The Batman: 10 Perfect Casting Choices For Robin
Robert Pattinson is Batman, but who’ll be the Boy (or Girl) Wonder?
Robert Pattinson has finally been confirmed as Bruce Wayne in Matt Reeves’ The Batman, and the reception has been surprising, but mostly positive. There was some initial eye rolls from those who don’t know Pattinson beyond Twilight, but on the whole, most have been receptive.
The types of people who follow casting news also tend to have a big interest in movies, and so know of Pattinson’s terrific work elsewhere, carrying Remember Me and doing a brilliant job in things like Life and Good Time. There’s been many more people defending him from criticism than there has been criticism itself. It’s a funny old world.
Affleck’s departure has had a strange tone too; the actor never looked like he was enjoying himself and this had been a long time coming. That said, he’ll go down as one of the best Bruce Waynes, even if he was an average Batman.
Now though is the time to look to the future, and to Pattinson’s potential sidekick: Robin. There’s a wide range of actors who could fill the role, depending on Reeves’ vision. With a younger Batman, will we see a younger Robin too, or a Nightwing style character much closer in age to his mentor?
10. Abraham Attah
Abraham Attah is by far the youngest contender featured here, at the ripe old age of 17. Most entries here would age Robin up from his comic book age, one or two quite significantly and have him beginning in more of Nightwing mould.
Typically, a star of any significant name value or experience will be 25+, and it would be quite the risk for Warner Brothers to go for a debutant in the movie set to (hopefully) steady the ship of the DCEU. In Abraham Attah though, they do have a potential solution.
Attah has limited experience, granted, with only two features under his belt. Still though, it’s much more than the average 17-year-old. He’s even featured in another superhero movie too, as Peter Parker’s mathlete classmate in Spider-Man: Homecoming.
Even out of the classmates though, he has probably the smallest part, so it’s nothing to really boost his chances with Robin.
However, the other movie was his debut picture; Netflix’s Beasts Of No Nation. His performance as child soldier Agu was mature beyond his years; if not for the Academy’s distaste for streaming he could have been one of the youngest Oscar nominees ever.
9. Finn Wittrock
The road for Finn Wittrock to climb out of his role of supporting television man and reach Hollywood is well worn. Evan Peters has already made a name for himself breaking out of American Horror Story, starring as Quicksilver in X-Men.
Sarah Paulson too, while she had a fairly successful career in any case, has moved up a few levels through AHS, while it provided a platform for Lady Gaga to showcase her talent before scoring the Oscar nomination for her lead in A Star Is Born.
He hasn’t starred in as many seasons as some, but he’s shown remarkable range in Horror Story. His Dandy Mott was drenched in creepiness yet still managed to be complex, while Hotel’s Tristan had an outward aggression with inner vulnerability.
These qualities could make for a great Robin, though Wittrock will need to adjust the ratio from the deeply unpleasant Tristan. His bumpkin role as Jether probably won’t be of much value, except to show his range and commitment to his parts.
After bit part roles in La La Land and The Big Short, the time is right for Wittrock to make another step up.
8. Thomas Brodie-Sangster
Thomas Brodie-Sangster obviously drank from the fountain of eternal youth at some point during his everlasting childhood. The Maze Runner star is the epitome of 13 going on 30, turning 30 next year while still looking as he did in Love, Actually, only taller.
With that in mind, he’s versatile enough to play various versions of Robin, depending on what exactly Matt Reeves is looking for. To only consider Brodie-Sangster for his ageless quality does a massive disservice to him as an actor though, and there’s plenty more reasons he could be a suitable Robin.
His boyish looks do make up the majority of his reputation, but that’s not for lack of trying on his part. With supporting roles in Game Of Thrones, Star Wars and Wolf Hall, he has an enviable back catalogue with clear blockbuster experience and a decent range.
As Jojen Reed, he had one of the tougher roles in Game Of Thrones, but with his on screen sister Meera he carried the complex ‘Bran becomes the Three Eyed Raven’ story arc well.
He’s more than proven himself capable, and is a rare mix of the youthful appearance yet bags of experience to pull it off.
7. Josh Hutcherson
Josh Hutcherson is used to playing the supporting role in a major franchise, featuring alongside Jennifer Lawrence in The Hunger Games series. He does well in that, even if the script grows more restrictive for him at the saga goes on, with more and more focus on Lawrence’s marketable Katniss Everdeen.
Robin will obviously be playing second fiddle to Batman too, and that’s before you bring in any of the bad guys. Whoever gets the part will need to bounce off the lead well and shine with the chances he gets; that’s something Hutcherson certainly knows how to do.
Even taking The Hunger Games out of the equation, he’s ratcheted up an impressive filmography for a 26 year old.
He’s had lead roles in animated adventure Epic and alongside Dwayne Johnson in Journey 2, as well as supporting parts in things like The Kids Are Alright and The Disaster Artist.
Interestingly, post Hunger Games he’s taken much riskier roles, most notably in Hulu series Future Man, and is garnering rave reviews for his passionate, enthusiastic performance.
The Hunger Games hype may have died down but there’s still plenty of reasons for Matt Reeves to look his way.
6. Dylan Minnette
Dylan Minnette is most recognisable for his role in Netflix’s controversial teen suicide drama Thirteen Reasons Why. The first season in particular was huge, and Minnette’s star power (along with co-star Kathrine Langford’s) skyrocketed overnight.
Even at just 22 though, he’s got more to point to in his back catalogue than just Thirteen Reasons Why. Admittedly, most are supporting roles, but his momentum is heading in the right direction. Although the controversy dominated Thirteen Reasons Why’s coverage, it still needed great performances to carry it through the headlines.
With Minnette, he nailed Clay’s naivety and vulnerability, and is perfect for a very wet behind the ears Robin.
He’s got a bit of an ace in the hole too; he’s worked with incoming director Matt Reeves before, in cult horror movie Let Me In.
Reeves isn’t the only hugely talented director Minnette has worked with in his short career either. He’s featured under Denis Villeneuve in Prisoners and Jason Reitman In Labor Day, as well as TV spots in Agent’s Of SHIELD, Scandal and Nikita.
He’s a rising star with everything heading in the right direction for him to score the role of Robi
5. Asa Butterfield
He’s only 22, but it seems like Asa Butterfield has been around for quite a while. If Matt Reeves wants to really highlight the ‘boy’ aspect of the Boy Wonder, Butterfield could be a great pick.
He first made a name for himself as Bruno in the 2008 adaption of John Boyne’s novel The Boy In The Striped Pyjamas, though he did have a couple of credits to his name prior to this.
It’s his teenage roles which most qualify him for Robin though, in the more action oriented Ender’s Game and Hugo. Ender’s Game in particular sees Butterfield in the role of both mentor and teacher; he’s closer to Terry McGinnis than any actual Robin, but that still shows his capabilities.
He had some decent roles following this, quietly going about building a name for himself in the industry. Though he’s nowhere near famous enough to be a box office draw yet, he’s shown more longevity and versatility than most actors his age.
Most recently he’s starred in Netflix’s Sex Education, showcasing more personality and wit than most of his roles. He’s a reliable pick just building to the point in his career where a blockbuster could tip him over the edge.
4. Dan DeHaan
Dan DeHaan may feel like his ship has sailed slightly, but he’s still got a couple of years to grab onto a lifeline before he’s doomed to the B-list forever.
DeHaan has had at least one shot already, as the lead role in Valerian. Despite the potential of the comic and its interesting and unique tone, that movie fell completely flat; considering DeHaan had absolutely zero chemistry with Cara Delevingne opposite him, he’s not entirely blameless.
He was, however, much better alongside Felicity Jones and Andrew Garfield in The Amazing Spider-Man 2, even if yet again that movie failed to deliver on its potential. As Harry Osborne, he was much creepier than James Franco’s crack at the character, and much more compelling.
Robin, whichever version of the character you pick, is rarely creepy. Instead, he’s various degrees of curious, cocky and enthusiastic depending on which version Reeves opts for.
A more obsessive version of the character could certainly work though, and DeHaan can do overly inquisitive Robin perfectly. If Reeves feels like giving Dan DeHaan a shot in the last chance saloon, he could pull a surprise on everyone.
3. Dylan O’Brien
Like fellow Maze Runner star Thomas Brodie-Sangster, Dylan Thomas is one of those stars who seems like they can play the young role forever. He’s still only 26 though, so is a decent pick in between the youngest candidates and the older, more-likely-to-be-Nightwing potential cast members.
As well as The Maze Runner, his stint in Teen Wolf showcased his ability to thrive in large casts, something which will be crucial in Reeves’ The Batman. The movie will probably be a soft reboot in the style of Thor: Ragnarok, trimming away everything which hasn’t worked in the DCEU so far and streamlining it.
Either that or it’ll go full reboot and tear down everything to do with Batfleck to build something better. Either way, if Robin features they’ll need to mesh well with everyone; something O’Brien is definitely capable of.
He’s been spreading his wings recently too, so The Batman may be arriving at the right time. American Assassin wasn’t great, but it did at least highlight his ability to lead a movie. Bumblebee on the other hand was a surprise hit, bucking the trend of terrible Transformers movies, with O’Brien voicing the robot perfectly.
2. Logan Lerman
Logan Lerman is another actor blessed with an eternally youthful face, and is arguably the closest in appearance to the classic Dick Grayson look; if Reeves indeed opts for the original Robin and keeps the traditional image.
Ezra Miller probably rivals him for this title, but then seeing as he’s already The Flash he’s not in the running anyway.
Lerman is only 26 but has a filmography more typically of a star 10 years his senior. Though he’s not a household name, he’s probably just on the brink of becoming one, with genres spreading far and wide.
Although Percy Jackson was not as commercially successful as fellow teen sagas Harry Potter, Hunger Games or Robert Pattinson’s own Twilight, it did well enough to garner a sequel. For Lerman to lead it at such a young age is a feather in his cap and would certainly boost his chances of becoming Robin.
Away from that, Lerman’s starred in angsty dramas Stuck In Love and The Perks Of Being A Wallflower, as well as gunslinger western 3:10 To Yuma and dark war drama Fury.
Whatever the role asks of him, he’d be up to the task.
1. Maisie Williams
Maisie Williams would certainly be a controversial casting, seeing as Robin is typically male in the comics. However, there is a female version of the character out there, and after nine male candidates, it’s worth considering the ladies.
Carrie Kelley was Robin in Frank Miller’s famous Dark Knight saga, while there’s also Stephanie Brown who went on to become Batgirl.
There’s a host of women who could fill the role, just as there’s likely to be more than just these nine guys in the heads of executives when casting rolls around. Maisie Williams has already been building a decent career away from Arya Stark, with a recurring role in Doctor Who as well as leads in Cyberbully, iBoy and the upcoming The New Mutants.
Fellow female Game Of Thrones breakout stars Emilia Clarke and Sophie Turner though each have blockbusters in their catalogue already, with Star Wars, Terminator and X-Men.
Williams certainly had the talent to match them in the show, stealing some brilliant scenes with Charles Dance in particular. She’s also the youngest and has experience through both Thrones and Doctor Who playing a Robinesque character, so if they go for Kelley or Brown, you feel the role is made for her.