Ranking De Niro's Performances In Scorsese Films
One of cinema's greatest teams - but which performance is De Niro's finest?
Film making is, by its nature, a collaborative medium. It takes a lot of manpower to make a motion picture, so it’s important to surround yourself with the right people. Sometimes, creative people bounce off each other and become more than the sum of their parts - and there can be few better examples of that than the combination of director Martin Scorsese and his leading man, Robert De Niro.
From a creative perspective there’s no denying that they tick each other’s boxes, and much of the strongest work from both parties has come when they work together. As of 2019 they have combined for nine films, all of which are at the very least somewhat interesting.
Picking the best of the best in De Niro’s filmography is a tricky task indeed, and he has some incredible work with other directors to be proud of. But ultimately it’s his work with Scorsese that makes up the most iconic part of his CV. You’re talking not far shy of 50 years’ worth of films there, and there are some astonishing characters and parts to choose from. But which will end up at the top of the pile?
9. Jimmy Doyle - New York, New York
When you think Bobby De Niro, you likely imagine a gangster picture, or a gritty tale of a troubled man in the big city. Similarly, Martin Scorsese made his name in heavy dramas replete with violence and morality tales. So it must have been some surprise when the pair decided to follow up the much lauded Taxi Driver with a musical drama about a jazz saxophonist, co-starring Liza Minelli.
Minelli shines in a genre she is far more suited to, but De Niro is a bit lost here. An actor of rarely matched talents, he throws himself into the role of an out of control musician with no little confidence, but it never quite clicks.
The film itself is a bit of a muddle, part relationship drama, part pop cultural love letter. Bobby at times dials up the intensity to an inappropriate level, and the leads can seem as though they’re acting in two different films. The movie was apparently hacked down from an initial four hour run time, which could explain some of the disconnect in the performance.
His charisma is as on point as ever and the very notion of Robert De Niro as a masterful jazz man is an amusing one, but the huge risk they took when making this distinctly odd film unfortunately never quite pays off. Bobby reportedly mastered the basics of the instrument in readiness for the film - you can’t help but think there might have been better ways to use that time.
8. Sam Rothstein - Casino
The biggest flaw with Casino is that it isn’t Goodfellas. Or rather, that it is Goodfellas, only not done quite so well. Scorsese’s Las Vegas mob epic is indulgent and fun, but lacks the laser focus of his earlier work, while copping just about all of its tricks. That’s not to say the film isn’t good, because it very much is - it’s just not a Scorsese essential, and the same can be said for De Niro’s performance.
Playing Sam Rothstein, he puts in what you might call a professional turn as a behind the scenes quasi-gangster. Rothstein wasn’t a flashy individual - he did his best not to attract attention, and De Niro’s performance somewhat does likewise. He takes over from Ray Liotta on voiceover duties, and much of this is used to show the levels of research Scorsese and co-writer Nicholas Pileggi carried out.
This is a busy film, dense with period detail and full of wild moments and characters. Bobby’s buttoned down performance can get a little lost in the shuffle.
As ever, he inhabits the character fully, building Rothstein from the ground up, paying incredible attention to how he dresses, moves, holds himself. He plays the guy as though he’s only just managing to stay in control, to keep himself together, and he’s as watchable as ever. With a CV as extraordinary as De Niro’s, though, this particular role can’t quite stand up to some of the competition.
7. Frank Sheeran - The Irishman
Scorsese getting the band back together can only be a cause for celebration. De Niro’s latter day work has come under a lot of criticism, and it’s fair to say the actor has phoned it in at times, but there was no way in hell he was going to do that for Marty. As an aging killer looking back on his violent life, De Niro is as engaged as he’s been in a long time, and in his ninth collaboration with Scorsese gives us a kind of Greatest Hits performance.
Much has been made of the newfangled de-aging technology used to allow De Niro to portray his character over five decades, and there’s no doubt it’ll be off putting for some. But for fans of this duo, it comes close to being heartwarming - closing in on 50 years after their first collaboration, they’re rolling back the years in style. This is a performance of remarkable maturity and experience: De Niro perfectly captures the regret and remorse of a man starting to realise just how badly he has misspent his life.
The subtlety of the role will likely mean it will not be one of the actor’s most memorable roles, but it’s terrific to see one of the true greats of cinema show that he’s still got the goods. And the fact that he’s doing it with his old buddy makes it all the more enjoyable. The film can’t help but feel like a swan-song, and if it’s the last time De Niro and Scorsese collaborate, it’s a hell of a way to go out.
6. Max Cady - Cape Fear
When you cast Robert De Niro, you know for sure he’s going to go all in (pre-1996 or so, anyhow). He’s not quite Daniel Day Lewis level of method, but he commits wholeheartedly. And there’s no better example of that than Scorsese’s 1991 remake of Cape Fear. As if dropping to 4% body fat wasn’t enough, De Niro paid a dentist $5,000 to grind his teeth down for added menace, followed by a further $20,000 to fix them afterwards. For a fairly minor Scorsese film, that’s real dedication.
Bobby has played some pretty scary individuals, but rarely if ever descends into straight horror. He does so here, and with gusto, taking Robert Mitchum’s slick psychopath from the 1962 version and transforming Max Cady into a swamp dwelling monster. De Niro is vengeance come to life here, an unstoppable killing machine. The killer who keeps coming back is somewhat of a hoary trope, but when played with the intensity the actor brings here, it’s genuinely frightening.
Max Cady lacks the subtlety of the actor/director combo’s finest work - Cape Fear is not supposed to be a subtle film - but the performance shows what you can achieve when you’re as talented as Martin Scorsese and Robert De Niro. Neither is known for their work in the horror genre, but they manage to create about as creepy and frightening a villain as you’re likely to see.
Even after The Simpsons’ note perfect spoof, De Niro’s performance still hits all the right terrifying notes.
5. John Civello - Mean Streets
Before De Niro, there was Harvey Keitel. As the director’s proto-muse, he appeared in Scorsese’s feature debut, before going on to star in Mean Streets, where Bobby got in on the action. This is his first film with his long time collaborator, and it’s a real statement of intent. Though known for his intensity, De Niro has never since been so electric, so hungry, as he is playing Mean Streets’ Johnny Boy.
From his entrance, scored by Scorsese favourites The Rolling Stones, to his unresolved exit, De Niro is on a mission to steal every scene. It’s the kind of role Joe Pesci would play for the director down the line - he’s a loose canon, pure trouble, acting out and taking great joy in doing so. Keitel shoulders the film’s weighty Catholic themes, but De Niro gets the show role, and makes it his own.
His status as a leading man means he didn’t often take on these flashy supporting parts, but here De Niro shows just how much he can do with relatively little screen time. The very next year he would put in an Oscar winning performance as Vito Corleone, but this will have been many folks’ introduction to the actor - and what an introduction it is.
4. Jimmy Conway - Goodfellas
Actors of De Niro’s status are used to occupying the starring roles, and that’s true for most of his work with Scorsese. In Goodfellas, he plays third or even fourth fiddle, and delivers one of the most understated and underrated performances of his career. As smooth criminal Jimmy Conway, he oozes charm from the outset, making the life of a criminal look highly desirable. Sharp suits, easy money, a disregard for the rules - it’s not hard to see why the likes of Henry Hill are hypnotised.
But as the good times lead to bad, De Niro peels back the layers of this character to reveal the ice cold sociopath beneath. Without a flicker of emotion, he dispatches his so-called friends in various brutal manners just to make his life that bit easier. In a truly great piece of subtle acting, you can read his mind as he considers icing a particular irritating underling - the smile on his face when he decides to go through with it is chilling.
Joe Pesci dominates proceedings as the explosive Tommy DeVito, but his colleague’s performance is a work of tightly crafted art. As is his wont, De Niro studied the real Jimmy closely, right down to how he held a cigarette, but this is no mere imitation. Just like a gangster might, he lures you in with easy going charm, before hitting you with the obvious truth - he’s a cold-hearted killer, no more, no less.
3. Travis Bickle - Taxi Driver
For sheer iconic status, Travis Bickle has to come near the top of the list. The mohawk, the army jacket, the aviators, the sliding gun - De Niro’s turn in Taxi Driver has done a lot for Hallowe’en costumes if nothing else. As it happens, it’s also one of Bobby’s best roles, and one which he plays with burning intensity, a hefty dollop of undeniable cool, and no small amount of sadness.
Ever the grafter, De Niro genuinely drove a taxi around New York City in preparation for the role, and something about the seedy side of the Big Apple clearly got under his skin. Travis’ dialogue entries are delivered as a monologue, and in the sheer detachment with which De Niro lists the city’s ills, you’re left with no doubt that something awful is about to happen. He plays Travis as though he’s on a mission from God, one of the righteous ones. Neither Scorsese nor De Niro judge Travis - instead he is a damaging man, doing damaging things, as though compelled to do so.
The Travis people remember is the Act Three Travis - in the shades, sporting the mohican, shooting down gangsters. But the real heartbreaking majesty in De Niro’s performance comes early on, when he tries to forge connections, to live a good life. Travis is a lonely man, a Vietnam veteran and an insomniac. He wants to meet a decent woman and settle down, but he simply doesn’t know how to conduct himself. And that, sadly, leads to hatred, and ultimately cataclysmic violence.
2. Rupert Pupkin - The King Of Comedy
Depending on your opinion of the Fockers films, De Niro and laughs may not be everyone’s idea of a good match. Luckily, The King Of Comedy is no lighthearted romp, and Rupert Pupkin is one of the most disturbing creations in his oeuvre. A passion project for the actor, he had to talk Scorsese into making the film - evidently this was the right move, as the director later described it as his longtime muse’s finest performance in front of his camera.
De Niro’s unearned confidence as Pupkin allows the film to veer wildly between funny and tragic. He lives in his own head, acting out charming dialogues with his favourite celebrities. He’s played for laughs at times, but it’s never unkind. De Niro understands this kind of obsessive fantasist. He can empathise with that desperate longing for recognition and fulfilment, and turns Pupkin, who could so easily be a cartoon, a stereotype of a nutter, into a relatable figure.
Indeed as time goes on this has become one of his most influential roles - Jake Gyllenhaal in Nightcrawler and Joaquin Phoenix in Joker are two examples of actors who’ve certainly been studying their mid-period Scorsese. De Niro hasn’t returned to a similar role since -to inhabit so fully such a beaten down, broken individual may just have taken a significant toll.
1. Jake La Motta - Raging Bull
For sheer dedication alone, it could only ever be this. De Niro learned to box, and to carry himself like a prize fighter. He got into the shape of his life - and then gained 70 pounds on an (undoubtedly enjoyable) eating frenzy in western Europe. But even if he’d used body doubles and fat suits, this would still be one of the great performances in cinema. De Niro is astonishing here, so tightly wound, explosive, and ultimately tragic.
De Niro’s greatest achievement in this masterpiece is making you feel sympathy for a man with as many repugnant qualities as Jake La Motta. What’s more, he doesn’t do this by ramping up the charm, or dialling down the nastiness (a criticism you might level at Wolf Of Wall Street). He gives you La Motta warts and all, the violent, wife abusing, walking ball of rage. And yet, when you see him twenty years down the line, desperately trying to cling on to some kind of relevance, De Niro breaks your heart all the same.
Backed by a stellar cast, De Niro is nothing short of astonishing here. Without chewing scenery or relying on volume, he commands every second of this film. It’s one of the most petrifying performances outside of horror - he disappears into this frightening man, completely embodying him over two decades of rises and falls. It earned him a well deserved second Oscar, but the transformation is so complete, he might count himself lucky he came out the other side.