Oscars 2018: Who Should Win Every Award (And Who Actually Will)

4. Directing

Lady Bird Greta Gerwig Saorsie Ronan
A24

Nominees: Paul Thomas Anderson (Phantom Thread, Guillermo del Toro (The Shape Of Water), Greta Gerwig (Lady Bird), Christopher Nolan (Dunkirk), Jordan Peele (Get Out)

Who Should Win

Christopher Nolan

It's a little shocking that this is the first time Christopher Nolan has even been nominated (The Dark Knight and Inception, at least, were both deserving), and while form suggests he'll leave empty handed he does deserve to take the gold here. Dunkirk isn't his best film, but he does some incredible direction it; the movie draws together his focus on time with a real emotion he's often accused of lacking, and puts it together in a masterful war epic. From the insane spectacle of everything on screen to the more intimate moments, this is pure filmmaking from a master of the craft.

Who Will Win

Guillermo del Toro

The Shape of Water director took home the Directors Guild of America award, which all but locks in his victory here. Only three times this century have they differed, and with del Toro winning a number of other awards along the way, being a highly-respected director who has never been recognised here before, and having such a well-liked film he's the easy favourite.


3. Actor In A Leading Role

Daniel Day Lewis Phantom Thread
Focus Features

Nominees: Timothée Chalamet (Call Me By Your Name), Daniel Day-Lewis (Phantom Thread), Daniel Kaluuya (Get Out), Gary Oldman (Darkest Hour), Denzel Washington (Roman J. Israel, Esq.)

Who Should Win

Daniel Day-Lewis

The Academy shouldn't award Day-Lewis because it's supposedly his final role, but because it's some of his finest work in one of cinema's most remarkable and distinguished careers. His role as fashion designer Reynolds Woodcock is much more understated than we're used to seeing from the actor, which leads to a more quietly impressive showing, hence the lack of awards hype. He's a character as driven as he was in There Will Be Blood, but that towering performance is instead replaced by one with a vulnerability; his bursts of anger less intimidating than they are a sign of emotional immaturity; his affectations right at the core of the character, rather than by-design to grab awards.

Who Will Win

Gary Oldman

With the make-up and prosthetics, disappearing into a famous role, and a whole lot of Acting with a huge capital A, Gary Oldman's performance in Darkest Hour is the kind awards voters lap up - not unlike Daniel Day-Lewis' turn in Lincoln, as it happens. He took home the SAG Award, and just about every other gong going as well. Tie in the fact he's got a long career of great work to be recognised for on top of all that and he looks a dead-cert.


2. Actress In A Leading Role

The Post Tom Hanks Meryl Streep
Universal

Nominees: Sally Hawkins (The Shape Of Water), Frances McDormand (Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri), Margot Robbie (I, Tonya), Saoirse Ronan (Lady Bird), Meryl Streep (The Post)

Who Should Win

Margot Robbie

Frances McDormand is going to win, and it's really hard to argue with that - she is great in Three Billboards. But Margot Robbie just does more in I, Tonya to make her worthy of the award. She conveys an incredible mix of strength and vulnerability, of charm and repulsiveness. She's unlikable in many ways but also makes you root for her, bringing empathy to a tabloid villain, along with a great mix of physicality and emotion that elevates I, Tonya as a movie.

Who Will Win

Frances McDormand

McDormand, as is the case with most of the actors set to win this year, has been cleaning up over the past couple of months, and it's tough to see that streak coming to an end in the Dolby Theatre. She's a well-regarded talent who last won here two decades ago for Fargo, and this is a powerhouse performance where her character does all manner of horrible things without batting an eyelid, but has a lot of complexity to go with it.


1. Best Picture

Three Billboards Outside Ebbing Missouri Trailer
Fox Searchlight

Nominees: Call Me By Your Name, Darkest Hour, Dunkirk, Get Out, Lady Bird, Phantom Thread, The Post, The Shape Of Water, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri

Who Should Win

The Shape Of Water

It took over a decade, but Guillermo del Toro finally made a movie that comes close to matching Pan's Labyrinth. Another dark, adult fairytale, this one's set in small-town 60s America against the backdrop of the space race, but that's only a part of it. It is, as you'd expect, full of various influences, with del Toro putting a new twist on elements of Beauty and the Beast, Frankenstein, Creature From The Black Lagoon and a host of B-movies. Despite that, it never feels derivative, but is instead taken straight from del Toro's heart and injected into ours; a hauntingly beautiful, romantic, and magical tale of love, beauty, and monsters.

The performances across the board are brilliant, not least in how much Sally Hawkins and Doug Jones are able to convey without speaking, the production design and cinematography lush, the music swooning. Much like Hawkins' Elisa and the Fish Man, it's almost impossible not to be swept away and fall completely in love with.

Who Will Win

The Shape Of Water

At first glance, this one appears to be a straight fight between The Shape of Water and Three Billboards. The latter has taken some of the biggies, including the Golden Globe and BAFTA, but the most telling might be the Producers Guild of America, which gave its top prize to Guillermo del Toro's period-fantasy.

Although the last couple of years have diverged, more often than not the recipient of the PGA award takes the top gong here, and that looks like being the case again this year as things stand. Shape has support from a lot of the other Guilds too, meaning it should receive plenty of votes across the board, though if they go for del Toro as Best Director they may feel inclined to split their vote and give this to Three Billboards or something else. Billboards didn't land a SAG ensemble nomination either, which every other Best Picture winner since Braveheart has had, so that is a dent to its chances.

Further muddying the waters is the preferential voting system in play here. Three Billboards is quite a divisive film, so while it might get plenty of 1st place votes, it's less likely to be someone's second or third choice. That's the factor that could lead to a big upset, with the likes of Dunkirk, Get Out, and Lady Bird typically loved or liked, meaning they'll pick up plenty of points - but the same could be said for The Shape of Water too.

It's close, and one of the most open in years, but Shape just has the edge.

Who do you think should/will win at the Oscars? Share your picks and predictions down in the comments.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.