Star Trek: First Contact - 5 Things That Worked And 5 That Didn't

Borg Queen First Contact was supposed to herald a new series of films that would keep the Star Trek franchise fat and happy after the baton was passed from the original crew in the unfortunately obligatory Generations, and by most measures it was a glorious success. Sadly of course, that success was largely voided by the next two TNG films, the TV show quality Insurrection and the abominable Nemesis. While the original crew has now been recast and have been a (debatable) success in their own right in J.J. Abram's films, it is unlikely that TNG will ever get the same vindication on the silver screen. So, let us take a look back at what worked and what didn't in what would and should be TNG's finest film hour. Click next to read the 5 things that worked in Star Trek: First Contact, and the five that definitely didn't...

5 Things That Worked

5. The Borg

borga What started off as a terrifying alien force on TNG culminating in the epic Best of Both Worlds was, over the course of the series, watered down to the point that by their final appearance they became nothing more than the henchmen of Data's evil twin, Lore. First Contact brought the Borg back as not only a formidable opponent in their actions (time travel to stop the essential birth of the Federation), but also made them frightening aesthetically in a way the television show never could on its budget and medium. Much like the Klingons were redesigned for Star Trek: The Motion Picture to make them more menacing, First Contact's Borg were the 1990's sci-fi equivalent of the modern zombies of The Walking Dead. Instead of an awkward, clunky robot with a pale make-up scheme, First Contact's Borg looked like they could eat phasers for breakfast and poop out photon torpedoes - helped by a new assimilation process that occurred virtually instantaneously.

4. Data

Data Star Trek There's really nothing to single out about Data in this movie that one couldn't single out in the entire run of TNG - and that's largely due to the excellent portrayal by Brent Spiner. In today's era television shows, even sci-fi ones, get much more acclaim and respect then they did when TNG was on. Much like Leonard Nimoy before him with Spock, Spiner made a non-human character the most human with his incredible acting abilities. It's a shame he never received even at least an Emmy nod. The movies strived to make Data more human first by reintroducing the emotion chip in Generations, and then taking it a step further by having the Borg queen seduce him figuratively and literally with actual human skin being grafted onto his exoskeleton. Still, in the end, Data rejects what he always desired to maintain his loyalty to Captain Picard and the Enterprise crew - once again showing that being human is more in one's actions than physical design.

3. The Enterprise-E

Star Trek First Contact Uss Enterprise 600x300 The Enterprise-D was always a goofy looking ship to me. It looked good from some angles (usually overhead shots) and while it maintained enough of the basic design to make it recognizable as a ship of the line from the original Enterprise, it just never looked particularly cool. First Contact introduced a brand-new Enterprise and it did not disappoint, taking the best parts of the original/refit Enterprise and the Enterprise-D and combining them into a formidable ship with sleek lines and an overall "Don't mess with the Federation" posture (which would have made an awesome bumper sticker by the impulse engine). The exterior wasn't the only part that got a much needed redesign; instead of looking like a day care, the interior was now darker and more down to business with an almost militaristic hue. There may still be kids somewhere on the Enterprise-E - but it no longer looks like they might walk onto the bridge and start playing dolls at any given moment.

2. The Payoff

Picard And Data Hunt Borg

Part of the problem with J.J. Abrams's Star Trek reboot is that I just can't get emotionally invested in these versions of the classic TOS characters. We'll see them in one more film at least, but who knows what will come of them after that - with the current film system we may see yet another reboot after the obligatory trilogy is up. Part of the reason the TOS Star Trek films were so popular is that people had years to become emotionally attached to those characters through the original run and then endless reruns. It was the same with TNG: I was born in 1974 so I missed the original run of TOS, but I literally grew up watching first-run TNG. I started watching it when I was thirteen and it ended when I was twenty; I remember speeding home from a third shift job to watch the finale "...All Good Things" that I had to tape (yes, you read that right. Tape. The nineties sucked.) For seven years those characters were part of my life as I grew up myself. First Contact finally gave Picard what one could call closure after his experience being assimilated by the Borg in a way that the television show never really did. The episode "Family" - one of my favorites set right after Best of Both Worlds - dealt with the immediate fallout, but didn't satisfy the need for Picard's revenge, the need for him to make them "pay for what they've done!" First Contact let Picard finally take down the Borg on a visceral level - noted by Lily after he machine guns (machine guns! In Star Trek!) several Borg down in the holodeck, including one of his own crew - and in turn, gave the fans a feeling of satisfaction as well after watching what they had put him through.

1. Picard/Patrick Stewart

Ag1 Speaking of Picard, Patrick Stewart was never finer as him than he was in First Contact. Some purists may argue that this portrayal of Picard was antithetical to the more cerebral version shown throughout the run of TNG - attempting to turn Picard into an action hero or another version of James T. Kirk - but I counter that with the fact that the filmmakers of Generations felt content to let him uncharacteristically get his ass handed to him by Malcom McDowell just to make an overweight, past his prime Shatner look good for his last hurrah. First Contact allowed Picard to shine and come into his own as the next film captain of the Enterprise, and Stewart held nothing back. His impassioned speech to Lily in the Observation Lounge, initially lying to himself that his actions haven't been driven by revenge before realizing they most certainly have, is one I never tire of watching and is a tour de force by Stewart. I love Shatner for what he is, but he could never pull off a speech like that - even his hatred of the Klingons in Star Trek VI for killing his son comes off stilted compared to this. One of the utter shames of the Abram's reboot is that it is very unlikely we will ever see Patrick Stewart don the mantle of Captain Jean-Luc Picard again; at least we'll always have First Contact.

5 Things That Didn't Work

5. Exposition

Worf Here's some actual dialogue exchange from the movie:
PICARD: The first thing they'll do in engineering is establish a collective, a central point from which they can control the hive. The problem is if we begin firing particle weapons in engineering there's a risk we may hit the warp core. I believe our goal should be to puncture one of the plasma coolant tanks. Data? DATA: Excellent idea. Plasma coolant will liquefy organic material on contact. WORF: But the Borg are not entirely organic. PICARD: True, but like all cybernetic life forms they cannot survive without their organic components.
The Enterprise is always the flagship of Starfleet. It's crewed by the best of the best. More so, this particular crew not only made first contact with the Borg (in the 24th century, anyway), but also stopped them on several occasions, including their first attempted invasion of Earth. With that in mind, does Worf really not know that the Borg are a mix of organic and cybernetic parts? Or that they can't survive without their organic components? Of course it's a bit of exposition for the audience First Contact also hoped to reach - non-Trekkers - but it's awfully clunky and makes it sound like at least one of the senior staff (one whose able to come on board from a different assignment and pick up right where he left off, nonetheless) has never encountered a Borg before. It probably would have been better to delegate that line to a nondescript crew member...but even then, it's not like the Borg are classified and no one outside the upper echelon of Starfleet knows about them. They damn near assimilated Earth in "Best of Both Worlds" - we all know more about Kim Kardashian then we ever wanted to and she's never done anything remotely worthy. Tomes would have been written about the Borg and their near assimilation of Earth.

4. The Borg Queen

Borg Queen Part of the threat of the Borg as initially conceived was that they were a threat individually and as a whole. There was no "head" to cut off to stop them; the threat was spread throughout the entire collective. Stop one Borg and forty more would take its place with the same knowledge instilled in it. More so, whereas previously in the series the assimilation process seemed to be a lengthy process, it was now almost instantaneous. More Borg were just a pinprick away. Writing wise for a movie, the introduction of the Borg Queen was almost a necessity€”there needed to be a definitive villain to beat instead of an entire collective as a whole. While I thought it was beautifully acted by Alice Krige and handled deftly - especially the subplot with Data being potentially turned by the Queen with the promise of becoming more human - overall it diminished what the Borg was for future endeavors, and made them just a little less unique in the Star Trek mythology.

3. Counselor Troi

Troi Although after a rocky start she was fleshed out to become a more essential character, let's face facts: No viewer (male, anyway) would care if Counselor Troi was on that ship if she wasn't played by the vivacious Marina Sirtis. It's an interesting dichotomy; the psychological well-being of people on a deep space mission would be essential not only to its success but their survival... yet, I'm not sure seeing the actual "counselor" counseling them was something we really needed to see. I mean, they have to go the bathroom to survive too, but they thankfully spared us from seeing that. Counselor Troi's main function in First Contact? To get drunk with Zefram Cochrane (beautifully played by the always brilliant James Cromwell) and let him think he has a shot at bedding her so she can "gauge" whether he's ready to learn about the future he helped usher in with the invention of the warp engine. Because showing him a tricorder or a phaser wouldn't have accomplished that in lesser time and without a hangover. It's a little bit of comic relief - as a lot of the story set on Earth was compared to that aboard the Enterprise - but completely unnecessary, and just reiterates the point that if they couldn't find much for Counselor Troi to do that anyone cared about in 7 seasons on television besides look pretty, there's even less for her to do in a motion picture with six other main cast members.

2. Suspension Of Disbelief

First Contact Lily When I say "suspension of disbelief," I'm not talking about the fact that you have to believe in starships, time travel, or alien races; it's more so that some of the characters and/or rules established in the Trek universe are bent so badly it temporarily throws you out of the movie. For example: Before he beams down to Earth, Geordi La Forge - allegedly brilliant engineer - dismissively tells one of his underlings to "check the environmental controls" because it's getting a little toasty in the Enterprise. McFly? Hello? In a tightly controlled environment like the Enterprise - which is technically called life support - the environmental controls being even just a tad off should not only be a big deal that requires immediate attention by its Chief Engineer, but should also be a tipoff that the Borg are on the ship. If the environment goes from "toasty" to "broil", the crew of the Enterprise isn't going to have to worry about the Borg. In fact, as the Borg are shown later to be outside on the deflector dish without any life support gear, it makes one wonder why they just didn't turn it off altogether and leisurely assimilate the rest of the ship. Another example? Lily takes a phaser away from Picard - set to kill no less - and she's apparently able to fire it by Picard's reaction. Yet, she shouldn't be able to. In the 21st century we're starting to develop weapons that won't fire unless they're biometrically matched to the user€”you're telling me in the 24th century, all phasers aren't coded to operate only if the person holding it is authorized to? One could argue that it's an unnecessary precaution... yet in a future where you have these immensely powerful computers that run everything, why not have that safeguard in place so your own weapons can't be used against you? It's not solely a First Contact or even a Star Trek issue€”writers of all mediums conveniently bend or forget the established rules of the fictional universe when it benefits the story€”but the little things detract slightly from an otherwise well-crafted narrative.

1. Time Travel

First Contact Time Travel Oh, don't get me wrong, I love me a good time travel yarn. Time travel stories are eternally appealing to virtually everyone because everyone has at least one thing in their past they wish they could go back and change or do differently. For instance; kind of wishing I wouldn't have gotten those Asian Zing wings at Buffalo Wild Wings for lunch right about now. However, once you open that door in a fictional universe, it should change everything in such a radical way that it's never the same again... and yet, everyone eventually shrugs their shoulders and goes on their merry way. To be fair, Star Trek opened up that door long before First Contact as far back as TOS (and went to that well again in the Abram's reboot), but in the context of this movie, it should make their temporary victory over the Borg a hollow one. If the Borg have time travel, why haven't they used it since (and I'll admit I'm not up on Voyager or Enterprise history to know if they did after that) to go back in time and mess with human history? For that matter, why go back and assimilate Earth while humans have even the slightest chance of fighting back? Why not go back to prehistoric times and assimilate it then? Or during the Middle Ages? Yes, first contact with the Vulcans was a pivotal point in the history of the Trek universe...but if you alter human history centuries beforehand, they never even get to that point. Beyond that, how does the Enterprise get back to their own present time? They analyzed the Borg's chronometric particles to recreate the temporal vortex...and then as far as I know, it's promptly forgotten about in any Trek incarnation after that. I mean, come on: Data dies in Nemesis? "Recreate the temporal vortex!" Kirk dies from radiation poisoning? "Recreate the temporal vortex ERRR Khan blood!" Yeah. Sorry. Couldn't resist a dig on that deus ex machina in Star Trek Into Darkness, either, as that's another fictional universe altering discovery that will be completely ignored. Trek has tried to address the quandaries of discovering time travel in various mediums by creating the "Temporal Investigations" unit, which is all fine and good for people of normally high ethical standards like Starfleet and they promise never, ever to muck around in time again, but you're telling me the freaking Borg aren't going to? Or the Klingons? The Romulans? It's just something that's never really "realistically" addressed in most fictional universes once the gimmick of time travel is introduced. That would be an impossible genie to put back in the bottle.

Contributor
Contributor

A What Culture writer since October 2013, I write about whatever interests me at the moment, which usually involves comics, sports, films, television, sci-fi, video games, and current events. Mostly I write as a stress release; it's cheaper than drinking and keeps me out of trouble. Most of the time, anyway.