Jesse Eisenberg: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked
From Facebook founder to billionaire megalomaniac… wait, is there even a difference?

Zombies, the CIA and Andrew Garfield – Jesse Eisenberg loves to pick a fight.
Probably best-known for his star-making role as real-life internet genius and billionaire Mark Zuckerberg in David Fincher’s The Social Network, Eisenberg has popped up in a huge range of films, from surreal indie comedies like Zombieland and The Double to epic superhero blockbuster Batman V Superman.
Whether he goes, though, there is a distinct set of Eisenbergish traits that come with him: a skittish, manic energy, motor-mouthed intellectualism (like an American Russell Brand if you actually understood what he was saying) and a restrained quirkiness.
This week sees Eisenberg return as Danny Atlas, the head illusionist of the Four Horsemen in Now You See Me 2, a follow-up to the absolutely ludicrous but romping magician face-off from a few years back which audiences seemed to love – even if critics were less friendly to it (although it’s not the only Eisenberg-starring film to divide viewers and critics)/
Nearly all of Eisenberg’s performances are worth watching – even if some are a distinct step-up from others. Let’s take a look at five awesome appearances that really make the case for Eisenberg as one of the best young actors working today, before diving into five performances that sucked – showing even the greatest actors have off days…
5 Awesome Performances
5. James Brennan - Adventureland (2009)

One of Eisenberg’s first leading performances, Adventureland pairs him brilliantly opposite Kristen Stewart to produce one of the most charming couples in any teenage coming-of-age comedy.
Even surrounded by a cast full of big names like Ryan Reynolds, Bill Hader and Kristen Wiig, Eisenberg’s theme park worker and part-time stoner James Brennan stands out in his plight to save up for university and helps Superbad director Greg Mottola to walk the line between his trademark crude humour and genuinely touching moments.
Of particular note is the closing scene, where Eisenberg passionately monologues about the universal need to embrace your screw-ups while standing in the rain. Plus, there's the scene where he gets an awkward erection in a swimming pool, which perfectly demonstrates the actor’s ability to flip effortlessly from being charmingly collected to racked with anxiety.
4. Columbus - Zombieland (2009)

The role that really set things in motion for Eisenberg, Zombieland doesn’t just share a similarity in name with Adventureland; it also came out the very same year, 2009, and once again let Eisenberg show off his skill in jumping from being confident and witty to flappable when faced with particular situations (normally involving women, this time around: Emma Stone). Oh, and they both reallllllly like theme parks.
Eisenberg’s own experience coping with obsessive-compulsive disorder is perfectly mirrored in Columbus’ list of 33 rules (Although eagled-eyed viewers will spot that there are actually at least 49…) to follow in order to avoid becoming dinner for the undead. Naturally, he then demonstrates almost all of them, from ‘Beware of bathrooms’ and ‘Check the backseat’ to the more obvious entries like ‘Cardio’ and ‘Double tap’.
As anyone who has seen the film knows, Columbus also ends up breaking a few of his own rules as he grows increasing fond of Stone’s Wichita. And through it all Eisenberg once again proves an alternative male heartthrob – who knew that accidentally murdering Bill Murray was such a turn-on?
3. Simon James/James Simon - The Double (2013)

Another Eisenberg film, another odd couple romantic pairing. This time, he plays Simon James, a downtrodden worker with a crush on Mia Wasikowska’s Hannah. But it’s not just Wasikowska that Eisenberg has to play opposite – it’s also himself.
That’s right, in a Tom Hardy-in-Legend or Lindsay Lohan-in-Parent Trap (the best one, obviously – but that’s a different article) turn, Eisenberg also plays James Simon, Simon James’ identical doppelganger. Get it? Because it’s just his name, reversed…
Anyway, Eisenberg puts in a superb double whammy as both the passive Simon and the outgoing James, who eventually butt (matching) heads over Hannah. Richard Ayoade’s script and direction set the scene for a surreal Brazil-like dark comedy in which Eisenberg delivers all of the (non) punchlines with razor-sharp deadpan. How can a pan be razor-sharp? Don’t ask me, but it works.
The Double hinges on Eisenberg’s performance(s) and he absolutely nails it/them. Many critics felt that it was his best work since The Social Network – even though the film had a much smaller audience than a Fincher movie about the biggest website in the world.
If you haven’t seen it, you really should – not least for the brilliant and shocking ending, which works all thanks to Eisenberg.
2. David Lipsky - The End Of The Tour (2015)

By this point, you’ve probably guessed what number one will be. However, you might not have guessed that Eisenberg’s second-best performance is also based on a real-life person.
In The End Of The Tour he plays Rolling Stone journalist David Lipsky as he interviews and takes a five-day road trip with acclaimed writer David Foster Wallace, played by How I Met Your Mother’s Jason Segel, shortly after the publication of seminal novel Infinite Jest.
While Segel’s Wallace is the centre point of the movie, it’s Eisenberg’s Lipsky who drives the stunningly deep discussion of life and everything in it, from alcoholism and personal identity to art and the effect of fame.
Outside of acting, Eisenberg is himself a writer and playwright, and said that he jumped at the part due to his love of Wallace’s writing, spending time with the real Lipsky (De Niro driving a taxi for Taxi Driver-style) to perfect his portrayal of the journo.
His passion and effort shows on screen – all the more impressive given that for much of the time he remains silent, letting Wallace speak into his tape recorder, with Eisenberg expressing with a single facial expression or reaction what pages of text couldn’t.
Jason Segel may have gathered most of the acting props for the masterful movie, but – like Lipsky opposite Wallace – Eisenberg’s quiet yet powerful presence is absolutely undeniable.
1. Mark Zuckerberg - The Social Network (2010)

Come on, admit it: when you heard a film was being made about the founding of Facebook by Mark Zuckerberg, you probably rolled your eyes and went ‘Like that will ever work’. It’s okay, we all did it.
But what fools we were! Backed by the dream team of writer Aaron Sorkin and director David Fincher, The Social Network turned out to be a modern masterpiece – and key to its success is the portrayal of Zuckerberg himself by Eisenberg.
The core traits that made Eisenberg a solid performer in everything I’ve listed so far - his nervous energy layered over quietly confident genius – was the perfect fit for Zuckerberg’s multifaceted personality. He simmers as he creates Thefacebook as a young student, boiling over years later as he clashes with former pal and Facebook co-founder Eduardo Saverin, played by future Spider-Man Andrew Garfield (quick bit of trivia: Garfield hooked up in real-life with Eisenberg’s on-screen Zombieland crush Emma Stone, for all you six degrees of separation fans out there.)
Among a flawless cast, Eisenberg is the driving force, putting in a performance as revelatory and influential as the entrepreneur he plays. He paints an admirable, despicable, heartless, emotional, passionate, cold picture of Zuckerberg – ensuring The Social Network will be a classic for decades to come.
But despite his extreme highs, Eisenberg has also put some real stinkers onto the big screen. Here are 5 that sucked…
5 That Sucked
5. Blu - Rio 2 (2014)

Okay, maybe I’m being a little harsh to slam a sequel to a film about an animated bird immediately after lauding one of the greatest films ever made, but it’s got to be said: Rio 2 is a bit of a let-down.
Eisenberg plays a blue Spix’s macaw who somewhat unoriginally is called Blu. He’s the mate to Anne Hathaway’s feathered counterpart Jewel, and the bird daddy to three children. Now the first Rio was a solid enough, if unremarkable, kids’ film, but this unnecessary follow-up just hammers home the old belief that sequels normally suck.
Eisenberg isn’t to blame for all of the film’s problems, but his delivery hardly sets the world on fire, and even he sounds a little tired of the series just two films in. Part of the issue seems to be that the pinpoint deadpan humour he’s able to master in films like The Double – or even the more outlandish comedy of Zombieland - doesn’t translate to a CGI bird and slapstick jokes aimed at young viewers.
It would be unfair to call it an unwatchable performance, but for an actor renowned for his skill in balancing emotional resonance and witty dialogue, Rio 2 stops Eisenberg from showing off his best elements.
4. Mike Howell - American Ultra (2015)

Reuniting Eisenberg with Adventureland’s Kristen Stewart, American Ultra looks on paper to be the perfect film: smart stoner comedy, action-packed fight scenes like Kick-Ass or Kingsman, and a script penned by Chronicle writer Max Landis.
Sadly, though it certainly has its good bits, American Ultra falls flat. Eisenberg and Stewart fail to spark in the same way they did before and seem a little out of their element – who can blame them, as the film clumsily mashes together more ingredients than a season of the Great British Bake-Off?
Eisenberg occasionally shines as he returns to his well of understated comedy performances, but he’s not a great fit for the fast-paced action scenes and struggles to sell pothead-cum-superpowered CIA agent Mike Howell once he swaps buds and spliffs for bombs and knife fights.
Unlike some of the entries coming up, Eisenberg remains likeable – but too many joke deliveries fall flat. Or maybe he has us all fooled, and his portrayal of someone stoned out of their mind is just that good.
3. J. Daniel 'Danny' Atlas - Now You See Me (2013)

In Eisenberg’s healthy filmography of memorable characters, J. Daniel ‘Danny’ Atlas wouldn’t even make the list.
The cocksure leader of Now You See Me’s band of thief magicians, the Four Horseman, Atlas comes across as a confident, clever and sharp-tongued illusionist. ‘Great,’ you think, ‘the perfect fit for Eisenberg.’
But there’s a caveat: while Eisenberg’s best genius assholes are underpinned with a layer of neurosis, Atlas somewhat ironically appears to have no such complexity up his sleeve. All of his tricks have a secret factor that unlocks their magic, but even Eisenberg can’t rescue Atlas from becoming an unlikeable cliché.
This is despite the film placing Eisenberg back into a proven formula, as Zombieland co-star Woody Harrelson plays fellow Horseman Merritt McKinney. In fact, at points it seems as though the entire cast could’ve been filmed in different rooms given their complete lack of chemistry.
Having said this, audiences seemed to be won over by Eisenberg and his crew, resulting in this year’s sequel and the announcement of a third film in the series. (Now You Three Me?) As they say, maybe magic just relies on distraction – in this case, from Eisenberg’s third-worst performance to date.
2. Jimmy Myers - Cursed (2005)

There’s a very good chance you haven’t heard of Cursed, even though it’s directed by one of the horror genre’s most iconic masterminds, Wes Craven, and stars big-name actors Eisenberg and Christina Ricci as a brother and sister battling against werewolves in LA.
Here’s the reason for that: the film stinks. Largely disowned by its cast and crew after release, Cursed took around five years to be made as it suffered various production issues and ultimately released to universally negative reviews and claims that it was ‘the worst werewolf movie ever made’.
A pre-widespread fame Eisenberg plays Jimmy Myers, who becomes infected by a werewolf bite and accidentally turns his dog into a hellish beast. Try as he might, Eisenberg fails to sell neither the horror nor the comedy of the film. Particularly bad is a scene where he connects dots to draw a pentagram on his palm and rattles off about the interplay between fiction and reality, before convincing his sister to pick up a silver picture frame to check if she is a werewolf.
Flashes of Eisenberg’s future brilliance are present under the surface, but all in all he comes across as a young actor yet to find his own voice, instead submitting to a run-of-the-mill performance.
1. Lex Luthor - Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice (2016)

Here it is: the big one. And boy, is it big. This year’s Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice stirred millions of film fans up, for both good and bad reasons.
I’m not here to argue whether the film itself is any good (it’s not) or if Ben Affleck makes a decent Batman (he does). One thing that I think everyone can agree on is that Eisenberg’s performance as Superman big bad Lex Luthor is pretty bloody terrible.
Saddled with a script that’s able as subtle as a breezeblock to the face ("You flew too close to the sun", "Devils don't come from hell beneath us - they come from the sky" and other eye-rolling examples abound), Eisenberg admittedly has a lot of work to do in order to try and turn Luthor back into the menacing but intellectually brilliant figure of the comics.
Only he doesn’t. Instead, he doubles-down on Luthor’s laughable exaggeration, playing him like a cross between a Jack Nicholson-era Joker and an amateur pantomime villain. All of Eisenberg’s best acting abilities – fast-paced delivery, smart dialogue, physical expression – are turned on their head and used not for nuance or characterisation but to insert a comic book performance into a film that is trying to take itself very seriously.
Luthor babbles away about nothingness in every scene he’s in, spouting random comments about the nature of god and man without ever really explaining quite why he hates Superman so much. This reaches a peak at the film’s climax, as Eisenberg’s performance ramps up (who thought that even possible?) alongside the increasing ridiculous spectacle on screen.
It’s a huge shame, as Luthor shares much in common with Eisenberg’s greatest character: like Zuckerberg, he’s a smart individual with almost unlimited resources driven to create something great, who comes up against the threat of someone who might challenge his claim to fame. But what we get instead is a barely one-dimensional caricature that not only ignores the strengths of its source, but also wastes the potential of a hugely talented actor.
What's your favourite Jesse Eisenberg performance? And what's his worse? Share your take down in the comments.