Oscar Nominations 2019: 6 Ups & 9 Downs

Black Panther makes Oscar history.

Black Panther Bohemian Rhapsody
Marvel Studios & Fox

The Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences has announced their list of nominations for the 91st Academy Awards, which will be presented on February 24.

And it's probably fair to call this year's slate of nominees a hugely mixed bag, right?

Every year without fail there's a ton of online hand-wringing about movies being "snubbed" while others are needlessly rewarded, but the 2019 Academy Awards really is set to be one of the most milquetoast and disappointingly dull ceremonies of recent times.

With surely the least inspired Best Picture field in years and numerous broad-playing films receiving an over-abundance of nominations across the board, it's clear where the unimaginative passions of the voter base are currently resting.

The race certainly isn't over, and it's still possible that one of four or five movies ends up scooping the Best Picture Oscar, but it's probably worth preparing yourself for the likelihood that this year's show is going to be incredibly safe - and incredibly white - where major awards are concerned...


Downs...

9. Too Much Love For Bohemian Rhapsody, Green Book & Vice

Green Book
Universal Pictures

Though it wasn't remotely surprising, it was disappointing to see the Academy spring so enthusiastically for some of the year's more middling, mainstream-skewing awards contenders, namely Bohemian Rhapsody, Green Book and Vice.

Bohemian Rhapsody scooped four nominations, and though its Sound Editing and Sound Mixing nods were expected and Rami Malek's Best Actor nomination is acceptable, the workmanlike biopic scoring a Best Picture nomination is completely absurd. This also makes it one of the worst-reviewed movies to receive a Best Picture nomination in recent years.

Green Book meanwhile overcame controversy to land five nominations for Best Picture, Best Actor (Viggo Mortensen), Best Supporting Actor (Mahershala Ali), Best Original Screenplay and Best Film Editing.

You can make decent enough cases for the strong performances, but does the movie's facile examination of systemic racism really feel remotely awards-worthy?

And finally, there's Adam McKay's Vice, which is easily the best of these three over-achieving awards prospects but still hardly a great film.

A mighty eight nominations feels pretty out-there, for as brilliant as Christian Bale and Amy Adams' performances are along with the fantastic makeup work, the nominations for Best Picture, Best Director and Film Editing are pretty damn suspect.

It's a bizarre, depressing reality that, after the diverse progress the Academy appeared to make in recent years, 2019 has seen voters en masse take a regressive step back to throwing nominations at movies this generic and unsophisticated.

Is this our punishment for spitting on the planned Best Popular Film award?


8. Snubbed: First Man For Best Original Score

First Man Ryan Gosling
Universal

There were a number of notable snubs in the Best Original Score category this year - Mary Queen of Scots and Suspiria both deserved to make the cut - but there's one especially egregious omission, and that's Justin Hurwitz's much-loved score for First Man.

The two-time Oscar winner is a big part of the reason that First Man's jaw-dropping Moon landing sequence is as powerful as it is, and for him to miss the cut here despite a mighty campaign over the last few months is just ridiculous.

Were the scores for Black Panther, BlacKkKlansman, If Beale Street Could Talk, Isle of Dogs and Mary Poppins Returns all really better than this? Absolutely not.


7. Snubbed: Bradley Cooper For Best Director (A Star Is Born)

A Star Is Born Bradley Cooper
Warner Bros.

Perhaps the most surprising snub of the entire lot was Bradley Cooper missing out on a Best Director nomination for A Star Is Born, despite seeming like a lock for a nomination for pretty much the entirety of Oscar season.

It's especially odd as Cold War's Pawel Pawlikowski even managed to sneak a shock Best Director nod, and it's just tough to make sense of how Cooper was pipped to the post by a niche filmmaker who didn't have anywhere near his level of support.

While Spike Lee, Yorgos Lanthimos and Alfonso Cuaron were untouchable in this category, having both Pawlikowski and Adam McKay in the mix but not Cooper is just wrong. It's Ben Affleck getting snubbed for Argo all over again, and puts A Star Is Born's Best Picture prospects in serious doubt.


6. No Technical Nominations For Mission: Impossible - Fallout

Mission Impossible Fallout Tom Cruise
Paramount

Mission: Impossible - Fallout was never going to be up for major Oscars, but considering that it's arguably the most technically accomplished blockbuster of the summer, it's shocking that the film didn't receive even a single nod.

Fallout was absolutely deserving of a Best Film Editing nomination - a category where tentpole movies can sometimes thrive - yet the Academy bafflingly felt that Bohemian Rhapsody, Green Book and Vice were all more deserving...somehow.

And then there's Sound Editing and Sound Mixing, which are action-friendly categories where Fallout was unquestionably worthy, yet it was beaten out by the likes of Black Panther, Bohemian Rhapsody, A Quiet Place and Roma.

Considering that Bohemian Rhapsody couldn't even convincingly sync up Rami Malek's mouth movements with the music half the time, was its editing and sound work really better than Fallout's glorious sensory assault?


5. Snubbed: Ethan Hawke For Best Actor (First Reformed)

First Reformed Ethan Hawke
A24

This was always a bit of an outside possibility, but Ethan Hawke ran an incredibly passionate campaign for his performance in First Reformed, and after picking up significant traction on the precursor circuit, it really seemed like he'd scoop a Best Actor nomination.

Though writer-director Paul Schrader did at least score a Best Original Screenplay nod, the film was otherwise shut out, with what was arguably Hawke's career-best performance being incredulously snubbed.

It seems likely that Hawke's slot ended up going to Willem Dafoe (At Eternity's Gate), though was Hawke's performance really lesser than Rami Malek (Bohemian Rhapsody) and Viggo Mortensen (Green Book)? Nonsense.


4. Countless Beloved Indies Get Shut Out

Hereditary Movie
A24

Every year without fail there are a number of much-loved indie films which just don't pick up sufficient momentum to actually make it onto the nominees list.

This year had some especially infuriating omissions, such as Leave No Trace losing out on Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Actor (Ben Foster) and Best Actress (Thomasin McKenzie); Hereditary for pretty much everything but especially Best Actress (Toni Collette); and Eighth Grade for Best Original Screenplay, Best Actress (Elsie Fisher) and Best Supporting Actor (Josh Hamilton).

It speaks to an awards show going through an identity crisis of sorts: it wants to skew towards popular appeal in order to salvage those fast-sinking ratings, but it also wants to purport to be rewarding the greatest artistic achievements of the year.

Without these movies getting even a single nomination among them, the Academy has fallen incredibly short of its apparently prestigious mark.


3. Snubbed: Burning For Best Foreign Language Film

Burning Steven Yuen
CGV Arthouse

Though Lee Chang-dong's searing mystery drama made the nine-film shortlist for the Best Foreign Language Film Oscar back in December, it sadly didn't land South Korea a spot as one of the final nominees despite Burning being one of the year's best-reviewed films, foreign language or not.

In total fairness, Best Foreign Language Film is a stacked category this year, but considering that Burning's critical response was decidedly more effusive than that of nominees Capernaum and Never Look Away, it's a damn shame the singular drama wasn't given the rub.

This is a category that routinely snubs worthy films, but it's extra galling in the case of Burning as it clearly made it so damn close to actually being nominated.


2. Snubbed: First Man & If Beale Street Could Talk For Best Picture

If Beale Street Could Talk
Annapurna

Due to the Academy's over-complicated preferential ballot system, there were only eight films nominated for Best Picture this year, leaving two spots unfilled which clearly should've gone to First Man and If Beale Street Could Talk.

In the case of First Man, the movie's detached tone and disappointing box office performance may be to blame, while Barry Jenkins' drama was one of the year's best-reviewed films and seemed like a total lock for Best Picture, so its omission is much more surprising.

In a year where a decidedly less-nuanced film about a race relations (Green Book) actually made the Best Picture field, it's especially infuriating to see Jenkins' film not making the cut.

Clearly, the balloting system needs a rework, because while there shouldn't be 10 Best Picture nominees by default, the final slate wouldn't seem quite so underwhelming if a few outside prospects made it into the field.


1. Snubbed: Won't You Be My Neighbor? & Three Identical Strangers For Best Documentary

Three Identical Strangers
Neon

Much like Best Foreign Language Film, the documentary category frequently ends up snubbing popular documentaries for no discernible reason.

The big casualties this year were the universally-acclaimed Fred Rogers documentary Won't You Be My Neighbor? and the riveting Three Identical Strangers.

Both received rave reviews pretty much across the board and seemed like sure bets for Best Documentary Film nods, but both ended up missing out.

In addition to the expected Free Solo, Minding the Gap and RBG being nominated, Hale County This Morning This Evening and Of Fathers and Sons also made the cut.

The latter is an especially odd choice as it's not had the critical momentum of the aforementioned snubbed films, but the Academy's documentary branch clearly saw something in it over these more mainstream docs.

As frustrating as this year's abundance of snubs is, the slate of nominees certainly wasn't all bad. Here's everything the Academy got really right...


Ups...

6. A Superhero Movie FINALLY Gets A Best Picture Nomination

Black Panther
Marvel Studios

More than a decade after the Marvel Cinematic Universe first kicked off, the superhero genre has finally landed its first Best Picture nomination.

Though The Dark Knight and Logan were famously snubbed for the award despite passionate campaigns in previous years, the sheer pop-culture spectacle that is Black Panther managed to smash the glass ceiling in a joyous moment for comic book fans.

There's already been a ton of backlash about whether or not the movie truly is worthy of being in the Best Picture race, but let's consider a few things here.

First and foremost, it hasn't got a chance in Hell of winning, and secondly, in a year where Bohemian Rhapsody, Green Book and Vice are nominated, is it really worth complaining about a universally acclaimed superhero film getting a nomination?

Bravo to Marvel Studios and everyone involved with Black Panther.


5. Sam Elliott Sneaks Into The Best Supporting Actor Race

A Star Is Born Sam Elliott
Warner Bros.

Though Sam Elliott's performance in A Star Is Born was singled out by pretty much everybody who reviewed it, his presence on the awards circuit has been pretty wishy-washy, such that the prospect of an Oscar nomination wasn't looking terribly bright.

What a pleasant surprise it was, then, to hear Elliott's name called out among the Best Supporting Actor nominees.

He'll be facing stiff competition from Mahershala Ali (Green Book) and Richard E. Grant (Can You Ever Forgive Me?) in particular, but could the industry-wide affection for Elliott help build the narrative that the 74-year-old actor deserves the award?

After all, this is the first Oscar nomination of his storied, 50-year career, and his outstanding performance helps anchor both Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper's also-nominated performances.

Whatever happens, it's just great to see him nominated.


4. The Diverse Technical Nominations

Cold War
Film4

The crafts nominations were a surprisingly widespread bunch this year, with a couple of slots ending filled up by foreign language films.

The Best Cinematography field, for instance, had three non-English speaking nominees in Cold War, Never Look Away and Roma, while Swedish fantasy film Border - which didn't even make the nine-film Best Foreign Film shortlist - scored a Best Makeup & Hairstyling nod.

Though much of this year's ceremony felt like Academy voters taking a few steps back, it was at least encouraging to see them voting more adventurously in the technical categories.


3. Willem Dafoe Gets His Fourth Acting Nomination

At Eternity S Gate Willem Dafoe
CBS Films

Another big, pleasant surprise this year was Willem Dafoe receiving his fourth acting nomination for his universally acclaimed performance as Vincent van Gogh in At Eternity's Gate.

The movie hasn't had much momentum at all on the awards circuit so far, but a Golden Globe nomination for Dafoe may well have prompted some voters to actually watch their screeners and see what it was all about.

Dafoe hasn't got a chance of winning up against the more volcanic likes of Christian Bale and Rami Malek, but if nothing else, it's another feather in the cap of one of our greatest living actors, who might one day finally scoop that damn Oscar.


2. Black Panther Misses Out On Best Visual Effects

Black Panther
Marvel

After it became clear that the Academy was going all-in with their love for Black Panther, it seemed probable that the film might end up landing a Best Visual Effects nomination...despite the movie's low-rent CGI being its most complained-about element.

Though Black Panther made the ten-film shortlist, it thankfully didn't land an arbitrary nomination, with the final five instead consisting of Avengers: Infinity War, Christopher Robin, First Man, Ready Player One and Solo: A Star Wars Story. That's a pretty solid bunch, in honesty.

The important thing is that Black Panther got its Best Picture nomination, but knowing the Academy's tendency to give a movie everything or nothing, it would've been frustrating to see the film nominated here over so many more visually appealing prospects.


1. Marina De Tavira's Surprise Best Supporting Actress Nomination

Roma 2018
Netflix

The most surprising acting nomination this year is without question Marina De Tavira's Best Supporting Actress nod for her performance as Sofia in Roma.

While her co-star Yalitza Aparicio received almost two-dozen nominations across the guilds, De Tavira earned not a single one, and just about nobody expected an Oscar nomination to be coming her way.

It's certainly a well-deserved nomination, though: her achingly human work holds up a mirror to Aparicio's focal performance, with each complimenting the other.

De Tavira being singled out is certainly encouraging for Roma's Oscar chances, even if she hasn't got a chance of winning the category against the likes of Regina King (If Beale Street Could Talk) and Amy Adams (Vice).

What's your take on the 2019 Oscar nominations? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.