Star Wars: The Force Awakens - 10 Behind-The-Scenes Secrets We Learnt From ILM
We sat down with the effects studio to talk all things Episode VII.

Star Wars: The Force Awakens was a success on every conceivable level, dominating the box office, scoring across the board positive reviews and winning back all but the most curmudgeonly fan burnt by the prequels. But its biggest success can't be quantified by numerical measures; put simply, on a basic level it felt like Star Wars. And while some of that came from John Williams' typically evocative score and the presence of a Harrison Ford who cares, a lot of it is down to how the visual effects accurately recreated and advanced that galaxy far, far away.
However, thanks to the movie's extreme pre-release secrecy, how exactly they were all achieved has been rather mysterious. In an attempt to shed some light on the film, we got a chance to sit down with Scott Pritchard, a Compositing Sequence Supervisor at ILM (who has previously worked on Avengers: Age Of Ultron, Spectre and The Martian), at Escape Studios' VFX Festival 2016 last month (check out there website for information on next year's event) and talk about his and the company's work on Episode VII. You can check out the highlights of the interview in the video below, but here's a full breakdown of the ten most interesting things we learnt.
Bonus: Rogue One Is Going To Have A Similar Mix Of Practical And CGI Effects
Given how unbearably secretive Lucasfilm are being about the future of Star Wars, there wasn't much in our conversation about upcoming films in a galaxy far, far away (it was almost like Episode VIII doesn't even exist).
However, we were able to learn one incredibly interesting thing about this year's Rogue One. In terms of the film's special effects, you can expect a "similar mix to Episode VII", meaning we'll once again see extensive practical effects augmented by more CGI than you may expect. This isn't that surprising, although given how much of the (minimal) word on the film has been about its down-and-dirty style, this suggests there'll still be an epicness to its scale. Exciting.
10. The Push For Practical Effects Actually Made Using CGI Easier

Something that was really pushed during the production of The Force Awakens was how it was going to show a return to more traditional practical effects, with real life models augmented by CGI, rather than the overly-fake prequels. You may think that and increased fan scrutiny would make ILM's job a lot harder, but it instead played very much into the manner in which they already operate:
"It made our job a lot easier, in a way, because it meant that instead of coming up with computer generated imagery on its own we could actually ground it in what was actually shot."
Across our conversation it became clear this melding between real and computers was an integral part of how ILM worked regardless of the movie at hand, meaning that even without the push we'd have still had a practical Episode VII. As Pritchard summarised:
"In many ways our work was extending or enhancing what was already in camera."
9. Even The All Digital Shots Were Rooted In Reality

Of course there's no avoiding the fact that there were dozens of shots in The Force Awakens that were completely CGI - around thirty according to Pritchard - many in the Escape from Jakku. However, even these totally unreal elements still actually had a grounding in reality, with footage from the set used as basis. In reference to that Millennium Falcon sequence, Pritchard said:
"We'd already done all the photography at Abu Dhabi a lot of what we do at ILM is we take as much reference photography on set as possible so we always have something to base our work off and that really helps when it comes to building those all digital sets. We're always looking for real, physical, photographic reference."
Things will probably have been less concrete for Starkiller base, another location where much of the work was all-digital, but even there there were sets to work from too.
8. BB-8 Was A Fully Digital Model In One Third Of Shots

Much has been made about the fact that there were several on set models for BB-8. In fact, Pritchard even listed a few in our chat - "one which had two rods that came out of the back which allowed a puppeteer to operate the body and the head", "one that was remote controlled and had two little stabiliser wheels", "another that just kinda wiggled around on the spot." However, despite all that, a fair bit of computer imagery was used for the character:
"A third of our BB-8 shots are fully digital."
Yup, a third. Given how seamless the character's integration is, that shows how far along CGI has come and how skilled ILM are at their trademark integration. The rest of the movie was, of course, made through augmenting of the various models, creations of which ILM had no qualms with being practical - the models made by the creature shop were just that good:
"Looking inside the mechanics of BB-8, he was like this incredible swiss watch."
Oh, and I also asked about the gender debate - various people involved in the movie have called BB-8 a "he" and a "she" in interviews. Sadly, the confusion runs through to ILM too.
7. Maz Wasn't Always Going To Be CGI

One of the most interesting things to come out of our conversation was how when deciding the best method to achieve an effect, "The idea was never going to be driven by the technology, it was always going to be driven by the design and what we need to do to capture a performance." This is seen best by Maz Kanta, one of the film's two main fully motion-capture characters; although it's retroactively obviously the best way to allow Lupita Nyong'o to play the character, plenty of other options were considered during the movie's development:
"I think they originally talked about having her as an animatronic puppet, they thought of having her played by someone wearing a suit, but there was a point where the nuance of the performance just demanded a digital version."
Of course, every effort has been made to ensure that there's no handicap to using one method or another, with both practical and computer-generated effects progressing in new and exciting ways that allow seamless integration in both directions:
"For Maz we had a maquette, a physical puppet built that we had in every shot, so that acted as a reference for our digital Maz to match to. [...] We had a digital model available for her in a later digital capture sessions where we were actually able to put a little digital Maz inside a scene which had been shot a couple of months earlier in principal photography and she was able to do the performance capture and see that reflected in Maz in real time."
6. Maz's Design Is Full Of Hints To Her Backstory

Set thirty years after Return Of The Jedi and starting an entire new trilogy, there was a lot of backstory to the The Force Awakens, and that's before you get to all the newly minted characters. But while not all of it was made clear in the movie itself, that doesn't mean the history of the likes of Lor San Tekka or Maz Kanata weren't meticulously mapped out. In fact, the character model for Maz was full of nods to her detailed history:
"A lot of her design was influenced by her backstory as well. She's an adventurer, she's a pirate. If you look at the details in her clothes we've got seven different types of fabric just in her boots. There's all these little details that tell her backstory all of its own."
As for the origins of the general design, it may seem she's somewhat drawn from the same sketchbook as Yoda - between the squat stature, bright coloured skin and affinity with the Force, the only thing missing is the ears - the definition of the character skews a little away from the Jedi Master to another iconic practical creation from ILM's past:
"With Maz, yeah, there's certainly an element of Yoda to her design. I think somebody was saying if you have Yoda at one end and ET at the other then Maz hits about the middle."
5. Maz's Role Change Was Mainly Economical

Like any movie, Star Wars: The Force Awakens went through a lot of changes throughout production. However, unluckily for fans trying to speculate ahead of release, one of the biggest made its way into the movie's trailers; the second Teaser featured a shot of Maz passing Luke's lightsaber to Leia, establishing Kanta at the Resistance base at the end of the second act, yet in the film she was left behind on Takadona, almost forgotten.
There were rumours leading up to release this was to do with Lupita Nyong'o's performance not gelling or a major shift in the film's MacGuffin, but it sounds like the real reason may be something a little less creative and more financial: keeping the special effects budget down. According to Pritchard:
"She was in the film towards the end, but she was very much on the sidelines and it was ultimately decided, well, is it necessary to do a load of visual effects shots for her standing somewhere off to the side of frame. So we decided to keep her where she was able to deliver that fantastic performance that Lupita gave. Ultimately that's J.J.'s decision."
That's a pretty satisfactory explanation, although it would have been nice to have had a scene establishing she survived the destruction of her castle (which she presumably did as Nyong'o is returning for Episode VIII).
4. Snoke's Defining Trait Was Being Intangible And Mysterious

There was plenty kept mysterious by The Force Awakens' marketing, but one of the most secretive was the design of Supreme Leader Snoke, who, bar some leaked concept art, hadn't been glimpsed until the movie hit. That wasn't the only mystery around the character though - he design was always meant to have a strange feel to it. Pritchard talked at length about Andy Serkis' character, jumping right from when he was first brought to ILM with many of his key elements already in place:
"Snoke was originally conceived as a small maquette and that was finished off in the middle of production. And all his scarring, that sort of thing, that was already there and then he was refined throughout post-production. J.J. wanted him to be very monumental. He had the Lincoln Memorial in mind and his idea was that it was very diaphanous, very difficult to figure out what actually was going on. We used references of things like jellyfish to give him an almost a semi-transparent look."
The Lincoln parallels should have been obvious, but it's the translucent approach that is most intriguing, pointing towards the desire to create something really intangible. And that wasn't the half of it:
"We actually built a full skeletal structure inside his head, and veins as well that you can see through, keeping him slightly mysterious. It was always the intention of J.J. to keep him so that he would only reveal himself as a hologram at the end of his first scene."
If you were asking questions about the character after the movie, you were playing right into Abrams' hands.
3. The Concept Of Snoke Being Female Never Made It To ILM

One of the most intriguing rumours around the development of The Force Awakens is that at some point during development Snoke was considered being female. It certainly chimes with the move to introduce more women characters to the saga, and has gained traction as it serves as a major knock against the theory that the Supreme Leader is really Darth Plagueis the Wise.
However, if that was ever the plan, it didn't make it to ILM; when I brought it up it was the first Pritchard has heard of it, with him saying he "certainly didn't experience any of that". What's most likely is that very early on in concept stage, the idea of a female big bad was floated, but was dropped once the plot of Episode VII (and the wider trilogy) became properly defined.
That wasn't the only interesting things to get floated at this stage but not make it through, including a Jedi Killer (who eventually became Kylo Ren) and a Half Vader-Half Anakin Force Ghost.
2. There's Clues To Snoke's Identity In His Design

Of course, being an ancient character with an unknown history in the galaxy, there's been a lot of speculation about the true identity of Snoke - the popular thinking is that he's Plagueis, but there's been all manner of theories, from resurrected pre-existing characters to saga-changing introductions. Obviously Scott couldn't comment on future events, but he was able to reveal his backstory is established and shed some light on how it was worked into The Force Awakens:
"It's all in his character design. It's very much shrouded in mystery still, but all those scars and all that damage has to come from somewhere."
It's not much to go on, but clearly someone at ILM knows what the deal is, which is pretty exciting.
1. The Shoe Mystery Will Never Be Fully Solved
Before wrapping up the interview, I did get a chance to quiz Scott about one of the biggest Star Wars mysteries and one that has intrigued me for years; the hidden easter eggs in the original trilogy space sequences. There's long-standing rumours of potatoes in Empire's asteroid chase and a shoe in Jedi's climactic battle, but nobody has ever found any proof of these (those circled images available online are complete hokum).
He was able to confirm that the potato is a background asteroid, as well as expand on the story behind the shoe, but unfortunately not even someone working for ILM knew where exactly either of them were in their respective sequences. Talking about Jedi, he said:
"The shoe. The legend of the shoe. The shoe belonged to a guy named Ken Ralston, one of the VFX supervisors on Jedi and he was supervising all the space fight scenes. There's one shot, and it's of the Millennium Falcon flying towards the camera and there's billions of spacecraft just flying around all over the place. If you think back to how they did those in Jedi, they shot each model separately. When you've got 300 spaceships in one shot I think it gets pretty boring, so I think Ken did shoot his shoe and put it in the back there, but I think the only person who knows where that shoe is is Ken Ralston."
So there we go. The mystery is solved but the culprit got away. As for whether there's any similar hidden gems in The Force Awakens, Pritchard was pretty coy about it:
"J.J. love to put easter eggs into his movies. I think it's much more fun for fans to find them that we reveal anything. That's no fun."
Something to keep an eye out for on the Blu-Ray then.
Like this article? What did you think of the special effects in Star Wars: The Force Awakens? Have your say down in the comments.