Spider-Man: Homecoming - Every Character Ranked Worst To Best

How does the new Spidey cast hold up?

Spider-Man Homecoming Characters
Marvel Studios

Spider-Man: Homecoming has a remarkably big cast, not only in terms of numbers but also in respect of their talents. Despite having to balance the massive profiles of Robert Downey Jr and Michael Keaton with a hugely gifted young cast (including the excellent Tom Holland), the film somehow finds space for names as recognisable as Jennifer Connelly, Hannibal Buress, Tyne Daly and Michael Mando.

That some of those names - and Bokeem Woodbine and Martin Starr - are given little more than a few lines says everything you need to know about Marvel's pulling power and how much they invested in making this movie work.

Obviously with casts this big there's an element of balance that comes into play, and some characters are unfortunately pushed to the side-lines. In some cases, brevity doesn't limit their impact too much, but some could probably have done with more focus. And of course, with new versions of old and established characters introduced, it's interesting to see how well they delivered.

So who are the best and worst characters in Marvel's already beloved Spidey reboot?


19. Anne Marie Hoag

Tyne Daly SpiderMan Homecoming
Marvel Comics

The prologue of Homecoming is all well and good for establishing why the Vulture has such a problem with Tony Stark (though there's no way he'd have been out of pocket after he lost the scrap contract, because government contracts like that come with cancellation assurances), but it didn't do much to establish Tyne Daly's Anne Marie Hoag.

She's really no more than a narrative device introduced to advance that story-line, and then she - and her entire operation - pretty much disappear completely. It's hard to say anything bad about her, but it's also very hard to say too much positive either. At least she looks the part, though.

Presumably, she'll come into her own in the spin-off TV show - assuming she's even going to star in it. As it is, she wasn't really a big enough presence here to leave much of an impact. And Tyne Daly deserves a lot more screen-time.


18. Jackson Brice/Shocker

Logan Marshall Green Spider Man Homecoming
Marvel Studios

After months of speculation relating to who Logan Marshall-Green was playing in Homecoming, he was confirmed finally as Jackson Brice - a cowboy gimmicked bad guy from the comics who was repurposed to take on the Shocker mantle first (as he did in the 2008 animated Spectacular Spider-Man series).

He exists pretty much solely to be a wildcard on Vulture's team, and to be punished to show that he's a zero tolerance leader (and won't stand for dangerous rogues), and for that reason, he's almost provocatively unlikeable. In that respect, it's a successful performance, but it's not really possible to get excited about him.

His death is admittedly hilarious - after initially looking like cold, calculated malice on Vulture's behalf - but he doesn't really deserve to be in the film. All he does is pull focus away from Bokeem Woodbine's alternate Shocker, and that's not god for him in the wrong run.


17. Pepper Potts

Pepper Potts Gwyneth Paltrow
Marvel Studios

It was a great surprise to have Gwyneth Paltrow's Pepper Potts back, even for little more than a glorified cameo - especially as she was basically counted as MIA in the wake of Civil War's revelation that she and Tony had broken up.

That being said, she doesn't really get much to do here, other than cracking a couple of jokes with Happy and Tony (and being part of the joke making light of their tumultuous relationship) and helping pay-off the gag that Peter doesn't believe there's really an Avengers press conference.

Presumably this means Paltrow will return for Infinity War, and the fact that she and Tony are back together suggests he's on the road to dealing with some of his personal demons, which might mean we'll see less of him wringing his hands and mooning about when Thano's big show kicks off.


16. The Tinkerer

Spider-Man Homecoming Tinkerer
Marvel Studios

Michael Chernus is a great comic actor, and The Tinkerer is a great supporting character to introduce to Homecoming on paper. He's a genius who relies on his brain (and his incredible knack for inventing complex gadgets out of the most useless seeming scrap), and who does get a chance to show off that skill a little in the film, but he's mostly just there as a support to Adrian Toomes.

In a packed cast of villains, he takes a pretty low-key role, and while he's clearly useful to the story, it's pretty hard to remember too much of what he actually does specifically, and that's probably not great news for him.

Hopefully, the fact that he's still at large might mean that we'll see more of him in future Spidey movies, because there's definitely more to develop. Let's hope he'll be kept on as a bridge to other villains (especially as we know he was responsible for building Scorpion's techy tail too).


15. Herman Schultz/Shocker

Bokeem Woodbine Shocker
Marvel Studios

Mercifully, Jon Watts and Marvel decided against introducing a Shocker who looked close to the original character's look from the comics. That would probably have been a little too silly, and would probably have robbed the characters of their grounded humanity (they're working class men who feel failed by corporate America, and it's actually crucial to feel a little sympathy for them).

Unfortunately, Bokeem Woodbine's Shocker is let down somewhat by the fact that he has to share too much screen-time with Logan Marshall-Green's version, which robs him of the precious space to build menace or mythology. The result is a surprisingly toothless graduated henchman, who ends up being beaten up way too many times to really matter.

And while Woodbine would be great as a full-time villain, leaving him to play with narrative scraps serves nobody.


14. Mac Gargan

Michael Mando Scorpion
Marvel Studios

Initially, it looked like Michael Mando's Mac Gargan was going to be killed off comically quickly without ever really impacting the new Spider-verse when he ate a car head on during the Staten Island Ferry disaster sequence. Had that been the case, and Watts had used an important villain's name - and a hugely talented actor - for a cheap fan-baiting moment, it would have been terrible, but it turns out it was all just a set-up.

When Mando's character name was withheld all the way through production, it seemed inevitably he would be playing someone recognisable and important, and the revelation that he's going to return as a vengeful Scorpion for the Homecoming sequel is great.

For now, all we really got to admire was Mando's snarling menace at Toomes in prison (and his bad-ass facial scar and painfully pinned arm), but there's lots of promise for the future there.


13. Mr Harrington

Mr Harrington Spider-Man Homecoming Martin Starr
TBS

Martin Starr's inclusion on the Homecoming cast looked like little more than stunt-casting as a nod to writer John Daly's time working on Freaks And Geeks, but his hilarious, almost fatalistic academic Decathlon coach Mr Harrington was a great little side character.

He didn't really add a great deal to the plot in real terms, but Starr's particular blend of awkward, geeky comedy and a defeated teacher vibe (perfectly crowned by the mysterious revelation that he may have overseen the death of a child on a school trip at some point) is a nice touch.

It's the kind of small, valuable performance that helps feel worlds like this feel truly lived in, and the idea of him returning for a sequel is wholly welcome, which is all you can really ask of him.


12. "Karen"

Spider-Man Homecoming
Marvel Studios

Once Peter is able to remove the Training Wheels protocol from his Stark-empowered Spidey suit, we're introduced to his "suit lady", the voice of his unheralded in-built AI who fills in some exposition by revealing the extent of what his new suit can do.

She's played by Jennifer Connelly, who brings warmth and an almost flirtatious spirit to the character, who becomes increasingly invested in Peter's teenage fascination with Liz. In that dynamic, it's almost possible to recognise the same Pinocchio-like fetishism for emotion that sees EVE learning about love from Wall-E, and it's hard not to find it all adorable.

It's a great touch to have Connelly involved as Spider-Man's AI when her real-life husband played Iron Man's original AI, JARVIS, but her playful performance is good in itself too.


11. Aaron Davis

Spider-Man Homecoming Donald Glover
Marvel Studios

Like the mystery around Michael Mando's role, the fact that Donald Glover had been cast on Homecoming without a character name was one of the more intriguing threads ahead of release. Ultimately, it turned out he's another recognisable name from the comics - the Ultimate Spider-verse's Aaron Davis, otherwise known as criminal The Prowler.

Though he was suggested to be playing an out-and-out villain, Davis is pretty much an anti-hero further towards the centre of the morality spectrum than Adrian Toomes and his goons. Sure, he's a thief, but in Glover's hands he's cool enough and charming enough to make that not care. And if the Prowler's traditional story arc is anything to go by, he'll turn good in the end anyway (as hinted at by his willingness to help Peter).

Glover is a cool customer obviously, and seeing him in here - and hinting at Miles Morales' existence - is a great little touch, even if he's on screen for precious little time. The banter he throws at Spidey when he's trying to intimidate him is definitely one of the script's high points.


10. Aunt May

SpiderMan Homecoming Aunt May
Marvel Studios

For all the outrage at the very idea of a young, sexually active Aunt May coming to the MCU in the shape of Marisa Tomei, she's absolutely the right fit for this version of Peter Parker. And her age is entirely fitting her relationship with him.

The best thing about this Aunt May is that she doesn't require the sort of emotional protection Peter has to give her in the comics, and she's never really played as a victim (even though Peter hints at her going through hell recently). At no point do you believe she will keel over and die if she finds out he's Spider-Man, and her relationship with him feels a lot more authentic than if she were played by an older actor.

She's also an effective anchor for Peter to the real world, and it's her who ultimately picks up the pieces when Tony takes his suit away, reminding him of what he really is and where his heart should be. And that dynamic is a perfect stand-in for the whole "with great power..." speech that would usually do that.

Plus, that final "what the fu-" moment is just delightful.


9. Flash Thompson

Spider-Man Homecoming Flash Thompson Tony Revolori
Marvel Studios

Though there will no doubt be some complaints about the decision to turn hulking jock bully Flash Thompson into a far more dorky, slightly bumbling bully played by Tony Revolori, the change serves Thompson, and the film well.

The jock archetype wouldn't have fit in Peter Parker's school of excellence, and it's far smarter to take the framework of the original character - he's still rich, he still loves Spider-Man and he still bullies Peter - but to transform him into something that better suits his new context. Instead of hating Peter because he's a dork, he hates him because he's not as smart and is threatened by that.

And Revolori's performance is still layered enough that you don't really hate him as much as pity him. He's pathetic - committed to upholding a personal image that is entirely fake and just as much hiding who he really is as Peter Parker and Adrian Toomes.


8. Tony Stark

Spider Man Homecoming Tony Stark
Marvel Studios

As soon as it was confirmed that Robert Downey Jr was coming in to Homecoming, it was assumed that Marvel would be using him as a "big money" crutch to try and recapture some of the Iron Man gold effect from all of his previous MCU movies.

But in reality, Tony Stark really isn't in Homecoming very much. He's there enough to offer Peter the Hollywood promise of what he wants to be (an Avenger) and to stand in for the berating side of Uncle Ben (his "if you're nothing without the suit, you shouldn't have it" speech is as close to "with great power..." here), but his appearances are surprisingly limited.

Still, you get the same old Downey Jr sparkle and he's irresistibly watchable, but he loses points somewhat for completely changing his thinking around Spider-Man being a viable Avenger so quickly. It's not really earned, and it comes across a little like it's done solely for a gag pay-off (and the reveal of that admittedly gorgeous Spidey Avengers suit).


7. Coach Wilson

The Mindy Project Hannibal Buress
Hulu

Yes, he may not be on screen for more than a few minutes, but Hannibal Buress' Coach Wilson - who is one of only a couple of characters seemingly not taken from the comics - is an incredibly funny addition to the cast and is gifted the film's best line.

When he adds a stinger to the first Captain America PSA video in Peter's school suggesting that he's "pretty sure this guy's a war criminal now" before shrugging off the school still using his videos, it's just the most perfect moment. Along with Mr Harrington's fatalism, his complete lack of f*cks given will make him the spirit animal of pretty much every disaffected high school teacher watching.

And it helps that Buress would pretty much be hysterical reading the phonebook, of course.


6. Liz Toomes

Spider-Man Homecoming Liz
Marvel Studios

Liz Toomes - based, of course on Liz Allan from the comics - is the closest thing in the film to an embodiment of Jon Watts' and Kevin Feige's desire to channel that intoxicating John Hughes spirit. She's the archetypal object of unrequited teenage love - or so it seems initially - but the film stops short of objectifying her too much.

She's Peter's intellectual equal and she's independent enough to ultimately reject Peter when he abandons her at the Homecoming dance, so she's no simple wall-flower, even if it would have been nice to have her do a little more.

Crucially though, the fact that she's left somewhat removed from Peter serves the twist that she's Adrian Toomes' daughter - a twist that's almost enough to knock the wind out of you - and that's very key to that excellent sequence that sees the truth dawn on him on their drive to the dance. It's a shame we won't get to see more of her, but her part in that twist is a good compromise.


5. Happy Hogan

Spider Man Homecoming Happy hogan
Marvel Studios

After he was almost killed in Iron Man 3, you could probably have expected Happy Hogan to be retired from being Tony Stark's not-very-good bodyguard, but he's important enough as the go-between for Peter and Tony to stretch that logic to fit.

Hogan is an archetype - of the downtrodden, put-upon side-kick - and it's interesting to see the difference in Tony's cool, almost aloof demeanour (the body of the swan) and his furious, almost neurotic attempts to keep everything afloat (the frantically kicking legs).

And while he's trusted with more to do, he's still the same hapless, bumbling oaf - entirely loveable with it, of course - and it's almost a shame he's not given more screen-time to bounce off Peter. Their clash of prickliness and youthful enthusiasm is very rewarding, after all.


4. Michelle

Spider Man Homecoming Zendaya
Marvel Studios

Even with the benefit of hindsight revealing that everyone was actually right about Zendaya's Michelle being MJ, the reveal at the end of the film was still a great little moment. And if you think that it matters that she's completely unrecognisable from the "traditional" iterations we've seen before of Peter's most enduring love, you've got issues.

Zendaya's sardonic, whip-smart nihilist is a breath of fresh air - precisely because of her disaffection towards Peter (and all of high-school life) and the buried but heart-warming message that outsiders can find a community that brings them out of themselves (if they want). In short, she's great and it's even better that we'll see more of her.

There's still some debate about whether she's actually MJ, but the fact that the reveal was framed as a big twist (and that lingering look suggesting she like likes Peter) suggests that cynicism is entirely wrong-headed. She's MJ, whether she's a new interpretation or not.


3. Ned

Spider Man Homecoming Spidey Skyline
Marvel Studios

He might be based more closely on Ganke Lee - Miles Morales' hyperactive friend from the Ultimate universe - but Jacob Batalon's Ned is still the best friend any Peter Parker has had in Spider-Man movies.

His fanboy enthusiasm for Peter's secret life as Spider-Man is entirely adorable, and the decision to have him question his friend on everything from his origin to his power-set is a genius way of dealing with necessary exposition without bogging the film down too much.

There was probably some temptation to make him slightly bumbling, but he's another high-functioning genius (able to crack the probably-too-lax Training Wheels protocol on the Spider-suit pretty effortlessly) who loses none of his functional value in the name of comedy. And he's still extremely funny - particularly when he tries to cover up offering Spider-Man support from the school computer lab by pretending he was "looking at porn".


2. Adrian Toomes/Vulture

SpiderMan Homecoming Michael Keaton
Marvel Studios

It was always a smart move to hire Michael Keaton as the Homecoming villain as he enjoys something of a career revival (not that he ever stopped being great), and Marvel's persistence in hiring him pays off in an excellent performance.

His Vulture is a full spectrum villain, taking in old school monster movie framing when he's in his suit and a sympathetic working man motivation that makes simply killing him off more difficult than it might have initially seemed. He's charming - and almost cult-like - in a way that perfectly suits a generation that voted for Donald Trump to take the country back for "normal" people, and he's still completely captivating as a normal father looking out for his family.

And crucially none of that complexity gets in the way of his menace or the threat he brings, and his switch from doting father to genuinely terrifying monster on the way to the Homecoming dance is the crowning glory of that performance. It's so assured, in fact, that Keaton feels like he's having a lot of fun, which is almost the opposite of his usual, idiosyncratic acting identity.


1. Peter Parker/Spider-Man

Spider Man Homecoming Peter Parker
Marvel Studios

Even though he wasn't involved in Civil War as much as some fans might have wanted, Tom Holland made a pretty firm claim to being the best Spider-Man ever seen on the big screen. If there was any doubt, Homecoming absolutely confirms that to be the case.

He is cocky and charming enough to balance perfectly, and while he skirts very close to being annoying (partly through his obnoxious enthusiasm for everything and partly because he makes frankly terrible decisions), he's always intoxicatingly likeable.

His Peter Parker isn't as awkward as Tobey Maguire's (but that is the point, as this film version is based on the Ultimate iteration) and isn't as cloyingly try-hard as Andrew Garfield's, and there's a good case for him being the best on that front too.

The best testament to his performance is that it already feels like a massive shame that he's not going to be involved in Infinity War very much.

What did you think of Spider-Man: Homecoming? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.