20 Most Underrated Actors Working Today
The most underrated actors working in movies and TV.
We all know who the biggest and best actors are working today: Denzel Washington, Meryl Streep, Anne Hathaway, Pedro Pascal, Timothee Chalamet, Zendaya, Robert Pattinson (insert your own considerations here), et al.
But in the vast landscape that is Hollywood, there are plenty of great actors out there who have never been given their due, despite often long careers delivering the goods in a wide variety of popular and well-received movies and TV shows.
Sure, plenty of these actors aren't front-and-centre like Leonardo DiCaprio and Emma Stone, but without their work, those projects in which they feature would surely be missing that special spark - that supporting character or compelling villain that gives the project its heart, keeps its leading characters grounded, or gives an added twist to the drama around them.
These are often the unsung heroes of the movies and shows we love so much - the performers stood just outside the drama, giving it life from the sidelines.
With that in mind, from veteran TV stars to young comedy aficionados, here are the 20 most underrated actors working today, on the big screen and the small.
20. Gina Torres
Despite a leading role on recent hit 911: Lone Star, an otherwise abysmal procedural that she injects with real heart and power, Gina Torres has almost always shone brightest as a supporting player.
As both hardened former soldier Zoe Washburne in the short-lived sci-fi thriller Firefly and tough lawyer Jessica Pearson on the legal drama Suits, Torres's strength has always been her ability to play characters able to ground the more volatile male personalities in her immediate orbit; she takes challenges head-on, keeping her friends steady.
Adept at playing capable characters unwavering in a crisis, she's always seen her best work through with an unshakable resolve, an uncanny ability to portray strong women who hold their heads high but are always willing, where needed, to let their guard down.
We've not seen a lot of her over the years, but what we have seen has been exemplary - the work of a soulful performer who brings real heart and emotion to every role she's tackled. With Lone Star out of the way, hopefully she can land another great role worthy of her talents.
19. Rosario Dawson
Everyone knows her face, too few have given her her flowers. For over two decades, Rosario Dawson has been one of our most consistent and dependable stars of both TV and film, and despite the depth of her back catalogue, audience and award recognition has always managed to elude her.
With affecting work in a wide variety of dramas, from Spike Lee's touching He Got Game and 25th Hour, to a whole host of breathless action flicks including Sin City and Unstoppable, Dawson has carved a career out of her brilliant ability to blend into any role regardless of genre or size; she simply turns up, and elevates the material by being present.
A quality of many great actors is how easy they make their work look - how they blend into the role and film they're a part of.
Dawson has never stolen a movie, but she's always been an integral part of them.
18. Barry Pepper
Another remarkable supporting player, Barry Pepper had a monster run throughout the late 90s and early 00s, turning up in a variety of radically different projects to strut his stuff.
A master of portraying scrappy, often broken men who are unwavering in their beliefs and struggling with their pain, Pepper's perhaps best known for Spielberg's searing Saving Private Ryan, where he plays a loyal sniper unflinching in the face of adversity.
But he's done so much more than his most famous film. He gave the war drama We Were Soldiers its soul as a war photographer caught in the heart of the Vietnam War, breathing life into a confident reporter torn apart on the frontlines, and he easily matched wits with Edward Norton and Philip Seymour Hoffman in 25th Hour, as a blunt trader conflicted about seeing his best friend whisked away to prison.
Full of heart, Pepper's ability to tear down the walls of confident men is honestly miraculous, and though his career has fizzled out, he should always be remembered as a master of his craft.
17. Maura Tierney
Despite gaining some well-earned recognition for the drama series The Affair, where she starred as an embattled wife in a marriage that ranged from loveless to impossibly passionate, Maura Tierney has always fell just outside the mainstream.
And that's crazy when you consider her work: Primal Fear, Insomnia, Beautiful Boy, Twisters, The Iron Claw. She's done them all and then, bringing heartbreak and emotional turmoil to women caught in the midst of tragedy - or at least the aftermath of it - but pushing through, knowing there's something brighter on the horizon.
Take The Iron Claw, a film that features career-best work from Zac Efron, Jeremy Allen White, and Holt McCallany, where she stars as McCallany's loyal but smothered wife, a woman who has to hold herself together in the face of insurmountable loss and a marriage that feels as suffocating as it does full of genuine feeling.
Never showy, Tierney is a heartbreaker, a force of real humanity who finds hope even in the most broken of characters. And don't forget Liar Liar - for all the tears, Tierney is great at comedy!
16. Will Patton
How does one even begin to describe the depth of work Will Patton has tackled over the years?
Perhaps we could start with the insane Michael Bay picture Armageddon, a ridiculous end-of-the-world disasterpiece in which he plays the only character with anything resembling real humanity. Or what about his touching recent work in the new Halloween trilogy, or his unforgettable narration in the masterful Trains Dreams? What about Minari?
It doesn't matter where you look, or how you start. Patton has been bringing a level of pathos to films both awful and grand for three decades now, and seems to have only become more affable, tender, and understanding in his work with age.
Best at portraying loving souls who often sail into the lives of bigger characters to offer warmth or wisdom, Will Patton has always looked like a caring uncle, the kind of man you'd trust, and he's used that to his advantage beautifully throughout his career. I mean, seriously, he's so great in Armageddon it's kind of absurd.
15. Allanna Ubach
It's not only dramatic actors who've failed to receive their due over the years; there are plenty of comedians who have spent too long left on the sidelines.
One such comedy genius is the great Alanna Ubach, a long-time TV guest spotter who's brought brilliantly over-the-top laughs to such modern gems as It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, Californication, Hacks, Ted, and The Flight Attendant. Often crass, always fearless, Ubach brings a real bolt of electricity to any ridiculous role she lands.
But the joy of Ubach isn't that she's a great comedienne - though she absolutely is - but that she's also a staggering dramatic actor, too, bringing a genuine gravitas and even heartbreak to the likes of The Last of Us, To the Bone, and Euphoria between hysterics.
Looking at her roster and how effortlessly she seems capable of moving between genres on TV and the big screen, you get the sense from watching Alanna Ubach that she's destined for greatness; for one great, big role that will win all the awards and blow everyone's socks off.
14. Carla Gugino
There have been plenty of actors over the years who have benefited from a late-career surge, few more so than the great Carla Gugino.
A star of both movies and TV, Gugino has done it all - superhero flicks like Watchmen, survival thrillers like San Andreas, guttural horrors like Gerald's Game - but it's only been in the last 10 years or so that she's really hit her stride, thanks in large part to her creative partnership with the wonderful Mike Flanagan.
From her terrifying work as the embodiment of Death in The Fall of the House of Usher to her sensitive performance in The Haunting of Bly Manor, Gugino has found in Flanagan a filmmaker worthy of her talents, who can see just how bold she can be.
It's not just Flanagan and the big world of horror, mind. Carla Gugino is always up for a laugh, her recurring roles in New Girl and Californication proof she's more than a good scare. And can, quite frankly, do it all.
13. David Morse
A long-time member of the "Hey, it's that guy!" club, David Morse has spent his career turning up in classics and never getting the recognition given to his bigger-name co-stars.
Best remembered for The Green Mile, Morse has done a little bit of everything over the past few decades, from tense thrillers like The Negotiator to heartbreaking tragedies like Dancer In the Dark. He's also had memorable bit parts in The Hurt Locker, The Rock, and The Long Kiss Goodnight.
Best when portraying a hardened military man or law enforcement officer caught between his job and his principles, trying his best not to be shaken by conspiracy or tragedy, Morse actually delivered his best work in the disquieting thriller Disturbia, where he plays a sweet neighbour with a terrifying secret to nerve-jangling results.
A towering figure who can be imposing and comforting in equal measure, Morse has stacked up an enviable track record over his career, though despite his credentials and the talent beside him, he's always felt a little left out in the cold.
12. David Boreanaz
David Boreanaz might just have one of the most enviable careers on this list, which may sound hyperbolic until you consider his filmography.
Through 1997 to 2005, he played the ensouled vampire Angel on the iconic Buffy the Vampire Slayer and his same-titled spin-off; directly after Angel ended, he landed the role of FBI agent Seeley Booth on the procedural drama Bones, which he held for its entire eleven season run; and then, straight out the gate, he found himself the lead of yet another gritty drama with the oft-underappreciated war drama SEAL Team.
Boreanaz has many tricks that have made him such a magnet for so many TV hits; there's something noble about the characters he's portrayed, and heroic, but he's always been willing to probe their flaws, unpack their demons - with Angel, quite literally - and he's always been up for a self-aware laugh.
Charming and brooding and as nimble as any TV lead should be - dramatic and comic, tough but open - Boreanaz has been lighting up the screen for thirty years now, and he's never got his flowers.
11. Lily Rabe
When we think about American Horror Story, we often think of two or three actors - Evan Peters, Sarah Paulson, Jessica Lange - who rightly deserve all the plaudits they've received over the years.
One name that rarely gets a mention alongside them, though, is Lily Rabe, who's starred in as a many seasons of the series as Peters and Paulson, but always feels tossed aside. Which is a damn shame, when you consider what she's given Ryan Murphy's twisted anthology show over the years.
Portraying haunted nuns, serial killers, witches and lost souls, Rabe has a resume to die for, even by AHS standards, and her ability to shift between pure evil and endearingly innocent can sometimes feel like magic; she embodies each character so thoroughly it's easy to forget you're watching her at all, such is the depth of feeling she finds in each role.
With plenty of roles outside AHS - including a tender supporting turn on the sitcom Shrinking and dramas such as The Tender Bar and The Underground Railroad - Lily Rabe is a talent of immeasurable magnitude, and she deserves more love.
10. John Carroll Lynch
Like Rabe, John Carroll Lynch is best known for his work on American Horror Story - particularly for his turn as the murderous clown Twisty - but he'd built a staggering career long before Ryan Murphy knocked on his door.
From harrowing horrors to hysterical rom-coms, breakneck thrillers to courtroom dramas, Lynch has starred in everything from Zodiac, in a bit role that steals the entire film, to Crazy Stupid Love, where he's clearly having a blast cutting loose as a loving but bumbling dad caught on the sidelines of a bitter divorce.
With a remarkable ability to be at once delicate and dangerous, at once sinister and intelligent, Lynch is the kind of actor that, regardless of role, always defies expectation - he plays characters who often seem to be leaning one way, only to pivot at the last second to devastating effect.
As unpredictable as he is dependable, John Carroll Lynch is the kind of actor who always keeps you guessing... but always promises to deliver the goods. He's a guy you can count on, and we're lucky to have him.
9. James Badge Dale
James Badge Dale is an actor who has always exuded an air of confidence that is difficult to shake, whether he's fighting wildfires in the tearjerking Only the Brave or pushing through war in the HBO miniseries The Pacific.
It's this natural confidence that has served Dale well throughout his career, allowing him at different times to portray villains and heroes alike who can shift between unwaveringly strong and beaten down but still prevailing in a single scene.
Best known for his work in the aforementioned The Pacific, in which he plays a scrappy marine in the Pacific Theatre of World War Two who is driven almost mad by its violence, Dale has done everything from superhero flicks like Iron Man 3 to survival thrillers like The Grey and World War Z.
Never centre stage but always offering his co-stars a confidant against their trials, James Badge Dale is one in a long line of great, prolific actors who we've all known and admired over the years, but who has never really received the flowers he's truly deserved for his successes.
8. Susan Kelechi Watson
If anyone reading this has happened upon the brilliant and heartfelt family drama This Is Us, I'm sure you'll rejoice to see Susan Kelechi Watson getting her flowers here.
Throughout This Is Us, Watson was one of the primary backbones of the show, playing the wife to Sterling K. Brown as a fierce protector, loving mother, fun friend, burdened by grief but never wavering. It was a tough role, to be sure, but Watson rose to the challenge for all its twists, and yet never landed the recognition given to her male co-stars.
It wasn't just on This Is Us that Watson has shone, mind you. Away from that heartbreaking family saga, her recent turn as a White House staff member caught in a murder mystery on Netflix's wonderful The Residence is proof that she's also an excellent comedienne, quick-witted and charming and up for a killer one-liner.
Filling her roles with real humanity and warmth, Watson is a talent worth seeking out when a new project comes your way; she's a vital weapon for any show's arsenal.
7. Kate Siegel
Muse and long-time collaborator Mike Flanagan, it wouldn't be a stretch to say the intrepid filmmaker's best work would have been as brilliant were it not for his wife, Kate Siegel.
Throughout her career, Siegel has stole the spotlight in a number of horror projects, most notably the home invasion thriller Hush and TV miniseries Midnight Mass, The Fall of the House of Usher, and The Haunting of Hill House.
A scream queen in every sense of the word, Siegel has played them all - vicious socialites, embattled writers, grief-stricken loners - and carried every role with the same commitment, each character burdened by something haunting them, something that they refuse to let beat them.
Outside of the Flanagan-verse, Kate Siegel hasn't done an awful lot, but no mistake: the work she's produced throughout her partnership with her husband would surely be enough to make any actor sleep soundly at night.
6. Garrett Dillahunt
Many great actors are known for embodying their roles so completely that it becomes impossible to imagine another person playing them. Such is the case with Garrett Dillahunt, an actor so natural he makes everyone he plays feel as tangibly real as the man portraying them.
Dillahunt will be most recognised by fans of Fear the Walking Dead, where he played John Dorie for two-and-a-bit seasons of zombie-killing mayhem. The role transcended the performances around him, his vision of Dorie that of a quiet, peaceable man who could never quite outrun his demons.
Despite his success in the role, Dillahunt never received the acclaim thrown at his co-stars, which is a surprise given it was such a break-out role for a committed supporting actor who had spent his career offering depth and resilience to such classic movies as No Country for Old Men and Winter's Bone.
An understated performer at his best when playing haunted men with hearts of gold, he's turned up most recently in a host of successful blockbusters - Army of the Dead, Ambulance - but still his due acclaim avoids him.
5. Zoey Deutch
Though she is by some margin the biggest actor on this list, there's still a remarkably good chance that Zoey Deutch is the most underrated comedic actress of her generation.
Though none of her films has been especially big with either critics or the box office, Deutch has carved an impressive career out of turning up in silly and heartfelt comedies alike and consistently delivering the goods.
From Netflix rom-com Set It Up to a scene-stealing, gloriously overblown turn in Zombieland: Double Tap, Deutch's ability to bring to life slightly chaotic but deeply endearing women caught in a crisis is something that you can't not marvel at.
Her best roles can be found in the dramedy Buffaloed, where she plays a desperate but brilliant debt collector fighting the system, and the aforementioned Set It Up, where he role as a struggling assistant to a terrible boss gives the silly romance its beating heart. One-liners galore, she brings warmth to comedy like few actors in her wheelhouse.
4. Shea Whigham
Shea Whigham's filmography is an absolute treasure trove: Boardwalk Empire, Silver Linings Playbook, Bad Lieutenant, Kong: Skull Island, First Man, Bad Times at the El Royale, Joker, Mission: Impossible, F1... the list goes on and on.
A prolific veteran of TV and film, Whigham has never landed himself a lead role, but such is his power; he's a character actor best found in the periphery, portraying complex, often bitter men whose stories and worldviews give extra depth to the difficult men in their immediate orbit.
In Boardwalk Empire, for example, he plays the corrupt police captain brother to Steve Buscemi's domineering crime boss, a role that contains so much murky moral uncertainty it seems unlikely that anyone should be able to keep hold of it before it becomes too much. Whigham, true to form, makes the character sing, makes his vices and pain and conflicts feel so real.
Content to be out of the spotlight, Whigham is often a tragic figure, but he can also be wryly amusing, tough as nails, even tender. He can do it all, and we're lucky he can.
3. Merritt Wever
Unlike most actors on this list, Merritt Wever at least has some award recognition under her belt, thanks primarily to her charming supporting role in the sitcom Nurse Jackie, but otherwise she feels decidedly undervalued by both critics and audiences.
Never content staying stuck in place, Wever has spent her entire career keeping audiences on their toes. She's been sweet and lovable in Nurse Jackie and New Girl, but she's also been tough and uncompromising in the brutal western miniseries Godless, and outright tragic in the true-life drama Unbelievable.
Like so many of our best actors, Wever's talent comes from being relatively unassuming; the characters she plays are often more than meets the eye, like her timid but ultimately strong-willed turn as a doomed survivor in The Walking Dead, or her conflicted performance in the recent sports drama Christy.
A chameleon-like actress who enters every role with the same commitment, Merritt Wever has won some awards, and been in some big hits... but her name isn't nearly as well-known as it should be.
2. Doug Jones
You may not know Doug Jones. If you saw him, you'd probably be hard-pressed to put a name to the face, because it's a face audiences rarely see.
A crucial ingredient to countless Guillermo Del Toro films, Jones is best known for vanishing behind heavy prosthetics to portray mythical creatures, gods, monsters, and demonic superheroes. He was the majestic Faun in Pan's Labyrinth, a genius crime-fighter in Hellboy and its sequel, and a ghost in Crimson Peak.
A successful contortionist and mime artist, Jones' ability to bring humanity and personality to so many weird and wonderful creatures has helped breathe so much life into Del Toro's work that his name should be uttered alongside the director's whenever their collaborations are brought up.
This is especially true of The Shape of Water, where he portrays the romantic and lonesome Amphibian Man - a mute fish who forms a relationship with a lonely woman - as achingly human. He's given so many films their heart and soul, offered audiences so many iconic characters, and yet too few know his name, or his face.
1. Samantha Sloyan
As it stands, Samantha Sloyan may just be the most underappreciated actor working today, a virtuoso powerhouse who has been quietly stealing the show of every project she's starred in.
Known as one of the primary collaborators of the great Mike Flanagan, Sloyan has every base covered. She played a grieving mother, recently, on the second season of The Pitt, delivering one of the show's most powerful guest performances, and she was a pivotal heartbreaker in a critical subplot of Grey's Anatomy's eleventh season.
But it's with Flanagan that the actress has soared highest. From a scheming parishioner in the psychological Midnight Mass - a treasure trove of superlative acting talent in which she emerges as the ensemble's most compelling personality - to a shaken entrepreneur hunted by the Death in the bloody Fall of the House of Usher, Sloyan has spent over a decade finding stark humanity in characters ranging from pure evil to hopelessly doomed.
As of this writing, she's currently set to portray the iconic Margaret White in Flanagan's upcoming Carrie miniseries, a role that will surely - hopefully - help her wicked talents be more appreciated by critics and audiences alike.