Nerve Review: 6 Ups & 5 Downs
An effective, but flawed techno-thriller.

In a summer of disappointing blockbusters, here comes an unassuming little tech-thriller to dust away the cobwebs and offer up an alternative to CGI-fueled superhero throwdowns.
Nerve may not be perfect, but it's nevertheless an entertaining stab at the role of technology in our lives, and the nefarious applications it potentially has. Garnering mixed-positive reviews from critics so far, Nerve won't be for everyone, but it certainly soars more than it stumbles, and is a rock solid calling card for directors Henry Joost and Ariel Schulman, not to mention on-the-rise talents Emma Roberts and Dave Franco.
On paper this one doesn't invite many expectations beyond being perversely enjoyable B-movie trash, but the end result is, surprisingly enough, a good deal more impressive than you'll probably anticipate, even if it could certainly use work in some areas. Still, it's earned better reviews than Batman v Superman, Jason Bourne and Suicide Squad: soak that one in for a minute.
Here are 6 ups and 5 downs from Nerve...
Downs...
5. The Actors Are Too Old To Play Teenagers

Something that was almost laughably apparent from the trailers alone is the fact that the majority of the movie's cast are far, far too old to be playing teenagers. Now, while it's never explicitly stated that Dave Franco's character is a high-schooler, even early 20s is a bit of stretch for him (he's 31 years old in reality), while the 25-year-old Emma Roberts is just scarcely believable as a 17-18 year-old.
The most embarrassing spot of casting in the entire movie, however, is Orange is the New Black's Kimiko Glenn as one of Roberts' high-school buddies. She's 27 years old and is hilariously unbelievable as someone 10 years her junior, all the more so because the wardrobe department have blatantly tried to "dress her young".
It's not a deal breaker, but it sure is distracting all the same.
4. Internal Logic Is Flimsy At Best

As on-the-pulse as the movie feels with modern tech trends, there's also an unfortunate lack of internal logic regarding the "rules" of the titular game above all else.
Even ignoring the implausibility of these people's phones managing to stay charged despite appearing to constantly be in use, the movie never really makes it clear how both the players and watchers interface with the game.
The fact that the players have to record the dares themselves feels like a clumsy addition solely thrown in to add tension to a certain ladder sequence mid-way through the movie, even though it limits what the players can actually do and is actually betrayed itself several times during the movie (where Roberts' character gets someone else to record her dare for her).
This is without even mentioning some third-act shenanigans that basically uproot any and all plausibility the movie had, with no convincing explanation given for the goalposts being shifted.
If you watch this movie, be prepared to accept that it's clever but also on shaky ground in terms of logical consistency.
3. There's A Mostly Pointless Dead Brother Subplot

A subplot hanging around Nerve's periphery is the death of Roberts' older brother two years prior to the movie's events. It's strangely never revealed how he died, only that he was a risk-taker and a good deal more "fun" than his younger sister.
It feels like this is going to lead to some sort of payoff, possibly that the brother actually died playing Nerve, but instead it's just kinda forgotten about except when a character wants to take a cheap shot at Roberts for her loss.
You can argue that having a dead brother deepens the bond she has with her mother (played by Juliette Lewis) and her desire to leave home for college, but it doesn't really have much psychological depth and feels like something that probably should've been shaved off the script in drafting. It adds very little and feels woefully tacked-on.
2. It's Tamer Than You Probably Expect

Nerve has an undeniably delicious premise that suggests an increasingly dark tone, where players are dared to do the most profane and degrading things in exchange for cash.
As it stands, probably because of that pesky PG-13 rating, this is a surprisingly tame film for the most part, with many of the dares being more silly and playful than legitimately dangerous (at least until the final reel, anyway).
The BBFC title card for the movie describes it as containing "risky imitable behaviour", such as characters going prone underneath trains and hanging off construction cranes, but in terms of salaciousness, the movie's actually more restrained and less trashy than a lot of people will be both expecting and hoping for.
No, nobody dares someone to get balls deal in a dead pig or anything like that, which makes it almost disappointingly classy.
1. The Third Act Is A Mess

As entertaining as that opening hour is, the film's third act goes wildly off-the-rails and might simply be too much for some audiences. The implausibilities mount up, and what was a semi-grounded premise basically ends up totally silly, amping up the ridiculousness and melodrama in fairly unsavoury fashion.
Don't be mistaken: it's still enjoyable to watch, though it almost feels like somebody else came in and rewrote the last third of the script, because it feels so much more heightened than what came before. Character logic falls off a cliff and the ending is sure to leave many unsatisfied, as it rushes to a conclusion that honestly doesn't really feel earned.
And now, let's look at Nerve's positives...
Ups...
6. It's Smart & Timely

For all of its issues, Nerve is a refreshingly smart techno-thriller that has its finger on the pulse of modern technology trends and concerns. The fact that the movie revolves around live-streaming dares feels all-too-relevant in 2016 given the current popularity of services such as Periscope and Facebook Live. This helps the film feel relatively grounded (for a time, anyway) when, a few years ago, it might not have seemed quite so plausible.
To this end the film also does a great job riffing on the narcissistic outlet the web provides for everyone, the notion of Internet "fame", the prevalence of social media in society and so on, all without getting overly preachy or suggesting that these technologies are inherently bad.
They merely lay the foundation for the high-concept premise, and with Catfish directors Henry Joost and Ariel Schulman at the helm, it's none-too-surprising that they manage to make the film both provocative and timely.
5. James Franco Has A Hilarious "Cameo"

That's right, Dave Franco's older brother James has a cameo... sort of. The first few minutes of Nerve take place largely on Roberts' computer as she learns about the game, and as she's browsing the web, she comes across a web link that asks, "Is James Franco Too Smart?"
It appears on the screen for just a few seconds, but it's a fun little nod at Dave's brother, while unobtrusive enough that you could easily miss it considering how much is happening on-screen at the time.
Don't be surprised if fans unearth a bunch more Easter eggs like this once the movie is out on home video.
4. The Terrific Visuals

Easily the most striking aspect right out of the gate is Nerve's superb visuals, both in terms of Joost and Schulman's stylish direction (which frequently covers the screen in flashy app-style interfaces), and Michael Simmonds' gorgeous cinematography, aided by liberal use of neon lighting throughout.
It's only a $20 million movie so a workmanlike style probably would've been acceptable enough, but instead Joost and Schulman make the most of their budget and ensure the film's smart riffs on our contemporary tech-addled society are also damn fine-looking too.
That's without even mentioning that scene where Franco and Roberts strip off in a department store, speaking of which...
3. Emma Roberts & Dave Franco's Chemistry

A major reason for the movie succeeding as well as it does is the palpable chemistry between Roberts and Franco. A movie of this sort can live or die on the basis of how believable the central pairing is, and these two cook up a storm on-screen.
It helps enormously that the movie throws them into increasingly outrageous situations throughout, and the film is arguably never better than when the two have their clothes stolen out of a department store changing room and are forced to leave the store in their underwear.
The chemistry, both sexual and otherwise, enhances the film's playfulness and makes it a little easier to buy into some of the sillier plot developments later on (a little bit, anyway).
2. Rob Simonsen's Score

Complimenting the movie's superb visuals is a cracking score from Rob Simonsen, and while the combination of synth and neon has been arguably overused to the point of cliche in recent years (especially in recent films from Nicolas Winding Refn), it rarely feels as appropriate as it does in this noirish tech thriller.
Simonsen's score functions extremely well both as a standalone album and a pulsing accompaniment to the gorgeous visuals, heightening the tension but also not lacking ethereal moments of breathing room every now and then. In short, even if the movie on the whole doesn't quite work for you, you'll probably dig the technical package.
1. It's Surprisingly Tense

That's right, when Nerve gets tense, it gets really, really tense. Even though a lot of the dares are fairly underwhelming, there are a couple of truly hair-raising ones, especially one involving scaling a ladder suspended over two 10-story apartment windows, and a certain character climbing atop a giant construction crane and having to free-hang from one hand for five seconds.
These scenes will induce sweaty-palmed anxiety in many viewers, especially as the movie is unpredictable enough that death could always be around the corner. Joost and Schulman do a fantastic job milking the tension, aided by the fact that most of the dares have a time limit and egg the player on to complete them as quickly as possible.
Don't be surprised to find your hand dug into your seat without realising during some of the movie's more high-wire sequences.
What did you think of Nerve? Shout it out in the comments!