Looper: 20 Mistakes Rian Johnson Should Have Avoided

11. Jesse Comes Back, Without Back-up

A former co-worker of Joe, Jesse arrives looking for him on Sara's farm. He takes a look around chats up Sara about seeing Joe around and leaves. Joe and Cid, Sara's kid, hid away in a secret passage from the Farm-House. The next day Jesse, obviously suspecting something was up returned to the home and takes Sara as a hostage. If he did indeed suspect something the day before, why go in alone? Call for back-up from HQ hell get everyone that is currently looking for Joe to Sara's farm ASAP.

10. Love In A Time of Crisis

Alright, listen I know films have this thing with accelerated romances, it was meant to be, they were made for each other, they're kindred spirits etc. Action movies exaggerate this idea even further and that is very much the case here with Sara and Young Joe. Just the other day she wouldn't trust him being within 10ft of her son. He nor she really don't seem that interested in anything romantic, it's just waiting for Old-Joe to show and close the loop for him. And yet they are suddenly making-out together. It was an unnecessary development that felt tacked-on, as he would've protected her and her son regardless of stronger feelings.

9. We Really Could Use Those Straw Diagrams...

It becomes obvious from the Diner scene that the film will not concern itself with the greater implications of loopers. Coming from a scientific background that hurts me a little inside. Do these people understand what they are doing, they are changing the very fabric of the cosmos. They are interacting with one's self from different time periods, when will we ever get a chance like this again? I know, it's an action movie, as it turned out to be, and it would've been extremely risky to take a time-out and diagram out the paradoxes but it would've been worthwhile at least to me.

8. Just How Did Joe Get The Rainmaker Information?

The main purpose of Joe's time-travel back into the past hinges on some computer hacker guy who only gets one line in the movie. He doesn't even give him anything definitive, three possible tracking codes for children born on the same day as the Rainmaker. Did Joe really trust this guy? How did this guy come about it? We have to make narrative leaps at times in movies, but this big leap stretches it. Since it is a driving plot point this needed a tad more elaboration.

7. Causality #1

Paul Dano's character is gradually dismembered in order to bait his future self into the an ambush. As the fingers and legs are cut away from the young Dano they disappear on the old one. Now, this use of causality is consistant throughout the run-time so it's no plot-hole but it's one of those head-scratching concepts. Since the film won't go into the intricacies of this paradox let's try to expand on this. They say that they can't just kill the guy here in the present because that would disrupt the time-line, not that cutting the younger version's fingers, legs and nose wouldn't do the same thing. His circumstances would be radically different than those that brought him back in time in the first place. A mildly interesting paradox that goes unexplored with this concept of instant synchronization of the timelines.

6. Closing Loops

Why do you have to kill your own future self? Wouldn't it be less of risk if another looper executed other loopers? Like with Dano's character, Seth, it's a small chance that self-preservation will set in, and apparently it does occur so why take the risks? Send the "closed loops" with a personalized id-card and have the looper's inform each other of the contract's end.

5. Causality #2

Again, this is really putting the time paradoxes to task. Nonetheless, Joe's purpose in going back in time is to eliminate the "Rainmaker" thus causing the circumstances of him being sent back in time non-existant. If he was never sent back in time then how could he... alright I see older Joe's disdain of the "Straw Diagrams"

4. Quick Withdrawal Recovery

For a new-age drug it must be a helluva trip with withdrawal symptoms that dissipate after only a night's sleep. Most illegal street drugs today are extremely potent in their withdrawal pains helping to fuel their addictive nature. If it's not going to affect him beyond delaying him a few hours meeting Sara, why put it in? To show that he is in fact a tortured soul? We could figure that all out ourselves.

3. Causality #3

Old Joe is hell-bent on terminating the rainmaker when he may in fact be terminating himself. If he did succeed in doing so according to the movie's logic he would save his wife he would be stuck in this time, time-travel is a one way street according to Abe. So, essentially he could wait around for his wife for another thirty years, in which case he would be pushing 90 years or commit suicide in the hopes he helped his younger self, that now hates everything old Joe was for killing Sara's kid. Bitter and depressed he wouldn't be the same man old-Joe's wife fell for.

2. Is Love Enough?

Now, I will start by saying I've never really been 'in love" before (trust me, you don't want to know the half of it), but I am pretty sure of what it would take for me to kill kids who may or may not turn into homicidal maniacs. There is no amount of pain or anguish that would drive me to do something that heinous. However, I believe the morale paradox they were aiming for is the Hitler question, would you kill him as a child to prevent WWII and the holocaust? Now, it is presumable that Rainmaker's powers threatened the world at large, but this is never directly addressed from old-Joe. He is singled minded in that this will bring back his dead wife, he's not trying to save the world. So is the love of one man really enough to justify killing innocents?

Contributor

Writer and film-nut I'm willing to have perfectly reasonable discussions about the movies I love... on the internet... perhaps I asked too much. Read and comment on my personal blog too at cityuponahillmedia.com/blog