2. Mandy Patinkin as Kyle Katarn
Now you gamers out there arent going to tell me youve never dreamed of seeing Kyle Katarn on the big screen done properly? And Im sure Mandy Patinkin could do it as properly as can be done. His work on Homeland shows that hes got the charisma and hard edge (not to mention the beard) to pull off the Stormtrooper-turned-special agent-turned-Jedi Master in his later years. And just look at his sword fight from The Princess Bride. Surely picking up a lightsaber would come easy to the man who played Inigo Montoya, no matter which hand he held it in?