Patrick Stewart: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked
Stewart's five finest hours and five he'd rather we forget. Engage!

Along with Sir Ian McKellen, X-Men star and veteran thespian Sir Patrick Stewart has been taken to the hearts of the film loving collective audience as a sort of grand old treasure. He is a walking meme, thanks to his delightful eccentricity and his relationship with McKellen, and of course, he's a hell of an actor.
It's hard to think of another actor of his generation who is so universally admired by both critics and the public, not just for his long career on stage and screen but for his support of charities like Refuge, Amnesty International and Combat Stress. He's made so many great and interesting choices in his career that it's hard to find any faults in his filmography - but rest assured, we have found them.
This week sees the release of the critically acclaimed horror thriller Green Room, in which Stewart stars as punk club owner Darcy - a departure from his usual fare, to say the least. By all accounts, it's a joy, and it deserves to be as widely watched as possible.
Here, then, is a retrospective on Stewart's long career, which stretches back to the early days of Coronation Street, singling out the best and worst the great man has committed to film. Because yes, even regal presences like Stewart make mistakes...
5 Awesome Performances...
5. Himself (Sort Of) - Extras (2005)

Though predominantly known for his serious, dramatic performances, Stewart proved himself a titan of comic timing for Ricky Gervais' second great comedy scene with a cameo that is as hilarious as it is cringe-worthy.
Reimagining himself as a skewed version of himself - defined partly by his thespianism and partly by a strange, perverse penchant for happening upon naked women. Stewart's delivery of the increasingly ridiculous lines, and the cumulative effect suggestion that his grand opus would effectively be a raunchier Carry On film are hysterical, and it's a wonder anyone got through recording at all.
That same comic commitment to self-deprecation has also seen him take on the Adam West-like role in American Dad as CIA boss Bullock. He's hilarious in that, but he's never quite as good in his brief appearance opposite Ricky Gervais.
4. John Of Gaunt - The Hollow Crown: Richard II (2012)

Though Ben Whishaw's performance in Hollow Crown is the most diverting, Stewart's should also not be under-estimated, especially since his character helps to set Richard's decline in motion.
In case you need reminding, Richard II covers the last two years of the monarch's reign at the end of the 14th century. Faced with a dispute between his cousin Henry Bolingbroke (Rory Kinnear) and noble Thomas Mowbray, Richard banishes the former for six years and the latter for life. After the death of Bolingbroke's father, John of Gaunt, Richard seizes all his lands and imposes heavy taxes to fund a war in Ireland. Bolingbroke, banished to France, assembles an army and invades England to claim back his money and take the crown. Richard complies and is imprisoned in Pomfret Castle, where he is eventually murdered.
John of Gaunt is a small but significant part for an actor, being the moral thorn in Richard's side who believes he was responsible for the actions that caused his son to be banished. While much of his career has seen him in refined, cool performances, here Stewart is grim and visceral, almost spitting out his every line with barely-contained rage. He delivers the play's most famous speech (the one about "this sceptr'd isle") with great heft, and even after his character has passed on his presence can be felt at the royal court. Stewart has done a lot of Shakespeare in his career, but this is one of the real highlights.
3. Sejanus - I, Claudius (1976)

As with so much great TV and cinema, it's only when you revisit something after a long period that you come to appreciate all the little details you may have missed. One such detail is Stewart's performance as Sejanus, a ruthless member of the Praetorian Guard who rises to become de facto emperor of the Roman world.
I, Claudius is a 1976 BBC series based on the novels by Rupert Graves, which tells the story of several Roman emperors of the Claudian dynasty. Beginning with the reign of Augustus (Brian Blessed) and ending with Claudius (Derek Jacobi), it shows the corruption and intrigue of the imperial family as its many different members plot and scheme to place themselves or their chosen children on the throne. It's a highly compelling work, structured like a soap opera or mob drama, and many of its performances and dramatic twists still put modern-day historical dramas to shame.
Sejanus' arc is one of the more under-appreciated aspects of the series. While not as schemingly Machiavellian as main villain Livia (Sian Phillips), the character is a fearsome enforcer whose loyalty to Rome eventually mutates into a cruel desire to manipulate others to guarantee his own power. But rather than go into hammy villain mode at the soonest opportunity, Stewart keeps a lid on things right up to the moment where his character is openly betrayed. It's a true example of how less is sometimes more, particularly when playing powerful characters.
2. Professor Charles Xavier - X-Men (2000)

Considering his physical appearance and reputation for given performances of great gravitas, it was perhaps inevitable that Stewart would have been approached to play Professor X at some point. While Hugh Jackman's performance as Wolverine often takes the limelight - not to mention all the spin-offs - Stewart's turn as Xavier has just as much right to be regarded as definitive. Xavier in the comics is a controlled voice of reason and a moral anchor, a role in which Stewart has often excelled.
X-Men focusses on the introduction of two main mutants: Wolverine, a reckless loner with a skeleton encased in adamantium, and Rogue (Anna Paquin), who can possess the ability of any other mutant simply by touching them. Isolated by their strange and dangerous abilities, they are taken under the wing of Professor Xavier, who informs them of the X-Men's existence and of his enemy Magneto (Ian McKellen). When Magneto's associates kidnap a Senator who wants all mutants to reveal their secret identities, the X-Men come together to foil his plans, resulting in a final battle on the Statue of Liberty.
The X-Men films have been at their best when they focus on the comics' subtexts about intolerance, adolescence and alienation. While neither this film or its sequel are by any means perfect, they are rooted in the characters' interaction rather than the pyrotechnics, and Singer's direction brings out these themes without ever becoming too preachy. Stewart may not quite get the screen time he deserves, but for every second he's on screen the film has a great sense of urgency and purpose. He brings a moral intensity to the character which makes him compelling, and his final scene with McKellen is very well-played.
1. Captain Jean-Luc Picard - Star Trek (various, 1987-2002)

It would be insane not to include Stewart's most famous performance on this list, and probably just as insane not to place it at the top.
Picard was introduced in 1987 in Star Trek: The Next Generation, a TV series set 70 years after the final mission led by Captain James Kirk (William Shatner). Unlike in the traditional series, the Klingons have become allies of the Federation, with the main enemies in the series being the Borg, the Romulans and a mysterious God-like entity known as Q. After seven seasons, the TV cast branched out into four films, beginning with Star Trek: Generations, in which Captain Kirk was finally killed off by A Clockwork Orange star Malcolm McDowell.
While much of The Next Generation era was silly, ridiculous or just plain underwhelming, the show always managed to pull through on the strengths of its central performances. Stewart is brilliant as Picard, possessing enormous intelligence and great cunning married to a deeply rooted moral compass and lacking the obvious and irritating vanity that dogged Shatner's performance. Debate will continue to rage between Trekkies about which was the better captain of the Enterprise, but it's almost impossible to not be impressed by Stewart, in what remains his finest performance.
Having been engaged by Stewart's best performances, now let's look at five occasions when his judgement was severely warped...
...And 5 That Sucked
5. Gurney Halleck - Dune (1984)

Many of Stewart's bad performances are not entirely his fault. He's turned up in many productions which are in some way sub-par, and often has been the best thing in them. But just because the film around them is terrible doesn't excuse an actor from looking lost in the part, which brings us nicely onto Stewart's ill-fated role in the equally ill-fated Dune.
Based on the seminal novel by Herbert Ross, Dune is a sci-fi epic set in the far future where it is possible to travel through space instantaneously through a substance called spice melange. The spice, as it is known, is found on only one planet in the entire galaxy - Arrakis, an arid desert world populated by people called the Fremen. The film centres around the conflict between the houses of Atreides and Harkonnen over the control of Arrakis, and around a prophecy that a figure called the Kwisatz Haderach will come and liberate the Fremen.
By anyone's standards, Dune is a complete mess. Its director David Lynch still refuses to talk about it in interviews, and whichever version you plump for the plot is convoluted, the terminology impenetrable and the imagery downright disturbing. Stewart isn't the film's biggest problem, but he makes the very least of a part that could have provided some welcome weight and momentum. He delivers his lines like he doesn't really understand anything what he's saying, and seems lost among all the unconvincing special effects.
4. Adventure - The Pagemaster (1994)

When famous actors are recruited for animated children's films, they often use it either as an opportunity to showboat or an excuse to kick back and enjoy the paycheck. Long before Dreamworks made a habit of casting celebrities to pastiche themselves in the likes of Shark Tale, Ted Turner tried the same trick in a bid to educate American children. The result was The Pagemaster, a dull and dreary offering which really hasn't stood the test of time.
The Pagemaster stars Macaulay Culkin as Richard Tyler, a pessimistic pantophobe (he's afraid of everything) who bases all his behaviour upon statistics. Forced to shelter in a library during a thunderstorm, he meets an eccentric librarian (Christopher Lloyd) and ends up in a strange imaginary world with the title character. He is told to search for the exit, accompanied by three anthropomorphised books: Adventure (Stewart as a pirate), Fantasy (Whoopi Goldberg as a fairy) and Horror (Frank Welker as a 'hunch-book', geddit?).
Looking at The Pagemaster now, it's not hard to see why it bombed at the box office. Even with allowances for changing standards in animation, the story is preachy, thinly-written and makes the very least of its basic premise. Most of the jokes feel like cast-offs from Abbot and Costello movies, and Stewart again makes far too little of his character: it's just another stereotypical pirate with no real presence or memorable value. Put it this way: his brief and inconsequential appearance as a 19th-century ship's captain on the Star Trek holodeck was much more impressive.
3. Ebenezer Scrooge - A Christmas Carol (1999)

On the very slim chance that you've never heard of it, A Christmas Carol is based on Dickens' classic story of the miser Ebenezer Scrooge, a man with no time for charity or Christmas. On Christmas Eve, having been persuaded to reluctantly shut up shop, he is visited by the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present and Future, who lead him through time in an effort to make him change his ways. The filmmakers on this version wanted to recapture the grim atmosphere of the Sim version, in contrast to the more consciously cheery ones that had followed it.
While it's very hard to get A Christmas Carol wrong, it's very easy to direct it without any energy, and this production has very little going for it. Director David Jones' stage background is all-too-obvious, with his pedestrian angles and lighting decisions failing to lift the material. The most curious thing about it, however, is Stewart's performance: having won acclaim for playing the part on stage in London and on Broadway, he seems confused or lost in the material. Whether through poor direction or a genuine lapse in technique, this is one Scrooge you can skip.
2. Rafe Bentley - Masterminds (1997)

There's a very good chance that you haven't heard of Masterminds, because hardly anybody saw it when it was first released. Its only really notable detail is that it is directed by Roger Christian, who only three years later went on to make Battefield Earth, widely regarded as one of the worst films of all time. Beyond that, it's just a dull, unfunny, poorly-directed comedy, which finds Stewart phoning it in and hamming it up.
Masterminds is the story of Oswald "Ozzie" Paxton (Vincent Karthusier), an adept young hacker who was expelled from school for hacking their security systems. Having dropped off his stepsister at his old school, Ozzie stays behind to pull one last prank on the principal, but his plans go awry when the new security officer (Stewart) knocks out the teachers and locks down the school. With Bentley holding the privileged children to ransom, Ozzie must use all his skills if he is to make it out alive.
Masterminds is essentially what would happen if you shoved Hackers and Die Hard in a blender and then gave it to someone who really didn't know what they were doing. Christian may have abstained from endless Dutch angles this time around, but his storytelling is still weak and the cinematography is very drab. Stewart's performance, however, is one of the biggest disappointments, as he fails to overcome a ridiculous moustache and brings nothing distinctive to the part. Not only is he no Hans Gruber, he might just be one of the least memorable villains in cinema.
1. The Great Prince of the Forest - Bambi II (2006)

Before John Lasseter became head of Walt Disney Animation, the studio had embarked upon a wave of straight-to-video sequels, prequels and midquels to many of its most famous titles. Most of these were made on tiny budgets by people who had no real understanding of the originals, and nearly all of them are either offensively bad or shockingly dull. But Bambi II deserves special derision, tackling a part of the original story that was unimportant and making it even less interesting.
Despite its title, Bambi II is not a sequel but a midquel. It takes place in the middle of the action of the first film, between the death of Bambi's mother at the hands of hunters and the flash-forward to birds twittering in the forest with Bambi now all grown up. It involves Bambi (Alexander Gould) being taken in by his dad (Stewart), who is forced to take care of him when a suitable doe cannot be found. The rest of the film is a mix of third-rate slapstick, awkward father-son bonding and a rival called Ronno, who gets his comeuppance at the hands (or beak) of a turtle.
Stewart isn't the first big-name star to take the Disney straight-to-video shilling: George Carlin turned up in the equally pointless Tarzan II just a year earlier. But while Carlin manages to put something of a stamp on the role, Stewart seems as completely disinterested as we are. He makes no effort to push the character in an interesting direction, being so sure of where he has to end up that he doesn't do the emotional legwork in the meantime. The whole film is boring and lazy as hell, but Stewart is especially lazy here and it remains his worst performance to date.
How would you rank Patrick Stewart's best and worst movies? Share your ranking below in the comments thread.