Mamma Mia: Here We Go Again Review - 7 Ups & 3 Downs
2018's most pleasantly surprising sequel.
It's the day everyone's been eagerly awaiting: the 10-years-in-the-making musical sequel Mamma Mia: Here We Go Again is finally in cinemas worldwide.
Though even unapologetic fans of the 2008 original probably had middling expectations for this belated follow-up, the sequel has scored shockingly positive reviews so far - much higher than the original's mixed critical response - and you know what? Rightly so.
This is not a movie that claims to be clever or delivering much of an insight into the human condition: it's just fun, frothy escapism and a damn fun two time at that.
If you're an ABBA fan and at least moderately enjoyed the first film, this is basically a slam dunk. It's far from perfect, and a third film would definitely be pushing it, but given the potential this had to be an utter disaster, the fact it's a genuinely good film is a total result.
The fact that a Mamma Mia sequel is better than a Jurassic World one is, honestly, astonishing...
Downs...
3. Meryl Streep's Glorified Cameo
The big mystery surrounding the Mamma Mia sequel has been the presence - or rather, lack thereof - of the previous film's illustrious star, Meryl Streep.
With the trailers scarcely featuring the acting legend and even hinting at the possibility of her character, Donna, having died since the last film, fans will be going into the movie not really knowing what to expect.
Well, we won't spoil the nature of Streep's role in the film, but it's fair to say you shouldn't hope to see much of her.
Her screen time amounts to around five minutes in total, and though the film survives just fine without her, it's definitely a shame the production couldn't find a way to accommodate her schedule and give her a more substantial part.
2. It's A Little Too Long
Did anyone really need an ABBA-themed musical to run just shy of two hours? Well, Here We Go Again clocks in at a rather suspect 114 minutes, which despite the film's surprisingly decent quality does feel rather excessive given the movie's material.
Sure, a good deal of that runtime consists of entertainingly ludicrous musical renditions, but there are a few talkier moments that could easily have been trimmed down a tad. After all, nobody's coming to this thing for the chin-wagging, are they?
It's hardly a chore to sit through, but it would help the movie feel as breezy as it wants to be if its length was a little more manageable.
1. The "Plot" Is Generic & Predictable
Look, nobody comes to a Mamma Mia movie - and especially a Mamma Mia sequel - to soak in a rich, nuanced narrative, but even for the rather forgiving standards of a musical melodrama, what passes for a story here is pretty damn flimsy.
You'll see every twist and turn coming a mile away because it's all telegraphed comically far in advance, and most of the plot machinations are basically sub-soap opera level quality.
Some will certainly enjoy that the movie basically leans into its tawdriness, but it honestly feels like the filmmakers just picked the songs they wanted to see performed, then haphazardly linked them together with a loose plot they rustled together over a boozy dinner.
It's functional and mostly makes sense, at least, but any time the movie actually starts to buy into its own story - which thankfully isn't very often - it becomes the wrong kind of laughable.
These gripes aside, Mamma Mia 2 gets a shocking amount right. Here's everything it nails...
Ups...
7. Lily James' Charming Performance As Young Donna
Though Meryl Streep is barely in the movie, audiences are given a pretty damn appealing substitute, with the lovely Lily James playing young Donna in the film's plentiful flashback sequences.
James, best known for her roles in Cinderella and Baby Driver, may not bear much of a likeness to Streep, but that's easily forgiven given the fun-loving charm she effortlessly brings to the movie.
Effectively the film's new protagonist, and certainly getting more to do than previous lead Amanda Seyfried, James has a cracking singing voice to match her likeable personality, helping her mostly fill the void left by Streep's absence.
6. The Ludicrously Entertaining Musical Numbers
What would a Mamma Mia movie be without some impeccable song and dance routines? They were the bread and butter of the first movie, and this sequel does a fantastic job of one-upping its predecessor with a more elaborate, campy and ridiculous set of musical numbers.
Especially enjoyable is a spirited rendition of "Waterloo" early in the movie and a mind-boggling duet of "Fernando" between Cher and Andy Garcia, but even the "lesser" ABBA songs on display here are still an absolute toe-tapping hoot.
Ol Parker's direction isn't particularly fussy, but he nevertheless does a decent job keeping the set-pieces visually dynamic and, most important of all, fun and energetic.
If you're an ABBA fan and not grinning like an idiot during the movie's many, many songs, there might be something wrong with you.
5. The Excellent, Enthusiastic Supporting Cast
One of the main reasons this film is so successful is that you can tell the cast had a ton of fun making it, and that enjoyment transpires through to the audience.
It doesn't hurt that the movie's supporting cast is absolutely stacked with talent: in additional to all the returning cast, Jessica Keenan Wynn is eerily spot-on as a young version of Christine Baranski's character Tanya, Josh Dylan is charming and absurdly handsome as a younger version of Bill (Stellan SkarsgÄrd), Cher and Andy Garcia's pairing speaks for itself, and Omid Djalili also has a fun recurring cameo as a Greek customs officer.
Even the movie's smaller roles tend to bring some giddy added value to the overall production, and as basic as the script might be, there's never the feeling that the cast themselves are just phoning things in or going through the motions.
4. It's Shamelessly Cheesy & Totally Owns It
If you're going to watch a Mamma Mia movie and complain that it's too "silly" or "cheesy", you're kinda missing the point. The first film revelled in its campy absurdity and the fact that its cast members weren't classically trained - looking at you, Pierce Brosnan - and the sequel basically takes this even further.
It is a quintessential "no f***s given" sequel, and almost entirely in a good way. No gag is too daft here, with the film being so committed to its harmless silliness that it's hard not to crack a smile even when a gag doesn't totally land.
It doesn't try to be something it isn't and just thoroughly embraces everything people have always loved about ABBA.
3. The Godfather-Inspired Plot Structure
The narrative structure for this movie earned many pre-release comparisons to The Godfather Part II, which famously peppers its story with flashbacks to the younger life of Vito Corleone, as performed by an Oscar-winning Robert De Niro.
Here We Go Again similarly cuts indiscriminately between the present day, where Sophie (Seyfried) is planning a grand opening for her mother's hotel, and the circumstances that led to a free-spirited Donna eventually falling pregnant with her.
It's a neat trick which helps the movie generally keep up a decent pace despite its overt length, and by spreading the cast over two time periods, things don't ever get too cluttered for their own good.
While it's obviously not a patch on the aforementioned gangster classic, there are clearly far worse things to take inspiration from and be compared to.
2. It Tries To Be Poignant (And Actually Succeeds)
A big problem with frothy, slushy movies like this is when they start to buy into their own sentiment a little too eagerly, and it often ends up falling flat.
What a surprise it is, then, that this film's infectiously earnest tone actually allows its emotional beats to mostly stick the landing. Though you're probably not massively attached to these characters, Here We Go Again does a solid job cementing the inevitability of time, the perils of love and the importance of family, all backed up by the undeniable musical power of ABBA.
Admirably the film doesn't lay things on too thickly, even if it is an inherently melodramatic project, and only in the final stretch does it make an overt attempt to wring bittersweet tears from your eyes. And honestly, if you're feeling vulnerable enough - and if you've had a few cocktails beforehand - it just might succeed.
1. The End Credits Sequence Is Brilliantly Insane
Because there's only one way to end a Mamma Mia movie, the film obviously concludes with an elaborate musical number, and boy, it's a doozy.
No spoilers for which ABBA song the entire cast tackles, but from the absurd costumes to pairing the past-and-present actors together, it's a wonderfully jubilant note on which to send audiences home.
It's basically a litmus test for whether or not these movies are for you: in isolation, the closing sequence will leave many cringing and only able to watch through splayed fingers, while others will be laughing hysterically and maybe even singing along.
For fans of ABBA and of these movies, it's just the perfectly ridiculous way to end the film.
What did you think of Mamma Mia: Here We Go Again? Shout it out in the comments!