Oscar Nominations 2021: 7 Ups & 8 Downs

A diverse set of nominees with some outrageous snubs.

Oscars 2021 Sound of Metal Hillbilly Elegy
Amazon & Netflix

The nominations for this year's Academy Awards have finally been unveiled, in what's undeniably been the most agonisingly, exhaustingly prolonged awards season of all time.

With the precursors all out of the bag, it fell to the Oscars to place a capper on the season, and though the ceremony still doesn't take place for another six weeks, the road to the final awards show of the year is now fully mapped out.

As with any year, the nominations were a mixed bag of pleasant surprises and frustrating snubs, though there was generally a lot less to be majorly upset than in recent times, largely thanks to the Academy's evidently successful diversity initiatives.

It may not have been the most exciting year for film for obvious reasons, but regardless of the state of the world, the Academy still rustled up a rock solid slate of nominees across the board, albeit with a few baffling inclusions and head-scratching omissions.

While it seems like this year's Oscars won't be offering up much outside the norm where winners are concerned, we've still got six weeks to cheerlead our unlikely faves and hope for the best...


Downs...

8. Snub: Delroy Lindo (Best Actor)

Da 5 Bloods Delroy Lindo
Netflix

The Best Actor field was absolutely stacked this year, and while there were numerous worthy actors who didn't make the cut - including Mads Mikkelsen (Another Round) and Tahar Rahim (The Mauritanian) - no snub stung more than Delroy Lindo (Da 5 Bloods).

Lindo's unforgettable performance as PTSD-afflicted war veteran Paul is the easy high-point of the actor's career, and upon release generated a heap of Oscar buzz.

Sadly Lindo's momentum cooled in the months following the film's release and never recovered, causing him to miss out on a nomination. It isn't easy to pick an actor for him to replace, admittedly, but this really felt like his time for a nod.


7. Glenn Close Nominated For Best Supporting Actress

Glenn Close Hillbilly Elegy
Netflix

Though it wasn't remotely surprising to see Glenn Close nominated for Best Supporting Actress for her performance in Hillbilly Elegy, it sure was a lazy pick by the Academy.

This marks Close's eighth nomination without a win so far and also makes her just the third actor in history - after Amy Irving and James Coco - to receive Oscar and Razzie nominations for the same performance, which is almost hilarious enough to merit her nomination.

While her performance isn't bad by any conventional metric, it just sticks out compared to the actually great works of her fellow nominees, while taking a spot away from worthier actors such as Dominique Fishback (Judas and the Black Messiah), Jodie Foster (The Mauritanian), Helena Zengel (News of the World), and Ellen Burstyn (Pieces of a Woman).

Best Supporting Actress is one of the more chaotic and wide-open categories this year, so don't be surprised if Close finally sneaks the win outright, if only to finally put her long-suffering Oscar bridesmaid status to rest.


6. Best Supporting Actor's Blatant Category Fraud

Judas and the Black Messiah Lakeith Stanfield
Warner Bros.

The Best Supporting Actor field is absolutely mighty this year, though one big surprise came in the way of Lakeith Stanfield's nomination for his superb turn in Judas and the Black Messiah.

Given that he was nominated in the category alongside co-star Daniel Kaluuya, the question soon arises - if they're both supporting, who the hell is the lead?

As deserving as Stanfield's performance is of a nomination, this is a clear-cut case of category fraud, the actor being pushed to the less-crowded supporting field because he doesn't have a chance of breaking into the lead field.

Though it's still a deserving nomination and he edged out only Jared Leto (The Little Things) and Chadwick Boseman (Da 5 Bloods), it's still a totally ridiculous cheat at the end of the day.


5. Snub: Mank (Best Original Screenplay & Best Film Editing)

Mank Gary Oldman Amanda Seyfried
Netflix

Despite leading the pack with 10 nominations, Mank failed to net two key nominations which are often heavy indicators of a film's major awards success: screenplay and editing.

David Fincher's late father Jack was a hot bet to receive a posthumous Best Original Screenplay nod for the film, while veteran cutter Kirk Baxter was widely tipped to score his expected third Best Film Editing nod

In terms of screenplay, it was edged out by the late-day momentum of Judas and the Black Messiah, and editing was pipped by Frédéric Thoraval's work on Promising Young Woman.

Though Mank's genuine Best Picture hopes evaporated a while ago, and it'll ultimately be lucky to go home with a couple of awards, the film's sharp writing and exacting editing are key components of why it works so well. An odd omission, then, especially for a film about writing and filmmaking itself.


4. The Baffling Best Visual Effects Nominees

Mulan 2020
Disney

Best Visual Effects is a category which leaves film fans mystified year in and year out, and 2021 is clearly no exception.

Though there wasn't much arguing with the likes of Love and Monsters, The Midnight Sky, The One and Only Ivan, and Tenet receiving nominations, the decision to throw Mulan a bone rings totally hollow.

Despite its $200 million budget, one of the chief complaints leveled against Mulan was its sub-par visual effects, too often devolving into blurry, ugly, scarcely coherent nonsense.

This fifth slot could've gone to so many other deserving films - Mank, Birds of Prey, Soul, or Welcome to Chechnya - yet voters instead made the mistake of springing for Most Visual Effects rather than Best Visual Effects.


3. Major Snubs For Best Documentary & Best International Feature

La Llorona
Shudder

The Best Documentary and Best International Feature categories so often seem like voters just throwing darts at a dartboard and hoping for the best, and the same was certainly true this year.

Best Documentary saw widely buzzed-about docs Boys State, The Painter and the Thief, and Welcome to Chechnya left off the slate, while the wildly over-praised My Octopus Teacher and the scarcely discussed The Mole Agent managed to get in.

The Best International Feature branch, meanwhile, predictably snubbed the only horror movie of the bunch, Guatemala's superb La Llorona, ensuring this was yet another year where no horror films received any nominations whatsoever.


2. Only Eight Best Picture Nominees

One Night In Miami
Amazon Studios

2021 marks the final year where the Best Picture field can nominate anywhere between five and ten movies - from 2022 it will be locked to 10 nominees no matter what.

And so, this year's slate contained a mere eight nominees, leaving a number of deserving films out in the cold, namely Ma Rainey's Black Bottom, One Night in Miami, News of the World, and hell, maybe even Borat Subsequent Moviefilm.

While some might argue that having a mandatory 10-nominee list devalues a Best Picture nomination, there are so many great movies released in even a soft year that there shouldn't ever be trouble to fill the slots.

Thankfully this won't be an issue from next year onward.


1. A Predictable Oscar Night Is Set In Stone

Nomadland 2021
Searchlight Pictures

The lack of major surprises in the big Oscar categories likely means we're in for an extremely predictable night on April 25th, with Nomadland's (admittedly deserving) path to Best Picture and Best Director glory likely to be unchallenged.

It's dominated so thoroughly on the precursor circuit that there's very little possibility of any other film pulling a Parasite and crashing the party.

Really the only fun and unpredictable major category is Best Supporting Actress, but beyond that there's likely to be little outside the expected.

Given that this year's Oscar race has been distended by an entire two months, it only makes the foregone conclusion feel that much more prolonged and played-out.

But these issues aside, this year's Oscar nominations got a hell of a lot right...


Ups...

7. The Most Diverse Oscar Nominees Ever

Minari film
A24

The Oscars have been routinely criticised for their lack of diversity in recent years, given the predominantly white acting nominees and mostly-male directing nominees.

With the Academy inviting a more diverse slate of artists to join its membership in recent years, it's great to see that reflected in the most diverse list of nominees in Oscar history.

Of the 20 acting nominees this year, only 11 (55%) were white, and just four (20%) white Americans. Better still, Steven Yuen (Minari) and Riz Ahmed (Sound of Metal) became the first Asian-American and Muslim Best Actor nominees respectively.

Best Director also saw two women - Chloe Zhao (Nomadland) and Emerald Fennell (Promising Young Woman) - nominated for the first time in history, and Zhao is the first non-white woman to ever receive a nomination in the category.

Simply, you love to see it.


6. Tenet Misses Out On Best Sound

Robert Pattinson Tenet
Warner Bros.

Many were waiting to see whether or not Christopher Nolan's Tenet would receive a Best Sound nomination or not, given both the controversy surrounding its complex sound mix and the sound branch's tradition of nomination unconventional mixes.

Despite nominating Interstellar for both Sound Editing and Sound Mixing back in 2015, Tenet was rightly snubbed for a Best Sound nod this year, a seemingly just move given the legions of viewers left frustrated by the oft-incomprehensible dialogue and overly bombastic music.

If you're not hard-of-hearing but still need subtitles just to understand the basics of the plot, then somebody didn't do their job.


5. The White Tiger Sneaks Into Best Adapted Screenplay

The White Tiger
Netflix

One of the more interesting surprises this year was seeing Ramin Bahrani's acclaimed Netflix drama The White Tiger secure a Best Adapted Screenplay nomination, while the likes of Ma Rainey's Black Bottom, The Mauritanian, News of the World, and indie darling First Cow were edged out.

With Borat Subsequent Moviefilm already sneaking into the slate, there didn't seem to be much room for another left-field nominee, and yet, here it is.

Though this is absolutely a case of the nomination basically being the win for Bahrani given that he has zero chance of actually winning, it's still neat to see his fine efforts rewarded, and the film's global streaming release no doubt helped it build a head of steam.


4. Sound Of Metal Receives Six Nominations

Sound Of Metal Riz Ahmed
Amazon Studios

Considering it premiered at TIFF back in September 2019 to a solid critical reception and wasn't released by Amazon until over a year later, few would've been surprised if Sound of Metal came and went without making a dent in the grander Oscar picture.

But a surge of critical acclaim late last year has allowed its momentum to build and build, even if many still doubted its chances to receive substantial Oscar nominations.

And so, it's a tremendous joy to see the superb drama receive six nods, for Best Picture, Best Actor (Riz Ahmed), Best Supporting Actor (Paul Raci), Best Original Screenplay, Best Film Editing, and Best Sound.

Raci in particular seemed like he might end up getting snubbed, but the Academy ultimately rallied to support one of the most affecting and original dramas of the last year.


3. Trent Reznor & Atticus Ross Get Two Best Original Score Nominations

Pixar Soul
Disney+

Composing duo Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross can now count themselves as three-time Best Original Score nominees after receiving dual nominations this year for their work on both David Fincher's Mank and Pixar's Soul.

This marks their first nominations since they won the award for Fincher's The Social Network a whole decade ago, and the two films they've been recognised for - a period biopic about Hollywood and an existential animated comedy - couldn't really be much different.

Better still, there's a strong chance the two actually end up winning the gong outright for Soul, given the general audience and critical love for both the movie and its sublime score.


2. Shaun The Sheep Edges Out The Croods: A New Age (Best Animated Feature)

Shaun The sheep Farmageddon
StudioCanal

Best Animated Feature is a field which often ends up relying on the most commercially successful films of the year while ignore more adventurous independent efforts, though this year's slate was rock solid indeed.

In addition to expected nominations for Soul, Onward, and Wolfwalkers, the less-sure prospects of Netflix's Over the Moon and A Shaun the Sheep Movie: Farmageddon ended up making the cut.

This was at the surprising expense of The Croods: A New Age, an entertaining if ultimately rather formulaic animated sequel which really didn't merit nomination at all.

Considering that Shaun the Sheep had its initial UK release back in late 2019, you'd be forgiven for not even realising it was eligible for a nomination (it didn't land in America until last February).


1. Eurovision Song Contest's "Husavik (My Hometown)" Is Nominated For Best Original Song

Eurovision Song Contest The Story of Fire Saga Rachel McAdams
Netflix

And finally, considering how the Best Original Song field is so often full of overwrought ballads and generic pop songs, it was fun to see something a little sillier crash the party, with Eurovision Song Contest: The Story of Fire Saga's "Husavik (My Hometown)" securing a nomination.

The rest of the field was pretty much exactly as you'd expect from Academy voters - yes, Diane Warren picked up her 12th nomination without a win to date - so it was refreshing to see something a little more tongue-in-cheek make the cut.

Plus, where else are you going to see a songwriter by the name of Fat Max Gsus get a damn Oscar nomination?


In this post: 
Oscars 2021
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.