Martin Freeman: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

A funny thing happened when Martin Freeman was cast as Bilbo Baggins in The Hobbit: almost everyone on the Internet went 'Well, obviously he's the right person for the role'. Rarely do you get such a consensus online: when any classic role is cast there's usually a cry of 'he's too young/old/English/Bolivian/short/tall/funny-looking/normal-looking/Un-Bolivian' but almost the entire population of the world simply nodded and admitted - yep, Freeman is Baggins. It's more than just the fact he looks, well, quite Hobbit-y, he has a body of work that has made him one of the most likeable screen presences Britain has produced in a while. Early reaction to public and private screenings of The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey are that he's playing the role perfect, but until we can judge for ourselves with the film landing in cinemas today, here's my take on the MF performances you need to see and those ones that are just awful. We'll start with Freeman's best performances...

5. Bruiser (2000)

Sparky the puppet ruins Martin Freeman's life

If you've never seen this BBC comedy sketch show, and chances are you haven't, you've missed some of the best work of David Mitchell and Robert Webb. But showing equally impressive comic chops, and the first real appearance of that 'Martin Freeman face' (you know the one, where he looks somewhere between bewildered, distant and hypnotised), this is an utter treat for Freeman fans. Whether it's as a James Bond type unimpressed by his Q-branch gadgets "It looks just like a pen" "It is just a pen, isn't it?", a loner with his own Peep Show inner monologue, a drummer in the band 'Pussy on a Stick' or - most brilliantly - a chap trying to meet girls constantly thwarted by Sparky, his puppet friend, there's some brilliant timing and nuances to his performance. One particular sketch, as a policeman struggling to break the news of a death to family friends, features one of the loveliest pieces of comic timing you're likely to see. Get it cheap on DVD or check out most of the best bits on Youtube. And if many people didn't watch it, at least it saw Freeman get introduced to one of the writers - Ricky Gervais, and that pretty much panned out okay for him.

4. Men Only (2001)

There's a bit in Family Guy where Peter Griffin is watching Philadelphia for the first time and comments "Tom Hanks. That's the guy. Tom Hanks. Everything he says is funny", and that always reminds me of this - the moment you realise an actor is much more than just able to play comedy. Men Only was a once shown, never repeated (or released on DVD) Channel 4 drama about a bunch of reprehensible lads, and the depravity they rapidly sink into. Their five-a-side matches result in the drinking sessions, which lead to strippers, then to drugs and prostitutes, and finally a vicious gang attack on one unsuspecting girl. As Jamie, Freeman manages to perfectly capture a young man who allows himself to become part of a gang, and the reprehensible consequences that bring. An incredibly tough watch, and by no means a perfect drama as some of the characters feel like cartoons, but Jamie's remarkable disintegration and attempt to make up for what he's been involved in still stands out nearly a decade after it was made.

3. The Office (2001-2003)

The Office isn't about David Brent, it's about Tim Canterbury. That's actually what it tells you on the back of the first series' DVD, and I'm not about to argue. The reason being, we identify with him more than anyone else. He's the bloke stuck in a job he hates, crushingly aware of his situation. He's unable to ask out the girl he fancies and can't stand the people he works with. Among the many 'characters' this was where Freeman showed that just being able to play normal wins you a lot of admirers. His relationship with Dawn, summed up by the things they don't say, is heart-breakingly played - so much so that, by the time they manage a 'sponsored kiss' for Comic Relief, you're punching the air for them. Never has the 'everyman' been down-played so beautifully. Tim has too many wonderful moments to pick out, but the final episode pay off involving a Christmas party, an art-kit and the words "Never give up" is an ending that every writer or performer - comic or not - should watch and learn from.


2. Micro Men (2009)

A lovely little BBC4 drama, which documented the 1980's battle between Alexander Armstrong as Clive Sinclair (he of the wonderful Sinclair Spectrum) and Freeman as his former employee Chris Curry (the man behind the BBC micro). Freeman embodies the DIY nature of the 80's computer scene, as a chain-smoking Cambridge boy determined to get one over on his old boss. Again, it's not about being showy, it's about portraying an underdog without patronising him. Plus he gets lamped by Armstrong's rather insane version of Sinclair in one of the most convincing pub punch ups (all wrestling and grappling, no actual martial arts skill) you're likely to see. Brilliant stuff, especially if you know your Repton from your Miner Willy.

1. Sherlock (2010-11)

It was going to take something truly special to steal the limelight from old Bendybobs Winklesnatch, but the fact that it's Freeman who walked off with the 2010 Bafta tells you a lot about his re-imagining of the quintessential sidekick. Again, the secret is about down-playing the role. He knows that Sherlock is a mad genius, so he adds the moral compass, the compassion, and the anchor that the great detective needs. His devotion to his friend, particularly by the time he's willing to blow himself up to save his partner after just 3 episodes, is wonderful. And in terms of balancing the comic with the dramatic, it's Freeman's perfect role to date. Let's hope the repairing of the two, as enemies, makes The Hobbit half as enjoyable. Don't agree? You clearly haven't watched Sherlock then. Go away now, resolve that, and we can be friends. And now on the five performances we'd prefer to forget...

5. Ali G in Da House (2002)

I find it very hard to be critical of the man, so I'll blame this on the fact that the 87-minute film is too long. 84-minutes too long to be precise. Ali G worked a treat as a character on The 11 O'Clock Show, almost making the prospect of Iain Lee and Daisy Donovan watchable (almost). But the movie version stretched the joke so far it became that most awful of things - boring. Freeman features heavily as 'Me mate Dave', a white boy gangster cartoon replete with bright yellow baseball cap, dungarees and comedy faux-patois. Like the whole concept, it's funny as a sketch but beyond that it simply grates and does that rare thing - it makes you hunger for less.


4. Love Actually (2003)

Love it or hate it, and you're probably mad not to hate it, Love Actually does have a few great things going for it. Bill Nighy and erm, that bit where someone kills Hugh Grant (I might have dreamed that). If you've ever seen this film on a plane, like I first did, you won't have rated Martin Freeman's performance as it was completed deleted from all airline versions. Playing John, a body double appearing in the sex scenes for a movie, Freeman is mainly naked in his role and is required to get squeaking sounds out of Joanne Page (not tricky, considering how she sounds in most other things). Again, there's a lovely sense of vulnerability to a bloke who's effectively just a love machine for hire, and the scenes far from the fornication - where he just can't express his love for his co-star - are beautifully played. It's just a shame the rest of it is a pile of tosh (the wife's gonna kill me for saying that...)

3. The HitchHiker's Guide to the Galaxy (2005)

Maybe it's because I was brought up on the original, but I just don't get enjoyment out of Martin Freeman as Arthur Dent. Overshadowed by a lot of other actors being larger than life characters, and a film more confident with its visual style than its script (something the radio version obviously never had a problem with) you just feel there's more they could have done with Arthur. In short - he's wasted here, used more as a lens for us to look through at the world they've created. Whether I'd have felt differently if he just had more to do, I don't know, but his version feels under-developed and - dare I say - just the wrong side of dull. Maybe that's the point, but if you wanted someone dull there were a lot more British actors you could have chosen. I'll save that list - that long list - for another day.

2. Confetti (2006)

God lord no. Cross The Office with Love Actually and what do you get? Uber-bilge, that's what. Reuniting some of the cast from the first item on this list, Bruiser, and then utterly wasting their time - this wedding 'comedy' is about as enjoyable as a best man's speech from an unwashed serial killer with a lisp. Freeman and Jessica Stevenson are a couple trying to win a dream wedding in the style of a 1930's musical. It's not as bad as it sounds. It's a lot worse. Allegedly improvised, in the same way you improvise a fart, it's the sort of film that sets British movie making back 10 years. So bad that co-stars Robert Webb and Olivia Colman attempted legal action to stop it getting released. Apparently, the writer/director of the film was inspired to make it after watching her sister plan her wedding. After months of planning her sister went blind on her wedding day. Frankly, I wished I'd gone blind just before I saw this. And deaf.

1. The All Together (2007)

As far as comedy gangster film goes, this effort is criminal. Like what I did there? No? Don't worry, it's about as funny and clever as the film itself. And it utterly wastes Freeman, playing him as the straight foil to the most-aptly-sounding-surnamed man in history, Danny Dyer. The result is a horribly lumbering script about a gangster hiding out at the home of a TV producer who ends up..blah blah blah... with "hilarious "consequences. The characters aren't so much poorly drawn, as scribbled in crayon by a gibbon, and the script is a series of events so contrived it makes Jonathan Creek look like Eastenders, only in a windmill. It's not often you end up praising the Daily Mirror, but their critic nailed it when he suggested "Give your money to charity. Throw it out of the window. Set it on fire. Just don't waste it by paying to see this." A crime-film, in every sense of the term. Did we miss any of your favourite or least favourite Martin Freeman performances out? Share your thoughts in the comments thread below.

Contributor
Contributor

I'm a Westcountry exile now living in Yorkshire with lovely wife and cats (also lovely). I'm a big fan of films, robots, timetravel, and films about timetravelling robots, as well as lots of other action, sci-fi and comedy. I'm currently trying to write a sitcom that doesn't involve robots, and I also blog nonsense on timolsky.blogspot.com. Thanks for taking the time to read my stuff, and feel free to comment.