Spider-Man: Into The Spider-Verse - Every Version Of Spidey, Ranked

There are eight Spideys in total (one for each leg, apparently). But who swings to the very top?

Spider-Man Into The Spider-Verse
Sony

Who would’ve thought that in the year Avengers, Ant-Man, Black Panther, Venom and Aquaman hit the big screen, arguably the best comic book movie would come from the studio behind The Emoji Movie?

That is precisely what happened though, as Spider-Man: Into The Spider-Verse swings into cinemas to end 2018 on a high. There’s an exceptional voice cast (Shameik Moore, Nicolas Cage, Hailee Steinfeld, Mahershala Ali and many, many more), but that’s par for the course in big-budget animation these days. You can really tell which movies the stars are phoning it in on, and Spider-Verse is definitely not one of those.

The whole thing is an explosion of colour and craft. It feels like a real labour of love for everyone involved. The yellow boxes displaying Miles’ thoughts and the on-screen onomatopoeia really draw you into the world of a comic book too.

Undoubtedly though, the biggest selling point is just how many Spideys they manage to cram in there. A hell of a lot have donned the moniker over the years, but the movie makes sure to pick a great blend. We see some beloved classics, some underappreciated gems and some rising stars. But which one is the ultimate?

8. Spider-Man 2099

Spider Man 2099
Marvel Comics

He’s only in the post-credits scene, so he was never realistically going to be anywhere else but dead last. Oscar Isaac isn’t even credited as Spider-Man 2099, or alter-ego Miguel O’Hara. Instead, he’s simply ‘Interesting Person #1’. However, from the suit and the context, it’s clear who he is.

Post-credits scenes are a major part of comic book movie these days. Some, like the one in Doctor Strange, are clear sequel bait, while others can just feel like a waste of time. Looking at you, Spider-Man: Homecoming. However, in Avengers: Infinity War and Ant-Man & The Wasp, we’ve had two stellar ones this year. And an ant playing drums, which was cool, but kind of pointless.

With Spider-Man 2099 though, not only do we get an interesting set up for a potential sequel, we get one of the funniest post-credits scenes there’s been to date. In keeping with the humour of the entire movie, Spider-Man 2099 finds himself in 1967, where he meets the classic cartoon counterpart. Into The Spider-Verse then riffs on the famous meme as we see both Spideys get into an argument about how it’s rude to point. Brilliant.


7. Spider-Man Noir

Spider Verse Spider-Man Noir
Sony

Once you get the post-credits cameo out of the way, it’s harsh that someone has to come bottom. Each of the Spideys, even the ones given smaller roles like Spider-Man Noir, bring something to the party.

No doubt each were chosen in part because of their unique animation style, and Spider-Man Noir certainly delivers there. The black and white flashes look cool against the colour splattered world the rest of the movie plays in, and it’s used for gags effectively with the Rubix cube.

That said, his fighting style does struggle to compete with Spider-Ham’s and SP//dr’s when things get chaotic. His dialogue is knuckle popping quick, but he definitely feels the most out of place in this dimension and so it sometimes gets a little lost.

The fact he’s not a whimsical character in the way of Peni and Ham is to his credit, as the movie needs that more grounded persona. However, when comparing it leaves him falling short. Despite the great work Nicolas Cage does voicing him, he just feels a bit too one-note, and probably the least likely to get a spin-off.


6. Blond Peter Parker

Peter Parker Grave Into The Spider-Verse
Sony

Chris Pine’s picture perfect Peter Parker has some great quips, but he’s just not in it enough to warrant putting him any higher. Plus, while he’s great and all, the story needed the sadder, sweatpants wearing Spidey to take it to the next level.

The shift to a blond hair, blue eyed Spider-Man was startling to seasoned readers of the web slinger, but the counter balance with the 616 Peter Parker means it all works out in the end.

In the initial battle with Kingpin, we see that patented level of Spidey wit we’ve come to expect from him. Because the purpose of the scene is really centred around Miles though, we don’t get anywhere near as much from him as we might have otherwise.

That’s not a criticism; the film needed to tell the story this way and making Miles the star was great move. But obviously, it hurts Blondie’s ranking a little.

In a way, this Spider-Man is the perfect Spidey. But in this story, perfect just doesn’t cut it. Nips in ahead of Spider-Man Noir only on the basis of how much his words drive Miles forward in the opening couple of acts.


5. Spider-Ham

Spider Verse Spider Ham
Sony

If Nicolas Cage’s casting as Spider-Noir has you nodding your head in agreement, John Mulaney as silly little Spider-Ham might even cause you to break out into a little smile too as you stroke your chin and think, ‘Good job, Sony’.

Because just like Cage, Mulaney is absolutely perfect, fully committing to his porsine personality. He already has animation experience from Big Mouth, and it shows here. His lines are used sparingly, sprinkled in between the more major conversations Gwen, Miles and Peter have. Every one of them is gold. It was hard to imagine how he’d fit in the movie when it was announced; now it’s difficult to imagine it without him.

He brings with him a sense of whimsy, and while the use of comic books to retell the back story is cool, it’s nice to see Spider-Ham change things up. The fact they managed to include the fact he was bitten by a radioactive pig in the film while still keeping it flowing is a huge credit to them.

As you might expect, he brings a lovely warmth to every scene, and a Looney Tunes-esque comedy to his action. The cartoon mallet in particular is wonderful.


4. Peni Parker

Spider-Verse Peni Parker
Sony

Peni Parker and her robotic assistant SP//dr have arguably the best action sequences of anyone in the movie. She certainly benefits the most from the animators going ‘all in’ on the comic book feel, with her climactic battle against Scorpion probably the best set piece Into The Spider-Verse dished up.

The Japanimation style looks brilliant and is bubbling with quirkiness. You get the sense the team thought long and hard about which of the more minor Spideys would give the best visuals. All three choices knock it out of the park.

She’s not without her flaws, however. Arriving at the same time as Spider-Noir and Spider-Ham, she too suffers from a lack of real input in the story. All three of them are depicted brilliantly, but if you take them out... what really changes?

That said, they do try and inject some emotions into her story as part of her relationship with SP//dr, but there’s not enough time dedicated to it. As a result, none of the emotion feels particularly earned. Still, with Gwen getting a girl power spin off with Silk and Spider-Woman, Peni might not be done just yet.


3. Spider-Woman

Spider Verse Spider Gwen
Sony

Yes, I know she’s Spider-Gwen but she refers to herself as Spider-Woman in universe so that’s what we’re going with. Maybe that will change if she ever meets the ‘real’ Spider-Woman, but for now... she’s Spider-Woman.

Hailee Steinfeld has been quietly building an impressive career for herself since her Oscar nomination for True Grit in 2011. She’s had a hit single (Starving), and starred in Pitch Perfect and Ender’s Game, as well as the upcoming Transformers spinoff, Bumblebee. And she’s still only 22. That Oscar nom? It came when she was just 13 years old.

All of those considerable chops are on display as Gwen Stacy. She has a confidence that meshes well with the other two ‘main’ Spideys, especially since her humour is much drier. As with everyone else, her animation is slick and enticing throughout too.

Her backstory and closed off harshness make her well rounded, and you feel she’s a prime candidate for the inevitable sequel. Sony obviously agreed, as a spin-off has been greenlit. The only thing that keeps her in third is the lack of a major arc; everything else from her is pretty much note perfect.


2. Peter B. Parker

Spider-Man Spider Verse
Sony

If Chris Pine was a great pick for the carved out of wood, blond Peter Parker, Jake Johnson was born for the role of the slightly doughy, down and out loser that crosses into Miles’ dimension. That’s not to do Johnson a disservice; he’s a great comedic actor. But this Spidey is basically if Nick from New Girl got bitten by a radioactive spider.

After seeing Maguire, Garfield and Holland tackle the role in the last 20 years or so, this Peter Parker needed to be different. If it felt like we’d seen him before, he’d have gotten lost in the eccentric clutter Into The Spider-Verse wrought. Give him a downtrodden vibe and slap some sweatpants on him though, and we get a great take on a classic character.

In such a large cast, it’s Peter and Miles who get most of the focus, with Gwen featuring sporadically too. That means as well as the laughs, he needs to be able to carry the story. Though his parting line is played a little too straight and comes off a bit schmaltzy, all in all there’s credible emotion between himself and Miles, allowing the audience to connect with them.


1. Miles Morales

Spider-Man Into the Spider-Verse Miles Morales
Sony

Shameik Moore completely steals the show in Into The Spider-Verse. They’ve peeled Miles Morales out of the comic books and pasted him directly onto the screen. Along with Mahershala Ali as Uncle Aaron and Brian Tyree Henry as his father, there’s more than enough here for this to be a solo movie. If he gets one of this quality again, selling Spidey back to Marvel in exchange for the universe rights will seem like a shrewd move on Sony’s behalf.

Miles is positively dripping with cool, although they nail that paper-thin confidence of the teenage years. The fact he’s able to learn on the job rather than need a training montage helps the movie’s pacing a great deal too. Times when he talks about his shoes being undone as a design choice really make him feel like he exists outside of just the movie. As superhero leads go, this is as well rounded as they tend to get in their first outing.

He’s endearing, charming, funny and above all else relatable. The action sequences are great, but what solidifies Miles at the top his how much he embodies the movie’s central theme. Sometimes, you have to take a leap of faith.

Who do you think was Spider-Verse's best Spidey? Let us know down in the comments.


Contributor

Self appointed queen of the SJWs. Find me on Twitter @FiveTacey (The 5 looks like an S. Do you get it? Do you get my joke about the 5?)