Ranking Seth MacFarlane's Properties From Worst To Best

So, which American idiot is best?

Seth MacFarlane Ensemble 2
Fox

Despite some stinging accusations, Seth MacFarlane boasts a bow with an enviable number of strings. He's a comedic creator, a genius writer who takes great pleasure in wrapping up dick jokes in social and political allegory, and he has the voice of a honey-drenched angel. You'll know that, because he takes every bloody opportunity to show it off he can.

If this was his monologue, he'd probably have sung by now.

As well as basically cornering the market at the adult end of the cartoon spectrum for a long time, MacFarlane cut his teeth writing for the kind of comedy shows that still enjoy longevity in spirit: Dexter's Laboratory, Johnny Bravo and Cow And Chicken. Looking back at those shows, you can see why the extreme extrapolation of them would end up with Peter Griffin and Ted and Stan Smith. And also what drew the writer to seek a medium with slightly less conventional taste boundaries.

From there he survived being cancelled multiple times (and continues to defy similar expectations with the same stubbornness as The Simpsons) and while his film career hasn't exactly flourished yet, you get the sense that he enjoys playing up to every cheeky expectation of him. How else could you possibly explain the torrent of penis jokes that meshed together to form Ted 2?

Never knowingly predictable, MacFarlane's creations guarantee laughs - it's just a matter of picking out which ones deliver the best...


7. A Million Ways To Die In The West

A million ways to die in the west Charlize Theron Seth MacFarlane.jpg
Universal Pictures

It seems the urge to reinvent the Western genre for cinema comes around on a cycle as deliberately as the need to find the next Harry Potter. There have been some successes that suggest revisionism is the way forward, but it's been a long time since anyone thought the genre could be anything other than glum and grim (a safe spectrum where grit is a remarkably successful currency).

When you look at almost everything that sought a more "mainstream" appeal in the wake of Blazin' Saddles, it's like an embarrassing roll call of misfits and monsters. Wild Wild West was an abomination, but even if it hadn't been a paint-by-numbers turkey it probably wouldn't have worked, because audiences simply aren't in the right mind-step for western frolics.

Perhaps that's why A Milion Ways To Die In The West sought to be a little more modern, blending MacFarlane's irreverent humour with an old Western spirit. Except it failed on both accounts. The comedy is puerile and oddly sterile, while there's absolutely nothing authentic about the setting (which was precisely what worked for Blazin' Saddles).

Everyone seems game enough, but this is one that sits alongside Cutthroat Island on the pile marked Expensive Failed Genre Experiment.


6. Cavalcade Of Cartoon Comedy

Cavalcade of Cartoon Comedy
Fox

Since discovering that he could get some pretty meaty laughs out of cut-aways and flashbacks, MacFarlane has made something of a name for himself as the king of non sequitors. They're part and parcel of his brand, with increasingly lavish and ludicrous sequences (like the Peter vs Chicken mechanic in Family Guy) taking more and more time in later seasons.

Cavalcade Of Cartoon Comedy is what happens when you take that idea and strip out the frame-work, leaving only the cut-aways, which don't have the pleasantly jarring contrast with the main story. What the comedy loses for that lack of "context", it attempts to replace with being more outrageous, more grotesque and more MacFarlane.

Watched on YouTube - as originally released - it makes for a funny enough experience, but consumed as an anthology, it doesn't really work, and you end up feeling like you've been somewhat short-changed. Which makes accusations that it's no more than a series of rejected Family Guy skits feel uncomfortably close to home.


5. Ted 2

Ted 2 Computer
Universal

To give Ted 2 its dues, it genuinely does have some stand-out jokes. Somewhat unfortunately, most of the ones that work best are taken wholesale out of Family Guy - or at least feel like they were - and the bits between those laughs sag quite noticeably.

It's not really that the film is bad, despite all of its faults: it's just that it doesn't really say anything new that pushes it beyond feeling like an extended Family Guy. But then perhaps that's the point?

When invited to make a sequel, MacFarlane could have followed expectations and gone with something as bland as sending Ted and John on holiday (see Paul Blart 2), or taking one element and pushing it relentlessly (as Magic Mike XXL somehow brilliantly did). Instead, he just made a second episode of the Ted franchise, which would always delight fans of the first, but which would inevitably deliver diminished returns.

Ironically for the film, it's all a little like masturbation. Do it once, and it's great fun: so much so that you might want to do it immediately again. But should you scratch that particular itch, you'll find it doesn't flow as easily, it doesn't feel quite as good and it definitely doesn't leave you as satisfied.


4. The Cleveland Show

The Cleveland Show
Fox

Looking back, you have to wonder whether MacFarlane ever really had faith in his own eventually failed spin-off. He lambasted the decision to choose Cleveland in his final Family Guy episode, as well as sticking two fingers up at the wide expectation that it should have been Quagmire.

But a Quagmire show would never have worked either. He's too much of a one dimensional character, whose comedic impact works 90% of the time when he's living up to his grotesque stereotype, and 10% when it is revealed that he actually does things other than sex. Cleveland at least had a family life and wasn't quite as tied to a single note.

And the show did genuinely have its moments when it played like a Family Guy #2: it's just that it made the somewhat cardinal sin of not quite fleshing the rest of the new universe out as well as something like Frasier did. But at least the Browns were added to the Family Guy cast as a result of the cancellation when it inevitably came.


3. Ted

Ted Movie
Universal Pictures

Ted's relationship with Family Guy is very, very obvious, which is entirely the point of the film's success. The film, spun off a genius little idea that proved both nostalgic and mythological (in that it fills in one of those nagging What Ifs), could actually have been a Family Guy episode, but there's something a little more nuanced in the writing, as if MacFarlane was putting lessons learned into practice.

As a character, Ted works because he's a very conscious amalgamation of the best three characters in Family Guy - he has Peter Griffin's lack of self-awareness (or lack of interest in it), he's as whip-smart but self-destructive as Brian, and he has the whole cute/outrageous contradiction that Stuey stole from Bart Simpson. 

All in all, you could be forgiven for thinking that a long series of jokes based on the simple question of "...but what if it was a teddy bear doing it" wouldn't work for long, but it's such a compelling idea that the film is hugely charming. There's also a surprising amount of heart in to balance the furry sex and weed smoking shtick, and the right casting blend that One Million Ways To Die In The West ignored horribly.

There will presumably be more films from Seth MacFarlane in future, but he'll probably be hard pushed to beat the immediate appeal of this one, no matter how many times he tries the same formula.


2. Family Guy

Family Guy Petarded
Fox

Pregnant with hilarious characters, genuinely very funny gags and surprisingly well written for something that flirts with the gutter so much, Family Guy has always pushed hard as Fox's best animated family sitcom. It's The Simpson's bawdy cousin, invited to the big table because of a cult appeal that quickly turned mainstream, and it remains eminently quotable.

Watching the first seasons back now, it's not exactly hard to see why the show was cancelled. Yes, it was funny and it offered an interesting counterpoint to The Simpsons (more profanity, less morality), but it wasn't the polished gem it would become, and while MacFarlane might not have been exactly delighted, the cancellations actually helped shape it.

Unlike The Simpsons, whose sag would have been series killing were it not for the decades long foundation, Family Guy has actually blossomed as it has progressed. Its later successes are buoyed by MacFarlane's commitment to pushing the envelope and the limits of good taste: he comes across as a naughty school kid flashing grins and committing sins, and it's terribly hard not to find it very endearing.

Plus, which other shows could manage to pull off the Star Wars redo with such impressive aplomb? Well, aside from Robot Chicken, maybe.


1. American Dad

American Dad Stan Crying
Fox

In a purely like-for-like, pistols at dawn-style duel, American Dad should always emerge as the victor in the battle for MacFarlane's best. 

The two are obviously very close siblings, built on the exact same genetic material and a lot of the same comic dynamics. But in its more overtly political material, and its slightly more intelligent-seeming agendas, American Dad feels more grown-up and braver, like its agenda is more subtle and less silly.

And frankly, the characters might not be as immediately quotable as their Quahog counterparts , but they're more legitimately likeable and their storylines ring far more true. The farcical approach to comedy also works beautifully, as it does for Family Guy, but there's a more extreme commitment to gallows humour facilitated not only by Stan's job, but also by his very obvious mental instability (which will always be more compelling than Peter Griffin's stupidity).

And in the battle of the most outrageous characters, Roger the alien has proved himself to have longevity and more dimensions than Stuey.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.