Saw: Every Movie's Main Game Ranked
The best and worst of Jigsaw...
Every Saw film has a central game. While there are usually a few other individual traps in the earlier scenes, most of a Saw movie's traps are connected with an overarching game testing the latest individuals who have fallen into the clutches of Jigsaw and his disciples - horror cinema's most brutal servers of karma.
And with the pleasantly surprising Saw X having arrived in cinemas, it's as good a time as any to see how all of the central games in the Saw movies stack up.
Well, it'll surprise no-one who's familiar with this series to say that these central games are, much like the films themselves, a mixed bag across the board. Some are painfully suspenseful and genuinely thought-provoking psychological games that'll grip everyone brave enough to stomach these unrelentingly brutal movies. Others are, to put it politely, considerably less successful.
Still, it's arguable that most of Jigsaw's games are at least partly successful as horror storylines go, so that's something to praise.
So, out of the nine Saw games to date (Spiral doesn't have a central game to speak of), which flopped the most? And which comes out on top? It's time to find out...
9. Saw 3D - Bobby's Game
Game: Bobby (Sean Patrick Flannery), a conman who pretended to have survived one of Jigsaw's games in order to become rich, is put through a real game. He goes through a series of traps in which he must try and save various people who helped him in his scheme before reaching the final trap, where he must re-enact the test he pretended to have survived in order to save his wife.
Everything about this game sucks - yes, that means everything. Out of all the main games in the Saw movies, this is the worst and it's not even close.
The acting, writing and visuals are awful, and all five of the traps in the game are duds. Not only are they bland as hell, but they don't make any sense at all - they're either unfairly difficult or seemingly so easy that Bobby's failure to beat them is utterly exasperating.
Speaking of which, Bobby fails to save any of the other four victims and at the end we're treated to the miserable spectacle of his wife (Gina Holden), a woman who'd done nothing wrong, being roasted alive and dying an excruciatingly painful death. This whole game feels pointless as a result and it leaves a hell of a nasty taste behind.
8. Saw V - The Fatal Five
Game: Five people who are all partly responsible for a deadly fire are put through a series of brutal tests.
On paper, this game actually sounds pretty good. Much like most of the best Saw games and traps, it's testing a group of characters who have done something truly appalling, and the final revelation that all five of them could've survived the game had they worked together was well-judged. At the very least, it shows Jigsaw and his apprentices giving everyone a chance and practicing what they preach just for once.
But once again, on paper.
The game does end well, with the last two survivors discussing their terrible mistake in quite a thought-provoking scene, and it's nice to see them both survive in a series where few characters make it out alive, but other than that? This is a truly awful storyline.
The traps are rubbish, the writing and direction are mostly risible, and worst of all, the only particularly interesting character of the five, Charles (Carlo Rota, aka Morris O'Brien from 24), dies far too early. Also, it seems pretty ludicrous that the five of them didn't work out that all five of them could've survived the game, as the second and third traps in particular were clearly survivable.
7. Saw IV - Rigg's Game
Game: Officer Daniel Rigg (Lyriq Bent) is put through a series of traps designed to help him let go of his obsession with saving everyone. Rigg is told that, if he completes his game within 90 minutes, his missing colleague Eric Matthews (Donnie Wahlberg, reprising his role from the previous two films) will be saved.
Saw IV's key game is a definite step-up from the others discussed so far, but it's still heavily flawed.
The huge, huge problem with this game is just how stupid and unfair it is. Officer Rigg is put through this grisly ordeal that ultimately costs him his life, and why was he tested? Because... he's a bit impatient and sometimes goes through doors without checking them. Seriously?!
The final scenes reveal that Rigg would've won the game and saved Detective Matthews had he arrived after the timer expired. Ere, who the hell would've ever been able to work that out? Just ridiculous.
Because this game was so unfair, and because wanting to save everyone isn't even really a negative quality at all, especially for a cop, pretty much everything about it feels largely un-earned. This game does, to its credit, have plenty of the powerfully gnarly moments we've all come to expect from Saw, but the writing deficiencies hold it back at every turn.
6. Jigsaw - The First Game
Game: In a game that is ultimately revealed to have been Jigsaw's very first large-scale one, which is taking place ten years before the film's other scenes do, five people who are (mostly) guilty of appalling crimes but were never caught are put through a series of tests in an abandoned barn.
Jigsaw's first ever game is pretty basic, with fairly simple and forgettable traps. Still, given that this is supposed to be Jigsaw's first game, that does make sense. Besides, even if this isn't the most creative of games, and even if most will guess that these events are taking place in the past very early on, it's still pretty solid overall.
The gore-effects are stomach churning, it's pretty darn suspenseful, and perhaps best of all, it is a thought-provoking look at karma, much like the best Saw games are. In stark contrast to, say, Daniel Rigg from the aforementioned Saw IV, the four characters in the game are genuinely repugnant people who've all caused at least one death. In fact, this game gets really disturbing at times, especially when the crimes of the characters are revealed.
It's certainly not deep - this is Saw, after all! - but it's a bluntly thought-provoking depiction of humanity at its very worst. Better still, we get to see these scumbags die horrific, gory deaths, which is joyous to watch.
5. Saw III - Jeff's Game
Game: Jeff (Angus Macfadyen), who's become vengeful after his son was run over, goes through a series of games designed to teach him to forgive. Unknown to him, his estranged wife Lynn (Bahar Soomekh) has also been kidnapped and is being forced to keep the seriously ill Jigsaw alive. If Jigsaw's heart monitor flatlines, the explosive collar around Lynn's neck will detonate.
This one's a mixed bag, although the pros slightly outweigh the cons. Much like with Rigg in Saw IV, Jeff didn't deserve this - he had gone through a truly horrific bereavement.
Additionally, this game is violent even for Saw, and it can be pretty grim to watch. Still, despite these flaws, it is a bluntly effective and consistently suspenseful watch that'll mostly keep viewers engaged.
It's actually the scenes with Lynn, Amanda and Jigsaw which work best. It's later revealed that Jigsaw was testing Amanda, who'd become unstable and vengeful, to see if she would show Lynn mercy; this is a test she ultimately fails. This storyline showcases the strongest writing of the film and features a cracking performance from Shawnee Smith, so this raises the game up quite a bit.
The ending to this game is bloody awful though. Jeff, apparently having learned nothing whatsoever, refuses to forgive Jigsaw and kills him, thus killing Lynn too. This makes the whole game feel pointless, and killing off Jigsaw and Amanda so early was a mistake that haunted all the subsequent Saw movies.
4. Saw X - The Scam Artists' Game
Game: John rounds up a group of con artists who pretended to cure his cancer in an abandoned chemical plant in Mexico and, alongside Amanda Young, wreaks brutal revenge on them.
Even though we're now ten films deep into this iconic franchise, the latest Saw film has the simplest Jigsaw game to date. It all takes place in just one room and the traps are pretty basic. This is a low-fi game which John simply assembled with the tools he had and without necessarily doing a huge amount of pre-planning, so this is a game that immediately feels different from all the others.
For the most part, Saw X was a very impressive entry into the series - that high, franchise-best Rotten Tomatoes score speaks for itself - and its central game is no different. A ferociously tense experience that'll have entire cinemas watching through their fingers, Saw X's game rises on the strength of its painfully suspenseful set-pieces, strong visuals, and impressive cast to deliver a cinematic anxiety attack of the best kind.
Or at least, mostly.
Unfortunately, the final stretch is disappointing, anticlimactic and gets way too silly, even for this franchise. A very bland final trap, an unnecessary kid character, and the final survivor of the game being revealed as a cartoonish villain who wouldn't look out of place in a James Bond film, do let Saw X down a bit by the end. Still, for the most part, good stuff.
3. Saw II - The Nerve Gas House
Game: Corrupt cop Eric Matthews' son has been kidnapped by Jigsaw, who tells Matthews that he just needs to talk to Jigsaw for a couple of hours and then his son will be freed. His son, meanwhile, is trapped in a house with seven ex-convicts who were framed by Matthews in the past. They are slowly being poisoned by a nerve agent and must survive a series of brutal traps to obtain the antidotes.
This one is awesome.
Of all these games, the Nerve Gas House is quite possibly the most complex and cleverly put-together, with all its riddles, clues and twists. In fact, one could easily adapt this into a real-life Saw-themed escape room.
Aside from the wickedly smart puzzle at the heart of the game, it's also full of brilliantly horrifying individual traps, and the stakes are further raised when one of the players, Xavier (Franky G), starts killing the others himself. Speaking of which, this game also deserves credit for the characterisation. There are a lot of different characters playing this game, yet they all feel clearly defined and reasonably developed, and all of the actors do a rock-solid job.
The game does feel rushed at times, and it seems like there were several other traps that the film didn't show; in retrospect, Saw II should've been half-an-hour longer. Still, the film delivers a fantastically brutal ending that compensates for the iffy pacing, and ends the game on a soaring high.
2. Saw - The Bathroom
Game: Dr. Lawrence Gordon (Cary Elwes) and Adam Stanheight (Leigh Whannell) awaken chained in a dilapilated bathroom. The test is simple: Gordon is told to kill Adam by 6 o'clock or his wife and daughter will be murdered.
All these years later, the game that started it all is still absolutely spectacular.
As a gnarly, brutal and painfully suspenseful psychological thriller that drives everyone involved right over the edge, and as a nerve-jangling showcase for Leigh Whannell's smart writing and James Wan's brilliant direction, this game is an absolute tour-de-force that is as disturbing as it is endlessly compelling.
The first Saw film is a simpler affair that's devoid of the excessive flashbacks and convoluted storytelling that plagued most of the sequels, so this game occupies almost the entirety of the film's run-time. As such, it was so important to get this central plot-line right, and it's arguably thanks to how good this central game is that the franchise's first film is still the best, despite the best efforts of movies like Saw VI and Saw X.
And of course, even the thought of that ending is enough to give one the shivers.
There are slight logic issues. Lawrence and Adam, obnoxious though both were, hardly seemed deserving of this level of brutality (they weren't criminals or anything), and the game felt unfairly rigged against Adam. That's why it's not at number one, but ignoring those minor quibbles, this game is absolutely terrific.
1. Saw VI - William's Game
Game: Corrupt health insurance executive William Easton (Peter Outerbridge), who once refused coverage for John Kramer to go abroad to try experimental treatment for his cancer, is kidnapped alongside many of his employees and put through a series of harrowing games in which he must decide which of them live and which of them die.
As Saw games go, William's Game in Saw VI might just be Jigsaw's masterpiece.
Several different factors contribute to a truly strong Saw game, including great traps, strong filmmaking, disturbing twists, thought-provoking moral ambiguity, and very importantly, morally grey characters so that, as appalling as Jigsaw's methods are, one can at least understand why he's going after those people.
Well, this game has all of that.
Saw VI is very well-directed, every single trap is an all-timer, the ending is nightmarishly twisted, it's filled with agonizing suspenseful and potent psychological horror. And as if all of those things weren't enough, the entire thing is a gloriously messed-up and unexpectedly effective attack on the US healthcare system.
The acting is hit-or-miss, but otherwise this game gets pretty much everything right. Quite frankly, it would've felt downright wrong to put anything else at the top.
As for whether or not it'll ever be topped, after the surprise success of Saw X the future of Saw is looking pretty bright, so who knows? It might happen. For now though, William's Game is the gold standard of Saw games.