Peter Dinklage: 5 Awesome Performances And 5 That Sucked

Which of the Pixel's star's roles achieve a level-up, and which force a Game Over?

With his turn as Tyrion Lannister in the HBO series Game Of Thrones, Peter Dinklage became a star. His rambunctious and energetic depiction of an unforgettable character captured the imagination of the TV-watching public, his face and lines emblazoned on everything from T-shirts to bumper-stickers as he claimed the title of series MVP. What's surprising is that Dinklage was a seasoned performer well before Thrones' debut in 2011, with a hoard of TV, indie and studio titles to his name. Much of Dinklage's early work pivoted around his diminutive stature (4 foot and 5 inches), but as his skills became more widely tested, the roles started to expand. This week he's in UK theatres alongside Adam Sandler and Kevin James for the much-derided Pixels, the story of '80s video-game characters sent from above to wreck havoc on earth. Dinklage plays Sandler's childhood nemesis, in a part styled on King Of Kong's Billy Mitchell. The results are... well, you'll see. As with any actor who's been professionally active for two decades, not everything Dinklage touches turns to Thrones. He's worked with indie darling Thomas McCarthy, been involved with not one, but two family films centred around a dog and dipped his toes in the superhero mania that currently engulfs Hollywood. The results have been... let's say mixed.

5 Awesome Performances...

5. Peter Drunklage - Saturday Night Live (2013)

In an episode hosted by Melissa McCarthy, Peter Dinklage still managed to steal the show. He joined Bobby Moynihan's Drunk Uncle, taking on the identity of the beautifully named Peter Drunklage. Drunklage is the whiskey slugging brother of Drunk Uncle, and the two apparently watching Game Of Thrones together during their down time. Together they discuss immigration, taxes and break into random verses of '80s glam-rock. It's a short sketch, but with co-host Seth Meyers' giggling along constantly, it makes an impression. Admittedly it doesn't see Dinklage stretched to his max, but he does make a great drunk and the bit never once uses Dinklage's height as a punchline.

4. Miles Finch - Elf (2003)

Another brief turn, but an absolute scene-stealer. Dinklage plays self-serious children's author Miles Finch, a man in command of both a formidable ego and a nasty temper. When Will Ferrell's Buddy crashes a meeting between Finch and James Caan's book magnate, he mistakes Finch for a Christmas Elf, and in his naive ignorance refuses to notice his faux pas. Finch responds with a verbal and physical tirade, sinking dialogue like "I get more action in a week than you've had in your entire life" into the heart of a family film. He's abrasive and the line delivery is killer, but what's more, Dinklage reads the comedic tone perfectly. He's severe to a fault, discussing the vulnerability of tomatoes as if they were concentration camp survivors struggling out of a cruel dictatorship. The movie loses minor points for using Dinklage's height as a gag (that's going to be a recurring theme) but his brief turn steals the scene with a cynical arrogance perfectly at odds with Ferrell's childlike disposition.

3. Frank - Death At A Funeral (2010)

Perhaps a bit of a controversial pick here, given that there are two versions of the film (one from 2007). Dinklage is in both, but as I marginally prefer the unrelenting mania of the 2010 incarnation, I'm going to stick it on the list. Death Of A Funeral has an amazing high-concept hook, with an at odds family regrouping to memorialise their recently deceased patriarch. Problem arise when a guest, portrayed by Dinklage, shows up claiming to be the dead man's lover, and if his family want it kept under wraps, they better play ball. Funeral is a more overtly slapstick outing for Dinklage, and in a way he's just playing a slightly more grounded incarnation of Miles Finch. He's initially sweet, but quick to anger and when Dinklage starts laying down threats, thanks to the actor's innate gravitas, you believe him. It's a really silly film, but he's a dangerous, bright spark, and he totally holds his own against the loud, physical work of Chris Rock, Martin Lawrence and James Marsden. Like the previous spots on this list, Dinklage doesn't have a whole heap of screen-time, but he still makes an indelible mark on the material. That's the sign of a super performance.

2. Tyrion Lannister - Game Of Thrones (2011-2015)

Let's get this one out of the way fast, yeah? As the blood-thirsty, booze-swilling, womanising and often strangely poetic Tyrion Lannister, Dinklage has come to personify everything people love about the HBO show. It's innately fantastical, yet imbued with a dark underbelly and dramatic reality that makes it play more like Deadwood than The Lord Of The Rings. Dinklage's turn as Lannister is probably the most concise and compartmentalised incarnation of Thrones's strengths, spouting off memorable one-liners with reckless abandon and utterly convincing as a fearsome warrior despite his unconventional frame. It's of course a great hook, the show's most masculine character being physically so much slighter than his peers, but Dinklage hasn't fallen back on the staple, indeed even when side-lined in captivity, the character routinely nabbed episodes, finding the right balance between empathy stirring humour and true, gritty pathos. It's a complex performance that can also be distilled to a handful of T-shirt shifting slogans, and in Hollywood that's a powerful combination. In other words, he's iconic.

1. Finbar McBride - The Station Agent (2003)

It was really tough to place Dinklage's lesser-seen work in The Station Agent above his globally revered shift on Game Of Thrones, but in a way, that's a good reason to justify the choice. Dinklage had been working pretty steadily for 7 years before he landed the lead in McCarthy's directorial debut, playing Finbar McBride, a train enthusiast who following the death of his only friend, moves to New Jersey in search of solitude and with a mind to follow his passion of locomotives. Whilst there he befriends other lost souls, and complex relationships ensue. Agent is a quiet but incredibly potent drama, the sort that slowly leads you through its first act before unleashing a flurry of emotionally wrenching insights, working you over on an almost subconscious level. As the lead Dinklage is key to the feature's success, bringing a guarded intensity that perfectly defines his character from frame one. Unlike other outings, The Station Agent addresses Dinklage's height in a perceptive and intelligent fashion, integrating its complications into the narrative, and not always in expected ways. The actor bravely confronts everything McCarthy throws at him, and as the belated Roger Ebert wrote, is "incredibly present" in every scene. It's a performance from a small man, that completely fills a big movie. A lot of people also credit The Station Agent with bringing Dinklage to wider attention, leading to his casting in bigger products, and eventually Thrones. As a result this powerful, impressive performance is a worthy topper for the list.

And 5 That Sucked...

5. Marlowe Sawyer - Nip/Tuck (2006)

For the sake of posterity, I should say it's really tough to find genuinely bad Peter Dinklage performances. His stint on Nip/Tuck is a good example of the performance not so much lacking, but the material and his take failing to coalesce. The popular FX show, set around the world of plastic surgeons, had Dinklage in for one season, as a man looking to rectify his height for the sake of an adulterous relationship. Dinklage pitches a similar intensity here as in The Station Agent, but it comes off at odds with the material, which is by nature trashier and less introspective than his 2003 triumph. Dinklage genuinely seems to be trying for truths that the material isn't equipped to accommodate, his moody focus playing out rather transparently against the melodramatic tone of the show. It doesn't help that the relationship between his smaller stature and sex life should be explored so predictably, again in stark contrast to what we see in The Station Agent. This performance definitely has its defenders, but for me, doesn't quite work.

4. Dr. Bolivar Trask - X-Men: Days Of Future Past (2014)

With Dinklage's popularity in the geek community at fever pitch, it was only a matter of time before he transitioned into the superhero fold. His bow in the ever-popular sub-genre occurred last year, playing the villainous Bolivar Trask in X-Men: Days Of Future Past. The film was reasonably good, but Dinklage found himself out-matched by other cast members, leading to an embodiment of Trask that felt perfunctory. Again, it's not horrible acting, and the writing surrounding the part isn't great, but there's no denying Trask comes across as a flat, two-dimensional bad guy for the majority of the film. He scowls, glowers and even wears a sinister lab-coat, but he also lacks presence or flavour. The movie explains why he wants the mutant threat eradicated, but I gotta say, I never really believed it. Dinklage presumably came to set, read his lines and then left with one of the larger pay-cheques of his career. That may sound cynical, but hey, so's the performance. I guess even the greats gotta go for the buck sometimes.

3. Dr. Simon Barsinister - Underdog (2007)

This one's kind of weird. You probably don't remember, but back in 2007, Disney tried to kick-start an Underdog franchise with this flaccid adaptation of the beloved cartoon. The reason you don't remember is because it turned a pretty uninspired $65 million at the worldwide box-office. Anyway, to bring things around, Dinklage is in it as the bad guy. Dinklage is easily the best thing about the film, but kind of in the same way Peter Sarsgaard is the best thing about Green Lantern. There's entertainment to be derived as Dinklage's scientist slowly loses his marbles, forcing the crime-fighting Underdog to take action. It's an incredibly overwrought performance in an otherwise flatter than thou film; Dinklage plots and gurns entertainingly, trying to suppress reactionary cringes to the mess around him. Is it good acting? No. Was it a necessary step in making an fathomably dull movie a little less boring? Maybe. Either way, we think Dinklage probably wants everyone to forget this thing ever happened.

2. Eddie - Pixels (2015)

You'd think acting alongside Adam Sander and Kevin James would be an easy job for Dinklage - even if he was phoning it in X-Men style he'd still come away as the best thing in the film. And yet while his turn in Pixels isn't terrible, it's totally insipid, with the Thrones star never coming close to eclipsing his comic co-stars. Part of this is down to Sandler and James playing characters so close to themselves that they're actually believable, whereas Dinklage's Donkey Kong champion is an arrogant, crude creation with such flip-flopping ideals that the actor can never really get a lock on him. That's no excuse though - the writing may be bad, but with a performance whose flair only goes as far as looking over a pair of sunglasses while sounding faux-badass, it's not like Dinklage is trying to elevate it one level. As some form of consolation, he does at least get the film's one genuinely funny line - he passively concludes that a night with Martha Stewart would at least result in getting a panini afterwards. Ha?

1. Rowlie - Lassie (2005)

It's a testament to Dinklage's skill that this sits as his worst performance. In fact, it's unenviable position can generally be blamed on one very simple problem. A problem that's troubled actors like Russell Crowe and Cameron Diaz before him. I'm talking about the Oyrish accent. Dinklage plays a weary traveler who befriends the eponymous dog in this inoffensive adaptation (it's certainly a better film than Underdog), complete with a forced and overcooked Irish accent. As the film plays out in England, it's possible the accent is intended as a hybrid (like Crowe's equally dire effort in Robin Hood) but it still distracts the pants off you. Doesn't much help that he spends most of the movie with a dog, which understandably renders conversation one-sided. So for Dinklage's portion of the feature the audio track's just a mix of whimsical music and dodgy Irish vocals. Not my favourite combination to be honest. Lassie is extremely forgettable. In fact, the only thing I properly remember is Dinklage's ignoble contribution. For that reason, and because he really is a fabulous actor, this turn resides at the bottom of my list. Agree with this list? Or did we get Dinklage totally wrong? Let us know what you think down in the comments.

Contributor

Writer, cinephile and owner of Vampire's Kiss on DVD. Take from that what you will.