Outlaw King Review: 7 Ups & 2 Downs

Chris Pine nails the Scottish accent.

Outlaw King Chris Pine Aaron Taylor Johnson
Netflix

The new historical epic from David Mackenzie (Hell or High Water) landed on Netflix this weekend, and despite its fairly middling critical reception so far, the Chris Pine-starring Outlaw King is a surprisingly sturdy effort that's well worth your time.

It's important to note that many of the Rotten Tomatoes reviews are from its TIFF premiere back in September, before Mackenzie went back into the editing room and cut almost 25 minutes from the film.

According to some prominent critics, this new version of the film is a significant improvement over what audiences saw back in September, so there you go.

On its own terms as a standalone Netflix Original, Outlaw King serves up the historical intrigue, buckets of gore and cracking acting you'd hope for, even if it's certainly not on the level of the director's previous Oscar-nominated hit.

There haven't been many lavishly-produced movies for history buffs to sink their teeth into lately, in which case this effort should serve starved audiences especially well...


Downs...

2. The Rushed Pacing

Outlaw King Chris Pine Florence Pugh
Netflix

Even though the consensus is that Mackenzie's film was drastically improved by losing a perfunctory fight scene and a sequence in which Robert the Bruce (Pine) coincidentally stumbles across William Wallace, the end result does feel a little on the rushed side regardless.

The 121-minute run-time is positively scant for the standards of a typical historical epic, creating a disappointingly breathless feel at times where scenes aren't allowed to gestate for long before we're whisked off to the next set-piece or dialogue exchange.

There was clearly enough material here for a Netflix mini-series, honestly, and while many early reviews state that the TIFF cut was frustratingly overlong and plodding, perhaps Mackenzie could've let the remaining scenes linger for just a little while longer.


1. The Script Is Pretty Basic

Outlaw King Chris Pine
Netflix

Though the movie's story is mostly effective and some of the dialogue proves memorably savage, the script as a whole - written by five screenwriters, including Mackenzie himself - does feel pretty rote and workmanlike at times.

There are countless moments where a character reels off exposition in a totally unnatural way solely for the audience's benefit, almost as though they're reading a Wikipedia summary to whoever they're sharing the screen with.

Clearly the feeling was that the inherent intrigue of the real-life plot would be enough to suffice, and thankfully it mostly is, even if the characters end up sounding a touch robotic at times. Just a little more poetry and imagination here could've gone a long way.

So, Outlaw King has its issues, but it's still absolutely worth a sit. Here's what Mackenzie and co. got right...


Ups...

7. Chris Pine & Aaron Taylor-Johnson's Strong Performances

Outlaw King Chris Pine Aaron Taylor Johnson
Netflix

There was a lot of pre-release concern about Chris Pine's ability to pull off a convincing Scottish accent, being an American as he is, but it's a pleasure to report that Pine clearly did his homework, and the end result is pretty damn great.

Sure, there are moments where he slips a little, but considering how notoriously difficult the accent is to pull off, especially for an American, he nailed it for the most part.

Plus, he manages to disappear into the role of Robert the Bruce rather than looking like a Hollywood star playing dress-up, as is so often a problem in these types of movies.

At least as good as Pine if not better, however, is Aaron Taylor-Johnson as James Douglas, also smashing the accent but also getting a far more volcanic role to sink his teeth into given Douglas' well-noted insanity.

He's not in the movie anywhere near as much as Pine, but he savours every moment he gets and continues to impress as one of the most under-appreciated young actors of his generation.


6. David Mackenzie's Sharp, Grounded Direction

Outlaw King Chris Pine Florence Pugh
Netflix

Despite the aforementioned pacing issues, this is another sumptuously composed movie from Mackenzie, impressively allowing his tendency towards gritty intimacy to shine through even when shooting a $120 million tentpole.

He's clearly more comfortable during the quieter, talkier scenes but regardless of the content, Mackenzie does a great job building an atmosphere and practically letting the audience smell the mud of the battlefield.

It's incredibly easy for movies of this size to lose any sense of personality and basically feel like they were assembled by a studio executive, but Mackenzie's voice feels distinctly present throughout.


5. The Epic, Brutal Battle Scenes

Outlaw King Chris Pine
Netflix

Though there's not a ton of action in the movie, the battle scenes certainly live up to the hype, with their unflinching, unrepentant approach to violence and agreeably diverse visuals.

The obvious highlight of the film is the climactic battle between Bruce's Scottish army and Edward II's (Billy Howle) English army, a stomach-churningly bloody affair that doesn't skimp away from showing both man and animal alike being impaled, hacked to pieces and generally savaged.

That's not to forget some of the other gnarly beats earlier in the movie, namely some of William Wallace's dismembered remains making a quick cameo, and one of Bruce's relatives receiving one of the most jaw-droppingly realistic disembowellings ever put on screen.

The battles clearly account for most of the film's blockbuster-sized budget, and Mackenzie does a wonderful job making them both highly entertaining and often shockingly brutal.


4. It's Surprisingly Funny In Places

Outlaw King Chris Pine Florence Pugh
Netflix

Despite the obviously grim subject matter, Mackenzie smartly includes some sporadic spicings of humour throughout, just as he did in both Starred Up and Hell or High Water.

Taylor-Johnson's James Douglas gets a number of perverse laughs simply from the heightened, almost surreal nature of his demented behaviour, while a number of broad gags are thrown in occasionally to break up the brutality.

One especially amusing sequence involves Bruce and Elizabeth de Burgh (Florence Pugh) consummating their marriage, and while a lesser director would've played the scene too goofy or allowed it to upend the film's generally serious tone, it ends up working incredibly well.

It's a tough tight-rope to walk, but it's a smart way to broaden the movie out a little while not derailing its overall mood.


3. Barry Ackroyd's Beautiful Cinematography

Outlaw King
Netflix

Oscar-nominated cinematographer Barry Ackroyd (The Hurt Locker, Captain Phillips) once again displays his impeccable talent for gritty beauty with his terrific lensing for this film.

The sweeping landscape shots in Outlaw King, of which there are many, are absolutely breathtaking, while even the most grounded and straightforward dialogue feels richly ravishing. The warmth of these scenes is contrasted with the more muted harshness of the exterior treks and battles.

An opening single-take sequence is for sure the most memorably-shot scene in the film, but if you own a 4K TV, you'll most likely be frequently wowed by Netflix's eye-wateringly impressive HDR presentation here.


2. The Excellent Supporting Cast

Outlaw King Florence Pugh
Netflix

Outlaw King is blessed with an exceptional supporting cast who do splendid work alongside Pine and Taylor-Johnson.

Especially note-worthy is the always wonderful rising star Florence Pugh, turning in another impressive performance as the strong-willed Elizabeth de Burgh, while Game of Thrones alums James Cosmo and Stephen Dillane do fine work as Bruce's father and Edward I respectively.

Elsewhere Billy Howle is also a hoot as Edward II, and though his character as written does begin to flirt with cartoonishness at times, it does seem like an apt realisation of the man's eventual status as a lazy, buffoonish King.

From the prime supporting roles to the smallest bit parts, though, everyone's doing fine work here.


1. Its Impressively Restrained Politics

Outlaw King Chris Pine
Netflix

It would've been incredibly easy for Mackenzie to make Outlaw King an astoundingly on-the-nose allegory for the current debate about Scottish independence, and though many will interpret the film through that lens regardless, he thankfully doesn't engage in any formal way.

Mackenzie has said in interviews that he intentionally didn't want the movie to take a deeply nationalist bent, especially in today's climate where toxic nationalism is a problem worldwide. When compared to its spiritual predecessor Braveheart, it's certainly a decidedly more restrained piece of filmmaking.

As a more isolated, vacuum-sealed look at Bruce's quest for freedom, it is extremely effective on its own terms and really didn't need the realities of 2018 being needlessly injected into the mix. Thankfully Mackenzie appeared to feel the same way.

What did you make of Outlaw King? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.