Star Wars: 10 Things That STILL Don’t Make Sense
Why do folks have such short memories when it comes to the Jedi?
Now finding itself in a position where new, intergalactic tales are being pumped into its ever-expanding corner of the galaxy by the quarter, the Star Wars franchise keeps finding countless inventive ways to provide answers to certain questions that have been occupying fans' minds for decades.
Look no further than the recent Disney+ Obi-Wan Kenobi series going out of its way to make sense of the titular space wizard's fondness for referring to Vader as "Darth", and his once-bizarre comments on the Sith being responsible for murdering and betraying Luke Skywalker's father, Anakin.
But even with that being said, there are still a great many strange Star Wars developments that are yet to be fully explained or entirely clarified, with some odd happenings still not actually making complete sense some 40+ years on from their debut!
From arguably one of the most important personalities in the galaxy weirdly going missing during a key spell in the Skywalker Saga, to the fact that many people within this sprawling galaxy appear to have particularly short memories, these are those moments and scenarios that fans are still struggling to understand after all this time.
10. What In The Hell Was Ahsoka Tano Up To During The Original Trilogy?
Getting the ball rolling with a puzzling reality that simply could not be avoided due to the character only being introduced to the Skywalker Saga decades after the original trilogy, the whereabouts of Ahsoka Tano throughout those flicks has been a question buried within the minds of many for some time.
Since it became clear that the former Jedi wasn't actually killed off by her former master while duelling within the Sith Temple on Malachor in Rebels - instead being saved from that fate by Ezra Bridger's World Between Worlds intervention - many wondered why Tano would've simply sat by and watched the galaxy rip itself apart throughout Episodes IV to VI.
And the fact that the one-time Skywalker Padawan rocked up in The Mandalorian after the events of the OG trilogy only added further confusion to the scenario.
It has been suggested that Tano was actually residing on Malachor during the Galactic Civil War, embarking on a spiritual journey of sorts as she figured out a way to find the missing Ezra. But it's safe to say many will be looking for some concrete answers within the upcoming Ahsoka series as to what she was actually up to in the time before joining forces with Sabine Wren to search for the Ghost Crew member.
9. Nobody Has A Clue Who Luke Skywalker Is
As this list will shine a light on before its conclusion, the folks within this galaxy far, far away aren't exactly boasting the strongest memories.
Now sure, to assume that every single soul living and breathing throughout the aforementioned Galactic Civil War would've laid eyes on (or even just heard of) the iconic Jedi who helped topple The Empire would be foolish. The galaxy is a pretty huge place, after all.
But the fact that folks as close to the good fight as the likes of Cara Dune didn't even seem to be aware of who in the hell the New Republic hero Luke Skywalker was upon him meeting the Mando gang in Season 2 makes for a rather baffling situation.
Even if Dune hadn't crossed paths with the iconic Jedi before, there's a strong chance his face - or at the very least, his physical description - would've been floated about by the folks he was once fighting with just a few short years before. And the fact that Luke is praised as some sort of Jedi celebrity by the time of The Force Awakens only makes the team's uncertainty over who in the hell he was at this point even more bizarre.
8. How Did Leia End Up With A New Dress On Endor?
Amidst the cuddly chaos seen going down upon the Ewoks' arrival in Return of the Jedi, one particular piece of clothing left some fans understandably scratching their heads.
Princess Leia Organa finds herself sporting an earthy-looking dress in the wake of being taken in by Wicket W. Warrick and co., and while many found themselves questioning how the leading light managed to come into possession of said clothing after rocking up to the forest moon in camo gear, that part of the mystery was actually solved thanks to Star Wars: Forces of Destiny's Ewok Escape explaining that the dress was a gift for Leia's assistance in saving some Ewoks from a bunch of stormtroopers.
The part that hasn't been fully detailed, however, is how in the heck the fuzzy little rascals came into possession of said dress in the first place.
There is one disturbing fan theory that suggests the Ewoks, as seen in their initial hostility towards Luke and Han, could've actually just eaten another woman and taken her dress as a horrific prize. But it's still not been 100-percent confirmed in canon if this was how said clothing was obtained.
7. How Did Jar Jar Binks Become A Senator?
After spending pretty much the entirety of his screen-time bumbling through The Phantom Menace, it's safe to say that seeing Jar Jar Binks don a set of robes and strut into the Galactic Senate caught just about everyone off-guard.
Admittedly, rewarding the slapstick fool with a cushy Gungan role for his (less than competent) displays during the battle against the Trade Federation's droid army on Naboo made a bit of sense. But having him act as the Gungans' Ambassador to Theed before eventually stepping into the high-pressure position of Naboo's Associate Planetary Representative whenever Padmé Amidala wasn't available was a pretty difficult pill to swallow for those who had last seen Jar Jar make a meal out of, well, something as simple as a meal in Episode I.
Sure enough, it didn't take all that much effort to manipulate the eternally clumsy politician into suggesting the Senate give emergency powers to Chancellor Palpatine in order to forge a grand army of the Republic in Attack of the Clones, begging the question why so many ignorantly allowed the likes of Palpatine to humour him into this highly influential spot in the first place.
6. How Could The Jedi Be Forgotten About So Damn Quickly?
The fact that figures such as Han Solo refer to the Jedi way as little more than a "hokey religion" during his early appearances in A New Hope just doesn't seem to add up upon assessing the timeline.
Some twenty years on from Order 66 all but obliterating the Jedi from existence, the fact many were so quick to forget about this particular aspect of the massive war between a Jedi-boasting Republic and the Separatists that ultimately birthed the Galactic Empire never really made sense, with the likes of the Rebels and Obi-Wan Kenobi series both suggesting that many Jedi did still find a way to pop-up over the years.
Sure, The Emperor definitely went out of his way to bury or destroy any remnants of the Jedi, which does partially explain why some corners of the galaxy either opted to ignore them, or simply had their brains washed into thinking they were little more than a myth.
But when folks like Han Solo (who was revealed to have actually been a member of the Imperial Navy earlier in his life, and must've surely come across the odd Jedi straggler) act as if the existence of the one-time Force-wielding heroes is laughable, this particular opinion/reaction feels increasingly odd.
5. Why Didn't Grievous Just Blast Kenobi To Smithereens?
Many quite rightly were all too happy to discard all logic when it came to one particularly strange tactical choice from one of the galaxy's most cunning generals during Revenge of the Sith.
That's because, had General Grievous done the intelligent thing during his showdown with Obi-Wan Kenobi on Utapau, there's a solid chance fans would've been gifted with a bit of an anti-climactic response to Ewan McGregor's immortal utterance of "Hello there!"
In reality though, what was stopping Grievous from simply lowering one of his bionic arms and commanding the room full of droids to open fire on the stubborn Jedi Master?
His own ego, perhaps?
But a strategic b*stard like this cyborg definitely should've realised that his odds of claiming another lightsaber for his collection would've been greater had he allowed his army to do his dirty work for him.
Maybe Grievous simply felt that his robot allies, no matter their superior numbers, weren't capable of besting a Jedi of Kenobi's talents? But it does feel like the General missed a bit of a trick in not at least testing Obi-Wan's deflecting capabilities against a few hundred blasters.
4. Why Did Nobody Use Force Speed More Often?
While there are a ton of Force abilities out there in the Legends and Canon universes that weren't fully explored within the live-action Skywalker Saga, one undoubtedly useful talent was actually given a run-out during The Phantom Menace's opening stages... only to pretty much completely disappear from there on out.
Your writer is talking about that moment Obi-Wan Kenobi and Qui-Gon Jinn utilise good ol' Force Speed to get out of droideka dodge on a Trade Federation ship. But far from opening the door for the Jedi to flaunt this massively useful talent in the Prequels in particular, the ability seems to go oddly missing shortly after this first use.
Mace Windu would tease the use of Force Speed during the animated Clone Wars series, with the odd other Jedi being able to dodge particularly rapidly within the animated sphere, too. But outside of these few quick beats, was the power kept mostly secret from those learning to wield the power of the Force on the big-screen?
It may have come in handy when trying to evade mind-controlled Clone troopers. Just a thought.
3. How Obi-Wan Kenobi Aged So Damn Quickly
One of the key happenings fans were hoping to see addressed over the course of Disney+'s recent Obi-Wan Kenobi series was what in the holy hell happened to the titular Jedi Master to make him go from luscious brunette-lock boasting space stud, to white-haired wizard in just under two decades.
Instead of shedding some light on how the Jedi who appeared to be in his mid-thirties during Revenge of the Sith ended up resembling a dude edging towards the end of his sixties in A New Hope, the series reached its conclusion (for now at least) with Kenobi still boasting a mane without even a flicker of grey.
Some have been quick to suggest that Ben's swift ageing may come about due to the character eventually being on the receiving end of a life-draining Force power, similarly to how Palpatine wound up resembling a battered vegetable after having his own Force-lightning deflected onto him in Revenge of the Sith.
Until said grey-hair-creating trauma makes itself known, however, this rapid ageing will continue to be filed in the "strange Star Wars mystery" category.
2. Anakin's Young Force Ghost In Return Of The Jedi
In another case of George Lucas attempting to sell fans on an odd scenario that just about nobody bought - or has any intention of buying some years later - the reveal of Hayden Christensen's version of Anakin Skywalker/Darth Vader being swapped into the again tinkered-with original trilogy in the 2004 DVD re-release of Return of the Jedi inspired an understandable amount of confusion.
Far from quickly offering a wise and logical response though, Lucas claimed in the film's DVD commentary that "the idea was that your [Anakin’s] inner person would go back to where we left it off when it turned to the Dark Side."
But this retcon pretty much negates the powerful beat that had seen Vader redeem himself and seemingly wander back towards the light side of the Force in the moments before the Sebastian Shaw version of the character dies in his son's arms.
In truth, Christensen being thrown into the original trilogy was likely little more than a way of connecting the OG flicks and the prequels, whether it made any actual sense or not.
1. How Did Anakin Not Clock That His Wife Was Pregnant With Twins?
While expecting someone to be aware of the fact that their partner is carrying not one, but two babies within them, when the mother herself seemingly isn't aware of that knowledge may seem a bit odd, Anakin Skywalker wasn't any old average Joe.
After all, it's demonstrated time and time again that Force users possess the ability to sense the lives of others from halfway across the galaxy, as seen when Palpatine senses his new apprentice is in danger from Coruscant when Lord Vader is battling with his one-time master on Mustafar.
So, would it have been too much of a stretch for Anakin to clock the fact that his beloved Padmé was actually set to give birth to a couple of lil' Skywalkers when she was literally stood right in front of him? Vader even went on record to admit that he could "feel" that Amidala was alive before her untimely end, so why couldn't he "feel" the two lifeforms within her?
Plus, the fact that Yoda and Obi-Wan were also unable to sense that there were two babies onboard (until being told moments before their birth) seems to suggest that this lot weren't as connected to the Living Force as they thought.
Watch Next
Star Wars Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Revenge Of The Sith?