Suicide Squad: 5 Things Critics Got Right, 5 Things They Got Wrong
It's not great, but that doesn't make Suicide Squad the worst movie of the summer.
Suicide Squad was supposed to be the movie that got DC Films back on track after Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. Depending on how general audiences feel about the film, it still might be. For critics, however, the book has been written and Suicide Squad is another misfire for Warner Bros.
Ridiculous petitions aside, it's fair to look at the critical reaction to the movie and see just how much of the negativity is warranted. Suicide Squad's Rotten Tomatoes score is still declining and it is now approaching Batman v Superman territory of critical disdain. Is it really that bad?
Suicide Squad is far from great, but closer to being good than so many reviewers would have you think. Many of the most frequent criticisms are valid, but some are little more than piling on and hyperbole. This list highlights 5 valid criticisms of Suicide Squad and 5 more that are questionable at best.
10. The Plot Is Thin
RIGHT.
Suicide Squad is not the richest or most complex comic book movie. In act, its plot is razor thin with a few missed swings at trying to provide real depth. The entire story can be explained in one sentence.
The Suicide Squad are brought together by Amanda Waller and forced to go on a mission to save a city. That is the entire movie, so it is fair to criticize the plot for being far too simple and straightforward. This criticism probably would not have been thrown in the direction of a superhero film just 10 years ago now, but the genre is now expected to have moved past such things.
Even so, if thin plotting is a deal-breaker, how do we explain Deadpool? Yes, Deadpool is more fun and a better movie overall, but its plot is as basic of a superhero origin story as we've seen. Raunchy humor draws laughs, but it does not flesh out a story and critics failed to call Deadpool on it.
9. Suicide Squad Is Overstuffed
WRONG.
This is just silly. So many critics, while slamming the film for its thin plot have called it bloated or overstuffed in the same review. I suppose a film can be both of those things, but it takes one hell of an argument that critics haven't exactly made.
Calling Suicide Squad overstuffed just sounds like a Batman v Superman review stuck on repeat. Suicide Squad is not overstuffed. If anything, the movie is under-stuffed because it does not have enough going on.
The story is very straightforward and while there are a lot of characters, only a few receive any noteworthy focus. There are several members of the Squad, but it really boils down to Deadshot, Harley Quinn, El Diablo, Rick Flag, and Amanda Waller with a little Captain Boomerang sprinkled in for comic relief.
Suicide Squad is an ensemble film and having actual storylines for only a handful of characters is hardly stuffing the story beyond capacity.
8. The Villain Sucks
RIGHT.
This section is going to venture into mild spoiler territory, in that I'm going to have to talk about who the villain is, which has not been officially announced. It's not really much of a spoiler in the context of the film, but if you don't want to know anything, then skip to the next entry.
Still here?
There are actually two villains in Suicide Squad and you have seen them both in the trailers. The one you've seen attacking the subway train in the promotional footage is Incubus, brother of the film's other villain, Enchantress. Together, they form one of the worst antagonistic duos in comic book movie history.
Their motivations are little more than "we must destroy mankind, because reasons." Enchantress spawns a horde of literally faceless monsters for the Suicide Squad to easily dispatch. By the time the Squad reaches Enchantress and Incubus for a final battle, both baddies have spent so much time looking and acting like cheap Imhotep ripoffs that they can't be taken seriously.
Billed as "Bad vs. Evil," Suicide Squad does not really deliver on the second part.
7. The Characters And Story Are Muddled
WRONG.
We've already been over how clear and simple the story is, so any talk of it being muddled feels off. The characters are also pretty straightforward. This is especially true of the small number of characters Suicide Squad actually focuses on.
It is not hard at all figure out where Deadshot, Harley Quinn, El Diablo, Rick Flag, and Amanda Waller are coming from. Will Smith does a lot with a little and make it enough to understand Deadshot's motivation in the film and his character works.
Harley Quinn is The Joker's crazy girlfriend while Margot Robbie does such a wonderful job in her performance of showing there's even more to the character that can be unraveled in future instalments. Jay Hernandez is great as El Diablo, a character with a very clearly defined arc that boosts the film.
Everything the audience needs to know about the main characters in on the screen.
6. The Joker Does Not Need To Be There
RIGHT.
Some critics have called Suicide Squad out for not giving The Joker enough to do. That is fair, as The Joker is not connected to the present day plot in a meaningful way. He is just kind of there.
The Joker may have been a casualty of the film's reported troubles in postproduction. Jared Leto has alluded to deleted scenes for his character, so perhaps Warner Bros. will once again go the route of an Ultimate Cut to make some things make more sense.
As it stands, Leto is very good as The Joker. He's even better in the scenes Joker shares with Harley Quinn, as Leto and Robbie have outstanding chemistry. There just is not quite enough there to justify The Joker's presence outside of Harley's origin story flashbacks.
Fortunately for the film, audiences love The Joker enough to not care if his place in the narrative is a bit flimsy.
5. DC Films Still Aren't Any Fun
WRONG.
In the wake of Man of Steel and Batman v Superman, certain buzzwords are just easy to toss into a bad review. Words like "joyless," "dark," and "cheerless" are once again showing up in reviews for a DC Films entry. For Suicide Squad, it seems like those words were used based on habit, not merit.
There is fun to be had in Suicide Squad. It may not have all the quippy goodness of other superhero films, but the film definitely has its own twisted sense of fun. More often than not, the film's sense of humor works well within the sensibilities of its premise and characters.
Sure, the movie is still dark, but what should we reasonably expect from a film in which villains are forced to be heroes? Suicide Squad is meant to allow its audience to have a good time being bad. It reaches that goal often enough and many moviegoers will have a good time with it.
4. The Movie Feels Uneven
RIGHT.
Suicide Squad is definitely the product of (at least) two competing visions, just as recent reports have indicated. There is a darker, more psychological story pushing back against a more comedic baddies being bad romp. It still kind of works, but critics have fairly noted how these different visions have made the film uneven at times.
The first sign of this problem really should have been seen months ago when the first official trailer was so tonally different from the footage director David Ayer brought to Comic-Con in July 2015. Somewhere along the way, Warner Bros. lost confidence in Ayer's darker approach and it probably had more to do with Batman v Superman than anything else.
Suicide Squad has the misfortune of suffering for the sins of its predecessor. Again, this is not something that completely destroys the film. It's weirdly appropriate for a movie about crazy villains to be uneven in places, regardless of whether or not it was intentional.
Unfortunately, it is still something that opened the film up to another critical shot.
3. It's Hurt By The PG-13 Rating
WRONG.
Suicide Squad was always going to be a PG-13 movie. Its budget demands a higher box office return than R-rated films can be counted on to receive. Some critics believe the constraints of a PG-13 rating hurt the movie, but that could not be further from the truth.
Sure, Deadpool was a huge hit and critics loved it. Deadpool fed the antihero appetite that Guardians of the Galaxy reignited within the superhero genre. Suicide Squad may have seemed to many critics like another Deadpool, and it could have been, but it never needed to go R.
All an R rating would have done for Suicide Squad was allow the cast to drop F-bomb while taking part in bloodier action. As it stands, Suicide Squad isn't lacking an edge and doesn't need more profanity. It is sufficiently violent and does not suffer from the lack of blood splatter.
Any improvements an R rating could have allowed would be superficial at best. There's nothing an R rating could do to overcome the more legitimate issues critics have noted.
2. It's Not As Good As The Trailers
RIGHT.
The plus side of having great trailers is that people get excited about seeing the movie. That's a trailer doing its job. The downside, if there is one, is that expectations can be elevated beyond a point the film can reach.
DC Films felt this sting once before with Man of Steel and it's happening again with Suicide Squad. The "Bohemian Rhapsody" trailer set the world on fire by promising a film so fresh, new, and full of energy. People who normally skip superhero films were actually talking about the trailer and looking forward to the film.
Suicide Squad does not fully live up to that trailer or the ones that followed. It is fun, but not as fun as the those trailers suggest. It is not quite as upbeat or energetic. There will probably be some general audience members who feel a little underwhelmed even if most moviegoers feel that Suicide Squad is close enough to what they were sold.
1. Suicide Squad Is A Total Disaster
WRONG.
Some critics really didn't like Suicide Squad. It's been called worse than Fantastic Four (2015) and Green Lantern. It's also been called the most disappointing movie of the summer and one of the most disappointing movies of all time. It's all hyperbolic nonsense.
First, Suicide Squad never carried enough expectations to be one of the most disappointing movies of all time. Second, it is, as can plainly be seen, a more adequately made film than Fantastic Four (2015) and Green Lantern. Such negative comparisons are bogus and tip the hand of the critic.
When a movie like Suicide Squad already has so many negative reviews, there can sometimes be a game of oneupmanship. The only way to garner sufficient attention and clicks for merely adding to the pile of bad reviews is to be the critic who is saying the worst things about the film. "You think it's the worst film of the year, well I say it's the worst film of the decade!"
Suicide Squad has enough redeeming factors to prevent it from being a total disaster even if one does not ultimately believe it's a good movie. It has interesting characters that are worthy of the audience's emotional investment. It has genuinely fun moments and is good for several (intended) laughs.
A fun time can be had with Suicide Squad despite its flaws. It may not be everything we hoped it would be. It has fallen short of fulfilling the role of DCEU savior that people have forced upon it. It is not a great movie, but it has great moments that really do work and make the movie, at least in part, worthwhile.
Granted, that's not the most ringing endorsement, but the point remains that Suicide Squad is far above the depths some critics have tried to drag it down into.
Did you enjoy Suicide Squad? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.