MCU Phase 4: 10 Villains Who Could Actually Replace Thanos
Thanos leaves big shoes (and one big glove), but who do Marvel have primed to step into them?
Once the dust from Endgame has settled, Thanos is surely done with the MCU, one way or another. He managed to unite the entire force of Marvel’s heroes against him and still come through Infinity War fighting; he leaves a massive void for the next villain to fill.
Thanos has been lurking in the background ever since Avengers brought a curtain down on Phase 1, so Marvel might not want to rush their next one in immediately. The MCU has patiently built their world and linked their characters together, so don’t expect a ‘new Thanos’ right away.
However, plans will be in place to have someone pulling the strings behind the scenes. It may be another mighty foe like the Mad Titan, needing the Avengers, Guardians and everyone else to team up, or it could be something altogether different.
A more intellectual, technological or mystical villain could keep the heroes on their toes and allow different Avengers to shine.
Whoever it is, Marvel certainly has a very deep bench when it comes to bad guys and gals. Even if all the ones listed here can’t be the next big big bad, they can still challenge the heroes in solo movies.
10. Deathbird
Fantasy Casting: Charlize Theron
With Disney’s acquisition of Fox, it’s surely only a matter of time until the X-Men join the MCU. However, Dark Phoenix still needs to be released, then Marvel face a casting problem. Keeping the likes of Sophie Turner, Jennifer Lawrence and Michael Fassbender implies they’ll be following on from Fox’s movies, which they won’t be.
However, recasting them too soon will lead to obvious comparisons and put undue pressure on the incoming star. No one wants to be compared to Hugh Jackman, after all.
That’s why Marvel should ease them in gently. There’s the obvious temptation to add Magneto or Mystique to the villain roster straight away, but a more nuanced approach may be best.
Deathbird offers a way to bridge the gap. As a Shi’ar, she has close links to Skulls and Krees too. A brutal and evil woman, Deathbird was exiled after murdering her mother and sister. With beautiful wings and razor sharp talons, she’d certainly make for a cinematic villain too.
Charlize Theron, with her action movie prowess (most notably in Atomic Blonde), killer glare and penchant for villain roles could fill Deathbird with dread and menace.
9. The Magus
Fantasy Casting: Sam Claflin
The end of Guardians 2 teased the introduction of Adam Warlock, though with a different arc to the comic books. Even with these changes though, fans can’t wait to see him. Hugely powerful and popular, it’s a little strange that he’s not appeared already.
Perhaps he’s just being saved until Thanos is dealt with. He could be a game changer, so keeping him on the sidelines makes sense; it would be a little boring if Warlock and Danvers just swooped in and deus ex machinaed to save the day.
However, he might be being kept back for a completely different reason. Elizabeth Debicki’s Ayesha gave life to Warlock, but she might actually have brought forth his villainous alter ego The Magus instead.
Considering a big Magus arc revolves around him gathering the Infinity Stones though, he needs a new plan to avoid becoming stale.
Many have speculated that Nikolaj Coster-Waldau could play Adam Warlock, and he’d be a solid pick if they go for an older Magus. As Ayesha’s twin though, Warlock/Magus might emerge from his chrysalis at around 30. Sam Claflin then, as one of the best things in The Hunger Games saga, feels like a good choice.
8. Sin Schmidt
Fantasy Casting: Elizabeth Banks
It seemed that Red Skull, like so many of the early MCU villains, had had his moment in the spotlight and was to be forgotten about forever; they were very much just getting used to the idea of interconnected movies at that point. The fact Hugo Weaving apparently hated the prosthetics the role demanded didn’t help either.
Most people had made their peace with this. Red Skull is a fascinating character, but Marvel’s roster isn’t short of brilliant characters, so they’re allowed to brush a few aside after a single use. However, with his surprise appearance in Infinity War, Red Skull is back under the microscope.
Many are speculating that Gamora or the Soul Stone could be the key to Endgame undoing the snap, so Red Skull might reappear again.
That could lay the groundwork for his daughter, Sin Schmidt, to be the next major villain. Merging her Mother Superior persona would grant her impressive psychic powers, and through her father she has a strong motivation to bring the Avengers down.
Elizabeth Banks, while known more for comedy, has biting wit, can pull off sultry easily and her villain was cleathe best thing in the Power Rangers movie.
7. Michael Korvac
Fantasy Casting: Domhnall Gleeson
Korvac is a computer technician who betrays humanity to collaborate with the reptilian Brotherhood Of Badoon overthrowing Earth. Given Yon-Rogg is still alive and wants vengeance on Danvers, the Badoon could become the Kree.
He doesn’t serve well though, and is punished by being turned into a cyborg. He’s then forced to fight for the Grandmaster, deliberately losing to learn how much control is being exerted over him.
Once he knows enough, he manages to escape and defeat the Badoon, with eyes on ruling over all creation in their stead, coming face to face with several Avengers along the way.
This all occurs in an alternate universe to the main Earth-616 dimension, but he does eventually space warp to the main canon. However, his motivation may be too Thanos-like there. Imbued with the Power Cosmic, Korvac attempts to turn Earth into a utopia. However, he’s very much a ‘make an omelette, break some eggs’ kind of guy.
As a villain who succeeds through his intelligence rather than his strength, Domhnall Gleeson seems perfect for the part. With his experience from both Star Wars and Deus Ex Machina, the Irish actor has a creepy, lurking quality without being physically imposing.
6. Ronan The Accuser
Fantasy Casting: Lee Pace... obviously
Ronan is the only one here who’s an existing villain in the MCU, but there’s good reason for bringing him back as the overarching villain aside from just his popularity.
He was working with Thanos in the first Guardians, then openly defied him to take the Power Stone for himself. In the end, this proves to be his undoing as (after a dance off) Star-Lord is able to use the Stone to obliterate him.
However, we all but know that the snap is going to be undone or reversed some way. When the likes of Spider-Man and Black Panther come back, could Ronan join them?
He was, after all, directly killed by an Infinity Stone, a fate which as far as we know has only befallen the snapped. There would be a sense of poetic irony if in bringing back the fallen, the Avengers also resurrect their next foe.
Even if he doesn’t return as the next in line to Thanos’ throne, Ronan seems to be heavily involved behind the scenes with the Kree and the Skrulls, so we’ll likely see him again in Captain Marvel 2.
5. Kang
Fantasy Casting: Joaquin Phoenix
Not the Simpsons Treehouse Of Horror villain, but instead the time travelling Conquerer. Although Disney do seem to own every property going these days, they have enough Marvel characters that a Simpsons crossover isn’t required quite yet.
Kang is an interesting character to set against Marvel’s current crop, as he has no superhuman abilities, but as a time traveler does have access to 40th Century technology. Even Wakanda would be dwarfed by his technological superiority.
With this tech comes advanced battle armour to make up for his regular human strength, and his Rama-Tut alter ego has a power sapping ray gun to cause more roadblocks for the heroes.
With access to weaponry from any era, Kang the Conquerer would definitely keep the Avengers on their toes. The Reality Stone was only utilised briefly by Thanos; Kang offers much more creativity.
If his Joker origin story gives Joaquin Phoenix a taste for comic book movies, he’d be a brilliant Kang. Famously hard to tie down, he might resist a recurring picture deal, but his ability to be treacherous, cruel, arrogant, manipulative and highly intelligent means he’d surely be one of the first phone calls Marvel makes.
4. Amora The Enchantress
Fantasy Casting: Saoirse Ronan
If Marvel decides to go in to opposite direction to Thanos’ sheer brute force, Amora The Enchantress (a different but not too dissimilar character to Cara Delevingne’s in Suicide Squad) could be a clever option.
She originates in the Asgardian canon, meaning her first appearance could be in Thor 4, or even (fingers crossed) the hypothetical Asgardians Of The Galaxy. Considering how quickly Strange finds Loki though, if she flees to Earth following Surtur’s destruction of Asgard, Doctor Strange 2 offers a possibility, as does Guardians 3 if she flees elsewhere.
A powerful telepath, Amora can travel through both dimensions and time, as well as weaponising her powers in the form of energy blasts. Despite these abilities, she doesn’t lack strength and can go toe to toe with Thor without using them, although Scarlet Witch has matched her telekinetics before.
She’s previously partnered up with Loki and has a rivalry of sorts with Valkyrie, so hopefully it’s only a matter of time before she’s on screen in some way.
Saorise Ronan reached three Oscar nominations before her 25th birthday, so no one could doubt her acting ability. Her Irish brogue is perfect for this mystical, graceful villain too.
3. Mephisto
Fantasy Casting: Andrew Scott
Based on the Faustian legend, Mephisto is a demonic villain who offers the MCU a new angle of darkness to explore. Just how Doctor Strange widened the capabilities of the heroes, Mephisto can bring new depths to the villains.
Part of what makes Thanos great is that he has real motivations. He’s brutal, and his ideas have led to billions upon billions of deaths, but you’d struggle to claim he’s ‘evil’.
You’d have no such problem with Mephisto. The demon often poses as Satan and is every bit as bad to the core. Complex ambitious are great, but there’ll always be a place for the truly irredeemable villains.
He’s crucial to both Silver Surfer’s and Ghost Rider’s stories in particular, so if those two arrive Mephisto will surely follow.
Andrew Scott, best known for his devilishly diabolical portrayal of Moriarty in Sherlock is the perfect fit. He has an enigmatic charm with a mask that ever so often slips to reveal a deep seated rage. The careful control he exerts in every situation makes you wonder too if the mask really did slip, or if he wanted you to see the furious depths of his soul all along.
2. Galactus
Fantasy Casting: Alexander Skarsgård
The issue with some of these characters here is that they’re noticeably weaker than Thanos. While there’s definite workarounds - Endgame may leave them decimated and vulnerable while villains’ powers can always be punched up - the reason Galactus has long been muted as the next overarching villain is because he’s one of the few in Marvel’s stable that outgun the Mad Titan, plus he’s a comic book icon to boot.
Both Galactus and Thanos are ruthless in their goals, but Galactus poses a completely different set of problems. Any sort of hand to hand combat is impossible with a being his size, meaning the set pieces can feel fresh after the heroes have whaled on Thanos for two movies straight.
Eating planets whole is a more monumental threat too. The snap is one distinct action, but there’s lots of planets out there for Galactus to destroy. Could he beckon in the cosmic era?
Alexander Skarsgård has an underlying creepiness to him, and a voice that, with a little work, could definitely belong to a planet devouring god. If Endgame’s post credit scene is just a yawning ‘I hunger...’, it’ll keep fans glued to the next phase.
1. Doctor Doom
Fantasy Casting: Bryan Cranston
The Fantastic Four have had two failed attempts to tell their story on the big screen (three if you include the fact that first one inexplicably got a sequel), but surely there’s another one coming. With the MCU gaining access to the Four through Disney’s merger with Fox, they’d be fools not to use them.
The nuances of when and how to introduce them can be discussed another time, but one hugely important factor has been overlooked in the excitement: Doctor Doom. As part of the Fantastic Four IP, snagging them means snagging one of Marvel’s best ever villains.
Whoever replaces Thanos will need presence, gravitas, and a spine chilling air of threat. Doctor Doom has all three in spades, and is the perfect replacement for the Mad Titan.
His genius level intellect might force the best out of Reed Richards, Shuri, Peter Parker, Bruce Banner and Doctor Strange too, with Doom much more malevolent than Thanos.
Bryan Cranston bubbles with intimidation when he turns it on, but he’s capable of nuance too. Walter White more than prepared him for the role of Victor Von Doom if Marvel turn his way.