Stephen King: Ranking His Films From Worst To Best

Wheeeeeeres Johnny?

"There's no harm in hoping for the best as long as you're prepared for the worst." Words of wisdom from Rita Hayworth And Shawshank Redemption, the Stephen King novella from his 1982 collection Different Seasons, which was later made into a film you might have heard of. It's advice given to the prisoners in that story, but it could just as easily be sent the way of the Stephen King faithful. King is prolific like no American author (or, really, any author) before him, knocking out a good couple of books a year - not to mention short stories - before he got hit by a car in 1999. Which slowed him down to, like, one book a year. He's also unprecedented in the amount of times his work has been adapted for the small screen, stage (you know there's a Carrie musical, right?) and especially film. In fact, King is so closely intimate with cinema that he's written an entire non-fiction book about it, and has an initiative called €œDollar Babies€, where he'll sell the rights to short stories which Hollywood hasn't optioned to student filmmakers, for the princely sum of a dollar. Which is perhaps an attempt to balance the scales in relation to the quality of his film adaptations. Certain King stories have made for some bonafide cinematic classic, others... less so. To settle any debate, here is every Stephen King adaptation (not including: Dollar Babies, sequels to adaptations with original scripts, remakes, or that one film King wrote about incestuous cat people) ranked from worst to best.

36. The Lawnmower Man

It turns out that the absolute worst movie ever to be made from a Stephen King story wasn't a crummy low-budget efforts, where a lack of good actors and awful special effects combine with a poor plot into something truly awful. Instead, The Lawnmower Man cost somewhere in the area of $10 million in 1992 money, and starred Pierce Brosnan. It also boasted what were (at the time) ground-breaking computer graphics, by it bore absolutely no resemblance to the King story of the same name, save for one scene, to the point that the author sued the producers for trying to put his name on it. Which, considering some of the other films on this list where he didn't do that, is saying something. From the looks of it, nobody involved in the making of The Lawnmower Man wanted anything to do with it. Jeff Fahey is the developmentally disabled groundskeeper Brosan's scientist drafts in as a human guinea pig for his experiments in virtual reality and that's the last time anything in this film makes any sense. It's all awful, unwatchable CGI and techno-mumno-jumbo from there on in.

35. Maximum Overdrive

Leave it to Stephen King himself to produce one of the all-time worst adaptations of his writing. The author was very much in his €œall cocaine, all the time€ phase when he made his directorial debut loosely based on his short story Trucks, which is memorable for having an all-AC/DC soundtrack decades before Iron Man sort of made that cool. A comet passes over Earth and somehow that causes a bunch of inanimate objects to gain sentience, with the most menacing amongst them being trucks. For some reason. Emilio Estevez leads a bunch of regular people who try to avoid getting smushed by a gang of big rigs, lead by one that has a Green Goblin mask over the grill. If it weren't for the involvement of cocaine in all areas of its production, Maximum Overdrive would be totally inexplicable. Knowing it was made under the influence, however, its absolute insanity makes a crazy kind of sense. Just a shame it was the bad kind of bad, instead of good bad.

34. Thinner

Thinner isn't all that much better, since it's not only one of the worst films based on a Stephen King work, but one of the worst horror films in history period. €œLet the curse fit the crime€ goes the tagline, which is not an actual saying, and is the earliest hint that this is a film totally devoid of any sort of logic, sense, taste, skill, talent.... One of only two of King's €œBachman Books€ (written under a pen name) to be adapted for film, you wonder if Tom Holland shouldn't have bothered. The screenwriter and director dropped the ball with this story of an arrogant, obese lawyer (Law And Order veteran Robert John Burke) who hits an old woman with his car. The €œgypsy woman€ dies, so Burke, the judge and the arresting officer who all helped him get off get cursed by her angry father. Burke loses weight, the judge grows scales, the cop gets boils. And then it goes inexplicably Death Wish at the end. A mess of a film, with simplistic, troubling morality.

33. Graveyard Shift

Graveyard Shift stars off well enough. As usual set in King's own home state of Maine, the action centres on the reopening of a decrepit old textile mill. Within the first couple of weeks several employees have met mysterious deaths, with the only thing connecting them being they all worked the graveyard shift. Spooky, right? All of that cool build up gets thrown away the instant foreman Stephen Macht hires a bunch of hobos to clear out the mill's basement, where they discover a labyrinthine series of tunnels beneath the mill which might explain all this disappearances... Because the tunnels are populated by giant bats that come out at night to hunt. But they only hunt within the mill for some reason. And lay dormant until somebody decided to start up the town's textile industry again. It's a ridiculous story that never quite falls into a pulpy guilty pleasure. It's just a bad plot, poorly directed, with terrible performances.

32. Secret Window

Now here's a controversial one. The accepted narrative is that Johnny Depp has more or less tanked his career, having committed to one too many Pirates Of The Caribbean films, put all his remaining eggs in the basket of the inexplicable Mortdecai, and now mostly getting by on Tim Burton casting him in everything. In reality, things had been on the downturn long before. It probably started, in fact, with Secret Window. This is another King adaptation that had the odds stacked against it from the start, since the novella it's based on is also pretty naff. Plus it mostly just revisits stuff done better in The Dark Half. Depp plays Stephen King analogue Mort Rainey, a successful author who goes off the deep end when his wife has an affair. At the same time John Tuturro's farmer accuses Mort of plagiarism, and when Mort's pets and loved one start getting picked off, Tuturro is the main suspect. And then there's the worst twist ever. A waste of time for all involved.

31. Mercy

Mercy is another expansion on a short story, this time Gramma from the collection Skeleton Crew. King was going for a H.P. Lovecraft vibe with his brief tale of a young kid terrified of his elderly grandmother, whose fears turn out to be pretty sound. Again, it's the sort of thing that just about works as a short story, but utterly collapses when you try to spin it out for ninety minutes. And again, that's despite Mercy having a decent cast - the kid is played by Chandler Riggs, aka Carl from The Walking Dead; Mark Duplass and Dylan McDermott also pop up - and a fairly basic, creepy story to tell. The filmmakers decided to go the route of modern hit horror films as opposed to creeping Lovecraftian horror, though, but the low budget and mediocre script ensured it'd never reach either the artistic or commercial heights of Insidious or The Conjuring.

30. A Good Marriage

Following his car accident in 1999, Stephen King slowed down significantly. He also focussed more on writing his own novels than adapting his work for film, so his return to the cinematic with last year's A Good Marriage should've been a big deal. But it barely made any noise at all. Again, A Good Marriage has everything on paper. King is a pretty good screenwriter, director Peter Askin had previously been behind celebrate blacklisting documentary Trumbo, and Joan Allen and Anthony LaPaglia are pretty great casting as the married couple the film focusses on. It never quite delivers the goods, though. Allen's happily married wife of 25 years discovers her husband is a serial killer and just sort of deals with it. It could've been an interesting, unique psychological thriller, but instead it was a sort of half-baked domestic drama where none of the interesting questions and themes brought up are ever explored.

29. The Mangler

The title of The Mangler makes it sound like a really crappy B-movie and, well, that's precisely what it is. The short story was first published in the collection Night Shift and involved a laundry press machine that had become possessed by a demon and was now killing people. To be fair to King, it was one of his earlier printed works, and was inspired by his working in industrial laundry to subsidise his writing career to begin with. Why on Earth Poltergeist and Texas Chainsaw Massacre director Tobe Hooper decided to adapt it is another matter. Especially since he totally half-assed it. Then again, Hooper has been without a decent film in a good couple of decades. Robert Englund - the original Freddy Krueger - is kind of fun as the owner of the evil laundry machine, but the premise and lack of production values add up to one total turkey.

28. Dolan's Cadillac

It's been quite a few years since there's been a really big, well received Stephen King adaptation. Perhaps that'll change when his zombie mobile phone novel Cell hits the big screen, starring John Cusack and Samuel L Jackson, later this year. In the meantime, his more obscure work continues to be mined for obscure films. Dolan's Cadillac is a King story even more unknown than most, although the film does boast some genuine talent. The short story of the same name was more of a straight crime thriller, as a teacher who plots revenge on the mob boss who killed his wife years ago. It's a pretty gripping premise, and one that both the short story and film fully deliver on. It's just that the film isn't presented with any sort of finesse by director Jeff Beesley, and even some game performances by Wes Bentley as the teacher and Christian Slater as the criminal can't save it.

In this post: 
Stephen-King
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tom Baker is the Comics Editor at WhatCulture! He's heard all the Doctor Who jokes, but not many about Randall and Hopkirk. He also blogs at http://communibearsilostate.wordpress.com/