Star Wars: The Last Jedi - 23 WTF Moments
4. Where Does Rose’s Love Come From?
It's always nice to have a little heart-warming romance in movies, but when it's completely unearned and comes out of the blue, all it does is open the writing up to criticism. Which is definitely the case with Rose's revelation that she's in love with Finn after saving his life.
Up to that point, there is absolutely no suggestion of that sort of dynamic, and it feels a little like an obligatory story swerve for the sake of manipulating more emotion out of the audience. In truth, it's not that believable and not at all satisfying.
Also, after she's made her heroic near-sacrifice, Rose falls unconscious - it actually seems like she's died in real-time - and Finn is forced to drag her back to the base on a sledge. He arrives with her prone body just as Luke's avatar has eaten the barrage from Kylo Ren's entire heavy artillery, suggesting that he was somehow able to get across the open ground of the salt plains and straight through the line of fire without so much as a scratch.
There's reasonable suspension of belief and then there's this.
3. Luke's Plan Relies On Ridiculous Contrivances
The ingenious plan to send in a projection to distract Kylo Ren so the rebels can escape is one of the most complex and contrived in the history of Star Wars, simply because it has to rely on so many coincidences and dumb luck.
The sensible version would have seen Luke's projection actually reveal that he was a distraction (even if he didn't reveal he was a projection), as nobody would have stopped him anyway and it would have been far more efficient. Instead, Luke had to rely on the crystal critters seeking security in the base, for BB-8's scan of the cave to not pick up the other entrance, for Poe Dameron to work out - umprompted - that he was a distraction, AND for Kylo Ren to be over-zealous with his barrage. If even one of those things didn't work, he would have used up his last energy pointlessly.
Also, the justification for there definitely being a rear exit is seemingly that if Luke could get in there must be a way. But Luke never got in - he was a projection - and it's a remarkable coincidence that there actually even WAS a back-door for Poe to completely wrongly assume exists.
2. Leia Lives
Though we were told before the film's release that we weren't going to see the death of Leia on screen in The Last Jedi, getting to the end of the film without something in the story reflecting the fact that she presumably cannot be in Episode IX was still something of a shock.
Now, we're all faced with the same question that met Carrie Fisher's sad death: what do Episode IX's writers do with Leia to both respectfully and satisfyingly write the end of her story?
It's particularly odd that they didn't choose to slightly alter the film to have her killed when Kylo Ren attacks her ship and she's blown out into space. The way that scene was framed would have been a beautiful end for Leia, but the reality is that the revelation of her impressive Force powers simply opens up more loose ends that Episode IX can't hope to tie up.
1. The Force Child?
The end of the film is built on a message of enduring hope: Luke's sacrifice isn't just a means to help the rebels escape, it's also the foundation for his mythology to be built even further to help capture the imaginations and hearts of a new generation of rebels.
And we see that in direct action, as the stable children that Rose and Finn help on Canto Bight immediately mythologise the Battle Of Crait and use it as inspiration for their own mini rebellion. We were supposed to use that scene to extrapolate the fact that others would follow suit, but the biggest thing to come out of it was actually the reveal of one of the kids having Force powers.
In essence, that confirms that there are new potential Jedi out there, who could follow in Rey's footsteps and that there is cause for hope for the Resistance that they could once more have Force-users on their side beyond just Rey, Maz and Leia.
Did you enjoy Star Wars; The Last Jedi? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.