Morgan Review: 3 Ups & 7 Downs
A crushing disappointment.

Arriving with little fanfare this past week was the debut feature from Ridley Scott's son Luke, a low-budget sci-fi thriller that nevertheless had a lot going for it on the surface.
Sadly Morgan mostly fails to live up to its promise and is one of the year's most frustratingly underdeveloped projects, especially considering the solid potential.
Probably the worst thing that can be said about Morgan is it'll end up in your Netflix recommendations a year from now and you'll likely have forgotten that it even had a wide theatrical release at all.
It's not without some bright spots, but for the most part it's a quintessential example of an intriguing premise undone by a mediocre execution and distinct lack of fresh ideas.
Here are 3 ups and 7 downs from Morgan...
Downs
7. It Mostly Wastes An Excellent Supporting Cast

What an absurdly brilliant cast this movie somehow acquired. Considering the low $8 million budget couldn't afford to pay them much and the script's hardly Shakespeare, it's baffling what attracted so many name actors to the project, and yet here they are.
Sadly the likes of Toby Jones, Rose Leslie, Boyd Holbrook and Michelle Yeoh are largely left juggling cliches and reeling through exposition, while the most criminal abuses of Hollywood talent are Jennifer Jason Leigh and Brian Cox, whose characters are so inconsequential the movie could basically have happened without them.
In honesty, much of the movie's fun stems from wondering which name actor will randomly show up next, even if they're egregiously wasted in pursuit of a seemingly meager payday.
6. The Atrocious Fight Scene Editing

Morgan's bursts of violence are horrendously directed by Ridley Scott's son Luke, who has clearly graduated from the Taken 3 school of "edit the fighting into oblivion to disguise the bad choreography".
The numerous fight scenes in Morgan's third act employ an almost seizure-inducing number of cuts: one character punches another and we apparently need about a dozen spliced shots to convey it to the audience, the result of which is both annoying and completely incoherent.
One can try and blame the movie's editor, Laura Jennings, but it's much more likely that she merely had to make the best of what Scott delivered to her, especially considering the last movie she edited was the terrifically-cut Edge of Tomorrow.
5. The Messy Pacing

Morgan has a somewhat fatal combination of being both a slow burn and an extremely short movie, running in at just 92 minutes long.
Movies that fleeting don't really have the luxury of a slow pace, and yet the film's first half in particular is an absolute slog, weighed down by rampant exposition when it really should just show the viewer rather than continually tell them.
The second half, however, ramps up considerably and ends up feeling rushed as the film hurtles towards its climax. It wouldn't have made the film a masterpiece, but balancing out its pacing and perhaps adding 10 or 15 minutes to allow the second half to breathe a little more may have worked in its favour.
4. The Cliched Third Act

Regrettably, the film goes wildly off the rails in its third act, devolving from a mildly intriguing sci-fi thriller into a straight-up slasher movie, as Morgan inevitably goes haywire and those who remain try to bring her down (that's not a spoiler: it's straight up in the trailers).
It's the least imaginative, most predictable path the film could've taken, and makes it even tougher to care about what's going on. Sure, it's at least more lively and exciting than the leaden first half, but it feels lazy and driven by commercial concerns rather than thought-provoking ideas.
3. Kate Mara's Bland Lead Performance

Kate Mara has proven herself to be a terrific actress in Netflix's political thriller series House of Cards, though has struggled to find solid roles for herself on the big screen.
Morgan isn't really an exception, though Mara doesn't help herself because she gives such a howlingly bland performance.
While the icy, detached nature of her corporate problem solver character means that she's fairly cool and calm throughout, Mara just doesn't do much to give Lee any palpable screen presence.
The fact that she's given precedent over the title character for most of the movie was clearly a big mistake given how much more compelling Morgan is.
2. The Hilariously Predictable Plot Twist

Yes, there's a plot twist in Morgan, though it's so laughably transparent you may've even guessed it from the trailers.
If you made it through the movie without guessing the twist, then you probably weren't paying enough attention, because it's frequently signposted and among the least surprising twists in recent movie memory.
The twist itself has potential despite its unoriginality, but the poor execution just ends the film on something of a shoulder shrug. You'll probably ask yourself, "Is that it?"
1. It's Basically A Poor Man's Ex-Machina

Watching the film, it's hard not to feel a distinct pang of deja vu, as stylistically and thematically, the film is rather similar to last year's outstanding sci-fi thriller Ex-Machina.
Without saying too much about specifics, both plots revolve around a unique creation who is locked inside a facility to be experimented upon, before things go haywire and the creation attempts to escape.
The mood and tone are also extremely similar even if some ideas are different, though Morgan is basically inferior in every single way (except perhaps for having more name actors in it). If Ex-Machina wasn't so fresh in the mind and not as great as it was, then perhaps the prevailing feeling that this is an ersatz imitation wouldn't feel so pronounced.
And now, here's what Morgan actually didn't screw up...
Ups
3. Anya Taylor-Joy's Solid Performance

Anyone who's seen the recent horror movie The Witch will know that Anya Taylor-Joy has enormous promise as a young talent, and she's easily one of the few bright spots of this movie.
Made up to look distinctly alien-esque with Scott making terrific use of her almost impossibly large eyes, Taylor-Joy is curious as the initially more stoic Morgan, while also utterly convincing as a murderous maniac once things go wrong.
She modulates the performance extremely well, but it's a shame she didn't get stronger material, because she clearly deserves it. The film's failure critically and commercially won't hurt her career in the slightest, but hopefully she'll find more inspired projects in the future.
2. Max Richter's Electronic Score

It won't be ending up in any year-end awards conversations, but Max Richter's pulsing electronic score is a major highlight that clearly belongs in a much better film.
Ratcheting up the intensity when things go haywire while also evoking a more serene mood in the calmer first half, Richter melds synths with orchestral swells to entrancing effect, and again, it's just a shame the rest of the movie isn't as strong as his fine work here.
1. That Incredible Paul Giamatti Cameo

Yes, Paul Giamatti is in this movie. He shows up halfway through as a psychologist sent to evaluate Morgan's state of mind, and absolutely runs away with the film in a 10-minute sequence that's among the movie's few scenes that totally works.
Giamatti brings intensity to the role, and while he's clearly just here for the payday like everyone else (his character even says "I want to get this over with as fast as possible"), he sure as hell doesn't phone it in.
The fact that he's working opposite the movie's other prized asset, Taylor-Joy herself, makes his scene effortlessly compelling, and a prime example of the sort of psychological intensity the movie should've been more concerned with. Instead, it's a jarringly brilliant scene in an otherwise thoroughly mediocre movie.
What did you think of Morgan? Shout it out in the comments!