Oscars 2014: Who Is Winning Best Picture Race?

American Hustle Trailer The leaves are falling, the air is crisp, and the pumpkin patches are being picked over, which can only mean one thing: Oscar season is heating up. Yup, that's right folks, we are knee deep in the thick of it now. With the announcement of the Gotham nominations (the first unofficial precursor awards), there is no turning back now. To paraphrase Bette Davis, "Fasten your seatbelts, it's going to be a bumpy awards season." If you are a dogged follower of the annual circus that is the awards season circuit, or maybe even if you're only a casual star-gawking awards season neophyte, you have probably picked up on the post-festival narrative that has formed: this year's battle to the death has come down to 12 Years a Slave vs. Gravity. 12 Years a Slave stunned critics and the public speechless upon its debut at the Telluride and Toronto Film Festivals (where it won the prestigious and often auspicious Audience Award), and over-eager pundits quickly declared the Oscar's Best Picture race a mere formality. Meanwhile, Alfonso Cuaron's space-thriller, Gravity, which also managed to collect a slew of impressive plaudits on the festival circuit itself, totally blew open the box office, launching past even the most optimistic estimates of monetary success. The film's stratospheric success with the public vaunted Gravity to co-equal frontrunner status with 12 Years a Slave, setting up an epic Oscar duel that appears to be the cinematic equivalent of Ali vs. Fraizer. Of course, before we go too overboard here, there are a number of movies that would undoubtedly cry foul, although with films such as Foxcatcher and The Monuments Men catching the 2014-release-date-flu, the number of films that could alter this seemingly inevitable narrative are rapidly dwindling. Basically, there a two major films left that have yet to be seen by any appropriately christened awards season pundits, American Hustle and The Wolf of Wall Street (with my apologies to minor threats such as Out of the Furnace and Lone Survivor). While I would hate to ever be accused of underestimating Martin Scorsese (and I am extremely thankful that the film will make the 2013 release window after all), my gut tells me that the only film left that could seriously contend for the win and throw a wrench in the 12 Years/Gravity pas de deux is David O. Russell's American Hustle. Russell has been extremely hot with the Academy lately and the movie strikes me as a potential culmination of work, the type of auteur piece that is so undeniably indelible, that the Academy is forced to momentarily set aside its usual middle-brow taste and award true genius, a la the Coen Brothers win in 2007 for No Country for Old Men. Regardless of whether we are in for the long haul now with the metaphorical clash between 12 Years a Slave and Gravity, it's been quite some time since I updated my view of the current awards landscape, and now, after all the major film festivals but before the major precursor awards, seemed like the perfect time to pen my virtual ink on the matter. What follows then is a breakdown of the current Best Picture race, with my predictions, ranking, and percentage chances of the contender's potential nomination, as well as a list of a few possible alternatives on th very last page. Keep an eye out for my upcoming updates on the other major categories as well. Here goes nothing!

1. 12 Years a Slave

12 Years A Slave In the battle between 12 Years a Slave and Gravity, I still give the slight edge to 12 Years a Slave. The subject matter, while maybe a bit difficult to stomach for some when presented in such a stark and unfettered manner, is right up the Academy's alley, and I'm sure there are many an Academy member who are only too eager to declare possibly the first serious cinematic endeavor to tackle the issue of Southern Slavery, a Best Picture winner. Also, the film is much more likely to appeal to the Academy's Actors branch given how technologically dependent Gravity is, which is a definite advantage for Steve McQueen's 12 Years a Slave. Nomination Chances: 99%

2. Gravity

Sandra Bulluck Gravity 600x300 Gravity has become a cultural sensation. With three consecutive weeks atop the box office, approaching nearly $200 million in U.S. box office, for most of the public, Gravity is certainly going to be one of the most memorable experiences of the year in film for 2013 (definitely more so than 12 Years a Slave, which sadly far too few will see). For some in Hollywood, every extra million dollars Gravity makes is another convincing argument in its favor, although as we saw in 2009 with Avatar, all the money in the world doesn't necessarily buy you a Best Picture Oscar, especially if you're a science fiction film. Nomination Chances: 98%

3. Captain Phillips

Captain Phillips If 12 Years a Slave and Gravity are like two older brothers a year apart from each other, Captain Phillips is like the third youngest brother about three or four years younger, straggling be-hiving its older siblings, but doing a good job keeping up considering its age. The film has done relatively well at the box office, and given its fairly enthusiastic reviews, this is pretty much all it needed to do to secure a Best Picture nomination. The fact that Hollywood favorite Tom Hanks gives a terrific performance in the movie, which marks a bit of an awards season comeback for the two-time Oscar winning actor, is just an extra incentive that virtually guarantees a name call when the Oscar nominations are announced. Nomination Chances: 95%

4. American Hustle

American Hustle 2 It's a bit dangerous including one of the few unknowns this high up on the list, sight-unseen, when so many of the other contenders are known quantities now, but that's how confident I am in this film. David O. Russell has had his admirers for awhile now, but if his films were a little heavy on raw talent and light on careful refinement earlier in his career, he seems to have the formula down now. With two-consecutive Oscar smashes in The Fighter and Silver Linings Playbook, Russell has quickly become a favorite of the Academy, and the FBI/con-artists/politician mix that is at the heart of the subject matter of American Hustle should appeal to the Academy. Throw in an astounding cast of terrific young actors such as Christian Bale, Amy Adams, Bradley Cooper, Jennifer Lawrence, and Jeremy Renner, and as long as the film isn't a total misstep, I got think American Hustle will at the very least be a nominee. Nomination Chances: 75%

5. Saving Mr. Banks

Saving Mr Bank Screen 1 While many having been predicting Saving Mr. Banks as a major Oscar player for quite some time, I have been a skeptical holdout up to this point. Personally, the film simply looked too sachrinated and glossy to be of major significance, and while director John Lee Hancock managed to overcome these criticisms to secure a Best Picture nomination for his film The Blind Side in 2009, I considered that to be a fluke. However, after its premiere at the London Film Festival, it appears pretty likely that Saving Mr. Banks will be a Best Picture nominee. The reviews out of London weren't ecstatic for the film, but they were surprisingly solid, even from the artsy set, which is probably good enough for a film such as this. Most importantly, the film is said to have moments of genuine comedy, which is key for a middle-brow film like Saving Mr. Banks (see Argo and The King's Speech). When you factor in the key British and Australian voting blocks, then things only get even rosier for Saving Mr. Banks. Nomination Chances: 70%

6. Inside Llewyn Davis

Inside Llewyn Davis 3 Maybe even more than David O. Russell, the Coen Brothers have become the new directorial staples of the Academy. Once indie outsiders, since their Best Picture win for No Country for Old Men, they have been batting .750 in getting Best Picture nominations (a case of last generation's rebels being this generation's establishment, I guess). Inside Llweyn Davis, the Coens' latest film exploring the folk music scene in the early 1960's, first premiered earlier this year on the Croisette at the Cannes Film Festival where it was enthusiastically received, earning the runner-up prize from the Steven Spielberg headed jury. Since then, the film has strategically festival hopped, appearing at the Telluride and New York film festivals, and while it was just as warmly greeted in the States as it was in France, the low key nature of its campaign has become a bit concerning. With all the focus on the more high profile prestige pictures, you do wonder if Inside Llewyn Davis could be overlooked. Its voting block will likely come from the same people who propelled Amour, The Tree of Life, and the Coen's A Serious Man to Best Picture nominations (the high-art block), and they're likely not to be distracted by the Saving Mr. Banks of the world, but even on the high-brow front, Spike Jonze's Her, which was rapturously received by critics upon its debut in New York, could prove a very real threat, putting Inside Llewyn Davis in a bit of a precarious position at the moment. Chances: 65%

7. The Wolf Of Wall Street

The Wolf Of Wall Street 39749 The movie hasn't even come out yet and it has already been a bit of a wild ride for The Wolf of Wall Street. Based on the autobiography of the corrupt Wall Street white-collar criminal Jordan Belfort, when Scorsese handed in his first cut of the film with a length approaching four hours and explicit material that, according to rumors, could very well earn the film an NC-17 rating, the prospects of a 2013 release looked dim. In fact, even though the film was never officially delayed, many pundits began to write the film off as a 2014 Oscar contender, but now Paramount has officially marked Christmas Day for a wide release of the film with a running time of 165 minutes. The studio also released a second trailer for film, which in the humble opinion of this film enthusiast, looks fantastic, but many Oscar pundits are skeptical that the film's edgy, darkly comedic tone won't jive with the Academy's historically more restrained predilections. However, many of these same prognosticators were doubtful over the prospects of Quentin Tarantino's Django Unchained landing a Best Picture nod for very similar reasons last year as well, and we all know how that turned out. The Wolf of Wall Street is anything from a sure bet, but given Scorsese's excellent track record with the Academy as of late, I am cautiously more optimistic than some on its chances to break into 2014's Best Picture field. Chances: 60%

8. Nebraska

Nebraska Alexander Payne has lived the charmed life in his career with respect to his relationship with the Academy. Other than the exception of his debut feature film, Citizen Ruth, every one of Payne's movies have managed some sort of Oscar nomination. Three of these films have landed Payne Oscar nominations himself, including two Oscar victories in the Best Adapted Screenplay category for the films Sideways and The Descendants. In total, over five feature films, Payne has amassed six Oscar nominations for writing, directing, and producing, which only goes to show that the Academy really, really likes his work. This is why back in May, even after Nebraska's muted response from Cannes critics had many pundits declaring the film D.O.A. outside a possible Best Actor nomination for Bruce Dern, I was still pretty high on the film's Oscar outlook. The fact of the matter is European critics and Cannes Film Festival-goers tastes vary drastically from your average Academy member, and sure enough, as soon as Nebraska premiered to enthusiastic American audiences at Telluride (followed up a month later by screenings at the New York Film Festival), the film became a bona fide player. While teetering dangerously close to crossing over the "arrogant ass" threshold, I can't help but throwing in a, "I told you so". However, given the hyper-competitive year we're having, Nebraska is far from a sure thing. In fact, the film probably is right on the knife edge of being in or out at the moment, but given Payne's popularity with the Academy in the past, I'm betting Nebraska makes the cut. Chances: 55%

9. Philomena

Philomena1 Since the Academy went to a variable Best Picture field, ranging anywhere from 5-10 nominees, part of the fun of predicting the Best Picture lineup is predicting how many nominees will be in the final field. As with the first two years under this brave new world, I am predicting that there will be nine Best Picture nominees when all is said in done, which makes Philomena my last current prediction for Best Picture. Now, admittingly, while I am not anticipating the film so much myself (and there are plenty of other films I would love to predict here instead), my gut tells me that Philomena just might sneak in. First, from the reviews coming out of the festival circuit, it's clear that Philomena is a well-executed middle-brow film, which is pretty much the definition of an Academy Award nominee for Best Picture. Secondly, the film is said to be just the right blend of comedy and drama, the type of comedy that is far from ever being described as subversive but has just enough bite to it to let 60-year-old woman feel like they're being naughty for laughing at it (but in a, you know, non-offensive way). Thirdly, with beloved British queen of Actress starring in the title role, Dame Judi Dench herself, the film is likely to receive large support from the Academy's significant British block (the same people who undoubtedly helped Slumdog Millionaire and The King's Speech to Best Picture wins). Finally, and probably most importantly, Philomena looks like it may be The Weinstein Company's best shot at Oscar glory, which means the film will receive the full benefit of an all-out campaign from the Oscar guru himself, Harvey Weinstein. For this reason alone, Philomena should be considered a serious Oscar contender. Chances: 50%

Dark Horse Contenders

Blue Jasmine

1. Blue Jasmine

2. Lee Daniels' The Butler

3. Dallas Buyers Club

4. Her

5. August: Osage County

Long Shot Contenders

All Is Lost

1. All is Lost

2. Prisoners

3. Before Midnight

4. Rush

5. Out of the Furnace


Contributor
Contributor

A film fanatic at a very young age, starting with the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle movies and gradually moving up to more sophisticated fare, at around the age of ten he became inexplicably obsessed with all things Oscar. With the incredibly trivial power of being able to chronologically name every Best Picture winner from memory, his lifelong goal is to see every Oscar nominated film, in every major category, in the history of the Academy Awards.