Russell Crowe: 5 Awesome Performances & 5 That Sucked

Are you not entertained?

Russell Crowe Les Miserables Javert
Universal Pictures

Russell Crowe once (allegedly) said "I'm the greatest actor in the world and I can make even sh*t sound good." Now that's a pretty bold statement (and from a modern perspective a little laughable), although considering that quote came from 2000 you can kinda see where he was coming from - for a brief period it did look like he was going to be an untouchable, eternal giant.

Breaking out from obscurity in the late-nineties and going straight into two on-the-trot Best Picture winners, he's an actor with a proven versatility and strong name recognition that no amount of phonecall issues can dampen. Things have taken a bit of a tumble recently (I'm talking movies, rather than his outbursts), with fewer high profile releases and a greater proportion of duds stinking up his filmography, even if there's still strong reminders of his early heights.

So is he the greatest actor in the world? Was he ever? Let's find out. With him back on UK screens in Shane Black's incredibly enjoyable 70s pastiche The Nice Guys, let's take a look back over the Kiwi's career with five of his most awesome performances and five where he couldn't quite make sh*t sound good.


5 Awesome Performances:

5. Maximus - Gladiator

Gladiator Russell Crowe
Universal Pictures

Like any film that wins Best Picture, some people are very quick to tarnish Gladiator as overrated. To those people, I ask, "Are you not entertained?"

Seriously, its awesome, and that it holds up is down to Crowe. Sure, there's Ridley Scott at the top of his game and Joachim Phoenix making Joffery look like a fair and decent ruler, but it's Maximus' arc, finding spiritual retribution through Gladiator fights, that drives the whole thing.

He's never unnatural, be it as general, slave or icon, and really sells the emotive throughline alongside the action.

This was the film where he made that "greatest actor" quote, by the way. He's also reported to have said to a producer "You motherf*cker. I will kill you with my bare hands", so it sounds like a very stressful shoot.


4. Noah - Noah

Noah Russell Crowe
Paramount Pictures

Everyone dissed Noah because it was a revisionist biblical epic coming out in 2014. Who's it for? Religious types will find it blasphemous and non-religious types will find it preachy.

But, guess what? It's actually great! And while much of that is Darren Aronofsky's decision to treat it like high fantasy, Crowe is excellent as the ark builder. He's racked with the ancestral guilt of Cain and Able, but also heavily doubting his faith, with God only communicating through visions that are immensely confusing.

It's a big, epic role, seeing Crowe go through idealistic family man, action hero and greyed recluse in record time. Its not very book accurate, sure, but its the best a Russell Crowe Noah could be. He also gets to deliver the best take on the Book of Genesis you'll ever hear.


3. Jackson Healey - The Nice Guys

The Nice Guys Russell Crowe
Warner Bros. Pictures

The Nice Guys is awesome and if you went to see Angry Birds instead then it's your fault when we're doomed to a future where no original movies are made and civilisation descends into anarchy.

As I said in my written review, the best thing about this hilarious, genuine pastiche thriller is the Russell Crowe/Ryan Gosling double act. Shane Black gleefully flaunts convention by making them different to the typical 70s cop duo, so while Crowes Healy is a hard boiled heavy, he's contradictorily highly disparaging of Gosling's alcoholism and aspires to be a legitimate Private Investigator.

We get the scumbag-with-a-heart-of-gold arc, but on a less open level, something Crowe rises to. Hes affecting, hes funny, hes violent. Did you really see Angry Birds instead of this?


2. Bud White - L.A. Confidential

Russell Crowe L A Confidential
Warner Bros. Pictures

Crowe broke big with L.A. Confidential, the last great, straight neo-noir, and despite going up against industry icons like Kevin Spacey, Kim Basinger and Danny DeVito, managed to steal the show.

Bud White is the the sort of character that Healey is riffing on. Hes a powderkeg, a violent cop whose anger helps kick off the main plot and initially makes him the most unlikeable of the central cast. But hes a striking, nuanced powderkeg, with the films plot about about gangsters and corruption making way for his redemption. You can just tell hes going to be a star.


1. John Nash - A Beautiful Mind

A Beautiful Mind Russell Crowe
Universal Pictures

It probably annoyed Russell Crowe no end when A Beautiful Mind snagged Best Picture, but failed to get him Best Actor - unlike fellow greatest actor contender Tom Hanks hed not managed to do the double.

Although he shouldnt have got too upset, because his performance as Josh Nash is some of his finest, eye-opening work. I am - or rather was, now I shout about movies on the internet - a mathematician and Nash popped up a fair bit, but no amount of knowing his theory can help you know the man.

A paranoid schizophrenic, Nash here is a genuine normal guy whos unable to find true normality. In fact, A Beautiful Mind feels at points more like a thriller than a straight biopic, with shades of espionage and a heartbreaking psychological element, but Crowe grounds all this in the tragic illness of one man.


5 That Sucked:

5. Jor-El - Man Of Steel

Jor El Russell Crowe Man Of Steel
Warner Bros. Pictures

Casting Russell Crowe as Jor-El is like casting, well, Marlon Brando as Jor-El - a borderline genius move that gives a new Superman movie real gravitas.

Unfortunately, like much of Zack Snyder's reboot, Crowe's sorely mishandled, with the actor getting too much sci-fi schlock and not enough dramatic weight and thus not really leaving much of an impact.

It's rather odd that, despite having more screen-time than Brando, this actually hurts the performance. In the Reeve films Jor-El is this mystical presence, but here he's is like Clippy the Paperclip, popping up to give advice whether you want him or not.

At least he didn't come back in Batman V Superman to tell Clark about the time he killed a bunch of Kryptonian horses, so there is that.


4. Inspector Javert - Les Miserables

Javert Les Miserables Russell Crowe
Universal Pictures

Aside from acting and throwing telephones, on of Crowe's favourite pasttimes is singing - he's performed in several bands over the decades. This makes it all the more shocking that his turn of Inspector Javert in Les Mis is so unbelievably bad.

Its incredibly low hanging fruit to mock his misguided decision to join a cast alongside Hugh Jackman and Anne Hathaway, but you just can't listen to him and take it seriously. It's flat singing, but what makes it stand out is that it's such a step down from everyone else.

Because hes clearly trying so hard to hold a tune, everything else is put on the backseat. We never really get to learn Javert's motivations beyond being petty and a subplot with him undercover beggars belief. Perhaps he thought it was a parody and nobody told him.


3. Robin Longstride - Robin Hood

Robin Hood Russell Crowe
Universal Pictures

Reuniting Ridley Scott and Crowe, Robin Hood is like Gladiator, but with Nottingham swapped for Rome. Well, sort of.

Its got all the sheen of a gritty prestige action picture, but none of the charm. And just as Gladiator thrived off of Crowes arc, here its riches are stolen by the actors weakness. His accent is all over the British Isles. In fact, all of the English speaking world, with shades of Irish, Scottish, Geordie, Cornish, Australian, everything except the midlands, really.

Everything else about the role fits what Scott was going for - theres no tights and not much merriment, but what we get does fit Robin Hood. Its just not enough to save an already iffy film.

The movie was originally going to have Crowe play both the Sheriff and Robin Hood, which sounds so much cooler at first, but when you look at what he did here probably wouldnt have been much better.


2. Zack Grant - No Way Back

Russell Crowe No Way Back 1995 900x555
Columbia Pictures

Because he went from a New World nobody to self-professed greatest actor in the world so fast, many of Russell Crowes earlier roles have been forgotten. Which is a good thing for him, seeing as theyre full of massive swings-and-misses.

Fortunately for you, Im here with the preposterous No Way Back, an action cheapy that went straight to video and would be completely forgotten if it hadnt got lucky with its star.

While L.A. Confidential would get him noticed, this was Crowes first big American role, and yet he doesnt seem all that excited about it. He just meanders through the gangster-on-gangster-on-cop kidnap story, sharing no chemistry with Helen Slater (not hard given how poor she is too) and clearly hasnt quite mastered the American accent just yet. Not an early gem worth checking out.


1. Pearly Soames - A New York Winters Tale

Winter's Tale Russell Crowe
Warner Bros. Pictures

Akiva Goldsman is one of the most confusing writers in Hollywood. In 1997 he seemingly put his career on ice (sorry) with Batman & Robin, yet less than five years later was accepting an Oscar for A Beautiful Mind. Directing-wise, its a bit more clear-cut. His first film was A New York Winters Tale, a period romance set in an alternate past where spirits and demons define destinies, or something, and its just dreadful.

Having worked with Goldsman on A Beautiful Mind and Cinderella Man (another awesome performance), Russell Crowe honours a favour and stars as the villain. Urgh.

To his credit, Crowe puts on a good Irish accent and maintains it throughout (thats a big deal), but he can never get past the fact his character is a destiny-halting demon posing as a cop in 1916 New York. Its hammy, but even though he tries, its still naff. Turns out he cant make shit sound good after all.

What's your favourite Russell Crowe performance? And what's his worst? Have your say down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Film Editor (2014-2016). Loves The Usual Suspects. Hates Transformers 2. Everything else lies somewhere in the middle. Once met the Chuckle Brothers.