Oscars 2013: If We Picked The Winners (Best Supporting Actor)

Django5 In the very first lines delivered in the brilliant opening scene of The Social Network, Mark Zuckerberg (Jessie Eisenberg) rifles off the interesting trivial tidbit that there are more people with genius IQs living in China than there are people of any kind living in the United States. Zuckerberg goes on to pose the question, "How do you distinguish yourself in a population of people who all got 1600 on their SATs?" This is how I feel about the Best Supporting Actor category almost every year. At this current juncture in the history of cinema, it just so happens that the availability of choice roles for male supporting players and characters actors is as plentiful as adorable pet videos are on Youtube. This makes the daunting task of whittling down the gargantuan field of deserving Best Supporting Actor candidates to a mere five nominees a Herculean effort. It also guarantees that without a doubt there will be, every year, a host of wonderful supporting performances that don't make the final cut, and 2012 was no exception to this rule. In fact, I could write a whole article on the best supporting performances from male actors in 2012 that did not get nominated (or even those that were not even in the conversation to be nominated), that's how deep this field is, but in the interest of focus and brevity, I will just mention a few that would have made it on my own personal ballot. The first and foremost of these is the astounding performance from the non-professional actor Dwight Henry in Beast of the Southern Wild. Playing Wink, the father of Hushpuppy (Quvenzhane Wallis), it's very evident that this is a performance from someone other than a professional thespian, and I mean this in the best possible way. It's a performance clearly based on observation and experience, which is why it's my favorite performance of the year, regardless of category. I would have also made room for the revoltingly creepy turn from John Cusack as Hillary Van Wetter in The Paperboy. The film proved to be pretty divisive amongst critics, most of who derided it with the exception of a few vocal ardent defenders (of which I am one). Even if you're not so hot on the film itself though, it's hard not to appreciate, or at least remember, some of the crazy performances in this Southern Gothic Neo-Noir and among all the film's fine performances, none stood out as much as John Cusack's performance. Finally, I would also have nominated Scoot McNairy in Killing Them Softly. Like The Paperboy, Killing Them Softly was another film in 2012 that I felt was criminally underrated, but if you haven't seen the film, it is worth checking out just for its plethora of fantastic supporting performances. From Richard Jenkins to James Gandolfini to Ray Lioatta, this film had an amazing lineup of character actors, but Scoot McNairy, appearing to be channelling Casey Affleck, was particularly impressive. All in all though, the nominees the Academy came up with weren't half bad. As you will see momentarily, I took some exception to a few of them, but most gave terrific performances that will undoubtedly be well regarded for years to come.

5. Alan Arkin in Argo

Argo-Alan-Arkin "You had me at Argo-f**k-yourself." I imagine this was the sentiment of many an Academy member, as they clearly ate up this cartoon-ish caricature of an egotistical, crotchety old Hollywood producer. Now don't get me wrong, nobody does old-man grump with as much smart-ass precision as Alan Arkin, but the problems I had with this performance is that it just accentuated all the problems I had with the movie itself. Cliche, predictable, and aggressively middle-brow, every line uttered by Alan Arkin contributes to the "derp de derp de derpity derp" (to borrow from "South Park") beats that this film hits. It's not that Arkin's performance is bad, but again, much as with the film itself, it's delivered with a self-conscious smirk that makes you want to smack it across the face. I understand its appeal. It's a fun, shtick-y performance that immediately draws attention to itself, and I would be a lying stubborn old fart myself if I didn't admit that the performance made me crack a smile from time to time. As I mentioned above though, with such an endless list of great performances from supporting actors, is this the type of performance we need to honor? Even if you are determined to honor more roles with a comedic bent to them, something I could definitely get behind, it's not like this performance approaches, say, the level of Bill Murray's work in Wes Anderson's films, just to throw out an example. Que sera sera, ashes to ashes, and to each his own I guess, but personally I think the Academy could have done better nominating a more worthy performance.

4. Tommy Lee Jones in Lincoln

And here's Alan Arkin's cranky-old-man spiritual twin-brother (I keep waiting for the announcement of a remake of Grumpy Old Men co-starring Alan Arkin and Tommy Lee Jones). In all seriousness though, these performances have a lot in common. Both actors approached these roles with the attitude that they were cast because of who they were, not who they can become, and that's probably true. Playing a variation on yourself, or on the character you've come to personify on film, isn't necessarily a negative thing either. Too many critics and fans alike tend to dismiss performances simply because, "it's what they always do." I will be the first to argue against this line of reasoning. Some of my all-time favorite actors, such as Cary Grant, basically made a career out of playing variations on the same character. The difference between when this line of criticism is legitimate and when it is not comes down to if the particular character in question ultimately benefits or detracts from the film itself. For instance, in the case of Cary Grant, he was a genius at tailoring his character just enough to perfectly fit the tone of the film. Tommy Lee Jones on the other hand just appears to be lucky when his performance actually fits the movie and when it doesn't. In the specific case of Lincoln, in his turn as the Radical Republican Senator Thaddeus Stevens, I think his "usual thing" mostly works, although the fact that Jones couldn't even bother one iota to work on his clearly Texan accent while playing a Pennsylvanian senator can only be chalked up to laziness. With his patented sarcastic one-liners in hand, it's unsurprising all the acclaim this performance received, and it fits the character well enough, but it's hardly a stretch for the actor. Yet again, I would have preferred the Academy honor some younger actor honing in on his skills than reward an old dog for doing old tricks.

3. Robert De Niro in Silver Linings Playbook

deno Many might lump in this performance with the last two as a case of the Academy giving a hearty pat on the back to acting veterans giving "good efforts." Unlike the previous two nominees though, I do not see this as a "pity nomination" for a former acting legend years past his prime. While it's an undeniable truth that Mr. De Niro, one of the most esteemed actors in the history of the medium, has been mailing it in for well over a decade, his performance as Pat Salitano Sr. was a true return to form, not simply an improvement over his recent sub par work. Maybe De Niro finally got tired of half-assing it or maybe this is just the first time in a long time that De Niro has worked with a director who had real vision and passion for the movie he was creating, but whatever the reason was, it's just good to see a craftsman doing the fine work he was born to do. Playing a gambling addicted, super-superstitious Eagles fan (something I can relate to as a diehard Patriots fan), De Niro expertly walks the fine line between goofy eccentric and real human being. It's a tough mix, but when the film needs him to be all so slightly over the top for comedic purposes, he's there, and when it needs a sincere moment of emotion, such as the scene in which he has heart to heart talk with his son, De Niro pulls it off in spades. In terms of De Niro's filmography, it's also an interesting role in that it is one of his rare turns as a father figure, but he proves he can be just as convincingly paternal as any actor out there. Easily his best performance since Jackie Brown, it might not have quite made my own personal ballot, but it is an award worthy turn none the less.

2. Phillip Seymour Hoffman in The Master

The Master Philip Seymour Hoffman I've been a big Phillip Seymour Hoffman fan for a long time, and not just because he hails from my hometown. It's always a pleasure to watch an actor slowly grow in stature over time, from playing bit parts, to more substantial supporting roles, and finally to becoming a leading man/woman. In the case of Phillip Seymour Hoffman though, watching his ascension has been particularly sweet, because he has made his way through the ranks based solely on merit alone. Hoffman has a certain quality, which very few actors possess, that automatically adds depth to his character. It matters not how small his part in the movie is, whenever he is on screen, his character's automatically demand your attention because they feel real and lived in, with backstories that could make interesting movies in and of themselves. This is certainly the case in The Master, where Hoffman, riffing on infamous Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard and reteaming with long-time collaborator Paul Thomas Anderson, adds another virtuoso performance to his ever growing list of memorable turns. While I have slightly mixed emotions about the film itself, I have no reservations about the performances in the film, particularly Hoffman's. The cult and its relationship to its cult leader is one of the most fascinating psychological relationships in the history of mankind, and the enigmatic mix between insanity and charisma that lies within all cult leaders is on shockingly real display in Hoffman's characterization. Intriguing and appalling all at once, and especially mesmerizing in the chemistry between Hoffman and Phoenix in scenes such as the "processing" scene and the jail scene, this is one brilliant performance that will only add the to the legacy of an already brilliant actor.

1. Christoph Waltz in Django Unchained

Django5 Choosing between Phillip Seymour Hoffman and Christoph Waltz was one agonizingly tough decision to make. Both actors are among my favorite thespians currently working in the movie business and both gave stellar performances that will go down in the annals of cinematic history as two of the finest performances of their times. If I were an actual member of the Academy and had to pick between the two for real, I would have probably stared at this part of my ballot for hours, continually switching my vote back and forth between to the two, until I would finally give up and just flip coin and let Lady Luck decide my vote. For the sake of this article though I ended up going with Christoph Waltz, and the reason why you ask? In the end it came down to Waltz's performance being the more entertaining of the two. Watching Christoph Waltz breath life into the character of Dr. King Schultz was probably the single most enjoyable element of my year at the movies in 2012. Even just thinking about it gives me goosebumps. While some have complained that the performance is too similar to Waltz's first Oscar-winning performance as the Nazi villain Hans Landa in Quentin Tarantino's previous effort, Inglourious Basterds (and there is some undeniable similarity between the two roles), I actually marveled at fine differences between the two roles. While Landa was an amoral pragmatist who had no real ideological leanings but was more interested in the game of the hunt, Schultz is only a no-nonsense assassin on the outside, secretly covering up his compassionate soft underbelly. In the scene where Schultz is forced to watch a pack of enraged dogs rip a poor slave to pieces, we see the anguish eating him up inside, and it is this genuine inversion of the character Schultz previously played that I found so impressive. Plus, when you add in the perfect inflection of which Waltz delivers the dialogue (Tarantino compares it to a talented singer), and this is one choice by the Academy I can get behind without the slightest reservation.

In this post: 
Oscars 2013
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A film fanatic at a very young age, starting with the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle movies and gradually moving up to more sophisticated fare, at around the age of ten he became inexplicably obsessed with all things Oscar. With the incredibly trivial power of being able to chronologically name every Best Picture winner from memory, his lifelong goal is to see every Oscar nominated film, in every major category, in the history of the Academy Awards.