Razzies 2020: 10 Nominees That Make No Sense
Justice for Bruce Willis.
On the eve of the Academy Awards, the nominees were announced for the annual Golden Raspberry Awards - better know as the Razzies.
The Razzies aims to celebrate the "worst" in the previous year of film, but as anyone who's followed them in any depth knows, the half-joking awards body tends to actually vote for those movies which are simply fashionable to hate at the time.
The history of the Razzies is full of baffling and embarrassing nominations, be it giving Danny DeVito a Worst Supporting Actor nod for Batman Returns, handing Stanley Kubrick a Worst Director nomination for The Shining, or giving the legendary Ennio Morricone a Worst Original Score nod for his sublime synth work on The Thing.
As such, though the Razzies' goal is seemingly to make fun of the most pathetically awful movies of the year, the voting body's tastes don't always age well, and clearly, 2020 is sure to be no exception.
Across this year's categories, there are a number of thoroughly undeserving nominees, from genuinely good films getting slapped with bizarre nominations for the sake of publicity, to simply mediocre films that were too forgettable to actually be nomination-worthy...
10. Godzilla: King Of The Monsters - Worst Prequel, Remake, Rip-Off Or Sequel
Now, as disappointingly as Godzilla: King of the Monsters turned out, was it really worthy of a nomination for "Worst Prequel, Remake, Rip-Off Or Sequel," alongside Dark Phoenix, Hellboy, A Madea Family Funeral, and Rambo: Last Blood, all of which received significantly worse reviews than it?
King of the Monsters was too aggressively mediocre to deserve a nomination, especially with so many genuinely awful movies releasing over the past year.
Was a cheesy movie about giant monsters fighting one another really worse than, above all else, the ultra-cynical "soft reboot" that was Men in Black: International, and the deeply insulting, painfully pandering new Black Christmas?
That's not to ignore lame offerings like 47 Meters Down: Uncaged, the new Addams Family animated film, or even the flop Charlie's Angels reboot, all of which were more fitting for the fifth slot in this category.
9. Francesca Hayward (Cats) - Worst Actress
It wasn't exactly a surprise to see Cats leading this year's Razzie nominations with an impressive nine nominations, especially considering how much of a viral punching bag Tom Hooper's big-budget misfire has become.
But in typical Razzie form, voters' hatred for the movie as a whole has blinded them to its actual meritorious aspects, and instead they've simply thrown nominations at pretty much anyone involved with the production.
And so, poor Francesca Hayward ended up with a Worst Actress nomination for her performance as protagonist Victoria, despite the fact that she's easily one of the best things about the movie.
It feels like an especially mean-spirited move as this was Hayward's first ever major movie role, and was her work really worse than, say, Elisabeth Moss in The Kitchen?
8. Will Smith (Aladdin) - The Razzie Redeemer Award
The Razzie Redeemer award was introduced a few years ago and is effectively the single "nice" award the show gives out.
The idea is to honour an actor who has returned to critical acclaim after being nominated for or winning a Razzie, having previously gone to the likes of Ben Affleck, Sylvester Stallone, Mel Gibson, and Melissa McCarthy.
Though four of this year's five nominees make sense - Jennifer Lopez, Eddie Murphy, Keanu Reeves, and Adam Sandler - the nomination for Will Smith's apparently career-saving performance in Aladdin doesn't really convince.
Sure, Smith was the best thing in the film, but Aladdin is still a totally mediocre movie, so it's tough to accept that this was really a major career turnaround for the actor. After all, he did still star in the execrable Gemini Man last year.
In terms of alternatives, what about Charlize Theron becoming a Best Actress Oscar nominee this year for Bombshell after receiving a Worst Supporting Actress nomination in 2014 for A Million Ways to Die in the West?
Or better yet, Anthony Hopkins rebounding from his dual Worst Supporting Actor nominations for Transformers: The Last Knight and Collide in 2017 with a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination this year for The Two Popes?
If Smith was going to get a Razzie Redeemer nomination at all, it'd make more sense for it to be next year, given the recent critical and commercial success of Bad Boys for Life.
7. Matthew McConaughey (Serenity) - Worst Actor
This year's Worst Actor slate is full of baffling nominees, honestly: both David Harbour (Hellboy) and Sylvester Stallone (Rambo: Last Blood) were unarguably the best things about their respective films, and their performances did nothing to cause the unsatisfying end result.
But the weirdest nomination has to be for Matthew McConaughey in the admittedly infamous dud Serenity.
Now, nobody's excusing that Serenity is indeed an hilariously bad misfire of a film, but there was absolutely nothing wrong with McConaughey's performance or how he approached the material.
His performance was ultimately more forgettable than anything, but not nearly of the low-caliber necessary to actually merit a nomination in this category.
Do people really think his performance was shoddier than, say, those by Ed Skrein (Midway) or Adam Devine (Jexi) this past year?
6. Jessica Chastain (Dark Phoenix) - Worst Supporting Actress
Dark Phoenix was by no means a good movie, but the acting was for the most part pretty acceptable: even Sophie Turner gave a not-terrible performance despite her wretched previous turn in X-Men: Apocalypse.
Nominating Jessica Chastain for the Worst Supporting Actress award for her totally forgettable non-event of a performance as the villainous alien shapeshifter Vuk - don't worry, we couldn't remember her name either - is just a lazy low-blow.
Chastain's work is too innocuous and bland to be the worst of anything, especially with more compellingly roughshod possibilities such as Sasha Lane (Hellboy) and Rebecca Ferguson (Men in Black: International).
5. Joker & Dragged Across Concrete - Worst Reckless Disregard For Human Life & Public Property
The Razzies occasionally introduce a random "comedy" category that typically allows them to nominate movies which were, you know, actually good.
This year that award is for "Worst Reckless Disregard for Human Life and Public Property," and in addition to nominating actual not-good movies like The Haunting of Sharon Tate, Hellboy, and Rambo: Last Blood, Razzie voters also nominated the terrific Joker and Dragged Across Concrete.
It feels as though voters just wanted to nominate Joker for the enormous social media publicity it would generate, and then shaped a dubious awards category around it.
Dragged Across Concrete is an even weirder pick, though, both because of its low-budget nature and the fact that there's not that much carnage in it.
Michael Bay's 6 Underground is clearly a far worthier nominee than either of those films, given how much obvious human collateral damage is racked up amid the chaotic action sequences, and given how the Vera Farmiga twist in Godzilla: King of the Monsters played out, that also makes way more sense.
4. Cats - Worst Screenplay
The five films nominated for Worst Screenplay this year were The Haunting of Sharon Tate, Hellboy, A Madea Family Funeral, Rambo: Last Blood and...Cats.
While none of these films have even remotely good scripts, Cats doesn't really feel like it belongs here because, let's be honest, it barely actually has a script.
Cats largely consists of songs in which characters introduce themselves to the audience with some scattered lines of dialogue in-between.
As an adaptation of the musical, it's pretty much what you'd expect, and of all the things that made Cats an utter failure, the script was pretty far down that list.
When films like Serenity, Black Christmas, Countdown, Men in Black: International, Midway, The Hustle, and Gemini Man exist, nominating Cats here just reeks of Razzie voters having their claws out for it above all else.
3. Bruce Willis (Glass) - Worst Supporting Actor
M. Night Shyamalan's Glass may have been a crushing disappointment, but the blame can be laid squarely at the feet of Shyamalan himself rather than any of the film's cast members.
And yet, Bruce Willis ended up with a totally unearned Worst Supporting Actor Razzie nomination for reprising the role of David Dunn, despite actually giving a totally solid - if hardly revelatory - performance in the low-fi superhero flick.
Though the rest of the category pretty much makes sense - especially James Corden's nomination for Cats - it's inexplicable that Willis made the cut above Keean Johnson (Alita: Battle Angel), Ben Mellish (The Haunting of Sharon Tate), or Cary Elwes (Black Christmas), to name just a few.
This was, honestly, Willis' best film work in several years, so to nominate him for it just feels totally disingenuous and off-base.
2. Neil Marshall (Hellboy) - Worst Director
Though none of this year's Worst Director nominees ended up producing good movies, there's one among the pack that just doesn't really belong.
In addition to Fred Durst (The Fanatic), James Franco (Zeroville), Adrian Grunberg (Rambo: Last Blood), and Tom Hooper (Cats), Hellboy's Neil Marshall pointlessly made the cut.
As bad a film as Hellboy might be, the majority of the problems actually lie with Andrew Cosby's Razzie-nominated script.
Between Marshall's lower-budget genre film work (Dog Soldiers, Doomsday) and excellent helming of several pivotal Game of Thrones episodes, he's clearly an extremely talented director, and in this case, didn't have much to work with in the first place.
More to the point, it's no secret that Hellboy was put through the studio mangle during post-production, so it feels a tad unfair to blame Marshall for the end result.
Compare that to Cats, where the janky, CGI-slathered production was actually Tom Hooper's misguided idea, and so he should probably win the award outright.
1. Rambo: Last Blood - Worst Picture
And finally, we come to the Big One - Worst Picture itself.
Though it'd be fun to see the Razzies eventually switch to a wider field of nominees like the Oscars, this year's five-film slate nevertheless consists of Cats, The Fanatic, The Haunting of Sharon Tate, A Madea Family Funeral, and Rambo: Last Blood.
Except, in addition to having easily the "best" reviews of the five films - rocking a cool 27% on the Tomatometer - Rambo: Last Blood is more a bland, forgettable sequel than it is a deeply terrible movie in any way.
That the film was nominated for Worst Picture over the likes of Serenity, Black Christmas, Hellboy, Countdown, Men in Black: International, The Silence, Midway, The Hustle, Jexi and so many more is just nonsense.
Still, the Razzies have had an historic hard-on for Sylvester Stallone and his movies, with the actor-filmmaker racking up an absurd 34 nominations over the last 35 years.
With so many genuinely terrible, irredeemably bad movies to choose from, is a "whatever" Rambo sequel really the best the Razzies can do?