Madame Web Review: 1 Up & 9 Downs

Morbius is no longer the worst movie in Sony's Spider-Man Universe.

Madame Web
Sony

Kicking off 2024's superhero movie slate we have Sony's Madame Web - the dubiously awaited fourth entry into Sony's Spider-Man Universe, consisting to date of two Venom movies and... Morbius.

Expectations weren't exactly high for the MCU-adjacent franchise's latest installment, but even with that in mind, this is an impressively awful piece of work which somehow plumbs even lower depths than most could've anticipated.

Early reviews have quite rightly panned Madame Web into the ground, because this represents some of the most soulless, un-creative blockbuster filmmaking of recent years.

And though superhero fare has generally had a tough time as of late on the big screen, nothing we've seen lately is nearly as much of a misfire as this.

Despite the potential to acquaint mass audiences with an entirely new corner of Spider-Man lore, it's tough to imagine many coming away from Madame Web caring much at all about the title character or her Spider-Women sidekicks.

2024 is still young, but if this isn't up for a shedload of Razzies next year it'll have to be a really grim year. Even if you're planning to hate-watch this thing, be warned that it's not nearly as much so-bad-it's-good fun as you might have hoped for...


Downs...

9. The Insultingly Dumb Plot

Madame Web
Sony

Plenty of good superhero movies have had so-so plots, but Madame Web can't even deliver the basic, generic beats with competence.

The movie kicks off with an unintentionally goofy, Peru-set origin story for Cassandra Webb (Dakota Johnson) and only gets more inane from there.

The villain, Ezekiel Sims (Tahar Rahim), is meanwhile haunted by a premonition of his future demise at the hands of the Spider-Women and employs hilariously contrived means to track them down in the present, bringing him into conflict with Cassie as she discovers her own burgeoning ability to see the future.

On top of that, the means through which Cassie is then forced to team up with future Spider-Women Julia (Sydney Sweeney), Mattie (Celeste O'Connor), and Anya (Isabela Merced) - involving her being framed for assaulting a fleet of cops - is eye-rollingly convoluted.

Nothing in the story feels fresh or organic - you can practically hear the narrative's rusty machinery aching as the film traipses along, delivering a supremely idiotic rendition of a superhero movie formula we've been subject to far too many times by now. Just... no.


8. The Villain SUCKS

Madame Web
Sony

Madame Web's villain, Ezekiel Sims, is an absolute bust. Beyond his rather dull, self-preserving motive and the silly methods he employs to try and save his own life, he's desperately lacking in personality beyond "intense looking rich dude who walks around barefoot in a suit."

And it's an embarrassing waste of the supremely talented Tahar Rahim, made even worse by the fact that a large percentage of his dialogue appears to have been re-dubbed in post-production.

In numerous scenes Sims' mouth is curiously obscured from view while he's speaking, and there are even a few moments where his spoken words are entirely out of sync with his mouth movements.

It only further compounds how much of a non-entity Sims is in the movie, and so we can only hope that Rahim at least got nicely paid for this evidently undemanding gig.


7. The Trailers Lied About The Spider-Women

Madame Web
Sony

Arguably the biggest sell of Madame Web's trailers was the presence of the Spider-Women, that audiences would eventually get to see Julia, Mattie, and Anya suit up and kick ass.

Except, the marketing is basically lying about this aspect of the movie, given that within the linear context of the story we never actually see the Spider-Women in action.

At the beginning and end of the film, we see brief flash-forwards of the Spider-Women fighting Sims and protecting their city, but within the timeline of the film itself, they never actually get that far.

As such, the fact that we only get 45-or-so seconds of the Spider-Women fighting makes Madame Web feel more like a feature-length teaser trailer for a sequel which, if the early box office tracking is to be believed, will probably never happen.

Simply put, if you were enticed to see this film on the basis of the Spider-Women, avoid this like the plague.


6. It's A Technical Mess

Madame Web
Sony

Though there's a compelling argument to be made that the world needs more mid-budget superhero movies, the $80 million Madame Web is an absolute trainwreck from a technical perspective.

Where to begin? The film is chaotically edited to within an inch of its life, with both the slapdash action sequences and frantic premonitions suffering from their fidgety inability to just sit still and focus on any one image for more than about a second.

The camerawork isn't good, either: director S. J. Clarkson bafflingly over-uses both annoying shaky cam and pointless zooms, and this being a recent Sony Marvel movie, of course the visual effects are also horrendously ugly.

Beyond the basics of the film capturing watchable, decently exposed images, this is extremely rough around the edges and one of the wonkiest-looking blockbusters released lately - though at least not quite as hideous as Expendables 4.


5. The Spider-Man References Feel Desperate

Madame Web
Sony

Sony's Spider-Man Universe continues to be an absolute misfire of a franchise, hopelessly tethering itself to the Marvel Cinematic Universe even while Kevin Feige and company seem determined to keep it as distant as legally possible.

The Venom films and Morbius both established that the SSMU is effectively a parallel universe to the MCU, and so Madame Web runs with this by introducing a major subplot relating to the origins of Spider-Man in 2003.

Without getting into too much detail, the film features several notable characters from Spider-Man lore, yet these links most often feel like desperate, uninspired attempts to inflate the movie's importance, by tethering it to something mainstream audiences actually recognise.

Yet the nods to Spider-Man's future are likely to be more confusing than exciting, especially to general audiences who might be unfamiliar with the precise place the SSMU holds within the context of the MCU.

And ultimately this is such a vacuous, rancid piece of filmmaking that few will likely want to commit the mental energy to untangling its messy web of references and associations anyway.


4. All The TERRIBLE Dialogue

Madame Web

It's a common joke to say that poorly scripted modern films feel like they were written by ChatGPT, but Madame Web's screenplay is such a generic mishmash of superhero movie tropes and uncanny, scarcely human-sounding dialogue that it absolutely feels true in this case.

While the filmmakers sensibly cut that infamously terrible exposition line from the trailers - "Ezekiel Sims. He was in the Amazon with my mom when she was researching spiders right before she died" - the final cut is still chock full with dreadful, snooze-inducing chit-chat.

This is a movie positively awash in flavourless exposition, but even the attempts at pithy, witty, MCU-style banter between the focal heroes mostly end up falling flat.

That so much of the dialogue was clearly added in post-production doesn't seem to have helped it much, either.

Though the risible lines will occasionally rouse a smirk, the dialogue is mostly just sawdust-dry.


3. The Obnoxious Pepsi Product Placement

Madame Web
Sony

While you may not leave the movie wanting to know anything else about Madame Web, you'll surely be left craving a cold, thirst-quenching Pepsi. In the very least, PepsiCo absolutely got their money's worth with how aggressively Pepsi products are shoehorned into scenes throughout the film.

The two most egregious examples involve a baby shower scene where Cassie is shown holding a Pepsi can - logo strategically facing the camera, of course - and the final battle, which oh-so-naturally takes place on the roof of a Pepsi factory. Hell, the Pepsi sign on top of the building even plays a major role in the final fight.

It's embarrassingly on-the-nose even for the standards of creatively bankrupt blockbusters desperate to offset their production costs, and yet at least provides one of the film's few genuine laughs.


2. The Lousy Action Sequences

Madame Web
Sony

Madame Web could surely deliver some decent action even if the story sucks, right? Nope.

Despite director S. J. Clarkson having helmed numerous episodes of hit TV shows such as Heroes, Dexter, Jessica Jones, and even Succession, she seems completely lost when it comes to delivering kinetically entertaining action here.

Now, it doesn't help that the film wildly overplays the "oh, but it was only a premonition, you see" trick during many set-pieces, but even the basic fighting beats feel clunkily choreographed and shot with little flair. Clarkson's repeated use of James Wan-style 180-degree camera flips feels especially hackneyed and desperate.

Overall there's not much personality or excitement to the relatively minimal action on offer, ensuring that even as a switch-your-brain-off spectacle, Madame Web is basically worthless.


1. Yes, It's Worse Than Morbius

Madame Web
Sony

If you thought things couldn't get any worse than Morbius, this movie proves that assessment quite wrong.

In terms of its script and filmmaking in particular, this is even more of a shapeless mess, and one which proves even less convincing that its focal heroes are worth giving a damn about.

While Morbius went viral due to its campy appeal - headlined by that unforgettable Matt Smith dance scene - it seems unlikely that Madame Web will cast even a perverse, so-bad-it's-good spell with audiences.

This is just an artistic failure in every way that a film can be, and even as a crass commercial calculation, it seems destined to evaporate from the cultural consciousness in record time.

But with all this in mind, here's the single thing Madame Web gets kinda-sorta right...


Ups...

1. The Game Cast Deserves Better

Madame Web
Sony

The cast are the real victims of this movie, because on paper they certainly seem like decent enough fits for their parts, and yet each and every single one of them is given so little to work with.

Dakota Johnson's adorable awkwardness isn't taken advantage of, nor Tahar Rahim's smouldering intensity, and it's really only Celeste O'Connor and Isabela Merced who manage to make much of a dent as Mattie and Anya respectively.

Even the fast-rising Sydney Sweeney has oddly lacking screen presence here, and given her well-proven dramatic chops, she was clearly deserving of a beefier role - even accepting this as the fundamentally silly superhero romp it is.

There it is. "The casting department did nothing wrong" is truly the best thing that can be said about this movie.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.