Jigsaw Review: 3 Ups & 7 Downs

The "reboot" nobody needed.

Jigsaw Bucket
Lionsgate

The Saw franchise is back with the long-gestating sequel-reboot Jigsaw, because Saw VIII just isn't a good look. Even though the series' dedicated fanbase has been highly anticipating the follow-up, it's safe to say that expectations were never particularly high for this being anything more than a warmed-over retread...and that's basically exactly what it is.

Jigsaw recycles the series' most base elements without bringing much new to the table, and even scaling things back in some respects, while hoping that a new generation of gorehounds might propel it back to box office glory (which it currently looks like they will).

It's certainly not among the worst horror sequels you'll ever see, but it's just a disappointingly familiar, unimaginative attempt to breathe life back into a series that had a perfectly respectable seven-movie run.

Most disappointing of all is that Jigsaw just doesn't offer much hope or intrigue for the future, except a glut of more listless sequels until the box office grosses start dwindling again (and it gets rebooted...again...probably on Netflix this time)...


Downs...

7. It's Tamer Than Previous Movies

Jigsaw Corn Silo
Lionsgate

Though there are some undeniably grisly sequences in Jigsaw, overall the focus has been pulled away from the comically over-the-top death scenes towards a more sparing, even tasteful sort of blood-letting, which may disappoint fans who've stuck with the series this long.

Aside from two or three grotesque moments, for the most part this feels like a tame attempt to broaden the franchise's appeal to those turned off by the "torture porn" label, but as a result it ends up feeling rather limp and ineffective.

It doesn't help that Jigsaw has the lowest body count of the series, which again will leave the gorehounds desperately craving more.


6. The Twists Are Dumb & Predictable

Jigsaw Billy
Lionsgate

It wouldn't be a Saw movie without a plot twist, and while even the lesser Saw movies tended to serve up entertainingly bonkers reveals, this is another area where Jigsaw sadly falls short.

The third act unfurls several twists in succession, but none of them hit with the desired impact because they're either hilariously predictable, lazy repetitions of previous twists in the series, overly contrived (even for the standards of this franchise) or require an audience investment in the continuation of the Saw movies that even the hardcore crowd might struggle to muster after eight films.

You'll likely roll your eyes rather than be blown away by the demented genius of it all, to be honest.


5. It Totally Wastes The Spierig Brothers

Jigsaw Tape
Lionsgate

There was some cautious optimism about this movie when it was announced that The Spierig Brothers would be directing it, given their entertaining two prior films, Daybreakers and Predestination.

Though they do absolutely fine work, especially given the fairly tawdry directing standards of the franchise, their talents are nevertheless completely wasted in a movie this shoddily written.

While they don't embarrass themselves at all, it's a shame they took a detour from low-key genre fare into a straight-up payday like this, but hopefully their upcoming Helen Mirren-starring horror movie Winchester: The House That Ghosts Built might get them back on track.


4. The Dull, Unimaginative Traps

Jigsaw Shotgun
Lionsgate

Perhaps the most disappointing thing about Jigsaw is that the traps are really, really dull for the most part. Lacking the darkly comic bent of the earlier films in the series, most of this movie's traps feel like lazy tweaks on earlier ones, but without any of the amusing moral relativism.

Most of the traps feel like they were thought up in a half-hour pitch meeting rather than given much creative input, which is ultimately emblematic of the movie entire: rushed, lazy, and given the seven years it spent in gestation, ludicrously underwhelming.

If you were hoping for something as outrageously satirical as Saw VI's Pound of Flesh trap, it's probably best to stick to your Blu-ray collection.


3. The Terrible Editing & Pacing

Jigsaw Logan
Lionsgate

Even though Jigsaw clocks in at a svelte 92 minutes, it still feels like a slog at times, in large part due to the horrendous pacing, with the script frequenting darting back-and-forth between the traps and Detective Halloran's investigation of the new Jigsaw crimes, even though the latter is extremely uninteresting.

Oddly enough, the film even cuts back to the investigation mid-trap on more than one occasion, which undercuts any potential suspense and again feels like Lionsgate attempting to push the series further away from its torture porn label by focusing less on the traps themselves.

The script unfortunately believes that the talky thriller narrative is much more interesting than it actually is, making a good half of the film feel almost unbearably snoozy at times.


2. It's Got An Awful Sequel Hook

Jigsaw Billy
Lionsgate

It's not a spoiler to say that Jigsaw has been made as an attempt to reboot and reinvigorate the Saw franchise, to kick off another run of movies over the next few years for a new generation of horror fans.

Unfortunately, Jigsaw concludes with only the least imaginative and, yes, laziest of sequel hooks, one so thoughtless and obvious you probably assumed they wouldn't dare do it.

Of course, whether a sequel actually materialises or not depends entirely on how the film performs at the box office, but early projections suggest it's probably going to open very healthily, almost certainly guaranteeing Saw 9 (or Jigsaw 2) this time next year. Brace yourself.


1. It's The Worst Film In The Series

Jigsaw Halloran
Jigsaw

While it's not terribly surprising to hear that the eighth movie in a horror franchise is the worst (just look at Friday the 13th and Halloween), it's at least a little disappointing that Jigsaw, planned as a reinvention of the series, lands at the bottom of the pile.

Though Saw V was a boring dumpster fire and Saw 3D saw the series at its absolute silliest, Jigsaw's more mild tone and penchant for rehashing the series' greatest hits makes it the absolute rock-bottom the franchise has hit to date.

Yes, it's not the worst-of-show in every aspect of its creation, but in terms of the overall product, it is the dullest and least-watchable of the lot.

Yet as much as the movie basically sucks, it didn't quite get everything wrong...


Ups...

3. It's The Best-Looking Saw Movie

Jigsaw Corn Silo
Lionsgate

Though the film falls short of its predecessors in most departments, make no mistake that Jigsaw is easily the best-looking of all the Saw movies.

For starters, the cinematography and lighting are decidedly more cinematic, evoking less the feel of a low-budget TV show and more resembling an actual, well, movie.

Furthermore, the editing is less chaotic and there are less cheesy effects, with the Spierig Brothers' more restrained direction ultimately classing things up somewhat, even if the script totally lets them down.


2. The Performances Are Rock Solid

Jigsaw Anna
Lionsgate

The Saw movies have been pretty up-and-down in terms of performances, and even the classic original had some howlingly wonky moments (especially Cary Elwes hamming it up), but you know what? Jigsaw isn't half bad here.

The casting is totally rock solid throughout, and even though the characters are mostly bland cardboard cutouts, the actors do their best to imbue them with...something. Especially praise-worthy are Laura Vandervoort as Anna, Paul Braunstein as Ryan and Hannah Emily Anderson as Eleanor.

And of course, Tobin Bell once again lending his voice to Jigsaw is an undeniable delight, absurd though it is that he's still around some five movies after John Kramer was killed.


1. The Terrific Gore Effects

Jigsaw Ryan
Lionsgate

Though the gore is decidedly dialled down in this instalment, the little that's there is well-executed for the most part. The glimpse of a head sliced in half, for instance, is stomach-churningly detailed and has clearly had more money poured into it than pretty much any prosthetic effect in any of the prior movies.

There's also one hilariously over-the-top gore sequence in the third act that, though largely achieved through CGI, lacks the cheesiness of some of the earlier movies' cheap-looking effects, and is generally a good deal more convincing.

Again, there's not enough of it, but what's there feels visceral and genuinely intense.

What did you think of Jigsaw? Shout it out in the comments!


In this post: 
jigsaw
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.