Ranking Black Panther's Oscars Chances In Each Category
Can a superhero movie really win Best Picture?

Disney are preparing to give their biggest awards push ever to a Marvel Cinematic Universe, with the Mouse House submitting Black Panther into no fewer than 12 categories.
The studio’s For Your Consideration list reveals that it’s putting Panther in for most of the big categories, including Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor, Best Supporting Actor, Best Supporting Actress, and Best Adapted Screenplay.
On top of those, it’s also gunning for Film Editing, Original Song, Original Score, Cinematography, VFX, and Costume Design.
Black Panther has been generating awards hype ever since its debut back in February, and is aiming to become the first superhero movie to win big at the Oscars. Best Popular Film is scrapped, and Disney fancies its chances, but does the movie have what it takes?
12. Costume Design

While it may be one of the smaller categories, costume design marks one of Black Panther's best chances because, well, the design work from Ruth E. Carter is stunning. Utilising a range of different colours and materials, Carter - a two-time nominee (for Malcolm X and Amistad) - pays great respect to a number of African influences, while meshing them with the looks from Marvel Comics.
Whether it's the military uniforms of the Dora Milaje, or the green suit and lip plate of the River Tribe elder, the looks are instantly iconic, stand apart from pretty much anything else, and are quite unforgettable.
Chances Of Nomination: 9/10
Chances Of Winning: There's some big competition, with Mary, Queen of Scots, The Favourite, and Mary Poppins Returns all certain to be in contention, but this is a good chance for the Academy to recognise Black Panther. 8/10
11. Original Score

Like Carter, composer Ludwig Göransson spent a lot of time researching in Africa to delve into different musical instruments and styles from across the continent, and it works to bring something completely fresh to the Marvel Cinematic Universe, while also heightening the emotion of certain scenes.
At the same time, however, the score does take a backseat to the soundtrack - produced by Kendrick Lamar - so it might not have done enough to stand out.
Chances Of Nomination: 6/10
Chances Of Winning: Even if it gets the nomination, it'll have heavyweights like First Man and If Beale Street Could Talk ahead of it. 3/10
10. Original Song
All The Stars, which is the song submitted by Disney, was everywhere in the build-up to Black Panther's release, and for a while afterwards as well. It's not just synonymous with the movie's marketing, but as the end credits song it's the one voters will come away remembering, and it's a big number that ties into the movie's plot and, with it being so popular, it should have a good chance at getting a nod.
Chances Of Nomination: 8/10
Chances Of Winning: A Star Is Born is already the heavy favourite here, with a number of songs likely to be in the running, and the other major contender - Mary Poppins Returns - hasn't debuted yet. It'd take something special for Black Panther to beat either of those two, which are far more fitting with what this category usually goes for. 4/10.
9. Visual Effects

With Best Popular Film postponed, this is still the one category where you're guaranteed to find the ballot filled by blockbusters, and Marvel have had eight movies nominated here since the MCU started.
They should reach double figures in 2019, with Infinity War and Black Panther both likely. The latter does have some CGI issues in its third act, but the scale means you'd expect it to get a nomination nonetheless (for reference, the Star Wars prequels and The Hobbit trilogy got plenty of noms here, despite some at times wonky effects).
Chances Of Nomination: 8/10
Chances Of Winning: There are movies with better and bigger CGI here, and indeed the main competition might come from Infinity War itself, which is a more deserving winner. 5/10
8. Cinematography

Rachel Morrison made history when she was nominated for Mudbound last year, so she'll certainly be on members' radars again this time around. Some of her work in Black Panther is gorgeous, especially in capturing the intense fight sequences and, most of all, the otherworldly, dream-like ancestral plane.
That said, Cinematography is a typically stacked category, and there are a lot of other options here, from early favourites like Roma, First Man, and If Beale Street Could Talk, along with the likes of Widows and The Sisters Brothers.
Chances Of Nomination: 6/10
Chances Of Winning: It might just sneak into the five, but Morrison will once again come up short against this competition. 3/10
7. Film Editing

Ryan Coogler reunited with Creed editor Michael Shawver for Black Panther, with him teaming up with Spider-Man: Homecoming's Debbie Berman. Most of the movie is well-edited, but it's in the fight scenes where it really shines.
Like with Creed, there's a kinetic energy there that elevates them far beyond more basic punch-ups, and here it helps imbue them with as much emotion as it does intensity.
Chances Of Nomination: 7/10
Chances Of Winning: This award doesn't go hand-in-hand with Best Picture like it used to, and the past three winners - Dunkirk, Hacksaw Ridge, and Mad Max: Fury Road - indicate how well blockbusters have been playing here, and that if nominated Black Panther does have a chance. It still won't be favourite, though, when First Man, If Beale Street Could Talk, and A Star Is Born are in the mix. 5/10
6. Best Adapted Screenplay

As Logan proved, Best Adapted Screenplay is an area where a comic book movie can break through, and it's somewhere Black Panther should do well.
So much of the praise heaped on the movie comes from its heavy themes surrounding black lives, black culture, and colonialism, and all of that weight starts on the page with the screenplay from Ryan Coogler and Joe Robert Cole. With a more diverse group of members, this is one of the big awards where Panther might have a good shot, although again there's a LOT of competition.
Chances Of Nomination: 7/10
Chances Of Winning: Yeah, about that competition. In this category will presumably be BlackKklansman, First Man, A Star Is Born, and If Beale Street Could Talk, so taking the trophy is going to be another big ask, but this is a category where voters often recognise less typical Oscar fare. 6/10
5. Best Supporting Actor

Disney have submitted a number of Black Panther's supporting actors here, including Martin Freeman, Daniel Kaluuya, Winston Duke, Sterling K. Brown, Forest Whitaker, and Andy Serkis, but there's only one serious contender.
Michael B. Jordan gives a performance that not only steals the movie, but transcends the comic book genre in a similar vein to Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight or Hugh Jackman in Logan. It's complex, powerful work, that is still being discussed many months after the event, and the changing voter base opens the door further, although again there's plenty of competition.
Chances Of Nomination: 7/10
Chances Of Winning: Timothée Chalamet's turn in Beautiful Boy is the early favourite, while there's still Adam McKay's Backseat to come, which will bring a strong challenge from at least last year's winning Sam Rockwell. If voters really want to recognise Black Panther in a big category, though, then this is one of the more likely. 6/10
4. Best Supporting Actress

Another where Disney are submitting a number of names, with Lupita Nyong’o, Danai Gurira, Letitia Wright, and Angela Bassett all being entered into the race.
There's not quite as obvious a standout as with Jordan, which hinders its chances: Letitia Wright's Shuri steals every scene she's in, but it's more of a comedic role, and while the others get to flex their dramatic chops a bit more, there's not an obvious moment that would cement their Oscar nomination.
Chances Of Nomination: 3/10
Chances Of Winning: "Even if one of Black Panther's actresses gets a nomination, it should be impossible to get past probable nominees like Amy Adams (Backseat), Claire Foy (First Man), and Margot Robbie (Mary, Queen of Scots). 1/10"
3. Best Actor

Chadwick Boseman is excellent in the movie, perfectly splitting the dual role of T'Challa and Black Panther. Not only he is incredibly charismatic, but he helps form the film's emotional core and lands a number of powerful moments.
However, he's outshone by co-star Jordan, and if Hugh Jackman's work in Logan couldn't make a breakthrough here, it's hard to imagine Boseman doing so, even with the massive cultural response to the movie of which he's the face.
Chances Of Nomination: 4/10
Chances Of Winning: It's unlikely that he'd end up on the shortlist anyway, but if he did Boseman would be up against much more worthy and awards-friendly turns from Ryan Gosling, Christian Bale, Bradley Cooper, and Robert Redford. 1/10
2. Best Director

While it's still an MCU movie, Black Panther has Ryan Coogler's fingerprints all over it, and he's undeniably made a movie that fits with his own vision and sensibilities as a director.
There are some third act issues, but otherwise Coogler does a great job of balancing action with moments of humour and genuine cultural weight, and his efforts are well-liked and respected across the industry. But will it be enough to get in when the outsiders include Steve McQueen and Adam McKay?
Chances Of Nomination: 4/10
Chances Of Winning: If Coogler does sneak in, it'll be as the fifth man. Damian Chazelle and Barry Jenkins will likely go head to head again, Alfonso Cuaron is a lock for a nod and a previous winner making his first movie in five years, and Bradley Copper the buzzy newcomer. 2/10
1. Best Picture

With Best Popular Film scrapped, Black Panther's Best Picture chances are a whole lot better. It's still by no means a frontrunner, but the movie has been generating awards buzz since its debut, and it's only going to ramp up further. Of all the categories, Disney will be pushing particularly hard here and, after a win for Moonlight and a nomination for Get Out, this seems more likely this year than it would've done before.
At the same time, the movie isn't among the best of the best and does have a few issues, but it's cultural heft may cover that. If the nominations list is, say, an 8 then it might just miss out, but if it goes 9 or the full 10 it should sneak in.
Chances Of Nomination: 7/10
Chances Of Winning: If it does get a nomination, then there might be an even bigger swell to give it the award and really make a statement, especially after the controversy around Popular Film. Then again, many voters may decide a nomination is enough, and there are a lot of great contenders set to stand in its path: First Man, Roma, Beale Street, A Star Is Born, and even BlackKklansman seem to have better chances right now. 4/10
How do you feel about Black Panther's Oscars chances? Let us know down in the comments.