Leonardo DiCaprio: Ranking Every Performance From Worst To Best

We had your attention... but now we have your curiosity.

"Oscar... Oscar..." The words of a guy talking to his friend named Oscar, or is that the sound of Leonardo DiCaprio muttering in his sleep? Just kidding, Leo: WE LOVE YOU. After all, who would have thought that the floppy-haired rapscallion from that billion dollar boat movie would evolve into one of the most critically acclaimed, well-respected and downright beloved actors of his generation? Seriously. Ask around you. You'll be pretty hard pressed to find somebody in your immediate radius who doesn't think Leonardo DiCaprio is the bomb. So what is it about Leo that has allowed him to take his place at the top of the Hollywood pile? Is it the fact that he rarely puts in a bad performance? That he dedicates himself entirely to each and every role? That he isn't afraid to take risks, try new accents, and play a vast range of characters? Or maybe it's just that he's so darn charismatic, we just can't help ourselves. To celebrate the man that is Leonardo DiCaprio - and the fact that he might FINALLY get his Oscar this coming March - we've decided to rank his performances from worst to best. Like any actor who has appeared in more than 25 flicks, there are going to be some stinkers, of course... all of which have been highlighted here for your general amusement. Hey, nobody's perfect. Okay. Except for Leo. Leo might be perfect.

26. Richard - The Beach

Aside from being a massacre of its far superior source material, The Beach is a testament to Leonardo DiCaprio the non-actor. As Thailand-based backpacker Richard, Leo plays this way over the top, bizarrely chewing the scenery like it's going out of style - and the results are sort of cringeworthy to watch. He's just SHOUTING all the time, throwing tantrums and acting like a child. There's a reason he got a Razzie nom for this one, people. Because he was pretty darn awful.

25. Derek - Dom's Plum

Sorry, did you say Dom's... Plum? Plum, as in, the fruit? WTF is this movie about? Pretty much, it's Leo sitting in a diner booth for an hour and a half being generally detestable, and MY GOD he won't stop talking. This movie wasn't even supposed to be released, apparently: DiCaprio reportedly made it as a favour to a friend with his buddy Tobey Maguire. He's... not great in it.

24. Josh - Critters 3

Leo is just a kid in Critters 3, and though he isn't particularly bad in this movie, he's not particularly good, either. The reason for that should be obvious: this movie is called Critters 3. How did Critters make it to a third movie, even? WTF is a Critter? If you're imagining something along the lines of a Gremlin, then yeah, that. Anyway, this flick marked Leo's debut role - and he's probably better here than he was in both The Beach and Don's Plum. Which says a lot about those roles.

23. Arthur Rimbaud - Total Eclipse

Don't pretend you know what this is. Seriously, you're not fooling anybody. This little-seen movie focuses on the turbulent relationship between two poets, Paul Verlaine - played by David Thewlis - and Arthur Rimbaud - Leonardo DiCaprio - who sort of bicker their way through 19th century France, getting on each others nerves and occasionally stopping to talk about poetry. Oh, Thewlis' character has a big crush on DiCaprio's character in the movie, so there's that... but it's an otherwise missable performance from our favourite Hollywood star, sadly.

22. Brandon Darrow - Celebrity

Minor Woody Allen movie, minor DiCaprio performance. There's not much to like about this movie, really, and DiCaprio's character - who is presumably supposed to represent a bizarro world parody of himself or something - is so unlikeable that sitting through Cassandra's Dream ten times in a row would be more fun than sitting down to a meal with him. So Leo is a jerk; Kenneth Branagh does a Woody Allen impression for two hours - no thanks, actually.

21. King Louis XIV/Philipe - The Man In The Iron Mask

Remember this? It actually happened - like, in real life. For this adaptation of The Man in the Iron Mask, then, DiCaprio took on the role of twin brothers - King Louis XIV and his brother Philipe. Rather hilariously, the actor won a Razzie for "Worst Screen Couple" for his dual roles, which is... just a bit weird, actually. So The Man In The Iron Mask isn't a very good movie, and - Razzie aside - DiCaprio is sort of serviceable, but doesn't really stand-out.

20. Roger Ferris - Body Of Lies

Much like the movie itself, nobody remembers Leonardo DiCaprio's performance in Ridley Scott's CIA thriller Body of Lies, mainly because there's much nothing to really remember. The film is about... it's about this operation, and... Russell Crowe... well, Russell Crowe is in it, and there's... there's this part where there's a desert. Definitely a desert in it, in Iraq or Iran or something, and Leonardo DiCaprio, he wears, like, these sun glasses as well. That's definitely something that happens in this movie. ... His name is Roger? Are you f*cking serious?

19. The Kid - The Quick And The Dead

Sam Raimi set out to play homage to his favourite spaghetti westerns with The Quick and the Dead, and managed to assemble a cast including Sharon Stone, Russell Crowe, Gene Hackman and our boy Leonardo DiCaprio, who spends the movie looking terribly handsome and being cocksure about the fact that he looked terribly handsome (oh, and his mad gun skills, too). Not a terrible performance, but not a particularly memorable one either. Also: not a very convincing cowboy.

18. J. Edgar Hoover - J. Edgar

As real life human J. Edgar Hoover, who founded the FBI back in the days when the world was black and white, Leonardo DiCaprio slapped on a bunch of make-up, made himself look fat and generally unattractive, and pretty much begged the Academy to give him an Oscar in the process. They said "no," of course, and that's a bit sad, isn't it? So whereas Leo makes a big effort, this still isn't a very notable performance - makeup aside, it's a bit bland and forgettable. And gross.

17. Jay Gatsby - The Great Gatsby

On paper, at least, we all presumably thought that Leonardo DiCaprio would make for the perfect Jay Gatsby - charming, handsome... but capable of getting across that inner turmoil, you know? So it probably came as a bit of a surprise when Leo turned out to be just an "all right" Gatsby - close, but no cigar, old sport. "Old sport" - like what Gatsby says in the book and everything. Anyhow, this falls in with that collection of Leo roles that are perfectly fine, but just aren't firing on all cylinders. Or maybe the movie was so bad that were just distracted by Baz Lurhman's questionable direction.

16. Amsterdam Vallon - Gangs Of New York

Gangs of New York marked the first time that Leonardo teamed with his friend and frequent collaborator Martin Scorsese, who decided that he wanted to make the actor into his late-stage Robert De Niro when that actor became more interested in stuff like Meet the Fockers. The results are somewhat mixed here, though - Leo shows promise, but he also feels far too boyish to play the thuggish Amsterdam Vallon, which certainly wasn't helped by the fact that he was acting across from, oh, DANIEL DAY-LEWIS. Seriously, what kind of raw deal was that, Marty?

15. Jim Carroll - The Basketball Diaries

The Basketball Diaries is not a great movie by any standard, but DiCaprio is pretty darn great in it and is enough of a reason to seek this one out, despite its obvious flaws. The Basketball Diaries is based on the real life memoirs of an actual guy named Jim Carroll, which is who DiCaprio plays so vividly here. As a promising teenage basketball player who develops an addiction to heroin, Leo's performance is raw, bold and nervy. As critic Peter Travers said at the time: "You leave the movie believing that Leonardo DiCaprio could do anything." He wasn't far off.

14. Romeo Montague - Romeo + Juliet

Well, of course he played Romeo once - look at him. All floppy-haired and wide-eyed - he's the perfect modern incarnation, surely? Just before Titanic, then, and before pretty much every female below the age of fifty fell madly in love with Jack Dawson, Baz Luhrmann plucked DiCaprio up and cast him as the lead in his adaptation of William Shakespeare's classic play. It's a good performance, purely because he doesn't play it too soppy, nor does he go too far with the whole "look, there's a cigarette dangling from my lip - isn't that cool?" side of things either.

13. Hank - Marvin's Room

What do you get when you put Meryl Streep, Diane Keaton, Robert De Niro and Leonardo DiCaprio in a movie? Lots of great bloody acting, that's what. So in this fairly underrated (but by no means perfect) film based on the stage play of the same name, DiCaprio stretches his acting chops and finds a great, natural performance in Hank, who has been put in a mental institution because one day he decided to burn down his mother's house. Oops. It's a shame that Marvin's room is so frequently dull, though. Still, Leo absolutely shines as his troubled character.

12. Dominic Cobb - Inception

Inception gave Leo the opportunity to act broody for two hours, which he did whilst delving into various dream layers wearing a suit with his hair all slicked back. Dom Cobb isn't an amazingly interesting character, no, and he does seem to exist primarily as the guy who's there to answer Ellen Page's questions regarding the complicated nature of Chris Nolan's puzzle-like narrative. Still, DiCaprio manages to make us feel for Cobb and provides a good straight man in a movie that otherwise consists of characters like "the Japanese one," "the British one," and "the Indian one."

11. Tobias Wolfe - This Boy's Life

Sometimes people say, "Oh, wouldn't it be great if Leonardo DiCaprio and Robert De Niro were in a Martin Scorsese movie together - both of Scorsese' boys in one motion picture extravaganza, bringing together classic Scorsese and modern Scorsese into what could arguably be his greatest movie ever." And whilst that is a superb idea, whoever said that, are you aware of the non-Scorsese This Boy's Life, in which DiCaprio - in one of his earliest roles - stars alongside Robert De Niro as Tobias Wolfe. In a breakout performance that goes down as one of his absolute best, he upstages everyone - even freakin' De Niro. It's not an easy film, but it's worth watching for some great Young Leo.

10. Jack Dawson - Titanic

"I'M KING OF THE WORLD!" Not only is that a quote that you'd pay $1000 to never hear again, it's also what Leonardo DiCaprio should say when he wins his Oscar, as to his inspire countless memes and send the internet into something of a LOL meltdown. Say what you will about Leo's turn in James Cameron's movie about that famous unsinkable ship, but this is where it all began. Every girl in the world fell in love with Jack Dawson, and for good reason: he's a total dreamboat. BOAT! Get it?

9. Edward "Teddy" Daniels - Shutter Island

If it's your wish to spend two hours watching Leonardo DiCaprio descending into total madness, then this is the movie for you. As US Marshal Teddy Daniels, who has been sent to a remote mental institution housed on an island off the coast of Boston to investigate the disappearance of a patient, he's mesmerizing in a strange and nearly sickly fashion. Watching an actor edging his way around an old building for an entire movie could have been boring as hell, but Scorsese's knowing direction, coupled with Leo's acting chops, make it near-unmissable.

8. Danny Archer - Blood Diamond

"MA' NAME IS DANNY ARCHER, AL'RIGH BRO?" That's to say, most people tend to be more caught up as to whether or not Leo did a convincing South African accent for his role as a rouge-ish gunrunner in Edward Zwick's divisive film about political unrest in 1999 Africa. The problem is that nobody seems to have the answer to that question. Seriously. Nobody. Good or bad, we can all probably agree that DiCaprio was brilliant regardless - many felt this was the first movie role where he seemed like an actual man, and not a boy-man. AL'RIGH BRO?

7. Howard Hughes - The Aviator

There's a sense that Leonardo DiCaprio invested a lot of time and energy into getting his performance in tune for Martin Scorsese's The Aviator, the director's long-coming biopic of innovator, pilot and film director Howard Hughes, one of the 20th century's most controversial - not to mention elusive - figures. What we all remember, of course, is the part where Leo has the beard and the long nails and it's all a bit disgusting, but this is an otherwise haunting portrait, carefully rendered. Oscar nomination, of course, but no win this time, either. Those sons of b*tches.

6. Frank Abagnale - Catch Me If You Can

What fun! And here's a post-Titanic flick that successfully embraced DiCaprio's boyish charms instead of trying to subvert them - he's fresh-faced and consistently wonderful from start to finish, a true movie star in every sense of the word. Look: he's practically glowing! So as Frank Abagnale, a con artist who travels across America pretending to be other people because that gives him his kicks, Leo felt totally in sync with the breezy nature of one of Steven Spielberg's most underrated movies.

5. Calvin Candie - Django Unchained

Leo's first and only truly villainous role to date, Django Unchained saw the actor stepping into new, crazed territory as Southern plantation owner Calvin Candie - a despicable fellow if ever there was one - in Quentin Tarantino's spaghetti western blaxploitation mash-up. Clearly relishing the opportunity to chew the scenery as an unhinged madman, DiCaprio manages to be both smooth and diabolical all at once, made better by his on-screen chemistry with Sam Jackson. It's a delicious role, and DiCaprio gets to drink out of a coconut. Lucky guy!

4. Arnie Grape - What's Eating Gilbert Grape

What is eating Gilbert Grape? We'd all love to know, I'm sure. It sure as hell wasn't the amazingly confident and brilliantly complex performance that ol' Leo put in when he was just twenty-years-old, though - one which nabbed him an Oscar nomination, don't you know? Yes, he's playing a mentally-challenged fellow, but it doesn't come across in that "Give me an award!" Dustin Hoffman Rain Man way at all: there's a lovely sort of innocence about DiCaprio's acting here, almost like he's... not really acting? Not to imply that he's mentally-challenged. Just... it doesn't seem calculated at all.

3. Frank Wheeler - Revolutionary Road

Revolutionary Road made everyone super excited when they realised that it would re-team super awesome lovebirds forever Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet (FROM TITANTIC!), and hey, maybe this'll be a nice, lovely romantic comedy set in the 1950s or something? Oh, it's not? You don't hear anyone really talking about Revolutionary Road anymore, which is a damn shame, give that Leonardo DiCaprio is absolutely sensational as Frank Wheeler in it. If there was, like, a list of underappreciated Leo roles, this would certainly find its way to the very top. Both Kate and Leo are so good here, in fact, that you don't - even for a second - think about the fact that they were in another incredibly famous movie together once upon a time. The urge to shout "I'm King of the World!" is pretty much silenced the moment the picture begins, and it's mostly thanks to Leo's tired, broken performance of a man dealing with the pitfalls of marriage and suburban repression. Problem is that DiCaprio is better than the movie itself, which is presumably why it's drifted from people's memories. Golden Globe nomination; no win. Pfft.

2. Billy Costigan - The Departed

Leo's turn as broken, undercover cop Billy Costigan marks what is without a doubt one of the actor's greatest performances (and was probably his all-time best until our number one pick took its place). In his third collaboration with Martin Scorsese (seriously guys, just get married already) and an adaptation of Hong Kong thriller Infernal Affairs, DiCaprio offers up a wonderfully nuanced portrait of a conflicted yet sympathetic character who finds himself in a terrifying situation, imbuing it with the right levels of paranoia and hysteria. Leo successfully steals the movie out from the likes of Jack Nicholson, Alec Baldwin, Matt Damon and all those other actors whose names we frankly aren't even going to mention, because this is all about Leo, dammit! Leo didn't even get an Oscar nomination for his turn as Billy Costigan, which is - quite frankly - a sin on the part of the Academy. Do you want money, Academy? Is that what's required so that you'll actually acknowledge this guy and all his good work? You're making it so hard for everyone, you know. Is this... is this some kind of sick joke to you?

1. Jordan Belfort - The Wolf Of Wall Street

That's right: we're calling it. After all, has Leonardo DiCaprio ever been quite as giddy and mesmerising as he is in Martin Scorsese's latest masterpiece, which chronicled the highs and... well, highs... of Wall Street millionaire and crook Jordon Belfort? "No" is pretty much the answer you're looking for. This performance marks the culmination of so many great, dedicated Leonardo DiCaprio performances, but whereas the man has felt occasionally ill-fitted to some of his roles, this one appears written entirely for him - and boy does it show. His charisma, attitude and dedication explode all over the screen for three relentless hours, and never do we get the sense that DiCaprio isn't 100% invested in every second. Without a doubt, Jordan Belfort is the character that DiCaprio was born to play - only time will tell whether or not the Academy agrees with that, but PLEASE GIVE HIM THE OSCAR ACADEMY. Do you want to make Leo cry? What does he have to do to appease you cruel people? Sacrifice a goat? Okay, we can totally do that. Somebody get a goat! Somebody get a bunch of goats right now! Like this list? Let us know in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Articles published under the WhatCulture name denote collective efforts of a number of our writers, both past and present.