Star Wars Rogue One: 20 WTF Moments

The trailers lied. A lot.

Star Wars Rogue One Stormtroopers
Disney

With Rogue One now finally released around the world, fans are getting to experience Gareth Edwards' epic journey for themselves, and fans and critics alike seem to have mostly fallen in love with what the Godzilla director cooked up, despite the much-discussed production issues.

As with any big blockbuster, though, there's plenty to soak in, from the good, to the bad, to the very, very weird, and true to the series' form, there was a high abundance of WTF moments in this spin-off.

From odd directorial quirks to strange performances, amusing nods to previous movies, some shocking brutal moments and two incredibly jarring attempts at exploiting nostalgia, these are the moments you're probably going to remember the most from the movie, both for better and for worse.

With massive spoilers to follow, here are 20 WTF moments from Star Wars: Rogue One...

20. There's No Opening Title Crawl

Star Wars Rogue One
Lucasfilm

Though this was confirmed ahead of the movie's release, it was still rather jarring that the film opened with the usual "A long time ago in a galaxy far far away..." title card, but didn't follow up with the customary opening title crawl set to John Williams' iconic theme.

Instead, the movie went straight into a flashback sequence featuring a young Jyn Erso, and the movie's brief title didn't appear until about 10 minutes in.

It makes sense of course, considering that Rogue One is a delineated story in the Star Wars universe rather than a core entry, but it still left a lot of purists scratching their heads, especially as various comics and video games in the past have featured their own opening crawls regardless.


19. Cassian Kills Tivik

Rogue One Cassian Andor
Lucasfilm

In Cassian Andor's (Diego Luna) opening mission, he is aided by Tivik (Daniel Mays), an undercover member of the resistance who provides him with vital information for his ongoing war against the Empire.

In a shocking moment, however, Cassian shoots Tivik dead before departing, presumably in order to tie off any loose ends during his escape.

It's a great scene because it immediately lets you know that Cassian isn't some squeaky-clean hero, and he's able to make some tough calls if it benefits the bigger picture of bringing the Empire down.

Luna, one of the movie's easy highlights, plays the scene perfectly, and moments like this make him a much more interesting hero than the more straight-laced Jyn.


18. Everything Missing From The Trailers

Star Wars Rogue One Stormtroopers
Lucasfilm

One of the more disappointing aspects of the film is just how much material was missing from the trailers, presumably due to the movie's heavy re-shoots.

Jyn's "I rebel" line, the Stormtroopers wading through water, a TIE Fighter appearing in front of Jyn on the communications tower catwalk, Jyn running on the beach with the data card, Krennic telling Vader "The power that we are dealing with is immeasurable" and the awesome shot of Krennic walking through a pile of Stormtrooper corpse were all absent from the final film, and weirdly K-2SO's "97.6% chance of failure" line was altered as well.

It's not a deal breaker, but considering how gorgeous so many of these images and lines were, it's a shame they couldn't find a place in the movie's reconstituted narrative.


17. Forest Whitaker's Bizarre Role

Star Wars Rogue One 66 Jpg Saw Gerrera
Lucasfilm

There was a lot of excitement when Forest Whitaker was confirmed to be playing resistance fighter Saw Gerrera in the film, a pre-existing character who previously appeared in the Clone Wars animated TV show.

Somewhat strangely, Whitaker has an incredibly small role in the film, appearing briefly when he meets Jyn as a child, only to meet up with her again as an adult, but before he can do much, his fortress is attacked and he's killed in the ensuing destruction.

Further odd is Whitaker's rather eccentric performance, full of over-the-top line deliveries, such as his rather cringe-worthy screech of "Save the rebellion! Save the dream!"

It's safe to say that Whitaker's fans were hoping for a little more from both the player and the part. Instead he's more of an oddity you'll basically forget about the second he's wiped out.


16. The Off-Kilter Editing & Pacing

Star Wars Rogue One young Jyn
Lucasfilm

It's not too surprising that Rogue One feels rather shapeless in terms of editing and pacing, considering the re-shoots that took place in order to fix issues Disney had with Gareth Edwards' first pass of the film.

This results in the film's pacing feeling totally off in the first and third acts in particular: we're rushed through being introduced to the key players and hurled into the war, and then the last third is forced to sprint through the final showdown while also paying lip service to Darth Vader.

The moment-to-moment editing is also fairly messy, with Edwards fleeting around fussily rather than lingering on some of his better shot selections, which is a shame.

Above all else it's a reminder that while The Force Awakens was an overly safe, risk-averse product, J.J. Abrams seemed to have a much firmer handle on the technical aspects of his film.


15. "What Is She Proposing?"

Star Wars Rogue One Jyn
Lucasfilm

One of the strangest moments in the film takes place during a meeting between the rebels, where Jyn chimes in with vital information she learned from a holographic recording of her father, all while many of the rebels dismiss her claims as dubious.

Hilariously, an unseen character can be heard shouting, "What is she proposing!?", with an incredibly odd, stilted delivery that's nothing if not unintentionally hilarious.

Everyone remembers the infamous "Things are worse than ever" line from The Dark Knight, and it's possible that the iconically bad line reading may have finally met its match with this peculiar inclusion to an otherwise totally serious, engaging scene.


14. The Mass Execution Scene

Rogue One Galen Erso
Disney

Mid-way through the movie, Orson Krennic (Ben Mendelsohn) asks Galen Erso (Mads Mikkelsen) to gather all of his engineers, because he knows that there's a traitor in his midst.

He urges the traitor to step forward, and when nobody does, Krennic announces that he's going to treat them all as collaborators and kill the lot of them.

At that moment, Galen steps forward and reveals that he is in fact the rebel sympathiser, but Krennic has none of it, executing all of the engineers regardless.

It may not be the most original act of villainy ever put to film, but it does a great, terrifying job of cementing Krennic's ruthlessness when faced with insurrection, and again demonstrates the movie's challenging morality, that Galen's actions just got a number of good men killed.


13. The Surprising Lack Of Character Developent

Star Wars Rogue One 65 Jpg
Lucasfilm

Rogue One is a 133-minute movie that has to introduce almost a dozen new major characters to audiences, and this is one area where the movie feels oddly lacking.

Considering that The Force Awakens did a remarkable job fashioning a new band of heroes and villains, it's a shame Rogue One barely develops the central heroes as people at all.

You likely won't even remember many of their names, and most of them fit some fairly basic archetypes (such as Donny Yen's wise martial artist) for the assumed sake of convenience.

In fact, the villainous Krennic honestly seems much better-developed than almost all of the heroes. Perhaps character development takes such a back seat because the filmmakers knew these characters wouldn't be sticking around, but it still makes the core of the film feel a bit empty.


12. Galen Erso's Cliched Death

Rogue One Mads Mikkelsen
LucasFilm

When the rebels assault Krennic and his men on Eadu, Galen is caught in an explosion. However, Jyn gets one last moment with her father before he dies, in a howlingly cliched, cheeseball moment that's clearly supposed to be affecting and dramatic.

This reeks of a scene that was tinkered with in re-shoots, because it feels so generic and tailored towards the biggest, most general audience possible.

Fantastic an actor though Mads Mikkelsen is, even he struggles to make the scene not play out as corny. It ends up feeling rushed and not "earned" than if more time was spent exploring Jyn's ambivalent relationship with her absent father.


11. That Shoehorned R2-D2 & C-3PO Cameo

Star Wars A New Hope R2D2 C 3PO
Disney

Just as the rebels take off to mount their final assault, R2-D2 and C-3PO can be spotted for a few seconds chilling out in the hangar bay.

There are a lot of entertaining callbacks to the original trilogy in this movie, though this is one that feels just a little too pandering and forced, as though they were simply thrown in because they've appeared in every Star Wars movie to date and it'd be rude not to include them here.

It's not exactly groan-worthy (it's too short to be, really), but it was totally unnecessary and a rare moment that employed nostalgia for an incredibly cheap fan-service moment without really justifying itself. ]

There's a lot of fan-service in the film, but most of it felt appropriate, though this definitely didn't.


10. Admiral Raddus Is The New Ackbar

Rogue One Admiral Raddus
Disney

An hilarious and peculiar new character introduced later in the movie is Admiral Raddus, a Mon Calamari admiral who provides tactical support to the rebels during the film's space battles.

Raddus of course bears a significant resemblance to the legendary Admiral Ackbar, the main difference being his skin colour is grey rather than Ackbar's brown.

This is a nod to the original trilogy that doesn't feel too on-the-nose, because Mon Calamari are a race of aliens and it's not inconceivable that other members of that race would have high-ranking strategic positions.

Plus, Raddus' personality seems a little different, and he was reportedly modeled after British Prime Minister Winston Churchill, which is all kinds of awesome.


9. Sexual Tension Between Jyn & Cassian

Rogue One Jyn Erso Cassian Andor
Lucasfilm

It wasn't too surprising but also totally unnecessary that Rogue One couldn't help but occasionally hint at a burgeoning romance between Jyn and Cassian.

At first, they didn't trust one another, they argued and then they began to respect one another heading into the climactic battle, before having a tender embrace in their final moments.

The film is restrained in that it doesn't show them making out or anything, but the numerous loaded glances clearly hint at a growing fondness that, tragically enough, can never be consummated.

In that sense it has a more haunting quality to it than any romance in the history of Star Wars, but honestly the entire film could've gone without those very specific lingering looks that just drip with sexual tension.


8. Darth Vader In The Bacta Tank

Star Wars Rogue One Bacta Tank
Disney

The first time Darth Vader is glimpsed in the movie, he's inside a bacta tank, seemingly nude or at least in some state of undress, before getting his signature outfit on and heading out to meet with Krennic.

It's a disturbing, fascinating scene, especially as the figure isn't immediately identifiable as Vader, and many fans may have suspected that they were seeing a younger version of Supreme Leader Snoke, considering the rumours that he would appear in the movie.

The shot lasts just a few seconds, but fans are going to be poring over exactly what they saw ad nauseum until the movie's out on Blu-ray for all to endlessly observe.


7. The Hamfisted "Rogue One" Name Drop

Rogue One Bodhi
Disney

The filmmakers just couldn't resist including a hilariously on-the-nose namedrop of the movie's title, could they?

Just as the rebels are about to take off in their commandeered ship ahead of the final battle, pilot Bodhi (Riz Ahmed) is contacted over the radio and asked for his ship's callsign. He reluctantly says "Rogue...Rogue One", and as the bemused officer on the other end remarks that the callsign doesn't exist, Bodhi takes off.

The title probably had to appear somewhere in the movie, but would've fit a lot easier during one of the many rebel meeting scenes, as their squad name could've had Rogue One as its official designation rather than one clumsily made up on the spot.

It might seem like a nitpick to some, and it's nowhere near as bad as "We're some kind of Suicide Squad?" or "That's Fantastic", but it's certainly not a bastion of subtle writing either.


6. Krennic Is Killed By His Own Weapon

Rogue One Krennic
Lucasfilm

Oh, the delightful irony of how Orson Krennic met his fate in this movie. The Imperial Military's Director of the Advanced Weapons Research finds himself obliterated by his own weapon after Orson finds himself fighting the rebels, allowing Moff Tarkin to assume control of the Death Star and fire it, obliterating the rebels but also Krennic himself.

It's a fitting and somewhat unexpected end to Krennic, which neatly explains how Tarkin ended up as commander (and him having taken control rather than inheriting it from a dead Krennic is way more bada** and keeping in line with Tarkin's character) while cementing how thoroughly outclassed Krennic was by both Tarkin and Vader.


5. Galen Designed The Death Star's Exposed Exhaust Port

Star Wars Rogue One Galen Erso
Disney

This had been heavily speculated before Rogue One's release, but it was still somewhat unexpected to see fans actually get their dose of wish fulfillment.

It's revealed that Jyn's father Galen, who is responsible for the Death Star becoming operational due to his research into kyber crystals, intentionally built the exposed exhaust port into the weapon's design as a flaw, in the hope that the rebels would be able to exploit this, as of course they eventually do in A New Hope.

To hear the most ludicrous "plot hole" in the franchise somewhat rectified after four decades was extremely cathartic for many fans, and while it's still pretty absurd that nobody else questioned Galen's design choice, it at least makes more sense now.


4. CGI Princess Leia

Princess Leia star wars carrie fisher a new hope
Lucasfilm

The movie ends with Princess Leia being handed the Death Star plans, and though the shot initially just shows her from behind, the camera then pans around to reveal a CGI rendering of a young Carrie Fisher.

By any objective metric, the attempt to recreate Fisher is pretty good...if we were playing a video game, but sadly it doesn't quite measure up in a movie being watched on the big screen. The fake Leia falls straight into the uncanny valley and feels like an over-the-top fan service moment when a more restrained over-the-shoulder shot would've been sufficient.

Hopefully this doesn't set a precedent moving forward with future anthology movies that we might see more of this.


3. All The Heroes Actually Die

Star Wars Rogue One 73 Jpg Jyn Erso
Lucasfilm

One of the biggest questions surrounding Rogue One was whether any of the heroes might survive in order to leave the door open for a new spin-off series of movies.

As it turned out, though, the entire band of heroes were killed off in the third act: droid K-2SO (Alan Tudyk) detonates himself in order to protect Jyn and Cassian, while Bodhi, Chirrut (Donnie Yen) and Baze (Jiang Wen) are blown up, and Jyn and Cassian are incinerated by the Death Star's blast.

It's a brave move and cements that Rogue One admirably was just a one-off. Considering this is so anathema to a studio as money-hungry as Disney, it's a genuinely shocking moment, especially as it initially seemed like the wall of fire might stop short of killing Jyn and Cassian.

Though Rogue One has a number of dubious creative calls, this one was 100% the right choice.


2. Beast Mode Darth Vader

darth vader rogue one
Lucasfilm

Easily the movie's most talked-about scene occurs in the final two minutes, as rebel officers frantically rush the Death Star's plans to Princess Leia, but out of nowhere, Darth Vader's iconic breathing can be heard, followed by his red lightsaber being switched on.

He spends the next minute slaughtering every officer in the vicinity, slashing away, using the Force to fling them around, and even stab through the door.

It's a marvelous scene and of course immediately sets up Leia being captured by Vader at the start of A New Hope.

Seeing Vader so murderous remains incredibly shocking despite audience knowledge of all his misdeeds, and that it manages to tie so neatly into the original trilogy makes it all that much better and weirder.


1. CGI Grand Moff Tarkin

Star Wars A New Hope Grand Moff Tarkin
Disney

And finally, by far the movie's most WTF moment is the peculiar decision to prominently feature Grand Moff Tarkin in the film, with his face recreated from distractingly sub-par CGI, while Guy Henry does an admittedly amazing job of replicating Tarkin's voice.

Though the scenes shot in low-light in which Tarkin speaks to Krennic are basically fine, Gareth Edwards oddly chooses a lot of close-ups which only emphasise the distracting uncanny valley effect of the CGI.

Again, much like the attempt to create a period-appropriate Leia, it just isn't up to the required standard to be convincing, but may well set an unsettling precedent moving forward.

Which Rogue One moments most left you baffled, confused and amused? Shout them out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.