Robocop: 10 Object Lessons In Making A Reboot

Hollywood, take note.

Looking around the internet at the various reviews one would be forgiven for thinking that the new Robocop reboot is an unwatchable flop. Reviews are almost invariably unkind with direct, negative comparisons to Paul Verhoeven's 80's masterpiece. But this is not a remake in the strict sense, this is what they call a reboot, or reimagining. These are Hollywood terms that have become more prevalent in recent years, with many more projects in the works at this moment. So what is it about these reboots that make them so popular? Reviews are rarely positive and fans react vociferously before the film has even been made, yet takings often justify the investment. There is something at the core of our psyche that enjoys being told the same story. Look at children; they love hearing the same bed-time story or watching the same movie over and over (and over) again, look at your own collection of BluRay, DVD, or digital movies. How many times have you seen the original Robocop film? In the theatre world remakes, re-imagining's, new adaptations of old stories and straight out copies are commonplace. Shakespeare, Chekov, even Homer's tales are told and retold, themes are copied and altered, characters, or pieces of them, appear again. Why should film be any different? But there are rules. Stick too close to the original and it's just the same play with different players, stray too far and you can't justify keeping the title. Robocop 2014 absolutely nails the balance with similar themes being explored from a new angle. Let's have a look at 10 ways the team got it right.

10. Don't Stick To The Script

Robocop Original Script Movie 1 Doing a reboot as opposed to a remake means you not only have a license to redo the whole script, you have a duty to. Sure, you can have the odd line that gets kept but a scene for scene copy, even with different actors and sets, is not the aim of the game. Robocop does this perfectly by effectively throwing out the old story completely. If you're going to be compared to a classic then you have to be either better or different, the studio went with completely different. Gone are the "Can you fly Bobby" and "Just gimme my f'ing phone call" quotable lines and in their place is an arguably more mature script. Where the original explored an America destroying itself, this version looks at a new American Empire being held together by machines keeping the locals of occupied lands at bay through killer-robot induced terror. Control and subjugation from a distance, a soulless, callous dictator with the blank face of a machine. This is reflected in the face of Samuel L Jackson when a young boy is mown down by 50 caliber rounds, perhaps the most violent moment in either of the two films, and he cares only if the white, blonde reporter is alright. Paul Verhoeven's film investigated our obsession with violence, selfishness, corporate greed and the nature of humanity. This new film manages to investigate those same themes but with a completely different lens. In the original, Paul Weller's Alex Murphy had his head blown apart and his eventual recovery of memory and some personality is remarkable, but his emotional journey is not explored too deeply. In Jose Padilha's story that question of what makes us who we are is central to the plot. Alex Murphy is allowed access to his memories and emotions but is later reduced to a mere automaton. His eventual overcoming of that programing is possibly a more satisfying resolution than his nemesis being fired.

9. Cast Away

Other than the titular character, at least a core element thereof, the rest of the cast in a reboot is ripe for change. Even in the recent Star Trek reboot the personalities of the main characters are changed significantly; a more emotional Spock, a less measured and thoughtful Kirk. The rest of the crew are actually more similar to their original incarnations but then they were never painted as broadly in the first place. In our new story the key characters are either different sexes, colours or were simply not in the original. We have a male Lewis who is a long term partner of Murphy instead of having just been flung together, a female captain who is up to her neck in the conspiracy yet pretends to be Alex's friend. Gone are Bob Morton and Dick Jones', 80's stereotypes of drug crazed, power hungry young execs and morally deficient old school incumbents, in their place are yes women and marketing executives. The slightly baffled old man in the original who we are meant to like, yet gets barely flustered by a man being slaughtered in his conference room, is replaced by Raymond Sellers. Raymond is two faced, media aware, manipulative, politically motivated and guilty of causing the very crimes he wants his machines to be allowed to rid the world of. This is a more complex and in depth cast than the original with a wife and child's reactions to their semi-loss and a well-meaning doctor struggling with the moral implications of his creation. Chucking out the old cast is a brave move, but one necessary if the intention is to make a different version of the story. Robocop 2014 manages to retain the titular hero while creating an ensemble that has the feel of the original but with more human and complex characters.

8. Keep It Relevant

When you think of the original Robocop perhaps the first thing that comes to mind is the 80's. It's a film of excess, drug abuse, open criminality, violence, gun and gang proliferation and an ineffective law enforcement owned by a private corporation. These themes and plot points were of the zeitgeist and in a way still are, but with a more nuanced view. Now we know that corporations don't run the cops, the politicians do, it's just that the corporations run the politicians. Paul Verhoeven's movie was in your face, brash, bold and fun. Everything that embodies the 80's. This new film is perhaps more sedate but allows itself to explore the psychological, human elements of the story. To reboot a classic properly requires making that same story relevant to the time in which the new film is made. We live in a media savvy world where everything is packaged, processed and made fit for consumption. The original Media Break team were instantly recognisable as any 80's anchor team, the new media though is far more insidious. Pat Novak is the very essence of Fox news and other, opinion based, so-called news channels. Opinion is presented as fact and facts are twisted to fit opinion. The whole mood of a nation is manipulated and changed through well-chosen snippets of footage or information, or by cutting off arguments that don't fit with the view of the channel. This is not just in the film, this is on your TV every day. The issues of drone warfare, artificial intelligence, personal responsibility, and, most importantly, consciousness are explored in this film to varying degrees but rather than ram them down your throat they are allowed to ruminate in your mind. Some may say that they are glossed over but this is a film that asks questions, not answers them. We see Robocop initially created in a Chinese lab, presumably because US laws would have forbade such actions, but even in 2028 the suggestion is that everything is made in China. Is it not a sad indictment of how far the mighty have fallen that their own saviour can't have a Made in the USA stamp?

7. Go Your Own Way

If the first version of a film is dark and gruesome it doesn't that mean the new incarnation has to be. As with the right to rewrite the story, a film maker also has the right to alter the tone of the film. The lack of on screen violence and gore in this new version does lessen the impact of some scenes and the tone set by the shocking opening is significantly muted during the rest of the film. Yet the point is still made. To see a person brought to the point of feeling they have no way left to fight their faceless enemies than to blow themselves up on camera is powerful enough without over the top blood spatter. Some reviewers seem to have wanted to see scenes remade; where is the melting man or the frustrated robber, where is the rapist being shot in the family jewels? These scenes would have been completely out of place in a more cerebral film. Where they brought laughter in the original this is an altogether more serious exploration of living in a surveillance and information filled society. Instead the film choses to explore what it would mean to find yourself little more than a head and some lungs, the property of a corporation. The scene where the suit is taken away may be cool for younger viewers who wouldn't really understand its significance, but to an adult watching and empathizing it is a truly disturbing and thought provoking image. How would you react to knowing you would never touch your wife or child again while still being in the same room as them? Interestingly, the inclusion of the family make the character of Lewis somewhat moot which is why he plays a lesser role than Nancy Allen's excellent portrayal. Where the first film revelled in being over the top, this new film is all together more introspective and more intriguing for it.

6. Can I See Your References

We have established that making a reboot is a delicate balancing act and none more so that when to reference the original and how. Do you go heavy handed and drop lines in everywhere? Do you hand the same lines to different characters? Do you have something in the back-ground, an advert for a 6000SUX somewhere? These are difficult to get right but when done properly can bring a smile to the knowing fans while also paying homage to the original. Using Basil Poledouris' original movie music as the theme for the Novak Report was clever and definitely brought a smile to the face. Similarly the distinctive 'thump, thump' of Robo's walk and the sound of the suit moving was a joy to the ear. We got "Thank you for your cooperation" (minus the "goodnight" unfortunately), "dead or alive you're coming with me" each well placed and respectful, not just shoe-horned in for the sake of it and other subtle, and not so subtle, references throughout the film. ED-209 is present, correct and meaner looking than the original version. The suit is there initially, albeit changed later due to focus groups, something almost presciently self-referential. Robocop 2014 manages to get the balance just about right between doing its own thing and throwing a nod to fans.

5. Don't I Recognise You

Beyond a few lines here and there, something deeper needs to link a classic with its progeny. If you use a known product name you must be respectful to its legacy. Robocop 2014 is considerably different from the original and yet there are so many similarities that it feels like a new version of the same story. It explores similar themes in a modern context but in a way the core story is the same: an uncaring, greed motivated corporation wants to monitor the population with a police force in their control and decide to use a dead cop in a machine to do it. They mess with his head, try to program him and make him forget but his humanity wins through in the end and in the process he usurps his would-be masters and brings down a crime syndicate. Murphy's desire to solve his own murder is a core element of both films and in each case is as a part of a wider criminal investigation. Where the original plot was around a corrupt executive pushing his defective product upon a society that didn't need it but the military wanted it the new one is about, well, the same thing. Except different.

4. Suit Up

Robocop 2014 This point is obviously limited to reboots where the main character HAS a recognisable suit, but when they do, it has to be, you know, recognisable. Superman, Batman, Spiderman, the X-Men, all have had various on screen outings and each time the suit is redesigned the reaction is the same as the cycles of grief. One can only imagine the process producers, directors and designers must go through with artists throwing various versions on paper from the ridiculous to the overly different. Focus groups and fans will no doubt have their say but ultimate blame, and therefore responsibility, lies with the director. So how does the new Robocop suit match up to the original? Well, initially we do see the silver, breast-plated suit looking very familiar but Raymond tells us that the focus groups found it comical and wants to make it more 'tactical', the translation of which is 'black'. When it comes down to it, the suit is not a distraction and in fact looks very impressive. This is helped by sound effects, animatronics and Joel Kinnaman's performance. The helmet coming down is a fun addition and some have commented that it should have stayed down. This though would only have left enough room for Judge Dredd style chin acting, as perfected by Karl Urban in another excellent example of how to do a reboot, or the pursed lips Paul Weller was limited to in the first half of the original film. Ultimately it comes down to taste. There will be those for whom anything other than a direct copy of the original is heresy but times change and people will get over it.

3. Don't Be Afraid To Alienate The Fans

This may sound like sacrilege but when making a reboot directors and studios have to be completely unafraid of alienating the fans. Ironically, the producers seem to have gotten cold feet after the movie was completed and had to go back and do reshoots. The majority of changes were most likely unnecessary as fans will almost always have a complaint or moan about a new version of a beloved film, but the key point is that they will go see it anyway. Whether out of curiosity or just so they can complain with authority about how it wasn't as good as the original, they will still come. If a director does their best work and allows to it stand or fall on its own account then that is all they can do. It's no secret that there were several reports of post production issues with the film as a result of studio worries, but Jose Padilha has sought to play down those reports. It seems he is happy that what we see on screen is representative of his vision for the film. Reading some reviews it would seem that many have failed to grasp that vision or appreciate what he was trying to say. The key point is to make up your mind based on the film you watch, not the film you would have made yourself. Fans will always have an opinion on a franchise close to their hearts but as a huge fan of Paul Verhoeven's film I thoroughly enjoyed Jose Padilha's version. I cannot be the only one.

2. What's The Point?

Nobody should consider touching a beloved franchise unless they are sure they can do it justice and have something new to say using the voice of the original. Why would you? Why not just make your own film with your own story? Sure, there's the previously mentioned financial benefits but those can back-fire if the product doesn't meet expectations. Not the expectations of fans, the expectation of a decent film. In the modern age of instant reviews and sites dedicated to nothing more than ripping apart whatever has been put on screen an awful film no longer survives. Beyond the opening weekend would-be viewer's opinions can be coloured purely from reviews on Flixster. What makes a film stand or fall is whether it has something to say that is worth listening to. To make a reboot you have a guaranteed initial audience but if the film is terrible or pointless it will soon be exposed. This new Robocop story is certainly compelling and has a lot to say about the modern media, the illusion of free will and artificial intelligence. We saw facial recognition being used to identify and locate known criminals. In one of the slightly more pedestrian and unbelievable scenes we are expected to believe that a known criminal would turn up to the inauguration of a robot cop, but the recognition, data retrieval and subsequent arrest are far from far-fetched. When Dr Norton is asked to remove Robocop's hesitation he is being asked to negate the whole project, this was supposed to be a man in a machine. But in reality all that Sellars wanted was to change public opinion enough to repeal the act blocking his sale of robot police in the US. This is an investigation of corporate greed and the meaning of self in a time of an increasing wealth gap and a populace distanced from their own decisions and responsibility. That's a good basis for a film in anyone's book.

1. Have Some Fun

Beyond all of these thoughts of balancing old vs new, keeping fans and studios happy and trying not to upset anyone, the key part is to make a good film that people enjoy. It has to be entertaining and interesting or it simply isn't worth seeing. If a film feels too laboured or too polished it becomes soulless. Having a potential informant labelled as "Totally Stoned" may have irked some but it showed that the film makers still had a sense of humour. This film may not be the best film ever made and it's unlikely to be in the running for Oscars, but as a piece of interesting, fun, enjoyable Sci-Fi it is hard to fault. There are bad cops, good lines, a competent cast and enough story to keep the audience engaged. It's not the same as the original but retains enough of its DNA to stand proudly in the same family tree. The original Robocop will always be the best and this new film doesn't change that, but it is a much better and more thoughtful film than it is given credit for in most reviews. Will it stand the test of time? Will it stand up to future viewings as well as Paul Verhoeven's film? Only time and future viewings will tell, but one thing is for sure, it delivers an entertaining cinema experience. At the very least, go make up your own mind rather than listen to people who just don't get the concept. Thank you for your cooperation, goodnight.

Contributor
Contributor

I.T. Consultant, technophile and Doctor Who fan. I like to talk about tech, take films apart and make excuses for Doctor Who's continuity errors. No other show has the power to make me feel like a big kid.