Joel Edgerton: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Checking out the highlights and lowlights from Hollywood's latest, greatest Australian import.

Ever since Mel Gibson made a splash with the first Mad Max film, Hollywood has had an ongoing love affair with actors who have cut their teeth in Australasian movies and television. While the success of some seems inexplicable (Jai Courtney lacks any obvious talent) others have brought a great deal to the cinematic table. Joel Edgerton is undoubtedly one of the most talented to have emerged from the region, turning out a number of intelligent and effective performances since he first appeared in a small role in the Star Wars prequels. Possessing rugged good looks and world-weary eyes which add layers of intensity to his best performances, of all the Australasian actors working in Hollywood today he's one likely to go far. Equally adept behind the camera as he is in front of it, his new film The Gift, which he wrote, produced and directed as well as taking on a lead role, is due out this weekend. A dark, psychological thriller starring Jason Bateman, it has already received rapturous reviews, with one critic describing it as "damn near perfect for his feature debut." Like most actors, Joel Edgerton's career hasn't always been on the up, and while many of his performances have been exceptional, others have left something to be desired. To mark the release of The Gift here are 5 awesome Joel Edgerton performances and 5 that sucked...

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Ramses - Exodus: Gods And Kings

Exodus: Gods And Kings marked yet another low point in the career of the once-great director Ridley Scott. Overlong, overblown and surprisingly weak when it came to spectacle, its poor performance at the box office could signal the nail in the coffin for future Scott historical epics. While the film is certainly hugely flawed, the blame for its failure certainly doesn't lie on the actors, and Joel Edgerton's performance as Egyptian Pharaoh Ramses is a high point. With his shaved head and gold-laden garb he certainly looks the part, but it's his neurotic, rage-fuelled intensity which amplifies the conflicted nature of his character perfectly. Ramses has a tendency to switch on the violence whenever he feels as if guilt or doubt - or a combination of the two - might get the better of his conscience, and Edgerton encapsulates these transitions without ever feeling the need to ham things up.

4. Dave Flannery - Wish You Were Here

With Wish You Were Here, Joel Edgerton took his career in more naturalistic directions than ever before. More than a few scenes see him stood with a look of nervous exhaustion etched on his face, struggling to decide what course of action to take next. While holidaying in Cambodia with his pregnant wife and friends, Dave (Edgerton) finds himself caught up in the mystery of the disappearance of their friend Jeremy, last seen during an ecstasy-fueled party. With revelations of infidelity and a plot thread involving child prostitution, the events increasingly come to bear on him as the truth of what transpired begins to reach the cold light of day. Edgerton's performance dominates Wish You Were Here from start to finish, each layer of deceit adding to the weight of his portrayal of a man loaded with secrets and grasping with the truth. It's one of his least known roles, and also one of his best.

3. Detective Malcolm Toohey - Felony

Edgerton proved that he was more than capable of simply playing characters with 2014's Felony, a crime thriller for which he wrote the screenplay in addition to appearing in the starring role. He plays Malcolm Toohey, a detective who becomes caught up in a web of lies after he's involved in a fatal accident while driving home over the legal alcohol limit. Jai Courtney (in one of his few performances where he actually feels like his character has a personality) and Tom Wilkinson play the other detectives caught up in the investigation, but it's Edgerton who dominates the film. Understatement is the key word in Felony, and Edgerton's pivotal role is played out with an assured restraint. The way in which tension is sustained effectively throughout the film is in no small part on account of his borderline melancholy performance.

2. Brendan Conlon - Warrior

If you're an up and coming Hollywood star it feels like it's obligatory to buff up at one point or another and prove yourself in the ring - in the case of Warrior that ring is a literal one, and Edgerton toned up alongside Tom Hardy to play a mixed martial artist teacher returning to the ring to fight his brother. Sports movie fans had a field day with Warrior, and it's a testament to Joel Edgerton that he was able to hold his own on screen alongside Tom Hardy, another great actor enjoying a similar career trajectory in recent years. Playing brothers, their on-screen chemistry is striking leading to the emotional punch (forgive the pun) in the film's finale. Edgerton and Hardy (Warrior is essentially a double act) balance the action in the ring with some subtle scenes of their personal lives, with Edgerton's reluctant warrior making him more compelling than most characters found in similar sports dramas.

1. Barry 'Baz' Brown - Animal Kingdom

Joel Edgerton found himself in the company of some real Australian acting heavyweights in Animal Kingdom, proving that he could easily hold his own alongside the best the country has to offer, including Guy Pearce, Ben Mendelsohn and Jackie Weaver. The Aussie criminal underworld forms the backdrop for this story of a dysfunctional family, with Edgerton playing Barry "Baz" Brown, a crook with a history of violence and armed robbery who wants out of the game. As always with these kind of crime thrillers which zoom in on the low lifes which inhabit cities across the world, going straight is never as simple as it should be. Again, it's Edgerton's ability to articulate the subtleties of his character without ever feeling the need to overact which makes his performance here so compelling. We feel his fatigue in his eyes and don't need the dialogue to articulate this any further - the sign of a great actor at work. Read on to find out when Edgerton wasn't quite so awesome...

... And 5 That Sucked

5. Jim Green - The Odd Life Of Timothy Green

There's something annoyingly twee and overly sweet about The Odd Life Of Timothy Green, that gives you the impression of the cinematic equivalent of a sugar-heavy diet - it's a feeling familiar to anyone who's watched their fair share of Disney live action movies. The Odd Life Of Timothy Green is a Disney feel-good movie through and through, telling of a married couple (played by Joel Edgerton and Jennifer Garner) unable to have kids of their own who discover the mysterious boy Timothy on their doorstep one night. Cue a barrage of cliched scenes of small town America, with Edgerton doing his small town dad thing as best he can. This is a performance characterised by "aw shucks!" grinning and shrugging; earnest pep talks which feel saccharine in the extreme; cries of "don't listen to the coach, son! You can do it!" Hardly Edgerton's fault, but not worth putting yourself through unless you really, really must.

4. Tom Buchanan - The Great Gatsby

It has to be said that there are far more problems with Baz Luhrmann's admittedly ambitious adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby than Edgerton's performance, from the inexplicably cardboard cut-out 3D sequences to the near-total absence of the novel's scathing critique of the American Dream. That said, while many of the performances waver in The Great Gatsby, Edgerton's take on Tom Buchanan is decidedly one-note, as if Luhrmann couldn't be bothered to give him any direction and, for want of anything else to do he simply maintained the same boorishness in every scene. He certainly gets this simplistic rendering of the character down pat, but while it's fair to say that blame for this simplistic rendering of a more complex character rests partially on other shoulders, Edgerton could have turned off the autopilot and upped the ante a little more.

3. Gawain - King Arthur

Often there's only so much even a great actor can do with the material he's given (unless you have the ego of a star like Russell Crowe, in which case you believe you can make any sh*t sound amazing). This was certainly the case with King Arthur, in which Edgerton does very little other than look ruggedly handsome. Directed by the king of the mediocre, mid-budget action movie Antoine Fuqua (who began his directing career ruining any chance Chow Yun-fat had of being a big star in the West with the risible The Replacement Killers), it stars Clive Owen as Arthur, with Edgerton in a supporting role as one of his knights, Gawain. It's a generically moody performance which barely registers once the film has finished, but Edgerton isn't entirely to blame - other great actors starring alongside him, including Mads Mikkelson and Ray Winstone, are similarly unmemorable in their roles in what is ultimately a completely forgettable movie.

2. Sam Carter - The Thing

Maybe it's because I have such fond memories of growing up with John Carpenter's version of The Thing, itself a remake of The Thing From Another World, that makes it so difficult for me to find anything good to say about the 2011 remake/reboot. There's probably some truth to that, but even striving to be as objective as possible it's clear that Edgerton's role doesn't hold a candle - or flamethrower - to Kurt Russell's laconic portrayal of MacReady. Given his ability as an actor, he never seems to transcend the generic "hero walking around cautiously" stereotype found in countless other horror movies. In that sense it's a perfectly passable performance which might have worked better had the accompanying scares actually worked - as it stands, it's a by-the-books plod through familiar acting territory we've all seen a million times before.

1. Charlie - Kinky Boots

The success The Full Monty inevitably led to a slew of pretenders desperate to capitalize on the "winning" combination of working class drudgery and sexual liberation. Kinky Boots is one of the most egregious examples of how badly they sometimes turn out to be. Joel Edgerton plays Charlie Price, heir to the Northampton shoe factory facing impending closure. Into his life walks transvestite cabaret star Lola (Chiwetel Ejiofor, an admittedly entertaining turn), whose penchant for the titular footwear offers a ray of light for the factory and its employees. Price's character is the everyman often found in these kind of films and Edgerton struggles to bring anything singular to his performance, even looking as though he's actually bored in some scenes. His attempt at a regional accent also falls flat, making Wish You Were Here a low point in an otherwise respectable (and sometimes exceptional) career. Do you agree with the selections on this list? Which performances from Joel Edgerton would you classify as awesome and awful? Let us know in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Andrew Dilks hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.