Oscars 2018: 8 Most Game-Changing Nominations

The Academy is finally changing its ways.

Logan Oscars 3
20th Century Fox

The nominations for the 90th Academy Awards are officially in, bringing with them a number of expected nods but also a fair few pleasant surprises, major shocks, and outrageous snubs.

The big winner was clearly Guillermo del Toro's period fantasy The Shape of Water, with the interspecies romance bagging a massive 13 nominations. Dunkirk, too, proved as popular as expected with eight nominatons, including a Best Director nod for Christopher Nolan, with Best Picture frontrunner Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri getting seven noms but surprisingly missing Best Director for Martin McDonagh.

The Florida Project missing out on Best Picture, or Blade Runner 2049 being largely ignored outside the technicals, were two unfortunate but not unexpected instances of worth movies being overlooked, and on the flip side The Big Sick (Best Original Screenplay) was deserved recognition for a film that didn't find much anywhere else. There were, however, a number of awards that went against the grain of what we expect from the Oscars, and do perhaps signal a big, more game-changing shift in their approach to the awards process, for better or (in at least one area) for worse.


8. The Boss Baby - Best Animated Feature

The Boss Baby Oscar
DreamWorks & AMPAS

The Boss Baby's nomination didn't come completely out of left-field, since there's a smaller pool of animated features to choose from than live-action, but it is still something of a shock given the movie's quality - or lack thereof.

The film is the worst to be nominated in this category - which is usually quite strong, and last year was ridiculously so - for some time, and it's also hard to remember a bigger gulf in class between a nominee and the frontrunner (Coco).

The Oscars nominating a bad film isn't itself a game-changer, but - when there were better candidates, namely The LEGO Batman Movie, The Girl Without Hands, or Mary and the Witch's Flower - it's either a blip or a shift towards something more populist (The Boss Baby grossed considerably more than either of those films), or perhaps a sign that any old sh*te can be nominated in this category. If nothing else, it's confirmation that the Academy really hates Lego, though we can just be thankful it wasn't The Emoji Movie.


7. Timothée Chalamet - Best Actor; The Best Actress/Supporting Actress Categories

Call Me By Your Name
Sony Pictures Classics

Timothée Chalamet's nomination wasn't a surprise - indeed, it was a dead cert - but it's still interesting for one reason: how young he is.

Chalamet, at just 22-years-old, is easily the youngest nominee this year, with three over 50 and Daniel Kaluuya at 28. Going further, he's actually the youngest Best Actor nominee since 1944, when Micky Rooney was nominated for Babes in Arms. It's unlikely Chalamet will win, even though he deserves to, because Gary Oldman has been sweeping up. But the first shift it might represent is recognising performances from younger male actors, rather than assuming they need to wait to be more seasoned before they can be recognised.

It's also interesting that this year brings the oldest acting nominee ever as well, with 88-year-old Christopher Plummer nominated for Best Supporting Actor. And this range could also be starting to shift to actresses too, where people in Chalamet's age-range are frequently recognised (recent winners include Emma Stone, Brie Larson, and Jennifer Lawrence). This year, three of the women nominated for Best Actress are over 40, and all five in the Supporting category are. It's often said that there aren't many good roles for women over 40 in Hollywood, and while there's still plenty to do on that front, this is a sign of things starting to change.


6. Mudbound - Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Cinematography, Best Supporting Actress

Mudbound Mary J Blige
Netflix

Mudbound may have missed out on the top awards like Best Director and Best Picture (it was an outside bet for both at best), but it did pick up three very notable nominations: Best Adapted Screenplay, Best Cinematography, Best Original Song, and Best Supporting Actress.

Aside from representing something of a comeback for Mary J. Blige (who's in for the latter two categories), it's bigger repercussions are in what it might mean for streaming services, and Netflix in particular.

Netflix has been trying for a few years now to break into the Oscars game without much luck, and this is easily their biggest and best contender yet. Four Oscar noms, all in strong categories rather than a bunch of below-the-line ones, show that they are becoming a serious player in the Academy game, and with some big releases on the horizon (including Martin Scorsese's The Irishman) that trend should only continue.


5. Rachel Morrison - Best Cinematography

Mudbound Rachel Morrison
Netflix

A breakthrough for Netflix isn't the only way Mudbound is making waves this year, with its DP Rachel Morrison picking up a (deserved) nod for Best Cinematography. Morrison has been doing some excellent work for a while now, especially in her collaborations with Ryan Coogler (Fruitvale Station, while Black Panther looks phenomenal), but what's more surprising is that she's the first female to be nominated in this category, well, ever.

Those who can feel unlucky to have been overlooked in recent years include Maryse Alberti, who also did some stunning work with Coogler (Creed), Mandy Walker (Tracks, Australia), and Ellen Kuras (Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind), but Morrison's nomination is a step in the right direction.

The bigger picture issue isn't so much those names being overlooked, but rather those candidates have been few and far between over the years, with a 2016 study showing only 5% of cinematographers were female. With Morrison getting an Oscar nomination, and that itself getting plenty of positive attention, it's potentially the first step towards a real change on that front.


4. Greta Gerwig - Best Director

Lady Bird Greta Gerwig Saorsie Ronan
A24

Greta Gerwig's Lady Bird was popular among Academy voters, with five nominations including Best Picture, Actress, Supporting Actress, and Original Screenplay. The fifth, though, was reserved for Gerwig herself, who became only the fifth woman in history to be nominated for Best Director, and the first since Kathryn Bigelow in 2010 (The Hurt Locker).

Like with cinematographers, part of the reason is that women don't make up as high a percentage of directors as men, and Gerwig's nomination - at a time when there's a real push for change in Hollywood and wider society - should help the process of adjusting that.

It's also important that she's been nominated for what's very much a female-led and feminine movie; Bigelow, the most acclaimed female director of the last 20 years, tends to tell more masculine stories (and Bigelow is the only woman to actually win the award). With Lady Bird performing so well here, and Wonder Woman (overlooked at the Oscars, though it wasn't really snubbed anywhere) doing big box-office numbers, it could be the sign of the beginning of a shift on that front.


3. The James Franco Snub

The Disaster Artist James Franco
A24

One of the biggest snubs of the 2018 Oscars nominations was James Franco being overlooked for Best Actor. His won Best Actor for his role in The Disaster Artist at both the Golden Globes and the Critics' Choice Awards, and was nominated at the Screen Actors Guild Awards.

The Academy can be quite averse to comedy, which might partially explain why Franco was overlooked (in favour of either Denzel Washington or Daniel Day-Lewis, based on other awards), but with so many of the biggies backing him, and The Disaster Artist popular with the WGA too, he looked like he'd be able to overcome their comedy allergy.

Immediately after his Globes win, and a few days before the ballot closed for Oscar submissions, Franco was accused of sexual misconduct. Franco denied the allegations, and there's no concrete way of knowing how much they hurt his chances, but the dates certainly suggest it played its part. And that's indicative of a wider move in Hollywood that's been taking place, as witnessed in cases like Harvey Weinstein and Kevin Spacey, and it looks like the Academy, which has been expanding its member pool away from crusty old white dudes, is following along with that.


2. Logan - Best Adapted Screenplay

Logan Wolverine Xmen Comic
Fox

Despite the genre's meteoric rise in the last 10 years or so, superhero movies are largely still ignored when it comes to awards season. They might get recognised in the technical areas, thanks to them often having extensive VFX or eye-catching makeup, but it's rare they'll get any serious attention. The last film to do so was The Dark Knight, for which Heath Ledger won a posthumous Best Supporting Actor award, but that film was overlooked in the other major categories.

That itself was supposed to lead to a change in approach, as it was in part the catalyst for the expansion of the Best Picture pool, and yet the Oscars have continued to snub the superhero genre despite it only getting bigger (if never better).

Logan, then, is a major breakthrough for the genre, as its the first writing Oscar nod for a superhero film. You could argue that if you stripped away the comic book trappings and made it a more pure Western, then it'd have Best Actor and Best Supporting Actor nods for Hugh Jackman and Patrick Stewart (who are deserving regardless of genre), but the fact the Academy have recognised it in the Adapted Screenplay category is still a massive step in the right direction. Add in serious Oscar pushes for Deadpool and Wonder Woman in recent years too, and it looks like the genre is finally being taken seriously when it comes to awards season. Now for it to get the win.


1. Get Out - Best Picture, Director, And Actor

Oscars Get Out 2
Universal/AMPAS

Get Out, Jordan Peele's racially charged horror film, was one of the heavy hitters of the nominations, receiving four in total: Best Picture, Best Directing, Best Actor, and Best Original Screenplay.

It's a big deal for a couple of different reasons. One is that Jordan Peele is just the fifth black director to be nominated for Best Director, with Lee Daniels (Precious), Steve McQueen (12 Years A Slave), and Barry Jenkins (Moonlight) all nominated in the last ten years, and the first being John Singleton (Boyz n the Hood) back in 1991. Like with Gerwig's nomination in the same category, it's a further sign of things shifting on that front.

It's also one of just a handful of horror movies to be nominated for Best Picture. Even more than superheroes, the Academy has a long-held aversion to scary movies. Alfred Hitchcock was constantly overlooked, as were Universal's classic monster movies, and it wasn't until 1973 a horror movie was nominated for Best Picture - The Exorcist. Since then, depending on how far your definition of 'horror' stretches, we've had Jaws, Silence of the Lambs, The Sixth Sense, and Black Swan (and a few of them are debatable in terms of placement in the genre).

Combined with The Boss Baby (an unlikely pairing), it shows they're allowing more populist films. Combined with Logan, it shows how genre films are gradually being accepted. Combined with Gerwig and a number of others, it shows how barriers are being broken down and, with new membership, the Academy is shifting in the kinds of stories it recognises. It's still far from a perfect system, but it's definitely going in the right direction.

What did you think of this year's Oscar nominations? Let us know down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.