Oscars 2015: 8 Biggest Mistakes The Academy Made

Those white old men don't know what they're talking about.

If you expect the Oscars to always get it right then you've clearly not been paying attention long enough. Awards season isn't a fight between the very best movies, but the most persistent producers and publicists, with actors, directors, writers and the rest of the filmmaking community only making it up onto the stage of the Dolby Theatre if they've engaged in a lengthy campaigning process. Recent years have shown this is rather blunt terms. Can you actually believe The King's Speech won the trifecta of Actor, Director and Picture? That totally, 100% happened, but only because industry juggernaut Harvey Weinstein was forcing the film down everyone's stammering throats. The 2015 Academy Awards did see a lot of things go the way they really should. J. K. Simmons would have had every right to throw his chair across the room had he not got Best Supporting Actor and, for all his child-like fawning upon winning, it's hard to find fault with Eddie Redmayne's remarkably subtle turn as Stephen Hawking. In fact, the biggest upset from the year's Oscars was Neil Patrick Harris, who delivered moments of brilliance, but left a lot of the ever-vocal Twitter community wanting. Still, while there were many deserved winners, there sure were a lot of awards where the rightful film missed out. Ignoring all the movies snubbed at the nominations (in an ideal world Nightcrawler would have got some serious love), here are the eight biggest mistakes the Academy made as the 87th Academy Awards.


8. Best Animated Feature

What Won: Big Hero 6 With The Lego Movie inexplicably absent from the nominees, it was a pretty open playing field for Best Animated Feature, although really it came down to Big Hero 6 and How To Train Your Dragon 2 - the other movies just didn't have a high enough profile to clear up in this niche section. In the end, Disney's latest took home the award, the Academy clearly connecting with Baymax more than Toothless. Feast, the short film that preceded it theatrically, won the Oscar for Best Animated Short, marking an Academy first. What Should Have Won: How To Train Your Dragon 2 How To Train Your Dragon 2 wasn't just a good animated movie, it was a good movie full stop. Although the kid friendly designs you'd expect were present and correct, the way the story and visuals were handled was above what you've come to expect from Dreamworks - as an action movie it sits comfortably alongside higher-tier blockbusters. When compared to the formulaic Big Hero 6 (it's a meldling of Disney conventions and the Marvel rulebook) it's clearly the better movie. Perhaps Big Hero 6's November US release just meant it was on people's minds more, Dragon already long since moved onto home video.

7. Best Sound Editing

What Won: Alan Robert Murray and Bub Asman (American Sniper) Clint Eastwood's Iraq War biopic was the big surprise of the nominations, loved by the Academy after being overlooked by most other awards, and, with such a strong right wing push behind it, was the film with the biggest chance of causing an actual upset. In the end, it got just one award - Best Sound Editing - which was something of a surprise given how most people's assessments of Sniper's technical proficiency was that it was "competent" at best. It winning an award early on in the ceremony did add some short-lived unpredictability to proceedings, suggesting Bradley Cooper and co. may throw a real curve-ball. What Should Have Won: Martin Hernández and Aaron Glascock (Birdman) With Whiplash absent from the Sound Editing nominations, it couldn't complete the common Best Sound double-whammy. In lieu of the film about drumming, the film with a soundtrack dominated by drumming seemed to be the obvious choice, given how much sound added to the feel of Birdman's Broadway theatre.

6. Best Adapted Screenplay

What Won: Graham Moore (The Imitation Game) For the second year running, Fox Searchlight has been behind the Best Picture winner, with Oscar fiend Harvey Weinstein only seeing his films get minor awards. So it is that The Imitation Game, Bob's horse for 2015, failed to capitalise on initial buzz, only taking home the Oscar for Best Adapted Screenplay. In all honesty, however, even that is too much. What Should Have Won: Anything else. The Imitation Game isn't a terrible film, it's just irritatingly typical Oscar bait, with a true life tragedy sanitised to ensure it jerks tears, yet never truly upsets. Compared to the likes of The Theory Of Everything, which took a similar "biopic of a smart Brit" idea and made something uniquely poignant, or Inherent Vice, which made sense of Thomas Pynchon's novel before removing it again, Graham Moore's script is woefully simple. Probably the most deserving winner is also the least deserving to be in this category - Whiplash. Only "Adapted" because Damien Chazelle made a short film of the same concept in an attempt to attract funding, it's a tense story that strings together electrifying 'action' beats with mostly one-sided verbal sparring. And the ending doesn't cut out the most interesting part of the story. This would, of course, have been a moot point had Gillian Flynn got nominated for adapting her own Gone Girl.

5. Best Production Design

What Won: Adam Stockhausen and Anna Pinnock (The Grand Budapest Hotel) Wes Anderson's visually lyrical movie had something of a monopoly on the technical categories, the director's typical aesthetic style getting gold for Costume Design, Makeup and Hairstyling, as well as Production Design, even though the man himself was an also-ran in his own category. It feels like something of a career recognition move, given how many of these obsessive details have punctuated the director's overlooked previous work. Now, there's no denying that The Grand Budapest Hotel doesn't boast great set and prop design, but just doing it well doesn't guarantee you'll be the best. What Should Have Won: Nathan Crowley and Gary Fettis (Interstellar) Interstellar did win the Oscar for Best Visual Effects, but as so much of the film was built for real (as is wont from Christopher Nolan), that's only rewarding half of the film's visual splendour. The design of Interstellar's future was achingly real, not just because it was based on sound science fact, but because it was so faithfully realised. Ever the stickler for sweeping reality, Nolan's obsessiveness in feel is at its most prominent in Interstellar; no matter what you make of the film itself, there's no denying its craft.

4. Best Original Score

What Won: Alexandre Desplat (The Grand Budapest Hotel) With two out of five of the Best Original Score nominations bearing his name, Alexandre Desplat was odds on favourite to win this year. Thankfully, it was his creatively fitting soundtrack to The Grand Budapest Hotel that got him on the stage, instead of the rather typical score for The Imitation Game. What Should Have Won: Hans Zimmer (Interstellar) This is Round Two of what has strangely become a big fight between Wes Anderson and Christopher Nolan, which again sees the former's film win out. Of course, it is just one of two almost-matched films being favoured, but again here it's hard to not say Interstellar doesn't edge it. It's massive and operatic, to the extent that just hearing a few notes sets images of swirling stars and black holes off in your mind. The only real problem with the score is that it at points drowns out the dialogue, although that's more a mixing issue than Hans Zimmer's fault. For a more political reason, this marks yet another time Zimmer's work for Nolan has been ignored; he also lost out for Inception to The Social Network.

3. Best Original Song

What Won: Glory - John Legend and Common (Selma) Recently, the Best Original Song category has become about recognising great, widely loved films that could easily have been otherwise ignored - The Muppets, Skyfall, Frozen. This year that was certainly true, but to a much more extreme degree; the category became a battle for a consolation prize for the two biggest snubs of these awards; The Lego Movie and Selma. After the pre-announcement rendition incited a standing ovation, with stars reduced to camera-friendly streams of tears, Glory was clearly the popular winner in the Dolby Theatre, treated by many as a the Academy admitting they messed up with the nominations. What Should Have Won: Everything Is Awesome - Shawn Patterson (The Lego Movie) C'mon guys, give The Lego Movie some love. Everything Is Awesome is a fun and catchy song that went above being a single tie-in to a merchandising feature, which is a pretty damn big achievement. That's not to say Glory isn't a good song, but, as the strong reaction to the racially charged acceptance speech proved, the statue wasn't really about the award in question, but the politics surrounding Selma, which isn't what a ceremony honouring film should be about. If movies were awarded on the emotional strength of what they were about, as opposed to what they actually brought to the table, then The Imitation Game would have swept the board.

2. Best Director

What Won: Alejandro G. Iñárritu (Birdman) The Best Director category has been one that's created a lot of controversy this year. People have grown irate over the lack of Ava DuVernay (although it's unclear whether that's due to her race and gender or whether people actually think she was one of the five best directors of 2014), bemused by the nomination of Bennett Miller when his film, Foxcatcher, was absent for Best Picture and irritated by the presence of Morten Tyldum after he went pedestrian for The Imitation Game. All that ignores, however, that it was always a two horse race between Richard Linklater for Boyhood and Alejandro González Iñárritu for Birdman, with the Mexican taking home the prize on the night (despite missing out at many other awards, such as the BAFTAs and the Golden Globes). What Should Have Won: Richard Linklater (Boyhood) Both Birdman and Boyhood are built on a strong central idea that is realised with such reverence that it pushes the films above being simple gimmick pictures, to the point that it'd be easy to argue either director should have won it. However, as evidenced by its wins elsewhere, Birdman was very much an all round team effort. Boyhood, on the other hand, is Linklater through and through, with the experimental filmmaker the driving force behind the ridiculous idea of a twelve year production.

1. Best Picture

What Won: Birdman This wasn't a year where Best Director and Best Picture went to different films, with Iñárritu returning to the stage once more before the night was out. Birdman had long been pegged for second place in the Oscar race, but a last minute sprint that saw it clean up at the Director, Producer and Actor's Guilds had it enter the night itself as the favourite. But, with Boyhood having only lagged slightly behind, there was still some uncertainly when Sean Penn opened that envelope. In the end, he gave the world the closest thing it'll ever get to a superhero Best Picture. What Should Have Won: Boyhood Now don't let the last couple of entries mislead you - Birdman is a great film. It's far and above the most deserving Best Picture winner this decade, possibly even this century, a fantastic melding of ambition and artistry that paints a story at once dealing with things incredibly current (the state of the entertainment industry) and eternally timeless (the plague of ego). But, put in the simplest possible terms, Boyhood is better. What did you make of the 87th Academy Awards? Did the right films go home with the prizes, or was Oscar way off? Have your say down in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.