Logan Reviews: 11 Early Critical Reactions

Logan goes for gold.

Logan Hugh Jackman
Fox

Proving just how confident Fox is in the movie, Logan unspooled at the Berlin Film Festival this weekend, several weeks before its wide release.

The critical embargo has also ended, resulting in an avalanche of reviews and fast critical consensus that, yes, Logan isn't just a great superhero movie, but one of the best-reviewed comic book films in cinematic history. Seriously.

At the time of press Logan is clocking in the high-90s on Rotten Tomatoes with an 8.2/10 average score, and if it holds this rating it could end up stronger than Batman Begins, The Avengers, The Dark Knight Rises and Captain America: Civil War.

Either way, the reviews are terrific (if not without their concessions in some cases), so fans can rest easy that Hugh Jackman's final time up to bat as Wolverine has been done solid justice.

Here are 11 critical reactions to Logan you need to know...

11. It's A Classic Superhero Movie For The Ages

Logan Hugh Jackman
Fox
"Without question the best superhero movie in years, and certainly the most ambitious one since Christopher Nolan hung up the cape." - Den of Geek
"The third – and by a significant margin, best – lone outing for Hugh Jackman’s well-knit and whiskery mutant." - Daily Telegraph

You can relax knowing that Logan isn't another promising solo Wolverine movie that quickly loses its way: critics by different measures have called it easily the character's best Solo movie, the best X-Men movie, and in some cases even one of the best superhero movies of all time.

While fans may end up divided on how many of these categories the film ultimately satisfies, the fact this discussion is being had is proof enough that it is provocative and powerful.


10. Jackman & Stewart Give Their Best Performances In The Series

Logan Trailer Professor X
20th Century Fox
"This is easily Jackman's greatest performance as Wolverine, allowing him to delve deeper into the persona than any previous film. He not only brings the usual cynicism, anger, and regret, but also a wonderfully confused mix of compassion, exhaustion, and bitterness in his complex relationship with Charles Xavier." - Forbes
"As for Stewart, he’s clearly having a blast playing this version of Professor X. No longer constrained to playing the wise old mentor, this Professor X is bitter, angry, and unafraid to swear his head off." - Collider

The words "fitting swan song" have been used in a high number of the film's reviews so far, and the easy consensus is that both Hugh Jackman and Patrick Stewart get to give their best performances as Logan and Xavier to date.

Unshackled by the needs of an entry into a distinct, lineal franchise, the two are able to elevate their characters to previously unseen heights, and the pair, by most accounts the two best actors in the entire X-Men series, don't merely lean back on the movie's novel, R-rated dystopian qualities.

This was their chance to take things to a new level, and it sure sounds like they seized it.


9. There's An Interesting Political Edge

Logan X 23
Fox
"Even though the film was shot a year ago...it somehow predicted many of the existential crises America is currently facing in the current post-election landscape." - IGN
"The fact Laura is of Hispanic origin and is being hunted down by a military group gives the film a topical tang, which is also detectable in the plot’s use of national borders, which become thresholds to redemption. The United States feels less like the Land of the Free here than a vast open prison, and Logan and Laura’s race northwards to safety has the knife-edge tenor of a jailbreak." - Daily Telegraph

Considering that the X-Men movies were some of the first superhero films to trade in weighty themes, namely prejudice against a class of people, it's apt that Logan is itself a political film, with many critics noting the film's unavoidable political leanings, creating a wasteland that resembles an extremely heightened, exaggerated version of the flagrant racism and fear running rampant in contemporary America.

Expect many think-pieces on the film to emerge when Logan hits cinemas in a few weeks, as all sides of the political spectrum scramble to interpret it to suit their own agenda.


8. It's The Goriest Superhero Movie To Date

Logan Wolverine Claws
Fox
"Seriously, there is so much blood." - Den of Geek
"Throats are torn out, skulls shattered and limbs sliced as Logan and Laura cut a bloody course through the American heartland." - IGN

While Logan's R-rating could've been an overzealous gimmick that resulted in far too much swearing and casual violence without any actual meaning or emotion behind it, it's now confirmed that this movie is no picnic, and does its more adult tone total justice.

The film's graphic violence has been a major talking point for reviewers so far, most commenting upon how while it's ferociously detailed and even occasionally over-the-top, it is sharply-executed and has a ton of visceral weight to it, not being as flippant as, say, the comical violence of Deadpool.

Though Logan has only a few R-rated comic book movies to contend with, the fact that it's being deemed bloodier than the likes of Watchmen, Blade, Punisher: War Zone, Sin City, Dredd and others is a very encouraging sign indeed.


7. Dafne Keen Is Excellent

Logan Trailer Laura
20th Century Fox
"Laura is a fun foil (being mute prevents her from getting annoying, and being Mexican allows her character more direct access to the film’s broader themes of systemic dehumanization)" - IndieWire
"Undoubtedly destined to be the crowd-pleasing favorite when the movie opens" - Den of Geek

Some of the film's most effusive praise so far has been for young Dafne Keen, who plays Laura aka X-23, the pint-sized mutant spawned from Wolverine himself.

It's now been confirmed that Laura actually doesn't speak in the movie as many fans already speculated, but Keen has nevertheless received acclaim for her expressiveness, conveyed through facial tics and the sheer physicality of her performance.

Several critics also questioned whether Laura could become an interesting new mascot for the franchise with this apparently marking Jackman's final appearance as Logan. Time will tell...


6. It's Got Real Emotional Depth

Logan Trailer Wolverine Laura
20th Century Fox
"The themes are weighty: loss, ageing and deep, almost unbearable regret." - Time Out
"It pierces the heart several times over and leaves you in pieces...Do bring your hankies." - Digital Spy

There's so often a disparity between R-rated superhero movies being mature and "mature". A film can be graphically violent and feature sailor-like swearing, but that doesn't mean its characters and ideas aren't juvenile. Deadpool, for instance, willingly indulges in such behaviour to hilarious effect.

Logan, though, brings the emotional resonance to match the rating, with deeply existential themes and a nuanced exploration of Logan as a character that often takes precedent over all the blood-letting.

Hearing that the film has an emotional payoff from so many critics is sure to only heighten intrigue ahead of the movie's release: could this mean Fox actually had the balls to kill Wolverine on-screen, or is there something else we haven't even considered?

Some reviewers also noted the film's intriguing meta quality, that it readily comments on the mythic quality of superhero movies today, and in light of the X-Men franchise's own recent blandness in particular, that's very much welcome.


5. Not Enough Richard E. Grant

Logan Trailer Richard E. Grant
20th Century Fox
"Richard E. Grant, always a welcome presence, is primarily wasted as the film’s other villain." - Den of Geek
"Grant unfortunately doesn’t have a ton to do aside from dropping some exposition which ties a few disparate plot points together in the final act." - IGN

The praise wasn't relentless without concession, though, and one of the most commonly called-out criticisms is the disappointingly scant role afforded to the legendary Richard E. Grant as villainous scientist Xander Rice.

Considering his seemingly pivotal role in X-23's creation, many critics were left underwhelmed at the rather piecemeal nature of his part, even if a solid amount of praise was still leveled at the film's central villain, Donald Pierce (played by the brilliant Boyd Holbrook).


4. The Visuals Are Terrific

Logan Caliban Stephen Merchant
Fox
"We get imagery and vistas reminiscent of iconic shots from the best John Ford films...Logan is the most beautifully rendered film in the X-Men franchise, and the most visually unique of the bunch. Within the genre overall, it stands out in this regard as well, with only a very few films comparing (the Dark Knight trilogy and Watchmen come instantly to mind)." - Forbes
"[It] feels more like a wake than a party. The colours are muted, all rust-red and glowering grey." - Time Out

As anyone who's seen the trailers should have been able to guess, indeed, this is a beautiful-looking movie and most critics praised Logan for doing a great job differentiating itself from almost every single other superhero movie.

Stylistic comparisons stretched from Mad Max: Fury Road to No Country for Old Men and the recent Hell or High Water, which through the prism of the superhero genre is quite an interesting series of touchstones indeed.

The bleak western feel shouldn't be that surprising, of course, considering that James Mangold directed the fantastic 3:10 to Yuma remake.


3. The Final Showdown Is A Little Weak

Logan Trailer
20th Century Fox
"The urge to serve up a stakes-raising big bad results in an unsatisfying reveal that externalises and personifies Logan's beneath-the-surface turmoil in an obvious and hoary way...The final confrontation is a little unfocused in comparison with the taut set-pieces that come earlier in the film." - Empire
"The beat-em-up finale is frustratingly illogical, offering nothing we haven't already seen." - Time Out

Easily the biggest worry fans had about Logan was that it would blow all of its promise in a wonky third act, and while most critics agree it doesn't do that, there is a common feeling that the final confrontation isn't quite as water-tight as what preceded it.

It's worth saying at this point that several reviewers made a point of comparing the final battle favourably to The Wolverine's widely-mocked robot samurai showdown, but still felt that it was more conventional than most of the preceding movie.

Thankfully critics have mostly been careful to avoid spoilers, so what the nature of this fight actually is remains to be seen.


2. Some Consider It Oscar-Worthy

Logan Trailer
20th Century Fox
"Logan is the first superhero movie since The Dark Knight to have a strong chance of being considered among the contenders for Best Picture come Oscar time in early-2018." - Forbes

Though it's extremely premature to start calling 2018's Oscars, Forbes led the charge in believing that Logan could follow a similar trend to Mad Max: Fury Road and be a rare bonafide blockbuster to end up scoring a ton of Oscar nominations.

With so much strong acclaim for its direction, screenplay, acting, cinematography, editing and other technical aspects, it's definitely possible, though it depends on how much the graphic violence and superhero movie stigma might put older Oscar voters off.

If nothing else, it's a fascinating conversation to be having, even though Logan releasing so early in the year puts it at a distinct disadvantage with the notorious short-term memories of Oscar voters.


1. No, The Trailers Haven't Spoiled Everything

Logan Hugh Jackman X 23
Fox
"There are still several major surprises here. Don't assume you already know where this is going to go." - Digital Spy

And finally, despite the trailers seeming to possibly give a little too much away, it's been explicitly stated that the film has a number of surprises and unexpected swerves that the marketing has carefully ensured to avoid.

Does this mean it's really not Xavier being buried by Logan in that unforgettable trailer shot? Or is there some additional context to it that completely changes the scene? Soon enough, we'll know, but don't worry that Logan's marketing pulled a Batman v Superman and gave away most of the big surprises.

What do you think of the Logan reviews so far? Excited? Or staying cautious in order to avoid hype backlash? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.