Pride And Prejudice: Ranking The Adaptations Worst To Best
Once upon a time, before Colin Firth, there were other on-screen Darcys for ladies to fawn over. After all Pride And Prejudice, published in 1813, is not only Jane Austen's most famous and popular novel, it also happens to be the most adaptable to screen, for a number of reasons. On the surface level, Pride And Prejudice is a fairy tale: poor (well, sort of) girl fights against all odds and lives happily ever after with the rich, handsome prince. The fairy tail attribute of this story is universally appealing, but what makes it so compelling and timeless is the wit and charm Austen uses to deliver her story. Those readers (or viewers) who only manage to see a light romantic comedy in Pride And Prejudice are missing the most important reasons for its persistent appeal - it is a story of empowerment and control over one's destiny. Our heroine (Elizabeth Bennet) and our hero (Fitzwilliam Darcy) don't succeed because of the advantages of their birth and their inherited wealth (or lack of) - it's their personal revelations, their ability to self examine and change their attitudes and behavior that appeal to us. Over the years, Elizabeth Bennet has been played by Greer Garson, Jennifer Ehle, and most recently, Keira Knightley. Elizabeth is not only Austen's most beloved and modern heroine, but her most relatable. When you read Pride And Prejudice, it's hard not to visualize yourself as Elizabeth - and I think that's why there is such a strong attachment to this character, and as a result, such strong feelings towards the women who have played her over the years, whether positive or negative. If you're reading this, you're most likely familiar with Austen's characters, and at least one or two of the adaptations of the story. I'll assume, then, that I can skip the details and descriptions of some of the characters for each version and instead focus on the merits of each adaptation. Lord knows any fangirl could write a novel on Mrs. Bennet's overbearingness or Caroline Bingley's haughtiness, but that isn't what this list is for. Some adaptations of Jane Austen's most famous novel were more successful than others, as it turns out. These days, as far as P&P is concerned, two versions fight over the top spot(you know the ones I'm talking about), but there are other adaptations worth watching along the way. Hundreds of adaptations of this story exist in book form, but ranking screen adaptations of the original text was challenging enough. Honorable Mention:
The only book I'll rank is Pride And Prejudice And Zombies, because it's been in development on IMDB for a while now and there is a possibility we may see it on the big screen in the next decade. Published in 2009, Seth Grahame-Smith's novel is one of the most blogged about adaptations in recent memory. Because who doesn't love a crossover between nerd culture and Regency England? It's a pretty simple concept: there's all the original text of Pride And Prejudice, and then there is zombies. Here's to hoping the development on this one starts moving along.
6. Pride And Prejudice (1940)
This production has its charms, but it's not for you if you're looking for a strict adaptation of the book. This version is a product of its time, and it's also important to note that it's adapted from a screenplay by Aldous Huxley. It enthusiastically takes liberties with its costumes, characters and time period. The creators of version do deserve credit for the only popular attempt to adapt this novel for the screen before the 1970's, even if the story is mostly sugarcoated. The tone is much lighter, more comedic, and has almost none of Austen's wit. Lawrence Oliver, who was 33, could get away with playing the 28 year old Darcy (Colin Firth in the '95 miniseries was 35) but Greer Garson is too old to play Elizabeth, who is but 20 in the novel. Even so, she does a spectacular job playing Elizabeth. She capture's Lizzie's humor and spunk. In fact, the two may be too spunky, and Oliver's Darcy is too much of a flirt. Despite this, they have good chemistry and are engaging as an on screen couple. The plot changes were conscious, made most likely to reflect differences in the stage play. Although one change made at the end is worth complaining about, in which Lady Catherine is reformed from the ignorant and self centered snob into a funny and sweet old lady who helped her favorite nephew 'get the girl.' I think the reason so many of us love Austen is because she has a great eye for authentic characters. She never would unceremoniously sugar coat her characters that way. TCM's website states: "MGM took several liberties with Jane Austen's novel, among them moving the time period of the story forty years ahead. According to modern sources, this was done in order to allow for more ornate costumes."One can wonder if these costume choices were made in the wake of Gone With The Wind's success the year before - GWTW had similar costumes, and it's safe to assume MGM was interested in drawing in the same audiences. If you go into this film not expecting a faithful historial and literary adaptation (which, to be fair, it doesn't set out to be) it's enjoyable. Besides, we have the BBC for that!
5. The Lizzie Bennet Diaries (2012-)
No list of P&P adaptations would be complete without mentioning the Lizzie Bennet Diaries, even if it doesn't qualify as a TV or film adaptation (I mean, the internet is our future and all that). The web series, a loose modernization of Austen's novel, was created in April of 2012 and consists of twice-weekly videos that run less than 5 minutes. This series is told in v-log style by a modern day Lizzie Bennet as she narrates to the audience her challenges with family life. As a graduate student with a boatload of student debt, she shares the original Lizzie's disdain for her mother's enthusiasm about marriage and men, and, like her original counterpart, believes women should be educated and do more with their lives than simply pursue husbands. When the handsome Bing Lee moves into town with his snobby (and rich) friend Darcy, Lizzie's life turns into a circus as her family desperately tries to attract his attention. Her best friend Charlotte happens to be great with cameras and editing, making it possible to document this story as it unfolds. These short videos are filmed by Charlotte, and all the events that take place are recounted by Lizzie, Charlotte, Jane and Lydia within the realm of Lizzie's bedroom which offers a new experience compared to previous adaptations. Starting with the 25th episode, the series began moving locations and introducing new characters, such as Caroline, Bing, and Mr. Collins. Additionally, all the characters have social media accounts which they use to interact and reveal portions of their stories that are not always represented in Lizzie's blogs. I like this format - the narrative is quirky (sometimes too quirky) and original. It gives the Pride And Prejudice fandom a chance to gush over new material on the web and be interactive at the same time. You can watch the first episode here.
4. Bride And Prejudice (2004)
A Bollywood-style adaptation of P&P that's energetic and engaging. Who would have thought that swapping the Bennet family in 1790s England to a middle-class home in modern Amritsar, India would go so smoothly? In this version, Mrs Bakshi, an Indian version of our beloved Mrs. Bennet, is eager to find husbands for her four unmarried daughters. When the rich single Balraj and his friend Darcy come to visit, the Bakshis are enthusiastic at the idea of romance. This was the first English-speaking feature for the beautiful Aishwarya Rai, who plays this version's Lizzie. The movie's tone shifts between parody and serious, as if it's not sure which it prefers. Martin Henderson, who plays Darcy, comes off as a cardboard cutout of a slice of white bread, which is unfortunate, considering the cast around him is more engaging and interesting than he is. His boring good looks and funny haircut help his lifeless performance stand out amidst a gorgeous movie. Also, this version's Bingley is played by Naveen Andrews - who is a giant babe - and when you've got Naveen Andrews not only being a babe on screen, but dancing on screen? Put a fork in me, I'm absolutely done. Bollywood style films aren't for everyone, but I would still recommend checking out this adaptation if you're interested in a light hearted, musical take on Pride And Prejudice.
3. Pride And Prejudice BBC Miniseries (1980)
This studio version was recorded on videotape, which almost makes it feel like you're watching a play. Almost all of the action takes place indoors, with small stuffy sets, generally due to the fact that videotape doesn't allow a terrible amount of flexibility for scenery changes. Charlotte Bronte's commentary on the book describes this version pretty well: No open country, no fresh air, no blue hill, no bonny beck. I should hardly like to live with her ladies and gentlemen, in their elegant but confined houses.Still, this version ranks as a lot of fan's favorite adaptation. David Rintouls Darcy is the ultimate version of this character to some. He's more of an asshole than usual, and arguably, the most accurate to the book's version of Darcy. He's a snob, and he smiles no more than three times throughout the entire miniseries. But he's handsome, and he does stone cold disdain so well that its hard not to admire his version of the character. Additionally, Elizabeth Garvie is also favorite version of Lizzie for many fans and I would attribute it to her eyes - she may be one of the few who can so clearly make the viewer recognize Lizzie's 'fine eyes' described by Austen. Unfortunately, this version suffers from lazy film-making. For example, when Elizabeth reads Darcy's letter, the viewer gets a static screen-shot and a boring voice over - exciting moments made uninteresting. Although letters are difficult to adapt to screen, as is the "show, don't tell" sentiment, I think other adaptations have done this more efficiently. On the bright side, the accuracy and subtlety in this adaptation, in terms of dialogue and characters, may trump the more recent ones, and is most likely why so many favor this version. If you're a die hard book fan, I would definitely recommend it.
2. Pride And Prejudice (1995 BBC Miniseries)

Jennifer Ehle presented us with a captivating Elizabeth. Twinkly-eyed, rosy cheeked and armed with wit and charm. Ehle does a wonderful job of portraying the headstrong Lizzie. Ehle's constant smirking was a drawback for me, and some may even classify her as smug throughout portions of the series. Her chemistry with Firth's Darcy is terrific, and it's not surprising that Ehle and Firth dated during filming. Speaking of Darcy, lets talk about Colin Firth. Colin Firth's star-making turn as the brooding, dashing Mr. Darcy may be the highlight of this version for many. It also just so happens that Firth is criminally handsome - just look at that face. It should be illegal. Firth's body language is so subtle, and his eyes, like Ehle's, are so expressive, which goes extremely far when acting in a Regency time period drama. Also - that lake shirt scene at Pemberley, when Elizabeth and Darcy accidentally encounter each other - that wet shirt. Does anything else need to be said? One of the things that stuck out to me was how Alison Steadman's overacting transformed this version's Mrs Bennet into a caricature. We know how irritating and insufferable she was in the novel, but we also were able to recognize her humanity and at times sympathize with her desire to get all her daughters married. Steadman dominates her scenes in the worst way imaginable. Five and a half hours is a long while to sit through a BBC drama, but if you love the book and you haven't seen this version, you simply have to make the time. All this being said, there is one last adaptation that I dare to rank higher than this near-perfect miniseries. Don't come for my head yet - my intention isn't to anger '95 purists, but instead to offer a different perspective.A fresh, lively story about real people. And make it clear that, though its about many things, its principally about sex and its about money. Those are the driving motives of the plot.