Oscars 2018: Who Should Win Every Award (And Who Actually Will)

And the Oscar goes to...

Oscars 2018 BEst Actor
Focus Features/AMPAS

We've had the Golden Globes, the Guilds, and the BAFTAs, and now it's time for the main event of awards season: the Academy Awards.

In less than a week the lights will go on at the Dolby Theatre, the red carpet will be rolled out, and a couple of thousand actors, writers, directors, producers and so on will gather round to watch Jimmy Kimmel and a number of A-listers hand out a bunch of awards - but to which movies is the big question.

The nominations for the 90th Academy Awards were dominated by Guillermo del Toro's inter-species period fantasy The Shape of Water, which picked up 13 nods, followed by Dunkirk with eight and Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri with seven. The awards themselves, though, could be quite evenly spread out, despite Shape and Three Billboards emerging as the main two contenders over the course of awards season.

Some of the gongs would appear to be locked in, but there is still room for a few surprises and plenty of injustices come March 4.

24. Actor In A Supporting Role

Willem Dafoe The Florida Project
A24

Nominees: Willem Dafoe (The Florida Project), Woody Harrelson (Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri), Richard Jenkins (The Shape Of Water), Christopher Plummer (All The Money In The World), Sam Rockwell (Three Billboards)

Who Should Win

Willem Dafoe

A tough call this, because Rockwell does some great work with a complex character in Three Billboards, but Dafoe's more subtle performance should edge it over Rockwell's showier one.

Dafoe - a great and oft-unappreciated character actor - delivers a career-best performance in the otherwise overlooked The Florida Project, playing the hotel manager who serves as the closest thing the movie has to a real father figure. It's a quietly powerful showing, with Dafoe saying it all through body language and facial movements. He's someone who cares in an often unkind world, and Dafoe plays it with astonishing compassion and authenticity.

Who Will Win

Sam Rockwell

As mentioned, Rockwell has the showier role, playing a racist cop who also does some good things even while you want to hate him. It's a great performance, and it'd be hard to begrudge Rockwell the win. He's long been doing great work, while he's won the majority of awards so far, including the Golden Globe, the Critics' Choice, the BAFTA, and the Screen Actors Guild, so the form is really with him.


23. Makeup And Hairstyling

Darkest Hour Gary Oldman
Focus Features

Nominees: Darkest Hour, Victoria & Abdul, Wonder

Who Should Win

Darkest Hour

All have their merits, but there's only one that has really stood out over the past few months and that's Darkest Hour, which placed star Gary Oldman under the heaviest of prosthetics. It may be seen by some as a cheap trick, but it helped completely transform Oldman into Winston Churchill, and while the film is out of its depth in the Best Picture race, it deserves some recognition here.

Who Will Win

Darkest Hour

This is a category that often has very little relation to the rest of the ceremony, as evidenced by Suicide Squad's win last year. However, Darkest Hour's Best Picture and Best Actor nominations should help it here, since it means more voters will have seen it and, more specifically, Gary Oldman, with the work done to turn him into Winston Churchill very memorable.


22. Costume Design

Beauty And The Beast Dance
Disney

Nominees: Beauty And The Beast, Darkest Hour, Phantom Thread, The Shape Of Water, Victoria & Abdul

Who Should Win

Phantom Thread

There's some strong competition here but, being a film that's actually about making clothes, the costume design in Phantom Thread is easily the best of the bunch.

It puts the costumes front and centre and pays an incredible attention to the detailing of them. From the luxurious dresses created by Daniel Day-Lewis' Reynolds to the sharp suits he himself wears, everything and everyone in this movie looks impeccable.

Who Will Win

Phantom Thread

It's the obvious and easiest choice in the category, as well as being the most deserving. It's won a few awards along the way, including the BAFTA, and it's clearly a film Oscar voters like but might not be able to recognise in the bigger categories, while designer Mark Bridges has previous having won the same award for The Artist.


21. Documentary Short

Edith Eddie
Kartemquin Films

Nominees: Edith+Eddie, Heaven Is A Traffic Jam On The 405, Heroin(e), Knife Skills, Traffic Stop

Who Should Win

Edith+Eddie

This documentary focuses on the two titular people, who are America's oldest interracial newlyweds (they're 96 and 95 respectively). The short at first seems like it's going to be a heartfelt tale about late-in-life romance, but instead takes a dark turn into abuse and a family feud. It's a film that pulls at the heart-strings while challenging viewpoints, which is an impressive feat in just 29 minutes.

Who Will Win

Edith+Eddie

The Shorts are often a difficult category to predict, since they're the most niche bunch. At the same time, that means something voters have had a better chance of seeing and knowing will play better, and this has had the most hype of the bunch, is the bookies' favourite, and contains universal themes everyone can relate to.


20. Documentary Feature

Faces Places
La Pacte

Nominees: Abacus: Small Enough To Jail, Faces Places, Icarus, Last Men In Aleppo, Strong Island

Who Should Win

Faces Places

The legendary Agnes Vardes is still making incisive films at 90, a remarkable feat itself before we even consider the quality of Faces Places - and what a documentary it is. A celebration of communities and the people they're made up of, it's at once both intimate and vast in scope and a powerful meditation on humanity and life.

Who Will Win

Faces Places

The Academy have already bestowed an honorary Oscar upon Vardes, but now they have the chance to give her - and collaborator JR - the real deal. Vardes' work stands out among the crowd and has played well to various audiences - it won the top documentary prize at Cannes - and, although there's some stiff competition (Icarus is another strong contender here) it should have enough fans to take it over the line.


19. Live-Action Short

Dekalb Elementary
Reed van Dyk/UCLA

Nominees: Dekalb Elementary, The Eleven O'Clock, My Nephew Emmett, The Silent Child, Watu Wote/All Of Us

Who Should Win

Dekalb Elementary

Based on an actual 911 call placed during a school shooting, Dekalb Elementary sees a gunman enter a school in Atlanta, Georgia and be confronted by an employee. It's an important and relevant short that takes an interesting approach to a very complex subject, and deftly handles the difficult story.

Who Will Win

Dekalb Elementary

The film is incredibly relevant, especially in the week of voting, and has already played well for festival juries, such as SXSW. It's an eclectic category and remains fairly open, but the poignancy and timeliness of the short should've appealed to voters.


18. Sound Editing

Dunkirk Movie
Warner Bros.

Nominees: Baby Driver, Blade Runner 2049, Dunkirk, The Shape Of Water, Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Who Should Win

Dunkirk

Dunkirk is the kind of film that makes your ears bleed in the best possible way (if such a thing can ever be considered positive). It's a humming, drumming war movie that explodes in a cacophony of sound, especially when seen (and heard) in IMAX, but with some slower, softer moments too that add layers of emotion to the chaos.

Who Will Win

Dunkirk

War movies tend to do very well in both sound categories, but especially editing. Those big, booming moments of Dunkirk, from the bombs dropping to the bursts of gunfire to the ships zooming by overhead, really standout and are almost surely going to be the go-to choice for most voters.


17. Sound Mixing

Star Wars The Last Jedi Crait
Lucasfilm

Nominees: Baby Driver, Blade Runner 2049, Dunkirk, The Shape Of Water, Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Who Should Win

Dunkirk

As already covered, Dunkirk does an incredible job of creating its explosive sound, but it does an even better job of mixing them all together and perfectly combining them with Hans Zimmer's score. The music and sound distort your senses, heightens emotions, and helps create the sheer immersion that Dunkirk offers you, placing you right in the heart of the searing action.

Who Will Win

Dunkirk

Although the two Sound awards don't always go the same way, when there's such a huge movie like this it's more likely to do so, as seen in recent years with Mad Max: Fury Road and Gravity. The fact Dunkirk has a score nomination helps too, along with its probable win in the Sound Editing category, and it means it should really stand out to voters here, with its only hurdle being the fact it's a summer movie.


16. Actress In A Supporting Role

Allison Janney I Tonya
Neon

Nominees: Mary J. Blige (Mudbound), Allison Janney (I, Tonya), Lesley Manville (Phantom Thread), Laurie Metcalf (Lady Bird), Octavia Spencer (The Shape Of Water)

Who Should Win

Laurie Metcalf

As the mother to the titular Lady Bird, Metcalf has a lot in common with Janney's part in I, Tonya, playing a frustrated, acerbic mother to a child intent on forging their own path. However, while that's mostly what Janney offers, Metcalf brings much more balance to the role. She perfectly conveys just how much she clearly loves her daughter, with plenty of warmth in their relationship, while also being annoyed at her actions and having to be the bad guy because of the way the father is. She strikes all the right notes, making her mean but understandable, and deserves it for the devastating airport scene alone.

Who Will Win

Allison Janney

With the Golden Globe, BAFTA, and - most tellingly - SAG awards all in the bag, this one is now Janney's to lose. She's emerged as the clear frontrunner across awards season, and she's a well-respected actor doing a great turn that plays different to how she's usually perceived (in other words, a million miles away from C.J. Cregg), and it's a spiky, loud performance voters will like.


15. Foreign-Language Film

On Body And Soul
Netflix

Nominees: A Fantastic Woman, The Insult, Loveless, On Body And Soul, The Square

Who Should Win

A Fantastic Woman

Starring Daniela Vega, Chile's A Fantastic Woman is a powerful effort that sees Marina, a transgender woman, faced with hostility as she attempts to mourn the death of her partner. It's an affecting story of grief and loss, centred around Vega's brilliantly nuanced and emotional performance.

Who Will Win

A Fantastic Woman

A very close race, with The Square having won the Palme d'Or but perhaps not being quite Oscar-friendly, A Fantastic Woman could well get over the line on the power of Vega alone, who was an outside bet for Best Actress. It's a chance for Academy members to be progressive too, something they might not want to pass up, but more than that it's simply a very strong story that, despite being foreign-language, has global appeal.


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.