Should Paul Verhoeven's Showgirls Be Remade?
Should we run the risk of remaking this record Razzie winner?Although hes not directed a film since Black Book six years ago, Paul Verhoevens name has been bouncing around the internet as a result of two of his best-known films being remade. This year we had the remake of Total Recall starring Colin Farrell, which was by all accounts deeply disappointing, and in 2014 we will be treated to a rebooted RoboCop (if treated is the right word). Assuming that it takes money, as Total Recall did, which other of Verhoevens films should the Hollywood remake machine be targeting next? Anything from Starship Troopers onwards is in far too recent memory, while his early and highly-regarded Dutch-language work isnt well-known enough for American audiences to be pulled in: there are few out there who would be hyped just from hearing the words The Fourth Man, Spetters or Soldier of Orange.
Assuming that we also exclude Flesh and Blood, on the grounds that any remake would require a humongous budget, that leaves us with two options. Basic Instinct is now 20 years old old enough for sex-mad teenage boys not to remember it but Sharon Stone is still very much in the public eye, and the failure of the recent sequel still haunts executives minds. That leaves us with an interesting question: should Hollywood take the plunge and attempt to remake Showgirls? And leading on from that is there a chance that the remake could actually be good?
Reasons For A Remake
1. The Original Isnt Any Good. At All.
Lets be perfectly honest: Showgirls is a really bad film. Whatever you think about the Razzies, Showgirls is the low point of Verhoevens career even Hollow Man is better. Its the one time that absolutely nothing about his approach worked for him: the nudity was gratuitous, the violence uncalled for, the dialogue was risible, and the prominent female characters were horribly written and badly acted. The film has a cult following because of how shockingly bad it is, with fans celebrating with vivid irony the awfulness of lines like different places! and the infamous everybody got AIDS and s**t. Most of the ire thats generated when it comes to remakes comes from the fact that the originals were pretty good to start with. There was no need to remake Total Recall, just as theres no reason to remake RoboCop. But when youre starting with something this bad, something thats a car crash on every level, its almost impossible for a remake to be objectively worse, and so theres no harm in having a bash.2. There Is Potential In The Story
The real tragedy of Showgirls was that the story has a certain amount of potential; it can be argued that it was just told in a really poor way. Joe Eszterhas script is one of his lazier efforts, but there is potential for someone to come along and give the character of Nomi some conviction. It would be especially interesting to see how a younger, female writer (say, for instance, Diablo Cody) would approach a character who goes from selling her body as a hooker to selling the prospect or image of her body as a striptease artist. The story could also tie in with debates about the promiscuity of women as a possible feminist statement, i.e. women viewing their participation in said professions as a form of empowerment. And if the story was to be updated from the 1990s to the present day, then a pop culture-literate writer like Cody could do wonders for the dialogue. Click "next" below to read the reasons why Hollywood should just leave the well alone...
Reasons for Leaving Well Alone
1. The Fans Backlash Could Hurt The Box Office
In an age where films get leaked online easily and potentially everyone is a reviewer, it doesnt take much to damage a films reputation and thereby hamper its potential box office takings. The example thats often cited is that of Batman and Robin; after a strong opening weekend, its second-week takings dropped dramatically as a result of websites like Aint It Cool News publishing copious bad reviews directed at the films target audience. It can often be hard to rationalise cult status, or the behaviour of a films fans, but either force should not be underestimated. Even if the number of people who like Showgirls is relatively small, they are more than capable of mobilising support for their cause, using the remake as a reason (or excuse) for casual cinema fans. Not all publicity is good publicity, as the makers of John Carter found to their cost, and any remake will struggle to keep the fans happy.2. It Would Have To Be An R-rated Film And Thats Pointless
If Showgirls had any worth whatsoever, it was conveyed by how just nasty it was. Verhoeven has recently defended the film, saying that audiences reacted so badly to it because they couldnt deal with its completely misanthropic, mean-spirited worldview. Regardless of whether you buy that claim (Im kind of on the fence), Showgirls deserved its NC-17 rating at a time when distributors were still willing to view that rating as a grown-up category, much like the 18 certificate in Britain. Since Showgirls changed peoples perceptions of the NC-17, the majority of films which have come near it in terms of explicitness have been trimmed for R ratings. But while giving the remake an NC-17 would be box office poison, toning things down for an R would defeat the whole purpose. Making an R version of Showgirls would have the effect of at least partially sanitising or taming the finished product, when the whole point of the original was to depict Las Vegas in the most graphic way possible. If you want an idea of how compromised an R-rated Showgirls would look, watch Burlesque, and then ask yourself: can we really afford another one of those?