Oscars 2014: Who is Winning the Best Actress Race?

If there is one thing the film blogosphere has enough of right now, it's articles about gender/racial inequality in the film business. Whatever the merits of these argument may be, I don't intend to add to the glut of the Voice of the Internet, a veritable megaphone that already has a natural tendency to act as a perpetual echo chamber as it is. I will then circumvent the typical opening paragraph of most Best Actress previews that inevitably begin with the "not enough strongly written females roles" spiel and cut to the actual field for 2014. One of the reasons I feel justified in forgoing the traditional Best Actress disclaimer is that, at least compared to the nadir of lead actress roles in the mid-2000's, this narrative just doesn't hold up anymore. In fact, there are enough strong candidates for the field this year that mathematically speaking, it is an absolute certainty that many "nomination-worthy" performances will be left out of the mix when the final five Best Actress nominees are announced. Some of my favorite female performances this year are, analytically speaking, on the outside looking in. Performances such as Greta Gerwig's infectious incarnation of the prototypical Millennial in Frances Ha, Rooney Mara's sly slight-of-hand work in Steven Soderbergh's underappreciated pharmo-thriller Side Effects, Amy Seimitz enchanting expressionism in the oblique Upstream Color, and Olga Kurylenko's channeling of Terrance Malick's understanding of feminine spirituality in To the Wonder will all go unnoticed by the Academy this year. Nevertheless, all four of these performances were outstanding examples of a growing trend of strong performances by lead actresses, which makes the clinging by some to the narrative that actresses don't get the same opportunities that their male counterparts do seem a bit silly. The downside, when it comes to awards season, of this expanding field of impressive female thespianism, is that there will be a lot of great work left unrecognized, and unfortunately, the need to come to consensus has been particularly brutal in the Best Actress field this year. Any Oscar prognosticator worth his beans knows that this race has been reduced to a six-to-seven lady royal rumble (eight at the very most), and many shrewd analysts believe announcing the five nominees is just a mere formality at this point. For the sake of the Oscars, I hope this isn't true, because as I outlined above, there are many more than the expected five nominees to consider when compiling a list of best performances by lead actresses in 2013. However, I take my job as an objective Oscar pundit seriously, so all wishful thinking aside, here is how I currently see the 2013 Best Actress race playing out.

Dark Horse Contenders

Amy Adams in American Hustle Brie Larson in Short Term 12 Kate Winslett in Labor Day Adele Exarchopolous in Blue is the Warmest Color Julie Delpy in Before Midnight

Long Shot Contenders

Greta Gerwig in Frances Ha Julia-Louis Dreyfuss in Enough Said Berenice Bejo in The Past Shailene Woodley in The Spectacular Now Rooney Mara in Side Effects

5. Meryl Streep - August: Osage County

This was a real tough decision for my last spot. My gut wanted to go with Amy Adams in American Hustle, and there are some good reasons to believe Ms. Adams can make the cut. The first of the reasons is the fact that Amy Adams is a four-time Oscar nominee, although up to this point, she has been exclusively nominated as a Best Supporting Actress and has never received a nomination for a leading role. The second reason why I really want to go with Amy Adams in American Hustle is the fact that the Academy is likely to really love this movie, and if they're really into the movie (some believe it has a shot at taking Best Picture), it only makes sense Adams could get swept up in the love fest. Finally, there's the fact that no one in recent history has been able to get Oscar nominations for his actors like David O. Russell, who just through his last two films alone managed a whopping seven Oscar nominations for actors. All that being said, when push came to shove, my brain won out after I considered Amy Adam's primary competition: Meryl Steep. Ms. Streep is Mrs. Oscar herself. Nominated for a staggering 17 Academy Awards (more than any other actor in the history of the Oscars), and with her win for Best Actress in The Iron Lady, joining the elite club of thespians who have won three or more Oscars (the more only referring to Katherine Hepburn's four), there is no actor who has been a more dominate force at the Oscars, male or female, than Meryl Streep. For this reason, it seems sacrilegious not to include her among the predicted Best Actress lineup, and no pundit wants to be the idiot who stupidly bet against Meryl Streep. However, August: Osage County has not been as big a player in awards season as many predicted it to be. The film has had a rough time with critics since its debut at the Toronto Film Festival and hasn't been a regular presence on too many "top ten of 2013" lists. It has managed to do fairly well among actors though, as evidenced by it's Best Ensemble nomination with the Screen Actors Guild, so for this reason, and the fact that we're dealing with Meryl Streep, I'm going with the safer bet. Don't be surprised though if Amy Adams manages to still Ms. Streep's thunder. Nomination Chances: 35%

4. Judi Dench - Philomena

Ms. Dame Judi Dench has been a fixture at the Academy Awards since her first Oscar nomination in 1997 for Mrs. Brown. After being initiated into the club, her Academy peers have seen fit to nominate her another five times, including a Best Supporting Actress victory in 1998 for her very brief appearance as Queen Elizabeth II in Shakespeare in Love. Even before her relationship with Oscar began, she was a legendary stage actor in England, so in terms of pedigree, Ms. Dench has what it takes for an Oscar nomination. (Fun random fact: Judi Dench starred in a 1968 production of Cabaret that was an influence on the early career of David Bowie). It has been a relatively fallow period for Ms. Dench when it comes to procuring Oscar nominations though. Her last nomination came for her performance in Notes on a Scandal back in 2006, which will make this current gap the longest break between nominations for Ms. Dench in her career. However, the buzz for her performance as the titular Philomena has been very positive, and the stars appear to be aligning to end Ms. Dench's cold streak with the Oscars. Based on a true story, Philomena tells the story of an elderly woman who attempts to find her long lost son that was taken from her by the Catholic Church in the 1950's, when the church made a business out of selling out-of-wedlock children for adoption. While the movie is undeniably middle-brow and will likely have more than a few detractors in the artistically minded sector of the Academy, it's hard to deny the effectiveness of Dench's performance. Playing a relative simpleton, Dench does a brilliant job of getting that point across without turning Philomena into a caricature (cough*June Squibb*cough). There's a lot of hidden depth and humanity in Ms. Dench's performance, and I think that edge, along with her reputation, will be enough to get her in. While the movie will likely miss out on a Best Picture nomination (much to the chagrin of Harvey Weinstein), I think Judi Dench will manage to sneak in to the Best Actress field, but given the competitive field, it's hardly a for sure thing. Nomination Chances: 55%

3. Emma Thompson - Saving Mr. Banks

Any Academy Award buff will know that when it comes to getting Oscar wins and nominations as an actor, it never hurts to play a historical figure. This is particularly the case when the historical person in question has a link to Hollywood, which is why sight unseen many Oscar prognosticators were declaring Emma Thompson's performance as Mary Poppins author P.L. Travers an instant Best Actress contender. While some may view this sort of analytical tact overly reductive and crude, those prognosticators are being proved correct, for even as the film Saving Mr. Banks has hit a few rough patches on the precursor circuit (although that appears to have been remedied with a Producers Guild of America Best Picture nomination), Emma Thompson has shown up as a Best Actress nominee on almost every conceivable list. Ms. Thompson has had some good history with the Academy in the past. In a span of four Oscar ceremonies (1993-1996), Ms. Thompson managed to win two Oscars (Best Actress in 1993 for Howard's End and Best Adapted Screenplay in 1996 for Sense and Sensibility) and received an additional three Oscar nominations (all for acting) in that four year time span. Beside the incredible hot streak that was the mid-1990s for Ms. Thompson though, she has never rendezvoused with Oscar again, but that will definitely end on January 16. As P.L. Travers, Thompson plays the infamously stubborn author in a bit of a cartoony manner, almost like the title character in Ms. Traver's book or Thompson's most famous recent role, Nanny McPhee. However, as the film settle down some, so does Ms. Thompson's performance, as the inner emotional life that P.L. Travers works so hard to mask is slowly revealed for the audience. Regardless of the finer points of the performance though, there is no denying that it is a turn that is delivered with much charisma on the part of Emma Thompson. When you combine this with a story line that Academy members are sure to love, about a movie, Mary Poppins, that they already showered with affection back in 1964, then I think we can safely count Ms. Thompson as a Best Actress nominee. Nomination Chances: 80%

2. Sandra Bullock - Gravity

While Cate Blanchett in Blue Jasmine might have figuratively been a one-woman show, Sandra Bullock in Gravity is, George Clooney not withstanding, literally all on her own. (In fact, that's kind of the whole point of the movie). Obviously, this is an enormous responsibility to put on shoulders of any actor, but Ms. Bullock passes the test with flying colors. The science fiction suspense thriller, which has grossed over $250 million domestically in the United States, has proven to be the cinematic sensation of the year (the rare film that high-minded critics and the general public can both agree on), and much of the credit belongs to Sandra Bullock and her heart-pounding performance as a distressed astronaut floating in the abyss of space. Somewhat sheepishly, I have admit that going into the film, I had my doubts about Ms. Bullock's thespian abilities. Having never been a fan of her work (although her relative "talent" for romantic comedies is fairly incontestable), and still a bit peeved over her 2009 Best Actress win for The Blind Side (although I was more angered over the film's Best Picture nomination), you could say I was bit skeptical that she could handle the heavy lifting of an Alfonso Cuaron space epic. However, going into the film's screening at the Toronto Film Festival, I remained cautiously optimistic, and as the now legendary opening shot of the film played out, as I'm sure you experienced yourself, I was instantly won over. I think what is most impressive about Bullock's performance is that, unlike say maybe Naomi Watts in The Impossible last year, Bullock goes beyond an incredible portrayal of a woman in distress, but creates a fully-living protagonist with Dr. Ryan Stone. To accomplish this in what is essentially an action-oriented film is no small feat, and given that the film is undoubtedly going to be a major player in this year's Oscar ceremony (and could even take the top prize), I really can't see Sandra Bullock missing out on a nomination. The only conceivable way Sandra Bullock misses out on a Best Actress nomination this year is if enough voters take her nomination for granted and decide to stick up for some relatively obscure name instead, but the chances of something like that happening are highly unlikely, even more unlikely than the odds of surviving being stranded in outer space. Nomination chances: 95%

1. Cate Blanchett - Blue Jasmine

For all practical purposes, this race is over, and Cate Blanchett will win her second Oscar. While "predetermined" Oscars such as this make the competition between Oscar night gambling pools a bit boring, and generally speaking I am not in favor of such automatic victories, in this case, it's just extremely clear who deserves the Best Actress Oscar. Cate Blanchett's enthralling performance as Jasmine, the emotionally distraught ex-wife of a Bernie Madoff-esque Wall Street con artist, is not only the best lead performance by a female thespian, but may be the single best performance from any actor this year, regardless of gender or status. In fact, her performance is one that is so mesmerizing and hypnotically good, that paradoxically, it could hurt the film's chances in other categories. Despite Woody Allen's deft structural crafting and psychological insight into his characters, Blanchett's performance is such a whirlwind turn, and dominates the film so completely, that it becomes difficult to separate Blue Jasmine from Blanchett's performance. While this is unfortunate for the film, a critically well reviewed movie that has nevertheless been mostly absent from the glut of year end "top ten" lists (although it did manage to land a Best Picture nomination from the Producers Guild of America), it is an understandable error. Inevitably, there will be many an Academy member who will feel that by voting for Cate Blanchett as Best Actress, they are in effect voting for the film in aggregate. I usually despise this sort of non-principled rationale, but in this case I think it can be somewhat forgiven, and anything that gets Cate Blanchett into the league of multiple-Oscar winning actors is okay in my book. Nomination Chances: 98% Who do you think will win the Best Actress Oscar? Share your thoughts below in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

A film fanatic at a very young age, starting with the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle movies and gradually moving up to more sophisticated fare, at around the age of ten he became inexplicably obsessed with all things Oscar. With the incredibly trivial power of being able to chronologically name every Best Picture winner from memory, his lifelong goal is to see every Oscar nominated film, in every major category, in the history of the Academy Awards.