Mark Hamill: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

It's not all about Luke Skywalker, you know.

Mark Hamill has been geek royalty for nearly four decades now, and not just for the obvious reasons either. While Star Wars might be a big part of his legacy, he's also an acclaimed voice actor, comic book writer and filmmaker; and unlike some actors who are bitter about being typecast in genre roles, Hamill has always embraced it. It would be fair to say that his career has been mixed since Return Of The Jedi in 1983, and he never emerged as the star he was expected to be. Audiences seemed unwilling to accept him as anything other than Luke Skywalker, and his desire to move away from the role meant he didn€™t get offered a lot of work. This leads to a CV that€™s all over the place in terms of quality; he€™s had some great roles alongside lots of embarrassing ones. Even then his range of credits show he€™s willing to take chances, so even if the gambles don€™t pay off he€™s usually a memorable presence in them. In 2015 he€™s found himself busier than ever; not only is he reprising Luke Skywalker for The Force Awakens, he also made appearances in various movies, videogames and TV shows like The Flash. Now€™s the perfect time to reflect on Hamill€™s career and discuss the work he doesn€™t get enough credit for; and the stuff where he should have remained uncredited.


5 Awesome Performances...

5. Brent Matthews - Body Bags

Body Bags is a horror anthology from John Carpenter and Tobe Hooper, and in the final story Hamill plays a football player who receives a rather nasty injury to his right eye after a car crash. He€™s so desperate to keep his career going that he agrees to an experimental procedure to have it replaced with a new one; however nobody tells him the eye is from the body of a serial killer, but then he probably couldn€™t read the small print at the time. Hamill is clearly having a blast here, playing the part of a nice family man who is slowly going insane thanks to his new eyeball. The whole story has a cartoonish vibe, leaving him free to ham it up to his heart€™s content; the scenes when the character turns into the killer is Hamill at his scenery chewing best. Body Bags isn't exactly a masterpiece, but it€™s one of the best places to see Hamill explore his range as an actor; and having a bloody good time doing it.

4. Professor Arnold - Kingsman: The Secret Service

Hamill made a bizarre cameo as himself in the comic that inspired Kingsman: The Secret Service, so it made sense to bring him for the film. His character was changed to that of a kidnapped professor, and for most of his introduction all he has to do is sit and react to a whole lot of crazy things happening around him. He witnesses a spy singlehandedly take out a room of gunmen, and then he watches said agent getting sliced in half by an assassin with blades for legs. The reason this scene works is because of Hamill's silent horror at all the bloodshed happening around him, and his poor character has no idea what the hell is going on. He also gets a great scene with Colin Firth, and watching the contrast between Firth€™s ice cool assassin and Hamill€™s scruffy, nervous professor is one the film€™s highlights; especially when his head blows up unexpectedly. Not a major role, but it was fun to see Hamill in a major movie again and quietly stealing scenes from everyone else.

3. Griff - The Big Red One

Sam Fuller€™s powerful anti-war film follows a squad of American soldiers during WW2. Hamill plays the token €œI don't want to kill€ soldier that€™s been done to death, but he brings something special to the role that really helps sell it. Instead of being whiny and preachy about his beliefs €“ like the way most war films would handle the character €“ Griff locks up his feelings inside himself. The performance is quiet for the most part, with Hamill expressing the character€™s sense of horror with looks inside of words. Of course the moment comes when he has to kill, but it€™s far from heroic; he finds a German soldier hiding inside a concentration camp oven, and Griff proceeds to empty his rifle into him with a chilling look of insanity look on his face. The Big Red One was Hamill€™s first attempt to break away from his Star Wars typecasting, and it€™s a shame he didn€™t get more chances to show what he could do; based on the evidence here, he was capable of so much more.

2. The Joker - Batman: Mask Of The Phantasm

It€™s no easy feat following up Jack Nicholson after his iconic turn as The Joker, so people were doubly shocked when Hamill was cast as the character for The Animated Series. They pictured someone with experience playing menacing characters like Tim Curry, not Luke Skywalker, but Hamill proved the haters wrong with his superb take on the Clown Prince of Crime. Hamill€™s Joker is a complex take on the character, spmeone who can turn from polite and charming one moment to a raging psychopath the next. He€™s constantly chuckling at his own terrible jokes, and will often take on a criminal plan just for the fun of it. Hamill also uses the character€™s laugh to indicate his moods; if it€™s light and gentle he€™s in good spirits, and if it€™s deep and frantic he€™s either furious or about to murder someone. Mask Of The Phantasm showed him at his maniacal best; he flirts with his robotic wife, kills some people and laughs hysterically while his hideout burns down around him. Hamill will reprise the role one last time for an animated take on Alan Moore's The Killing Joke, which promises to be his defining take on the character.

1. Luke Skywalker - The Star Wars Trilogy

Well, this isn€™t much of a shock is it? Star Wars was €“ and continues to be €“ the role that will define Hamill€™s career, and with good reason. Over the course of three films the audience got to see the character grow from an inexperienced farm boy to a fully fledged Jedi Knight, and it was because of Hamill€™s performance that they believed every step of it. The character was never as cool as Han Solo €“ or even Yoda €“ but he was the moral core of the story. He's the one with the most growth, with everything from his body language to tone of voice changing as he becomes the man he was destined to be. He also went from being something of a whiny git to a badass space samurai, which helps with the coolness factor. Hamill found it tough to escape the character because he was simply so good in the role, so it€™s no wonder he had a hard time shaking it off. He embraces it now though, and it's fantastic to see him return for The Force Awakens.

...And 5 That Sucked

5. Lt. Jennings - Sleepwalker

Hamill has just a small cameo in this tepid Stephen King horror, where cat monsters go around trying to eat attractive female virgins. The film is famous for having cameos from horror royalty like King, Clive Barker and John Landis, but it doesn€™t have much more going on besides that. Hamill appears in the opening scene as a cop investigating a bizarre murder, where strangled cats are hung everywhere and a body is found with a rose on it. The movie is a good example of why Hamill hasn€™t received a lot of roles that require him to be manly - he€™s a really bad fit. His role in Sleepwalkers requires someone with a jaded, world-weary attitude that he simply doesn€™t possess. It doesn€™t hurt the film that much since it would have been lame regardless of who was playing the part, but since he€™s the first character the audience meets he sets a low bar for the movie to come.

4. Cocknocker - Jay And Silent Bob Strikes Back

Kevin Smith is a real marmite filmmaker; he has rabid fans who love everything he does, and there are people who simply can€™t stand him or his movies. His love of geeky films - particularly Star Wars - is undeniable though, and it was a pure fanboy move on his part to cast Mark Hamill as comic book villain Cocknocker. Even though it€™s meant to be an intentionally silly cameo it€™s kind of sad to see Hamill reduced to a bad parody of his past glories, and his ridiculously hammy performance smothers the humour out of the scene. The film even feels the need to introduce Hamill with an onscreen credit, just so people will know who he is and why they should be laughing. They€™re not laughing because the scene isn€™t nearly as funny as it thinks it is, and the lame capper of him getting his hand lopped off €“ and then turning to the camera to say €œNot again!€ €“ sums up why the scene brings the film to a grinding halt.

3. Reverend George - Village Of The Damned

John Carpenter€™s remake of Village Of The Damned is definitely one of the director€™s weakest offerings; it lacks the scares or tension needed to make it work, and the cast all seem to be acting in a different movie from each other. Out of all the miscast actors though, no one is more out of place than Hamill as a crazed priest. The character is gradually driven crazy by the presence of the evil children in the town, though he€™s creepy and aloof before they even appear. His big scene is when he gives a speech about the nature of good and evil to the village, and he€™s not nearly as commanding as he needs to be to sell the dialogue. When he takes it upon himself to try and kill the children he just comes across as a monster, even though he€™s technically trying to save the village. It should be a disturbing scene about a man€™s moral breakdown; instead, the audience will be cheering the children on when they force him to shoot himself instead.

2. Max Reed - Guyver

Live action anime is almost always terrible (any Dragonball: Evolution fans out there?) and this adaptation of The Guyver is one of the very worst. It plays out like a nightmarish episode of Power Rangers, with the plot featuring a teenager who can turn into a cyborg who must defeat monsters for reasons that are too convoluted to get into. Hamill plays a CIA agent who tries to help the hero and expose an evil corporation, and he€™s blindingly miscast. He€™s not convincing in the least as a gruff, gun-toting badass and watching him attempt it is just cringe inducing. His character is eventually turned into a giant cockroach by the evil corporation - which is admittedly a cool effect €“ though he must have felt depressed during filming that his career had led him to that particular moment. Hamill was the only name actor in the cast so the distributor tried to trick people into thinking he played The Guyver himself, by morphing his face into the character€™s mask on the front cover. It didn€™t work; people stayed away from it in droves.

1. Luke Skywalker - The Star Wars Holiday Special

The Holiday Special of Star Wars is legendary; George Lucas has disowned it, Harrison Ford likes to deny it exists and Carrie Fisher uses it to clear people out of her house at the end of a party. Since it was first aired it has never been rebroadcast, and Lucas won€™t allow it to be released officially on DVD €“ a rare example of him not exploiting every revenue stream imaginable. Some people might question if it can really be that bad, to which the only reply can be: yes, it really is. Nobody comes out of the it with their dignity intact, but Hamill is really poor despite only having a few minutes of screentime. He appears when Chewbacca€™s family (please, don€™t even ask) call him to find out where Chewie is. Hamill €“ complete with a terrible haircut and layers of make-up €“ stares directly at the screen, making the viewer believe he€™s staring directly into their very souls. He delivers some horrible dialogue right into the camera and flirts a little with Chewbacca€™s mother, and it all makes for very uncomfortable viewing. Despite his best fake smile Hamill looks miserable performing his scenes, which might explain why Luke is barely in the show. What are some of your favourite Mark Hamill performances? And are you excited for the return of Luke Skywalker? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Handsome. Charismatic. Intelligent. Noble. Witty. I'm none of these things, but I'm a half decent writer, I guess.