Oscars 2014: 10 Underdogs Who Might Get Surprise Nominations

Sorting out the unlikely from the improbably before the names are drawn tomorrow.

Tomorrow the Oscar nominations are announced, and all of that annual posturing, campaigning and predicting will be over for everyone who follows, votes for and hopes for a nomination. As usual, you can expect a lot of complaining about what got snubbed and those brilliant performances that didn't make the cut, but ahead of that, it's time to refresh our memories about some underdog films and performances that just might sneak in the back door and score a nod. All of these films are sitting on the periphery, having enjoyed their fair share of critical acclaim, yet it would still certainly be a surprise if they managed to nudge out some of their better known competitors who are far more likely to be nominated. We all like surprises, so hopefully at least a couple of these will come true tomorrow. Also, if there any other surprises you're crossing your fingers for, let me know in the comments below!

10. Best Supporting Actor €“ James Franco (Spring Breakers)

Spring Breakers may not be among the most positively received films of last year, but there was plenty of praise to go around for James Franco's transformative performance as wannabe gangster Alien. Kitted out in grills, tats and braids, it was a totally against-type role for the actor, who has typically spent a career playing variations on his stoner fratboy character. To date, Franco has received a scattering of nominations for Best Supporting Actor among the various critics groups, and even scored a few wins with Ohio, LA, San Francisco, and the National Society of Film Critics. It would certainly be a shock to see him nudge out far more likely on-the-edge nominees like Bradley Cooper (American Hustle), Jonah Hill (The Wolf of Wall Street), Will Forte (Nebraska) and Tom Hanks (Saving Mr. Banks), but stranger things have happened. Perhaps don't count on it, but it's not totally outside the realm of possibility.

9. Best Supporting Actress €“ Margot Robbie (The Wolf Of Wall Street)

I get the feeling that Margot Robbie is going to owe a lot to Martin Scorsese in the years to come, as she went from relative obscurity (known primarily for roles on Pan Am and Aussie soap Neighbours) to being the prime love interest in Scorsese's latest crime epic, starring opposite Leonardo DiCaprio no less. It's fair to say that the Oscars love championing fresh talent, and this might give Margot Robbie the push over some of the other fringe potential nominees, such as Octavia Spencer (Fruitvale Station) specifically. It's also an exceptionally strong performance, and a brave one too, as Robbie quite literally bears all for the screen. The performance came very late in awards season to really merit much consideration from the guilds, but Oscar voters have had a few weeks to chew it over, and with the more wide-open nature of this category, consider it one of the more likely nominations on this list.

8. Best Actor €“ Oscar Isaac (Inside Llewyn Davis)

The Best Actor field is arguably the most competitive category this year, with performances from Chiwetel Ejiofor (12 Years A Slave), Bruce Dern (Nebraska), Matthew McConaughey (Dallas Buyers Club) and Tom Hanks (Captain Phillips) being considered virtual locks. The final spot is up for grabs, and though the majority belief is that it will be taken up by either Leonardo DiCaprio (The Wolf of Wall Street) or Forest Whitaker (Lee Daniels' The Butler), I can't quite keep Oscar Isaac's performance in Inside Llewyn Davis out of my mind. More crucially, Isaac has racked up over a dozen significant awards nominations, including Golden Globe and Independent Spirit Award nominations, with a few wins from some of the "lesser" critics groups as well. Still, it's an outside bet to say the least, yet the film's passionate following could push it over the edge.

7. Best Supporting Actress €“ Scarlett Johansson (Her)

Scarlett Johansson scooping a Best Supporting Actress nomination for her superb role in Spike Jonze's Her would be nothing short of a miracle, as it would be the first voice-only performance to receive such a nomination. While about half a dozen critics groups were forward-thinking enough to nominate her work, the Academy's notoriously traditionalist values will likely prevent this one from happening, as has frequently caused Andy Serkis' various performance capture roles to be snubbed in recent years. As with Margot Robbie, though, the Best Supporting Actress field is one of the most wide-open in terms of the fifth slot, and a Johansson nomination here would be a profoundly refreshing statement from the Academy. Don't count on it, though.

6. Best Original Song €“ "Doby" From Anchorman 2

Alright, so this one really isn't likely at all, as I doubt the song branch has enough of a sense of humour about itself to nominate such a radically against-type, self-aware song as the brilliant "Doby" from Anchorman 2. There are 75 qualifying songs to choose from, and Doby hasn't even made the outside lists of most notable Oscar prognosticators. But from a personal perspective, it's easily the most memorable and distinctive song of the year, even if it's pretty short and thoroughly poking fun at the sorts of maudlin songs that so often end up winning Oscars. This year's Best Original Song really lacks a barn-burning classic like last year's Skyfall by Adele, so they'll probably go for a relatively safe yet agreeable glut of tunes (like "Let It Go" from Disney's Frozen), rather than something this out-there. But wouldn't I love to see the Blu-ray adverts refer to Anchorman 2 as "the Oscar-nominated Anchorman 2"? You bet I would.

5. Best Foreign Language Film & Best Cinematography €“ The Grandmaster

Wong Kar Wai's opulent Ip-Man biopic didn't exactly take audiences or critics by storm as it rolled out across the world, but it's had a modest and consistent string of compliments to the extent that it's remained in the Best Foreign Language film race, even making it down to the final shortlist of 9 films. While it's reasonable to expect that The Grandmaster will be one of the 4 films chopped from the list tomorrow when it's facing off against dramatic heavyweights like The Hunt and The Broken Circle Breakdown, the fact that the film has made it this far is an indication that it has its share of fans in the Academy, and considering how well-known the film is compared to many of its competitors, its populist appeal just might make it scrape into the final five. A few critics groups were savvy enough to mark the film out for its gorgeous cinematography also, and though this is going to be a tough sell with Gravity, 12 Years A Slave, Prisoners and Nebraska being considered virtual locks, it could reasonably bump out the likes of Captain Phillips, Her, and Rush to steal the coveted fifth slot.

4. Best Supporting Actor €“ James Gandolfini (Enough Said)

The Academy loves to be sentimental, and it's not unfair to say that when a performer unfortunately passes away ahead of awards season, it inevitably gives their performance a push in the right direction. Just look at Heath Ledger's turn as The Joker in The Dark Knight. Brilliant though it was, the turn was far less likely to have been nominated had Ledger still been alive, and he eventually went on to win the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor. But this isn't to in any way diminish James Gandolfini's splendid work on romantic drama Enough Said. A fitting swansong for the actor, he has received nominations from SAG, the Broadcast Film Critics Association, the Independent Spirit Awards and several local critics groups, and the SAG in particular is often a strong indication of what ends up being nominated for an Oscar. The win is already pretty much sewn up for Jared Leto (Dallas Buyers Club), and Gandolfini will have trouble fighting off Bradley Cooper (American Hustle), Jonah Hill (The Wolf of Wall Street), Will Forte (Nebraska) and Tom Hanks (Saving Mr. Banks) in particular for the fifth slot, but it's certainly possible, and the fact that it's a posthumous performance only helps his chances.

3. Best Director €“ Woody Allen (Blue Jasmine)

Woody Allen's Blue Jasmine is, for my money, the director's best film in decades, and up there with his very best work. Most attention is turned towards a likely Best Actress win for Cate Blanchett, as well as a Best Original Screenplay nomination for Woody Allen. However, little has been said about Allen receiving a Best Director nomination, despite the assertion by many critics that this is Allen's strongest film in years €“ even more so than Midnight in Paris, which earned Woody a Best Director nomination in 2012. Working against the film is its low-key nature. It doesn't have the epic scope of 12 Years A Slave or the mind-boggling technical mechanics of Gravity, so it may struggle to distinguish itself with such a crowded field that also includes David O. Russell (American Hustle), Paul Greengrass (Captain Phillips), Alexander Payne (Nebraska) and Martin Scorsese (The Wolf of Wall Street). It's a distinct outside possibility, along with Joel and Ethan Coen for Inside Llewyn Davis, but I'll be rooting for him anyway.

2. Best Actress €“ Brie Larson (Short Term 12)

Short Term 12 was one of 2013's most critically acclaimed films, and earned Brie Larson a stack of Best Actress nominations on the awards circuit, most prominently from the Independent Spirit Awards, a ceremony which, to be fair, far better suits this little film than the Oscars ever will. Cate Blanchett (Blue Jasmine), Sandra Bullock (Gravity), Emma Thompson (Saving Mr. Banks) and Judi Dench (Philomena) are largely considered locks in this category, so it's all about the fifth slot for Larson, which is being heavily contested by perennial Oscar nominee Meryl Streep (August: Osage County) and Amy Adams (American Hustle). Oscar has been known to on occasion champion "the little indie film that could" as with their fanfare for Beasts of the Southern Wild last year, so Larson earning a shock nomination is far from impossible. Though she has an advantage in that Streep's performance is widely considered to not be one of her best and is contained inside a relatively average film, Golden Globe-winner Amy Adams has a lot of Academy love and will likely be the biggest threat for Larson to beat (and she probably won't).

1. Best Picture €“ Fruitvale Station

It's widely expected that we'll probably see another 9 films be nominated for Best Picture this year, and as far as locks go, 12 Years A Slave, American Hustle, Gravity, Captain Phillips, The Wolf of Wall Street and Nebraska are extremely likely to take the first six slots, with the final 2 or 3 being fought out between Dallas Buyers Club, Saving Mr. Banks, Her and Philomena. But what about the Sundance hit that everyone was championing last January as "the next Beasts of the Southern Wild"? Fruitvale Station has enjoyed a consistent stream of acclaim since its Sundance premiere last January, with it being an early potential Best Picture nominee, along with likely acting nominations for Michael B. Jordan and Octavia Spencer. However, over the summer Fruitvale's wave of Oscar hope began to fade, as awards season got into full swing and a glut of other films inevitably debuted. The film clearly has a passionate rabble of supporters, and it would be a great thing to see, but again, don't count on it. Still, we can only hope. Who do you want to see rack up a surprise Oscar nomination? Tell us in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.