - Terminal Velocity (1994)

Actors like James Gandolfini don't trade much in bad performances €“ rather, it's their poor choice in films, or else being lumbered with entirely ordinary parts unlike their usual fare, that really hampers them. Nowhere is that more obvious than this mostly-forgotten and god awful popcorn flick from the summer of 1994, starring Charlie Sheen as a skydiving instructor who somehow gets mixed up with Russian spies trying to recover a shipment of gold. Yes, this is an actual film that was made. To be fair to Gandolfini, he doesn't do a bad job in the role of Ben Pinkwater, a seemingly mild-mannered insurance man who turns out to be a violent Russian gangster. The twist is handled surprisingly well, he doesn't butcher the accent too much, and he's obviously the right sort of build for a mob enforcer. But he's also appearing in Terminal Velocity, an absolute turkey of a film, in a part that's even more underwritten than your average Bond henchman. You know, the ones who are usually mute.

3. Eddie - The Juror (1996)

Terminal Velocity was, unfortunately, partially responsible for getting him typecast as a mobster type for years after. Thankfully that lead to some of the best acting of his career, but the immediate after effect was to lumber him in lots of crummy film that nobody bothered watching outside of their breath cinematic runs. One such strikingly mediocre movie was The Juror, in which Gandolfini played a mob enforcer with a conscience. Sounds familiar, eh? Slightly less celebrated than The Sopranos, mind. In fact it holds a 14% on Rotten Tomatoes and star Demi Moore earned a Razzie for her performance as Annie Laird, a single mother and sculptor who gets picked for jury duty for a mafia trial. Alec Baldwin, meanwhile, appears as a mobster sent to intimidate her, wining and dining her and then asking her to lay off. When he murders her best friend, just to let her know he's serious, Gandolfini's Eddie is the one who tries to get him done for it. He's more plot device than character. What a waste.

2. Pat - Not Fade Away (2012)

One of the more surprising dark patches in Gandolfini's filmography was his reunion with The Sopranos creator David Chase. Surely such a project would be cause for celebration, as one of the most fruitful collaborations in modern popular culture finally come back together to make something new? Apparently not, since Not Fade Away came out two years ago and barely anybody has heard of it. Why would the cinematic directorial debut from the creator of The Sopranos make more waves? Because it's a bit naff, that's why. The Sopranos was a ballsy, complex and drama. Not Fade Away is a cheesy, nostalgic period drama seen through rose-tinted glasses, with teenager Douglas Damiano clearly being a Mary Sue insert character for Chase to live out his adolescent fantasy of being in a successful rock band during his favourite era for music in history. Gandolfini, meanwhile, is saddled with the thankless task of playing Doug's ailing and abusive father Pat. In The Juror he's nothing more than a plot device; in Not Fade Away, he exists purely to give the main character motivation. What a bore.

1. Tom Valco - Surviving Christmas (2004)

You know you're off to a bad start when you're watching a Christmas film in October. That was just the final nail in the coffin of Surviving Christmas, which DreamWorks elected to release in a thoroughly unseasonable slot so as not to clash with their other Ben Affleck film, Paycheck (which, as everybody knows, was a stonking success and didn't dissipate into obscurity). Another bad sign: the film was released on DVD just two months after the theatrical run ended. Oh, and the other big issue with Surviving Christmas it that it's bloody awful. Spectacularly terrible. Awful Christmas films are a dime a dozen, but rarely do they star so many actors who should've known better. And rarely are they ranked 91st in the 100 worst reviewed films of the 2000s, with a rating of 7%, on Rotten Tomatoes, or do they earn nominations for three Razzie Awards, including Worst Picture, Worst Actor and Worst Screenplay. Gandolfini can't be blamed for this whole mess, obviously, but his part as Tom Valco - a suburban dad who deals with Affleck's aggrieved ad exec showing up an demanding to spend Christmas with his family, because they live in his childhood home - didn't much help matters.

Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/